K1–K4 判档体系的分辨率下限:当档位比尺子还细

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: B

一句话结论

池④ 用 K1/K2/K3/K4 四档来决定”这个山头值不值得花钱去测”。本文逐格复算后给出的结论是:这套判档体系的分辨率(±3 dB 带宽)比它能拿到的参数精度(σ 只有一个数量级)细了一个量级,因此三档的实际有效域是空集,K4 不是”特殊情况兜底”,而是唯一诚实的默认档。

这个结论不来自任何新数据,只来自对文件自身三个数字的对照。三个数字都在库里,只是此前没有任何一轮把它们并排放过。


一、判档体系是什么,为什么它重要

high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md §6 与配套实验卡 P4-EXP-004 §4 定义了一套先验判档:

档 原文条件 原文含义
K1 可测 σ ≥ 3×10⁻² 且 连续厚度 ≥ 1.2 km 且 频段 ≥ 14 Hz 预期 A ≥ 10 dB,超出本底 → 值得投入实测
K2 边缘 落在 10 dB 线 ±3 dB 内 预期效应与未建模项同量级 → 强制双站差分
K3 透明 σ ≤ 10⁻³,任意 1–3 km 厚度,任意 1–30 Hz A < 2 dB → 不得作屏蔽论据
K4 不可判 仅有区域地质图 σ 估计(σ 不确定度 ≥ 1 个数量级) 三元表任何一格都跨 ±10 dB → 只能写”不可判定”

这套体系在库里承担的实际职能很重:它是 #14(靠山屏蔽系数实测)、#22(山体样本优先级)、#24/#25(Schumann 站选址)三个课题的共同前置闸门。判档判错,预算就投错样本。上一轮(第 22 轮)在池③ 立的「测量链分辨率下限」讲的正是这件事的另一面——先测尺子,再量东西。本文把同一把尺子转向池④ 自己的判档表。

复算所用公式就是文件自己写的那个:

A(dB) = 8.686 · d / δ,    δ = √(2/(ω μ₀ μᵣ σ))

代入后可以合并成一条更好用的形式(d 以米计):

A(dB) = 0.0172584 · d · √(μᵣ · σ · f)

下面全部数字都由这一条式子和文件自述的 σ / μᵣ 算出,不引入任何外部参数。工具 skin-depth-recompute.py judge 已独立复现。


二、第一处:K1 一档三定义

同一档 K1,在同一个文件家族里有三个互不等价的定义:

出处 K1 的条件 用 A(dB) 表达
文章 §6 表 σ ≥ 3×10⁻² 且 t ≥ 1.2 km 且 f ≥ 14 Hz 一个三维 AND 盒(不是 dB 门槛)
文章 §6 同表「含义」列 —— 预期 A ≥ 10 dB
工具 judge_tier() —— A ≥ 13 dB(= 10 dB 线 + 3 dB 带)

三者可以同时”正确”,因为它们在回答不同问题;但它们被并列写进同一张表,读者会当成一件事。差异有多大?把 AND 盒的角点代进去:

σ=3×10⁻², t=1.2 km, f=14 Hz
A = 0.0172584 × 1200 × √(3×10⁻² × 14) = 13.42 dB

角点值是 13.42 dB,不是 10 dB。「预期 A ≥ 10 dB」这句话在角点上偏低了 3.4 dB;若要让角点正好落在 10 dB,σ 得是 1.665×10⁻² 而不是 3×10⁻²。

方向更值得注意:AND 盒与 dB 门槛不是包含关系,而是交叉关系。 用工具逐个跑:

σ (S/m) t f (Hz) A (dB) 在 AND 盒内? 工具判档
1×10⁻¹ 1.0 km 7.83 15.27 ❌ 否(t<1.2km 且 f<14) K1
1×10⁻¹ 1.2 km 7.83 18.33 ❌ 否(f<14) K1
1×10⁻¹ 0.8 km 14 16.34 ❌ 否(t<1.2km) K1
3×10⁻² 1.2 km 7.83 10.04 ❌ 否(f<14) K2

第一行是最扎眼的:σ=10⁻¹、1 km、7.83 Hz 给出 15.27 dB——比 K1 门槛 13 dB 高出 2.3 dB,却因为”厚度差 200 m、频率差 6 Hz”被 AND 盒判成不合格。

物理上说不通:A 是 σ、t、f 的连续单调函数,任何”必须同时满足三个各自门槛”的盒子,都会在盒面上造出不连续跳变。一个场地的 t 从 1.19 km 改成 1.21 km,判档从”不值得测”跳到”值得测”,而 A 只变了 0.2 dB。

这不是判据严不严的问题,是判据的形状不对。 该判的是 A,不该判它的三个自变量。AND 盒唯一合理的用途是”预筛候选清单”(快速剔除明显不可能的组合),不能当成”值得测”的充分条件。


三、第二处:K3「任意厚度」是假的

K3 的原文写「σ ≤ 10⁻³,任意 1–3 km 厚度,任意 1–30 Hz → A < 2 dB」。

固定 σ=10⁻³,逐格算:

t f=7.83 Hz f=14 Hz f=30 Hz
1 km 1.53 dB 2.04 dB 2.99 dB
2 km 3.05 dB 4.08 dB 5.98 dB
3 km 4.58 dB 6.13 dB 8.97 dB

九格里只有一格满足”A < 2 dB”。最不利的一格 8.97 dB 是 2 dB 的 4.5 倍,并且已经越过 K2 下界(7 dB)——按工具自己的判档,σ=10⁻³, t=3 km, f=30 Hz 得到 K2-边缘,会触发”强制双站差分”规则。也就是说:K3 说”终止,不作屏蔽论据”,K2 说”进 Step 3,必须双站差分”,同一组参数被两条规则同时判给两个不同的处置。

反解真实边界:A<2 dB 允许的最大厚度是

t_max @30 Hz  = 669 m
t_max @7.83 Hz = 1 310 m

所以 K3 的正确表述不是”任意厚度”,而是 “σ ≤ 10⁻³ 且 t ≤ 0.67 km(按 30 Hz 最不利端)”。原文把 t_max 写成了”任意 1–3 km”,在 1–3 km 段高估了 1.5–4.5 倍。

这条错误的性质与第 20/21 轮修的那批不同:那批是数值错(δ 格算错倍率),这条是量词错——用”任意”把一个有限区间说成了全域。量词错的危害在于它不可通过复算单格发现:你随便抽一格可能都对,只有把边界推到端点才看得见。


四、第三处:K4 自己否证了 K1/K2/K3

这是本文最重要的一处,也是唯一不需要任何新计算的一处。

原文给 K4 的定义里写了这么一句:

仅有区域地质图估计(σ 不确定度 ≥ 1 个数量级)→ 三元表任何一格都跨 ±10 dB → 结论只能写「不可判定」。

这句话是对的。σ 差一个数量级(10×),而 A ∝ √σ,所以 A 摆动 √10 = 3.16 倍。在 A=10 dB 处,3.16 倍就是 10 dB 的摆动。原文的”±10 dB”准确。

问题在于:K2 的带宽是 ±3 dB。

一个 ±10 dB 的不确定度,套不进一个 ±3 dB 的判据带。这不是”精度差一点”,是参数误差比判据带宽大 3.3 倍。用一句更直白的话:你手上那把尺子的刻度抖动,比你要分辨的两个刻度之间的距离还宽。

把这个要求反解成对 σ 精度的要求(求 A 判到 ±3 dB 时,σ 允许的区间跨度):

目标 A 允许的 σ 区间 σ 需准到
5 dB ×0.16 – ×2.56 ±60%
7 dB(K3/K2 界) ×0.33 – ×2.04 ±41%
10 dB(K2 中心) ×0.49 – ×1.69 ±30%
13 dB(K2/K1 界) ×0.59 – ×1.51 ±23%
20 dB ×0.72 – ×1.32 ±15%

结论:要判 K1/K2/K3 任何一个边界,σ 必须准到 ±23%–±41%。

而现实中能拿到什么精度?

σ 精度 A 能可靠判到的上限
±2 倍(区间 4×) 3.00 dB
±3.16 倍(区间 10×,即 K4 定义) 1.39 dB
±10 倍(区间 100×,多数文献区间) 0.33 dB

K4 定义里那个”1 个数量级”,对应 A 只能判到 1.39 dB。而 K3 的上界是 7 dB。1.39 << 7,差 5 倍。

于是整件事就清楚了:

K4 的触发条件(σ 不确定度 ≥ 1 数量级)
  ⇒ A 只能判到 1.39 dB
  ⇒ 远小于 K3 的 7 dB 上界
  ⇒ K3/K2/K1 三档全部不可判
  ⇒ 任何满足 K4 触发条件的场地,必然全部落进 K4

K4 不是例外档,是默认档。它在表里被摆在第四行、写成”特殊情况”,实际覆盖面是判档体系的全部有效域——只要场地没有 ±40% 以内的实测 σ。

反过来说,K1/K2/K3 三档要成立,需要一个隐含前提:场地已有一份精度优于 ±40% 的实测 σ。这个前提在文件里从没写出来,也从没被检查过。而 #26(Schumann 站 σ 数据库)第 31 轮的自评是”6 站,a 级 0 站“——按该库自己的分级,一个 a 级都没有。


五、三处错误其实是同一个错误

把三处并排放:

# 表面现象 共同结构
1 K1 用 AND 盒判,不判 A 判据的维度选错——判了自变量,没判结果量
2 K3 用”任意”覆盖有限区间 判据的量词过宽——把 t_max 说成 ∞
3 ±3 dB 带宽 配 ±10 dB 输入精度 判据的分辨率高于输入分辨率

三者都指向同一件事:这套判档表是在”参数已知”的假设下设计的,而它的适用场景恰恰是”参数未知”。

再往下一层:为什么这个错误能存活这么多轮?因为它不在任何单格里。第 20 轮修的 6 行 δ 表是逐格复算能抓的;第 22 轮修的 SHAP φ₀ 是加性分解能抓的。本文这三处,逐格抽检任意一格都可能”对”,只有把判据的边界和参数的边界并排放才看得见。

这给出一条可迁移的方法学条目:

R26「判据分辨率必须与被判量的输入分辨率匹配」:任何分档/分级/阈值体系,除了检查”每一档的数值算对没有”,还必须检查”判据带宽 ÷ 输入不确定度”。比值 < 1 时,档位越多越有害——它给出的是伪精度。

R26 与已有几条的关系:

  • R13(区间不可单点判):R13 说”区间不能当单点”。R26 更进一步:即使你拿到了单点,也要问这个单点准到多少,判据带够不够宽。
  • R19(区间不可判 ≠ 区间没问题):R19 管”数值是否自洽”。R26 管”自洽的数值够不够用来分档”。两件事。
  • R22(canonical 表优先复算):R22 管”哪些表要复算”。R26 管”复算之后这张表能不能用”。
  • 池③ 第 22 轮「测量链分辨率下限」:那是一台设备换另一台设备引起的摆动。R26 是参数本身的不确定度。同族,但测量链分辨率下限能通过重复测量降低,σ 的不确定度在没做 MT 实测前降不下来——所以 R26 更硬:它不是”先测一下尺子”,是”这把尺子的刻度根本不够画这么多格”。

六、该怎么改(建议,须 JOE 批)

本文不修改任何已发布正文(见 §8 边界)。以下四条是给 D 清单的新增建议,不是已执行动作。

建议 1(P1,改动最小):K1 的 AND 盒降级为”候选预筛”,不再是”值得测”的判据;判档一律以 A(dB) 为准。同时把「预期 A ≥ 10 dB」与工具的「≥13 dB」统一成一个数——推荐直接用两条 dB 边界:A < 7 dB → K3、7 ≤ A < 13 → K2、A ≥ 13 → K1,删掉三个自变量的门槛句。

建议 2(P1,纯数值):K3 的量词从”任意 1–3 km 厚度”改为”t ≤ 0.67 km(30 Hz 最不利端)”,并在表下加一行 t_max 速查(30 Hz: 669 m / 7.83 Hz: 1 310 m)。

建议 3(P1,最重要):K4 从”第四档”提升为前置门禁——判 K1/K2/K3 之前先判 σ 精度,σ 不确定度 > ±41% 直接停,不进三档。这等价于承认”没有实测 σ 就没有档位”,与 #46a(补 f_meas 列)、#52(f_meas 原书溯源)是同一条因果链的下游。

建议 4(P2,工具):skin-depth-recompute.py judge 增加 --sigma-uncertainty <factor> 参数,输出”该 σ 精度下本判档是否可信”一行。这比再加判档功能有用——现有工具报 A 报得很准,但不报”这个 A 配不配分档”。


七、证据与局限

已有证据(可逐条复现):

  • 三处不一致全部由文件自述的公式与参数算出,skin-depth-recompute.py judge 独立复现了 §2 的四个反例与 §3 的 K2 误判(σ=10⁻³, t=3 km, f=30 Hz → A=8.97 dB → K2-边缘)。
  • 电磁屏蔽的工程背景有文献支撑(建筑地磁屏蔽实测:PMID 20000094;ELF 暴露测量:PMID 24131394;低磁环境生物效应综述:PMID 28654641)。
  • 岩石电导率的频率依赖(本判档”σ 当常数”这一近似的来源)有明确文献:Jonscher 通用介电响应(DOI 10.1038/267673a0)、Revil 非饱和多孔介质频段电导/介电模型(DOI 10.1029/2012WR012700)、Beskardes 低频电导率幂律分布(DOI 10.1093/gji/ggw375)。
  • 环境 ELF 与昼夜节律的关联有综述(PMID 36681118),仅作背景,不支撑任何屏蔽结论。

局限(必须与结论同读):

  1. 判”错”仅指”与文件自身声明的公式 / 参数区间不自洽”,不指地下真实 δ 或 A 为另一值。 若某档本意是某个未写出的等效 σ,问题从”算错”变成”没写清 σ”——但无论哪种,档位都不能按现在这样用。
  2. 全部为解析复算 + 文本解析,无任何实地测量。δ 公式本身假设均匀半空间、无位移电流、μᵣ 常数;真实山体分层、各向异性,且 σ 随频率弥散。
  3. 本文没有回答”靠山能不能屏蔽 ELF”这个物理问题,只回答”这套判档表能不能用来回答它”。目前的答案是:不能,除非先有 ±40% 以内的 σ。
  4. §4 的”K4 覆盖全部有效域”是一个逻辑推论,前提是接受 K4 自己的”≥1 数量级”定义。若将来 σ 实测精度提高到 ±40%,该推论失效——这正是希望它失效的方向。
  5. 本文未审计 skin-depth-reference-table.md §三 的 9 行(第 20 轮已单独审计过,6 行不自洽),也未重开 D18/D21/D22 的 δ 数值错配——那批是另一类错误(数值错),本文是判据结构错,两者不应合并处理。
  6. §5 的 R26 是从本例抽象出的方法学条目,只经本库这一处实例检验,尚未在池①②③⑤交叉验证。按 R11「零参数判据只可证伪不可验证」,R26 目前只承担”发现伪精度”的职能,不能反过来当”判据合格”的证明。

八、本轮未做(守边界)

  • 未修改任何已发布正文:high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md、skin-depth-reference-table.md、skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md、pool4-high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md(P4-EXP-004)全部 mtime 未动。
  • 未修改 skin-depth-recompute.py(建议 4 留待 JOE 批后单独做,避免”改了哪一处导致判档变化”无法归因)。
  • 未做 σ 实测;未新增”靠山→健康”通路(净增通路 0);未标 accepted;未直写 779/782;未新增或修改任何 OC cron 与心跳配置。
  • §6 四条建议全部停留在建议层,需 JOE 批后才可执行正文更正。

九、相关阅读

  • 《高电导岩性 ELF 屏蔽路径》(#42)——K1–K4 判档表的原始出处
  • 《趋肤深度对照表》(#16)——δ 数值层的对照表,第 20 轮已审出 6 行不自洽
  • 《靠山地形 ELF 屏蔽系数实测》(#14)——判档表的直接消费者
  • 《山体样本 σ 预筛 SOP》(#22)——被本判档体系修正过的上一版门槛
  • 《区间断言逐条判定》(第 52 轮)——区间层的处置;本文处理的是判据层

本文为 draft。结论为”文件内部判据结构不自洽”的方法学审计,不构成任何关于山体电磁屏蔽、建筑屏蔽或人体健康的实测声明与健康建议。
进入 779 终版前须走 intake;进入 782 前须去 AI 化。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的衰减量、电导率区间与判档门槛均为工程公式在文献参数下的推算,非实测值;真实地下介质存在分层、各向异性与频率弥散,实际结果可能显著偏离。任何”居住环境电磁条件与健康”的推论均停留在假说层,须经独立实验与同行评议后方可对外表述;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

Resolution floor of the K1–K4 grading system: when the grade scale is finer than the ruler

Evidence level: B

One-Sentence Conclusion

Chi④ uses the four tiers K1/K2/K3/K4 to decide “whether this hilltop is worth spending money on to measure.” After recalculating each tier individually, the conclusion is: the resolution of this judgment system (±3 dB bandwidth) is one order of magnitude finer than the parameter precision it can obtain (σ spans only one order of magnitude); therefore, the actual effective domain of the three tiers is empty, and K4 is not a “special-case fallback” but the only honest default tier.

This conclusion does not come from any new data, but from cross-referencing three numbers already present in the file. All three numbers exist in the repository; they were simply never placed side-by-side in any prior round of analysis.

I. What is the Tiering System and Why Is It Important

high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md §6 and the accompanying experimental card P4-EXP-004 §4 define a priori tiering:

Tier Original Condition Original Meaning
K1 Measurable σ ≥ 3×10⁻² and continuous thickness ≥ 1.2 km and frequency band ≥ 14 Hz Expected attenuation A ≥ 10 dB, exceeding background → warrants field measurement
K2 Edge Falls within 10 dB line ±3 dB Expected effect and unmodeled terms are of the same order → forces dual-site differencing
K3 Transparent σ ≤ 10⁻³, any 1–3 km thickness, any 1–30 Hz A < 2 dB → cannot serve as shielding evidence
K4 Untierable Only regional geological map σ estimate (σ uncertainty ≥ 1 order of magnitude) Ternary table any cell spans ±10 dB → can only write “undetermined”

This system bears heavy practical responsibility within the repository: it serves as the common upstream gate for projects #14 (back-shield coefficient measurement), #22 (mountain sample priority), and #24/#25 (Schumann station siting). Mis-tiering results in misallocated budgets. The previous round (Round 22) established the “measurement chain resolution floor” in pool ③, which addresses another facet of this issue—measure the ruler first, then measure things. This paper turns the same ruler toward pool ④’s own tiering table.

The formulas used for recalculation are exactly those written in the file itself:

A(dB) = 8.686 · d / δ,    δ = √(2/(ω μ₀ μᵣ σ))

Substituting yields a more convenient combined form (with d in meters):

A(dB) = 0.0172584 · d · √(μᵣ · σ · f)

All subsequent numbers are derived solely from this equation and the file’s stated σ / μᵣ values, introducing no external parameters. The tool skin-depth-recompute.py judge independently reproduced these results.

II. First Instance: Three Non-Equivalent Definitions for Tier K1

The same tier, K1, possesses three mutually non-equivalent definitions within the same document family:

Source Condition for K1 Expressed via A(dB)
Article §6 Table σ ≥ 3×10⁻² and t ≥ 1.2 km and f ≥ 14 Hz A three-dimensional AND box (not an A threshold)
Article §6 same table “Meaning” column — Expected A ≥ 10 dB
Tool judge_tier() — A ≥ 13 dB (= 10 dB line + 3 dB band)

All three can simultaneously be “correct” because they answer different questions; yet they are listed side-by-side in the same table, leading readers to treat them as a single criterion. How significant is the discrepancy? Substituting the corner points of the AND box:

σ=3×10⁻², t=1.2 km, f=14 Hz
A = 0.0172584 × 1200 × √(3×10⁻² × 14) = 13.42 dB

The corner value is 13.42 dB, not 10 dB. The statement “Expected A ≥ 10 dB” underestimates the corner by 3.4 dB; for the corner to fall exactly at 10 dB, σ would need to be 1.665×10⁻² rather than 3×10⁻².

The direction of the discrepancy is more noteworthy: the AND box and the A threshold are not nested but intersecting. Running the tool iteratively:

σ (S/m) t f (Hz) A (dB) Inside AND box? Tool tier
1×10⁻¹ 1.0 km 7.83 15.27 ❌ No (t<1.2km and f<14) K1
1×10⁻¹ 1.2 km 7.83 18.33 ❌ No (f<14) K1
1×10⁻¹ 0.8 km 14 16.34 ❌ No (t<1.2km) K1
3×10⁻² 1.2 km 7.83 10.04 ❌ No (f<14) K2

The first row is the most striking: σ=10⁻¹, 1 km, 7.83 Hz yields 15.27 dB—2.3 dB above the K1 threshold of 13 dB—yet the AND box deems it ineligible due to “thickness difference of 200 m and frequency difference of 6 Hz.”

This is physically inconsistent: A is a continuous monotonic function of σ, t, and f; any “box requiring simultaneous satisfaction of three individual thresholds” creates discontinuous jumps on the box faces. Changing a site’s t from 1.19 km to 1.21 km shifts the tier judgment from “not worth measuring” to “worth measuring,” while A changes only by 0.2 dB.

This is not a matter of strictness but of shape. The criterion should judge A, not its three independent variables. The AND box’s only rational use is as a “pre-screening candidate list” (rapidly eliminating obviously impossible combinations), not as a sufficient condition for “worth measuring.”

III. Second Point: K3’s “Arbitrary Thickness” is False

The original text of K3 states “σ ≤ 10⁻³, arbitrary thickness 1–3 km, arbitrary frequency 1–30 Hz → A < 2 dB”.

Fixing σ = 10⁻³ and calculating cell-by-cell:

t f = 7.83 Hz f = 14 Hz f = 30 Hz
1 km 1.53 dB 2.04 dB 2.99 dB
2 km 3.05 dB 4.08 dB 5.98 dB
3 km 4.58 dB 6.13 dB 8.97 dB

Only one of the nine cells satisfies “A < 2 dB”. The most unfavorable cell, 8.97 dB, is 4.5 times the 2 dB threshold and already exceeds the K2 lower bound (7 dB)—according to the tool’s own classification, σ = 10⁻³, t = 3 km, f = 30 Hz yields K2-edge, triggering the “mandatory dual-station differencing” rule. In other words: K3 says “terminate, do not use as shielding evidence,” while K2 says “proceed to Step 3, must apply dual-station differencing.” The same set of parameters is assigned two different dispositions by two conflicting rules.

Reversing to find the true boundary: the maximum thickness allowed under A < 2 dB is

t_max @30 Hz  = 669 m
t_max @7.83 Hz = 1 310 m

Thus the correct statement of K3 is not “arbitrary thickness,” but “σ ≤ 10⁻³ and t ≤ 0.67 km (at the most unfavorable end, 30 Hz).” The original text erroneously writes t_max as “arbitrary 1–3 km,” overestimating the range by 1.5–4.5 times within the 1–3 km segment.

The nature of this error differs from those corrected in rounds 20/21: those were numerical errors (incorrect multiplication factors in the δ-grid calculation), whereas this is a quantifier error—using “arbitrary” to describe a finite interval as if it were universal. The danger of such quantifier errors lies in their undetectability via single-cell recalculation: randomly selecting one cell may yield a correct result; only pushing the boundary to its extreme reveals the discrepancy.

IV. Third Instance: K4 Self-Nullifies K1/K2/K3

This is the most critical section of this paper, and the only one requiring no new calculations.

The definition provided for K4 states:

Regional geological map estimates alone (σ uncertainty ≥ 1 order of magnitude) → any cell in the ternary table spans ±10 dB → conclusion must be “undecidable.”

This statement is correct. A σ difference of one order of magnitude (10×), with A ∝ √σ, results in an A fluctuation of √10 = 3.16 times. At A = 10 dB, this 3.16-fold variation equals a ±10 dB swing. The original “±10 dB” is accurate.

The problem lies in: K2’s bandwidth is ±3 dB.

A ±10 dB uncertainty cannot fit within a ±3 dB decision band. This is not “slightly imprecise”; it is a parameter error 3.3 times larger than the decision bandwidth. In plainer terms: the jitter of the scale on your ruler is wider than the distance between the two marks you are trying to distinguish.

Reversing this requirement to determine the necessary σ precision (finding the allowable σ interval span when A is judged to ±3 dB):

Target A Allowed σ Interval Required σ Accuracy
5 dB ×0.16 – ×2.56 ±60%
7 dB (K3/K2 boundary) ×0.33 – ×2.04 ±41%
10 dB (K2 center) ×0.49 – ×1.69 ±30%
13 dB (K2/K1 boundary) ×0.59 – ×1.51 ±23%
20 dB ×0.72 – ×1.32 ±15%

Conclusion: To judge any boundary of K1/K2/K3, σ must be accurate to ±23%–±41%.

What precision is realistically achievable?

σ Accuracy Maximum Reliable A Judgment
±2× (interval 4×) 3.00 dB
±3.16× (interval 10×, i.e., K4 definition) 1.39 dB
±10× (interval 100×, common in literature) 0.33 dB

The “1 order of magnitude” in the K4 definition corresponds to an A judgment limit of only 1.39 dB. Since the upper bound for K3 is 7 dB, and 1.39 << 7 (a factor of 5 difference), the entire scenario becomes clear:

K4 Trigger Condition (σ uncertainty ≥ 1 order of magnitude)
  ⇒ A can only be judged up to 1.39 dB
  ⇒ Far below K3's 7 dB upper bound
  ⇒ All three tiers (K3/K2/K1) become undecidable
  ⇒ Any site meeting K4 trigger conditions inevitably falls entirely into K4

K4 is not an exception tier; it is the default tier. Although placed in the fourth row of the table and labeled “special case,” its actual coverage encompasses the entire valid domain of the decision tier system—provided the site lacks measured σ within ±40%.

Conversely, for the K1/K2/K3 tiers to hold, an implicit prerequisite exists: the site must possess measured σ with accuracy better than ±40%. This prerequisite is never stated in the document, nor ever checked. As noted in #26 (Schumann station σ database), the self-assessment of round 31 states “6 stations, zero a-grade stations“—according to its own classification, not a single a-grade station exists.

V. Three Errors Are Actually One Error

Placing the three errors side-by-side:

# Surface Phenomenon Shared Structure
1 K1 uses an AND gate for judgment but does not evaluate A Dimensional mismatch of the criterion—the criterion evaluates the independent variable, not the outcome quantity
2 K3 uses “arbitrary” to cover a finite interval Overly broad quantifier in the criterion—stating t_max as ∞
3 ±3 dB bandwidth paired with ±10 dB input precision Criterion resolution exceeds input resolution

All three point to the same issue: this grading table was designed under the assumption of “known parameters,” yet its intended application scenario is precisely “unknown parameters.”

Going one layer deeper: why has this error persisted through so many rounds? Because it does not reside in any single cell. The 6-row δ table revised in round 20 could be caught by recalculating cell-by-cell; the SHAP φ₀ revised in round 22 could be caught by additive decomposition. These three errors in this paper, however, can only be revealed by placing the boundaries of the criterion and the boundaries of the parameters side-by-side.

This yields a transferable methodological entry:

R26 “Criterion resolution must match the input resolution of the quantity being judged”: Any tiering/grading/threshold system, besides checking whether “the numerical value of each tier is calculated correctly,” must also check whether “criterion bandwidth ÷ input uncertainty.” When the ratio is < 1, more tiers are more harmful—they provide pseudo-precision.

Relationships of R26 with existing entries:

  • R13 (interval cannot be judged as a single point): R13 states “an interval cannot be treated as a single point.” R26 goes further: even if you obtain a single point, you must ask how precise this point is and whether the criterion bandwidth is wide enough.
  • R19 (interval cannot be judged ≠ interval is fine): R19 manages “whether values are internally consistent.” R26 manages “whether internally consistent values are sufficient for tiering.” These are two distinct matters.
  • R22 (canonical tables take priority for recalculation): R22 manages “which tables require recalculation.” R26 manages “whether this table can be used after recalculation.”
  • Pool③ Round 22 “measurement chain resolution lower limit”: That refers to fluctuation caused by swapping one device for another. R26 refers to uncertainty inherent in the parameters themselves. They belong to the same family, but the measurement chain resolution lower limit can be reduced through repeated measurements, whereas σ uncertainty cannot be reduced until MT actual measurement is performed—thus R26 is more stringent: it is not “measure the ruler first,” but “the scale of this ruler is fundamentally insufficient to draw so many tiers.”

VI. How to modify (Suggestions, subject to JOE’s review)

This paper does not alter any published text (see §8 Boundary). The following four items are new additions to the D list, not actions already executed.

Suggestion 1 (P1, minimal change): Downgrade the AND box of K1 to “candidate pre-screening,” no longer serving as the criterion for “worth testing.” All categorization shall be based solely on A(dB). Simultaneously, unify the “expected A ≥ 10 dB” and the tool’s “≥13 dB” into a single numerical scale. It is recommended to directly adopt two dB boundaries: A < 7 dB → K3, 7 ≤ A < 13 → K2, A ≥ 13 → K1, thereby removing the three threshold sentences involving independent variables.

Suggestion 2 (P1, purely numerical): Change the quantifier for K3 from “any 1–3 km thickness” to “t ≤ 0.67 km (worst-case at 30 Hz),” and add a row for t_max quick reference beneath the table (30 Hz: 669 m / 7.83 Hz: 1,310 m).

Suggestion 3 (P1, most important): Upgrade K4 from “fourth tier” to preliminary gate—assess σ accuracy before judging K1/K2/K3. If the uncertainty of σ exceeds ±41%, stop immediately and do not enter any tier. This is equivalent to acknowledging “no measured σ means no tiers,” which lies downstream of the same causal chain as #46a (adding f_meas column) and #52 (original source tracing for f_meas).

Suggestion 4 (P2, tool): The skin-depth-recompute.py judge script should add the --sigma-uncertainty <factor> parameter, outputting a line stating “whether this σ accuracy makes the current categorization credible.” This is more useful than adding another categorization function—existing tools report A very accurately but do not indicate “whether this A matches the required tier.”

VII. Evidence and Limitations

Existing evidence (reproducible item by item):

  • All three inconsistencies were derived from the formulas and parameters explicitly stated in the document, independently reproduced by skin-depth-recompute.py judge. This re-computation confirmed the four counterexamples from §2 and the K2 misjudgment from §3 (with σ=10⁻³, t=3 km, f=30 Hz → A=8.97 dB → K2-edge).
  • The engineering background for electromagnetic shielding is supported by literature (measured geomagnetic shielding in buildings: PMID 20000094; ELF exposure measurement: PMID 24131394; review of biological effects in low-magnetic environments: PMID 28654641).
  • The frequency dependence of rock conductivity (the source of the approximation “σ treated as constant” in this grading scheme) is explicitly documented: Jonscher universal dielectric response (DOI 10.1038/267673a0), Revil non-saturated porous medium conductivity/dielectric models (DOI 10.1029/2012WR012700), Beskardes power-law distribution of low-frequency conductivity (DOI 10.1093/gji/ggw375).
  • The association between environmental ELF and circadian rhythms is reviewed (PMID 36681118), serving only as background and not supporting any shielding conclusion.

Limitations (must be read alongside the conclusions):

  1. Judging “wrong” refers only to “inconsistency with the formulas and parameter ranges explicitly stated in the document itself,” not to the true subsurface δ or A having different values. If a grading scheme was intended for an unstated equivalent σ, the problem shifts from “calculated incorrectly” to “σ not clearly defined”—but either way, the grading scheme cannot be used as currently formulated.
  2. All calculations are analytical re-computations plus text parsing; no field measurements were conducted. The δ formula itself assumes a uniform half-space, no displacement current, and constant μᵣ; real mountain strata are layered and anisotropic, and σ disperses with frequency.
  3. This paper does not answer the physical question “Can a mountain backshield ELF?” It only answers “Can this grading scheme be used to answer that question.” The current answer is: no, unless σ is known within ±40%.
  4. The claim in §4 that “K4 covers the entire valid domain” is a logical inference, contingent on accepting K4’s own definition of “≥1 order of magnitude.” If future σ measurement precision improves to ±40%, this inference will fail—precisely the direction we hope it fails.
  5. This paper did not audit the 9 rows in §3 of skin-depth-reference-table.md (the 20th iteration was already audited separately, with 6 rows found inconsistent), nor did it re-open the δ value mismatches for D18/D21/D22—those represent a different class of error (numerical mismatch), whereas this paper addresses structural errors in the judgment criteria; the two should not be merged.
  6. The R26 in §5 is a methodological item abstracted from this example, validated only by this single instance in the current repository, not cross-validated across pools ①②③⑤. Per R11 “zero-parameter criteria can only be falsified, not verified,” R26 currently serves only the function of “detecting false precision” and cannot itself serve as proof that “the criteria are qualified.”

VIII. This Cycle: Not Done (Boundary Preservation)

  • No modification of any published main text: high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md, skin-depth-reference-table.md, skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md, and pool4-high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md (P4-EXP-004) all retain their original modification times (mtime).
  • skin-depth-recompute.py remains unmodified: (Recommended to reserve this for JOE’s post-approval separate execution, to avoid ambiguity regarding which specific alteration caused changes in the evidence-level categorization).
  • No σ measurements conducted; no new pathway established from “backrest” (a traditional consensus concept referring to a supportive spatial form) to “health” (net new pathways: 0); no items marked as accepted; no direct insertion of values 779/782; and no new or modified OC cron or heartbeat configurations.
  • The four recommendations in §6 remain strictly at the suggestion level and require JOE’s approval before any formal text corrections can be executed.

9. Related Reading

  • High Conductivity Rock ELF Shielding Path (#42) — the original source of the K1–K4 classification table.
  • Skin Depth Reference Table (#16) — a reference table for δ numerical layers; the 20th review round identified six rows as internally inconsistent.
  • Backslope Terrain ELF Shielding Coefficient Field Test (#14) — the direct consumer of the classification table.
  • Mountain Sample σ Pre-screening SOP (#22) — the previous threshold version revised by this classification system.
  • Interval Statement Step-by-Step Evaluation (Round 52) — the interval layer processing; this paper addresses the criteria layer.

This article is a draft. The conclusion that “the internal criteria structure of the document is self-inconsistent” represents a methodological audit and does not constitute any field-measured declaration or health recommendation regarding mountain electromagnetic shielding, building shielding, or human health.

Before entering the final version 779, intake procedures must be completed; before entering version 782, AI-driven elements must be removed.

Disclaimer: This article serves as an organized comparison and research design discussion of traditional knowledge and scientific literature, intended solely for understanding and reference. It does not constitute medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis and treatment. The attenuation values, conductivity intervals, and classification thresholds mentioned herein are calculated via engineering formulas based on literature parameters, not field-measured values. Actual subsurface media exhibit layering, anisotropy, and frequency dispersion, meaning real-world results may deviate significantly. Any inference regarding “residential environment electromagnetic conditions and health” remains at the hypothesis level and must undergo independent experimentation and peer review before external publication. If you experience physical discomfort or health concerns, please consult a medical professional for diagnosis and treatment.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *