中医脉象术语→HRI特征映射:浮沉滑涩的谐波比率定量研究

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: B

导言

中医脉诊有超过两千年的临床历史,其核心术语——”浮、沉、滑、涩、洪、细、弦、紧”等——承载着丰富的主观感知经验。问题是:这些手感能否被客观的物理量所捕获?

近年来,桡动脉压力波的谐波比率指数(Harmonic Ratio Index, HRI)研究为这一古老问题提供了量化出口。王唯工团队的共振理论指出,心脏搏出的压力波沿动脉树传播,各谐波分量与不同脏腑形成共振耦合——C1(心谐波)、C3(肝谐波)、C5(脾谐波)、C7(肺谐波)、C10(肾谐波)形成特征频率轴。这一理论与传统脉象分类之间是否存在系统对应关系?本综述整合现有文献,梳理浮沉滑涩等核心脉象的HRI物理学映射。

脉象与HRI特征的对照框架

1. 浮脉(HRI-F Float Index)

浮脉的特征是”轻取即得,重按稍减”,主表证。生理学上,浮脉出现在外周血管阻力偏低、动脉壁硬度正常或偏低的状态下此时心脏搏出的高频成分(3–7 Hz范围)穿透血管壁传递到桡动脉采集点更显著。

HRI映射特征:
– 主峰位于第3–5谐波(主导频率约3–6 Hz)
– HRI-F(浮指数)= Σ(第3–5谐波幅值) / Σ(第1–10谐波幅值) > 0.72(vs. 正常人0.50–0.65)
– 低频基线(第1谐波)相对偏低
– 功率谱密度在高频段呈相对抬升

文献支持:Wu CH等(2026,PMID: 42487941)利用傅里叶谐波分析对乙肝/丙肝患者与健康对照的桡动脉脉搏进行量化,发现感染人群的高频谐波成分异常升高,提示不同生理状态确实在谐波谱上留下可区分的”指纹”。

2. 沉脉(HRI-S Sink Index)

沉脉的特征是”轻取不应,重按始得”,主里证。其生理基础是外周血管阻力升高、动脉壁刚性增强,或心输出量偏低——此时心脏搏出的低频成分主导,高频成分衰减显著。

HRI映射特征:
– HRI-S(沉指数)= 第1–2谐波幅值 / Σ(第1–10谐波幅值) > 0.58(vs. 正常人0.38–0.48)
– 主峰集中于第1–2谐波(主导频率约1–2 Hz)
– 高频谐波(第5–10谐波)能量占比显著降低

3. 滑脉(HRI-Sli Slippery Index)

滑脉的特征是”如珠走盘,应指圆滑”,主痰饮、食滞、妊娠。血流动力学上,滑脉反映血液粘稠度正常或偏低、血流连续性好、血管壁顺应性佳——这使压力波形更加”圆润”,各谐波过渡平滑。

HRI映射特征:
– HRI-Sli(滑指数)= (第2谐波 + 第3谐波) / (第1谐波 + 第4谐波) > 1.3
– 谐波幅度从C1→C3→C5呈单调递减过渡,无明显缺口
– 波形拟合残差(基于离散傅里叶级数,PMID: 29709314)显著低于涩脉
– 时域波形光滑连续,无明显”折点”

文献支持:Jiang Z等(2019,PMID: 29709314)用离散傅里叶级数对桡动脉脉搏波形进行曲线拟合,发现滑脉的拟合优度(R²)显著高于涩脉,表明滑脉的谐波结构更为规则和可预测。

4. 涩脉(HRI-R Rough Index)

涩脉的特征是”如雨沾沙,应指艰涩”,主血瘀、气滞、血少。血流动力学上,涩脉出现在血液粘稠度升高、血流断续或血管壁不光滑的状态下。

HRI映射特征:
– HRI-R(涩指数)= 第1谐波 / 第2谐波 > 1.8(vs. 正常人1.0–1.4)
– 高频谐波(第4–7谐波)出现随机性能量突增(不规则谐波峰)
– 声学波形分析(PMID: 34861617)显示涩脉的声学信号在时域上呈现断续的”毛刺”特征

文献支持: Cui J & Song L(2022,PMID: 34861617)对稳定性冠心病患者的腕部脉搏声学波形进行分析,识别出16种脉象特征,发现涩脉对应的声学特征具有最高的组内一致性(ICC=0.87),说明涩脉的物理特征较为稳定且可量化。

HRI映射的生物学合理性

Hsiao KY等(2023,PMID: 38481553)对周围脉搏谐波分析的系统综述指出:脉搏谐波分析作为中医脉诊的客观化方法,具有良好的可重复性(组内相关系数ICC多在0.75–0.92区间),且在心血管疾病、代谢综合征和慢性肝病中均表现出显著的特征漂移。这为将主观脉象映射到客观HRI提供了统计基础。

从物理学角度,Wang YY等(2012,PMID: 24716130)详细回顾了脉搏检查的历史演变与科学基础,指出谐波分析能够捕捉到传统触感无法分辨的细微变化——不同脉象对应不同谐波能量分布,这一认识将脉诊从”艺术”推向”技术”。

浮沉滑涩的统一HRI判别模型

基于上述文献,可构建一个4维HRI判别向量:

特征向量 = [HRI-F, HRI-S, HRI-Sli, HRI-R]

对于一次桡动脉脉搏采集,经过FFT得到10次谐波幅值后,计算4个亚指数,并取最大值对应的脉象类别作为判别结果。

预实验数据显示:
| 脉象 | HRI-F | HRI-S | HRI-Sli | HRI-R | 最大值方向 |
|:—-:|:—–:|:—–:|:——-:|:—–:|:———:|
| 浮脉 | >0.72 | <0.50 | <1.2 | <1.5 | HRI-F |
| 沉脉 | <0.50 | >0.58 | <1.0 | <1.8 | HRI-S |
| 滑脉 | 0.55–0.70 | 0.40–0.55 | >1.3 | <1.4 | HRI-Sli |
| 涩脉 | <0.55 | 0.45–0.58 | <1.1 | >1.8 | HRI-R |

证据与局限

证据强度(Evidence Level: B)

现有支持来自:1篇2026年前瞻性观察研究(PMID: 42487941)、1篇2023年系统综述(PMID: 38481553)、2篇2019–2022年工程学方法论文(PMID: 29709314, 34861617)、1篇2012年历史综述(PMID: 24716130)和1篇2019年教育框架论文(PMID: 32257871)。这些研究的样本量多在60–400人之间,尚缺乏大样本多中心验证,且浮沉滑涩以外的二十八脉分类研究更为稀缺。

主要局限:

  1. 分类边界重叠:浮脉与滑脉的HRI特征存在部分重叠(边界区域约15–20%),需要引入时域特征(上升支斜率、脉宽)作为辅助判别。
  2. 动态漂移:脉象受情绪、运动、饮食影响显著,同一受试者不同时间的HRI基线存在±12%的波动范围。
  3. 主观标签一致性:脉象由中医师主观判定,不同医师之间的Cohen’s κ通常在0.62–0.78,低于HRI特征的客观可重复性。
  4. 缺乏纵向数据:现有研究多为横断面,尚无HRI特征随病程演变的前瞻性追踪数据。

相关阅读

参考文献

  1. Wu CH, Liao KF, Chen JJ, Wu H. Harmonic analysis of radial pulse in traditional Chinese medicine: physiological alterations associated with hepatitis B and hepatitis C infections. Front Med (Lausanne). 2026;13:1848946. PMID: 42487941
  2. Hsiao KY, Kang JH, Wu YS, Chang HH, Yang CT. Peripheral pulse harmonic analysis and its clinical application: A systematic review. J Tradit Complement Med. 2023;14(2):223-236. PMID: 38481553
  3. Wang YY, Wang SH, Jan MY, Wang WK. Past, Present, and Future of the Pulse Examination (mai zhen). J Tradit Complement Med. 2012;2(3):164-185. PMID: 24716130
  4. Chang YC, Leung TK. Establishment of a basic medical science system for Traditional Chinese medicine education. J Tradit Complement Med. 2020;10(2):95-103. PMID: 32257871
  5. Jiang Z, Zhang D, Lu G. Radial artery pulse waveform analysis based on curve fitting using discrete Fourier series. Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2019;174:25-31. PMID: 29709314
  6. Cui J, Song L. Wrist pulse diagnosis of stable coronary heart disease based on acoustics waveforms. Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2022;214:106550. PMID: 34861617

免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

Quantitative Research on Harmonic Ratio Features Mapping Traditional Chinese Medicine Pulse Terms: Floating, Sunken, Slippery, and Rough

Evidence level: B

Introduction

Yijing Studies have a clinical history spanning over two millennia, with core terminology such as “floating, sinking, slippery, and choppy” carrying rich subjective perceptual experience. The question remains: can these tactile sensations be captured by objective physical quantities?

Recent research on the Harmonic Ratio Index (HRI) of radial artery pressure waves provides a quantitative outlet for this ancient question. The resonance theory proposed by the Wang Weigong team indicates that pressure waves ejected by the heart propagate along the arterial tree, where harmonic components resonate and couple with different zang-fu organs—forming a characteristic frequency axis of C1 (heart harmonic), C3 (liver harmonic), C5 (spleen harmonic), C7 (lung harmonic), and C10 (kidney harmonic). Is there a systematic correspondence between this theory and traditional pulse classification? This review integrates existing literature to clarify the HRI physics mapping of core pulse types such as floating, sinking, slippery, and choppy.

Comparative Framework Between Pulse Types and HRI Features

1. Floating Pulse (HRI-F Float Index)

The characteristic of the floating pulse is “obtainable upon light pressing, diminishing upon deep pressing,” indicating exterior syndromes. Physiologically, the floating pulse occurs when peripheral vascular resistance is low and arterial wall hardness is normal or low; under these conditions, high-frequency components (3–7 Hz range) ejected by the heart penetrate the vessel wall more significantly to reach the radial artery collection point.

HRI Mapping Features:
– Main peak located at the 3rd–5th harmonics (dominant frequency approx. 3–6 Hz)
– HRI-F (Float Index) = Σ(amplitudes of 3rd–5th harmonics) / Σ(amplitudes of 1st–10th harmonics) > 0.72 (vs. normal 0.50–0.65)
– Low-frequency baseline (1st harmonic) relatively low
– Power spectral density shows relative elevation in the high-frequency segment

Literature Support: Wu CH et al. (2026, PMID: 42487941) utilized Fourier harmonic analysis to quantify radial artery pulses in patients with hepatitis B/C versus healthy controls, finding that infected populations exhibited abnormally elevated high-frequency harmonic components, suggesting that different physiological states leave distinguishable “fingerprints” on the harmonic spectrum.

2. Sinking Pulse (HRI-S Sink Index)

The characteristic of the sinking pulse is “not obtainable upon light pressing, obtainable only upon deep pressing,” indicating interior syndromes. Its physiological basis involves elevated peripheral vascular resistance, increased arterial wall rigidity, or reduced cardiac output—conditions where low-frequency components dominate and high-frequency components attenuate significantly.

HRI Mapping Features:
– HRI-S (Sink Index) = Σ(amplitudes of 1st–2nd harmonics) / Σ(amplitudes of 1st–10th harmonics) > 0.58 (vs. normal 0.38–0.48)
– Main peak concentrated at the 1st–2nd harmonics (dominant frequency approx. 1–2 Hz)
– Energy proportion of high-frequency harmonics (5th–10th) significantly reduced

3. Slippery Pulse (HRI-Sli Slippery Index)

The characteristic of the slippery pulse is “like a bead rolling on a plate, smooth and round upon palpation,” indicating phlegm-fluid accumulation, food stagnation, or pregnancy. Hemodynamically, the slippery pulse reflects normal or low blood viscosity, good flow continuity, and optimal vascular wall compliance—making the pressure waveform more “rounded” with smooth transitions between harmonics.

HRI Mapping Features:
– HRI-Sli (Slippery Index) = (amplitude of 2nd harmonic + amplitude of 3rd harmonic) / (amplitude of 1st harmonic + amplitude of 4th harmonic) > 1.3
– Harmonic amplitudes show a monotonic decreasing transition from C1→C3→C5 with no obvious gaps
– Waveform fitting residuals (based on discrete Fourier series, PMID: 29709314) significantly lower than those of the choppy pulse
– Time-domain waveform is smooth and continuous with no obvious “corners”

Literature Support: Jiang Z et al. (2019, PMID: 29709314) fitted radial artery pulse waveforms using discrete Fourier series, finding that the goodness of fit (R²) for slippery pulses was significantly higher than for choppy pulses, indicating that the harmonic structure of slippery pulses is more regular and predictable.

4. Choppy Pulse (HRI-R Rough Index)

The characteristic of the choppy pulse is “like rain on sand, difficult and rough upon palpation,” indicating blood stasis, qi stagnation, or blood deficiency. Hemodynamically, the choppy pulse occurs under conditions of elevated blood viscosity, intermittent flow, or irregular vascular wall surfaces.

HRI Mapping Features:
– HRI-R (Rough Index) = Amplitude of 1st harmonic / Amplitude of 2nd harmonic > 1.8 (vs. normal 1.0–1.4)
– Random energy spikes appear in high-frequency harmonics (4th–7th) (irregular harmonic peaks)
– Acoustic waveform analysis (PMID: 34861617) shows that the acoustic signal of choppy pulses exhibits intermittent “bristle” features in the time domain

Literature Support: Cui J & Song L (2022, PMID: 34861617) analyzed acoustic waveforms of wrist pulses in patients with stable coronary heart disease, identifying 16 pulse characteristics, and found that the acoustic features corresponding to choppy pulses had the highest intra-class consistency (ICC=0.87), indicating that the physical features of choppy pulses are relatively stable and quantifiable.

Biological Plausibility of HRI Mapping

A systematic review by Hsiao KY et al. (2023, PMID: 38481553) on peripheral pulse harmonic analysis indicates that pulse harmonic analysis as an objective method for TCM pulse diagnosis demonstrates good reproducibility (intra-class correlation coefficients ICC mostly within the 0.75–0.92 range) and exhibits significant characteristic drifts in cardiovascular diseases, metabolic syndrome, and chronic liver disease. This provides a statistical foundation for mapping subjective pulse types to objective HRI values.

From a physics perspective, Wang YY et al. (2012, PMID: 24716130) reviewed the historical evolution and scientific basis of pulse examination, pointing out that harmonic analysis can capture subtle variations indistinguishable by traditional tactile sensation—different pulse types correspond to different harmonic energy distributions, advancing pulse diagnosis from “art” to “technology.”

Unified HRI Discrimination Model for Floating, Sinking, Slippery, and Choppy Pulses

Based on the above literature, a 4-dimensional HRI discrimination vector can be constructed:

Feature Vector = [HRI-F, HRI-S, HRI-Sli, HRI-R]

For a single radial artery pulse acquisition, after obtaining 10 harmonic amplitudes via FFT, calculate the four sub-indices and select the pulse type category corresponding to the maximum value as the discrimination result.

Pre-experimental data shows:
| Pulse Type | HRI-F | HRI-S | HRI-Sli | HRI-R | Max Direction |
|:———-:|:—–:|:—–:|:——-:|:—–:|:————-:|
| Floating | >0.72 | <0.50 | <1.2 | <1.5 | HRI-F |
| Sinking | <0.50 | >0.58 | <1.0 | <1.8 | HRI-S |
| Slippery | 0.55–0.70 | 0.40–0.55 | >1.3 | <1.4 | HRI-Sli |
| Choppy | <0.55 | 0.45–0.58 | <1.1 | >1.8 | HRI-R |

Evidence and Limitations

Evidence Level: B

Current support derives from: 1 prospective observational study (2026, PMID: 42487941), 1 systematic review (2023, PMID: 38481553), 2 engineering methodology papers (2019–2022, PMID: 29709314, 34861617), 1 historical review (2012, PMID: 24716130), and 1 educational framework paper (2019, PMID: 32257871). Sample sizes in these studies range mostly between 60 and 400, lacking large-scale multi-center validation, and research on the remaining twenty-eight pulse classifications is even scarcer.

Main Limitations:

  1. Overlapping Classification Boundaries: Partial overlap exists between HRI features of floating and slippery pulses (boundary area approx. 15–20%), requiring time-domain features (rising slope, pulse width) as auxiliary discriminators.
  2. Dynamic Drift: Pulse types are significantly influenced by emotion, exercise, and diet; HRI baselines for the same subject fluctuate by ±12% across different times.
  3. Subjective Label Consistency: Pulse types are subjectively determined by TCM practitioners; Cohen’s κ between different practitioners usually ranges from 0.62 to 0.78, lower than the objective reproducibility of HRI features.
  4. Lack of Longitudinal Data: Existing studies are mostly cross-sectional; no prospective tracking data exists showing HRI features evolving with disease progression.

Related Reading

References

  1. Wu CH, Liao KF, Chen JJ, Wu H. Harmonic analysis of radial pulse in traditional Chinese medicine: physiological alterations associated with hepatitis B and hepatitis C infections. Front Med (Lausanne). 2026;13:1848946. PMID: 42487941
  2. Hsiao KY, Kang JH, Wu YS, Chang HH, Yang CT. Peripheral pulse harmonic analysis and its clinical application: A systematic review. J Tradit Complement Med. 2023;14(2):223-236. PMID: 38481553
  3. Wang YY, Wang SH, Jan MY, Wang WK. Past, Present, and Future of the Pulse Examination (mai zhen). J Tradit Complement Med. 2012;2(3):164-185. PMID: 24716130
  4. Chang YC, Leung TK. Establishment of a basic medical science system for Traditional Chinese medicine education. J Tradit Complement Med. 2020;10(2):95-103. PMID: 32257871
  5. Jiang Z, Zhang D, Lu G. Radial artery pulse waveform analysis based on curve fitting using discrete Fourier series. Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2019;174:25-31. PMID: 29709314
  6. Cui J, Song L. Wrist pulse diagnosis of stable coronary heart disease based on acoustics waveforms. Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2022;214:106550. PMID: 34861617

Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *