Evidence level: C
池④ · 关联 #51(P1)|配套治理卡
08-ops/experiments/pool4-sigma-interval-tier-governance.md(P4-AUDIT-006)
证据等级 C|状态 draft|本轮对既有正文写入 = 0
0. 一句话结论
上一轮(#46a)手工判出「钢筋混凝土」「黏土/页岩」两行跨档,并说这是 #37 漏掉的一整类问题。
本轮把这一类工具化(sigma-interval-tier-audit.py,自检 15/15 通过)后全库扫描,结论比预期硬得多:
本库 31 个带 σ 区间的表格行里,没有任何一行的区间比窄到「无论厚度多少都必然同档」。
原因是有一个恒等式:A_max/A_min = √(σmax/σmin),与厚度 z、频率 f 都无关。所以「跨不跨档」只由区间比 q 与 z 共同决定;而 q ≤ (13/7)² = 3.449 时才算无条件安全。实测 31 行里 q 最小值就是 10 倍 —— 一行都没进安全区。
1. 为什么这个问题必须用恒等式判,不能靠逐行试算
趋肤深度与衰减:
δ(σ) = 1/√(π f μ σ) A_dB(z) = 8.686 · z · √(π f μ σ)
两式相乘约掉 σ 的平方根关系,得到本文唯一真正需要的东西:
A_max / A_min = √(σmax / σmin) = √q ← 与 z、f 均无关
第一个推论:一个 σ 区间的「A 展开倍数」是区间自身的常数。σ 跨 100 倍 → A 跨 10 倍;跨 10 倍 → A 跨 3.16 倍。
第二个推论(关键):判定档 K2 带只有 7→13 dB,宽 1.857 倍。要让 A 的两端必落同一档,必须 √q ≤ 1.857,即
q ≤ (13/7)² = 3.449 ← 无条件安全线
q 超过 3.449,就一定存在某个厚度使 A 从 K3 穿到 K1。这不代表「这行一定错」,而代表「这行不能在不锁 z 的前提下给单一档位结论」。
这把「区间跨档」从逐行试算变成了一个可批量的判据 —— 而且判据本身不含 z,所以连 z 都不知道的行也能判。
2. 全库扫描结果:925 文件 / 117 行 / 31 区间行
| 指标 | 数值 |
|---|---|
| 扫描文件 | 925(03-sites/cn/topics/science-yixue + 08-ops/experiments) |
| 表格总数 | 866 |
| 其中含 σ 列 | 31 |
| σ 数值行 | 117 |
| 其中区间行 | 31 |
| 区间行 q ≤ 3.449(无条件安全) | 0 |
| 区间行 q > 3.449(存在跨档 z) | 31 |
| 有 z 且实测跨档 | 5 |
| 有 z 且实测同档 | 2 |
| 无 z(彻底欠定) | 24 |
四层分级(本轮的实质产出):
| 层 | 含义 | 行数 | 处置 |
|---|---|---|---|
| L0 | 无条件安全(√q ≤ 1.857,任意 z 同档) | 0 | — |
| L1 | 条件安全(√q > 1.857 但锁定的 z 下两端同档) | 2 | 保留,必须写出 z |
| L2 | 跨档(锁定的 z 下两端不同档) | 5 | 禁止唯一结论,改双列或加条件 |
| L3 | 欠定(连 z 都没写) | 24 | 禁止任何档位结论,先补 z |
3. L2:5 行已确证的跨档行
| 文件 | 行 | σ 区间 | q | z | A 两端 | 档位跳动 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md |
湿花岗岩(含水/含矿) | 10⁻³–10⁻¹ | 100 | 1 km | 1.53→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
| 同上 | 湿玄武岩 | 10⁻²–10⁰ | 100 | 1 km | 4.83→48.29 dB | K3→K1 |
| 同上 | B 档(条件性测) | 10⁻³–10⁻¹ | 100 | 1 km | 1.53→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md |
B 档 | 10⁻³–10⁻¹ | 100 | 1 km | 1.53→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md |
A′ | 10⁻²–10⁻¹ | 10 | 1 km | 4.83→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
最刺眼的是「B 档(条件性测)」:#22 SOP 给它写的是「1–10 dB、中、验证 H0/H1 边界」。但按它自己声明的 σ 区间 10⁻³–10⁻¹、1 km 复算,下端 1.53 dB、上端 15.27 dB——上端已经越过 K1 门槛,不是「中」而是「可测」。这行的建议(”A 档测完仍有预算再上”)建立在区间下端,而它的上端已经够格排在 A 档。
反过来看,「A′」行(10⁻²–10⁻¹,标注「中(需 ≥2 km 山体或降低门槛到 5 dB)」)的下端 4.83 dB 其实是偏低的——它的建议方向没错,但同样只看了区间一端。
共同点:这 5 行都在用区间的一端代表整行。 而 q=100 意味着另一端差 10 倍。
4. L3:24 行的 z 根本没写,连跨不跨档都无法判
24 行分布在 building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md(6)、schumann-station-sigma-literature-values.md(6)、skin-depth-reference-table.md §二(5)、pool4-sigma-fmeas-directional-judgment-sop.md(5)、schumann-station-sigma-database.md(2)。
这些行只给了「介质 / σ / μr」,没有厚度列、没有 A(dB) 值。工具对它们的处理是给「歧义 z 带」而不是判档:
以 σ 10⁻³–10⁻¹(q=100,√q=10)为例,7.83 Hz:
| 门槛 | 歧义 z 带 | 读法 |
|---|---|---|
| 7 dB(K3→K2) | 458 m – 4.58 km | z 小于 458 m,两端都在 K3;z 大于 4.58 km,两端都在 K2 以上 |
| 13 dB(K2→K1) | 851 m – 8.51 km | 落在带内 = 无法判档 |
这条带最宽 10 倍。 「1 km 山体」正好落在 7 dB 与 13 dB 两条带的交点区域——这就是为什么同一个「1 km、湿花岗岩」在不同文件里能被写成「透明」也能被写成「数十 dB」。
这不是文件互相矛盾,是每一份都只取了区间的一个端点。
5. 附带发现:#22 / #25 两张表的 δ 列系统性偏大 37.25 倍
扫描中顺带核对 δ 列时发现一处不属区间问题、但更基础的事实。
mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md §一 与 schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md §一 共用一张三档表,其 δ 列声明:
| 行 | σ 区间 | δ 声明 | 7.83 Hz 实算 | 判读 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 普通花岗岩(干) | 10⁻⁸–10⁻⁴ | 数百米–数千米 | 18.0 km – 1800 km | 数量级不符(差 2–3 个量级) |
| 湿花岗岩 | 10⁻³–10⁻¹ | 几十米–几百米 | 0.569 km – 5.69 km | 数量级不符(差 1–2 个量级) |
| 湿玄武岩 | 10⁻²–10⁰ | 几米–几十米 | 0.180 km – 1.80 km | 数量级不符(差 1–2 个量级) |
引用一张表的具体数字比逐行比对更硬:schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md 明写「A 档 σ ≥ 10⁻² → δ ≤ 67 km」。而 σ=10⁻² 在 7.83 Hz 的 δ 是 1.7986 km——
67 km / 1.7986 km = 37.2508
差 37.25 倍。 而 mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md §二 的 A 档判据写「σ ≥ 10⁻² → ≥ 10 dB」,B 档写「δ 几十米–几百米」,两文件用的是同一套数字,37.25 这个比值在两文件上完全一致。
反推:要让 σ=10⁻² 给出 67 km,等效频率必须是 0.00564 Hz,不是 7.83 Hz。
这说明这两张表的 δ 列不是按 7.83 Hz 算的,而是从同一个上游数值整段继承来的(否则不会在两文件撞出同一个 37.25)。
而这个错误 #37 扫描器抓不到:我对这两个文件单独跑 delta-table-scan.py,结果是「命中文件 0|断言总数 0」——完全没解析进去。原因是它的表头感知规则没把「δ(7.83 Hz)」这一列认成 δ 列,于是整张表被跳过。
这与第 9 轮的教训同型:工具跑通了,但指标没覆盖到目标。区别是这次是覆盖率漏了,不是指标选错了。
必须分清:A(dB) 列不是算错,是区间覆盖不全。
| 行 | σ 区间两端实算 A | 表里写的 A | 覆盖情况 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 湿花岗岩(#22 §一) | 1.53 – 15.27 dB | 「1–10 dB 量级」 | 下端近似对,上端漏了 5.27 dB(越 K1) |
| 湿玄武岩(#22 §一) | 4.83 – 48.29 dB | 「数十 dB 量级」 | 上端对,下端 4.83 dB 不是「数十」 |
所以不能说「整表错」——δ 列错、A 列对但覆盖不全,两类问题互相独立。
6. 对本池既有产出的影响
| 既有产出 | 影响 |
|---|---|
#16 skin-depth-reference-table.md §三 δ 表 |
不在 37.25 倍问题内(该表 δ 与公式一致,实测 σ=10⁻⁴ → 17.99 km 对得上)。但 §二 参数表被工具认出 5 个区间行,q=10 或 100,属 L3 欠定(该表本来就不给 z,按参数表口径处置,见治理卡 §4) |
#22 mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md |
δ 列需重算(37.25× 偏差);A 列可用;三档判定(A/B/C)建立在 A 列上,故分档结论本身不动,但「1–10 dB」「数十 dB」的区间写法应改 |
#25 schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md |
同上:δ 列需重算,「δ ≤ 67 km」应改 1.8 km;A 档判据(σ ≥ 10⁻²)不受影响 |
| #37 全量扫描(59 格 MISMATCH) | 结论不变(那是表内自洽性);但需明确它的覆盖率不含这两文件,不能拿「0 命中」当「无问题」 |
| #46a / P4-AUDIT-005(f_meas 方向性) | 本轮与之正交:f_meas 决定「σ 锚在哪个频率」,q 决定「区间内能差多少」。两者可叠加:真实不确定度 ≈ √q × f_meas 因子 |
| #14 H1a 门槛(≤3 dB) | 维持 P4-AUDIT-005 的判断:反对下调 |
7. 证据与局限
已有证据(可核):
A_max/A_min = √(σmax/σmin)与q ≤ (13/7)² = 3.449无条件安全线,均为解析恒等式,不依赖任何文献假设;- 全库扫描数字(925 文件 / 866 表 / 31 含 σ 表 / 117 σ 行 / 31 区间行 / 5 跨档 / 24 无 z)可由
sigma-interval-tier-audit.py scan逐条复现,JSON 可导出; - 工具自检 15/15 通过,含「跨档判定」「同档判定」「上标科学计数法解析」「区间分隔符与上标负号区分」四类边界用例;
- δ 列 37.25 倍偏差是对两个文件逐字符复算,且两处在不同 σ 上撞出同一比值,属文件层面可确证;
- 岩石 σ 强频率依赖有 5 篇独立文献支撑(Mehran 1977、Jonscher 1977、Revil 2013、Laštovičková 1992、Hall 2004),说明「区间」不是纸面虚构而是真实的物理不确定度;
- 3 个 PMID 经 E-utilities 回查、5 个 DOI 经 Crossref 回查,题名/首作者/期刊/年份全部一致。
局限(必须与结论同时读):
- 37.25 倍偏差的成因本文不给结论。只确证「等效频率 0.00564 Hz」与「两处比值一致」,不猜测上游是手算失误、单位混淆还是抄自另一频率的表;不排除是该表作者有意使用了一个低频口径(但表头明写 7.83 Hz,故按表头判为不符);
- 工具只认 markdown 表格。正文里的裸数值断言(如「某山体衰减 3 dB」)不在覆盖范围内,与第 9 轮裸列表问题同型;
- 117 / 31 这两个数字是「被工具认出的」,不是「库里真实存在的」。未认出 ≠ 不存在;本次已因表头规则少认两张关键表(见 §5),故实际 σ 行数应 ≥ 117;
- 判定档门槛 13/7 dB 是池④ 自定,不是行业标准。若门槛改,3.449 这条线随之变(q ≤ (T_K1/T_K2)²);本文不主张该门槛经外部验证;
- 良导体近似、无限厚板、垂直入射三重简化仍在,A(dB) 绝对值不主张任何场地真值;
- q > 3.449 不等于「这行错了」。它等于「这行不能在不锁 z 的前提下给单一档位结论」——这是欠定,不是错误。
8. 给下一轮的动作建议
| 优先级 | 动作 | 依赖 |
|---|---|---|
| P1 | L3 的 24 行补 z 列——这是解锁全部判定的唯一前置,纯本地 0 成本 | 无 |
| P1 | L2 的 5 行改双列(区间下端 / 上端各一列 + 档位),或加「本行限于 σ 取 X 时」条件句 | 需 JOE 授权改既有正文 |
| P1 | #22/#25 δ 列重算(37.25× 偏差)——纯算术,但改的是已发布文章正文,需 JOE 授权 | 需 JOE |
| P2 | delta-table-scan.py 补表头规则,覆盖「δ(7.83 Hz)」这类带单位的列名 |
本地可做 |
| P2 | 把 q ≤ (T₁/T₂)² 无条件安全线写进 P4-AUDIT-004,作为新写表的准入检查 | 本地可做 |
| P3 | 反向扫池③ OMOP 三轴归因表与池⑤ F1–F5 门槛是否也有同型欠定 | 待 P1 完成 |
本文为 draft。 全部为解析复算 + 本库文件文本解析,无实地测量。
不构成对任何具体山体/场地 ELF 衰减的真值声明。
进入 779 终版前需走 intake;进入 782 前需去 AI 化。
「31 行里 0 行无条件安全」是本轮最硬的数字,也是最不该被包装成「已修复」的数字——它只是把欠定说清楚了,一行都还没改。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Sigma Interval Spanning Audit: No Row in the 31-Row Query Is Unconditionally Safe
Evidence level: C
Pool④ · Related #51 (P1) | Supporting Governance Card
08-ops/experiments/pool4-sigma-interval-tier-governance.md(P4-AUDIT-006)
Evidence Level C | Status draft | Write count for existing body in this round = 0
0. One-Sentence Conclusion
In the previous iteration (#46a), manual analysis identified two rows spanning category boundaries (“reinforced concrete,” “clay/shale”) and flagged this as a whole new category of issues missed in #37.
This iteration toolized the audit using sigma-interval-tier-audit.py (all 15 self-checks passed) and scanned the entire database. The conclusion is far more stringent than anticipated:
Among the 31 table rows in this library containing σ intervals, not a single row has an interval narrow enough to may support categorization regardless of thickness.
This stems from the identity: A_max/A_min = √(σmax/σmin), which is independent of thickness z or frequency f. Therefore, whether a row spans categories depends solely on the interval ratio $q$ and thickness $z$. Unconditional safety only occurs when $q \le (13/7)^2 \approx 3.449$. In the empirical data of 31 rows, the minimum $q$ is 10 times larger — no row enters the safe zone.
1. Why an Identity Criterion is Required Rather Than Row-by-Row Trial Calculation
Skin Depth and Attenuation:
δ(σ) = 1/√(π f μ σ) A_dB(z) = 8.686 · z · √(π f μ σ)
Multiplying the two equations eliminates the square root relationship involving $\sigma$, yielding the sole necessary factor for this study:
A_max / A_min = √(σmax / σmin) = √q ← Independent of z and f
First Inference: The “A expansion ratio” for a $\sigma$ interval is a constant intrinsic to that interval. A $\sigma$ span of 100-fold results in an A span of 10-fold; a 10-fold span results in an A span of 3.16-fold.
Second Inference (Critical): The K2 band for judgment grade only spans 7→13 dB, a width of 1.857-fold. To ensure both ends of A fall within the same grade, it is required that $\sqrt{q} \le 1.857$, implying
q ≤ (13/7)² = 3.449 ← Unconditional safety threshold
If $q$ exceeds 3.449, there necessarily exists a specific thickness where A transitions from K3 to K1. This does not imply “this row is definitely incorrect,” but rather that “this row cannot yield a single-grade conclusion without locking $z$.”
This transforms the “interval crossing grades” issue from a row-by-row trial calculation into a scalable criterion — and since the criterion itself contains no $z$, rows where $z$ is unknown can still be evaluated.
2. Full-Database Scan Results: 925 Files / 117 Rows / 31 Interval Rows
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Scanned Files | 925 (03-sites/cn/topics/science-yixue + 08-ops/experiments) |
| Total Tables | 866 |
| Tables with σ column | 31 |
| Rows with σ values | 117 |
| Interval Rows | 31 |
| Interval rows where q ≤ 3.449 (unconditional safety) | 0 |
| Interval rows where q > 3.449 (existence of cross-tier z) | 31 |
| With z and observed cross-tier | 5 |
| With z and observed same tier | 2 |
| No z (completely underdetermined) | 24 |
Four-Tier Classification (Substantive Output of This Round):
| Tier | Meaning | Row Count | Action |
|:–:|:–|–:|
| L0 | Unconditional safety (√q ≤ 1.857, any z same tier) | 0 | — |
| L1 | Conditional safety (√q > 1.857 but locked z shows same tier at both ends) | 2 | Retain, must specify z |
| L2 | Cross-tier (locked z shows different tiers at both ends) | 5 | Prohibit unique conclusion; use dual columns or add conditions |
| L3 | Underdetermined (no z specified) | 24 | Prohibit any tier conclusion; first supplement with z |
3. L2: Verified Cross-Range Five Phases
| File | Phase | $\sigma$ Range | $q$ | $z$ | A Ends | Range Jump |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md |
Wet Granite (water/mineral-bearing) | $10^{-3}$–$10^{-1}$ | 100 | 1 km | 1.53→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
| Same | Wet Basalt | $10^{-2}$–$10^{0}$ | 100 | 1 km | 4.83→48.29 dB | K3→K1 |
| Same | B Phase (Conditional Test) | $10^{-3}$–$10^{-1}$ | 100 | 1 km | 1.53→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md |
B Phase | $10^{-3}$–$10^{-1}$ | 100 | 1 km | 1.53→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md |
A′ | $10^{-2}$–$10^{-1}$ | 10 | 1 km | 4.83→15.27 dB | K3→K1 |
The most conspicuous issue is the “B Phase (Conditional Test)” row: #22 SOP describes it as “1–10 dB, medium, verifying H0/H1 boundaries.” However, recalculating based on its own declared $\sigma$ range ($10^{-3}$–$10^{-1}$) and 1 km distance yields a lower bound of 1.53 dB and an upper bound of 15.27 dB. The upper bound already exceeds the K1 threshold; thus, it is not “medium” but rather “measurable.” The recommendation for this row (“Proceed to A Phase only if budget remains after A Phase measurement”) relies on the lower end of the interval, while its upper end qualifies for inclusion in A Phase.
Conversely, the “A′” row ($10^{-2}$–$10^{-1}$, labeled “medium (requires ≥2 km mountain mass or lower threshold to 5 dB)”) has a lower bound of 4.83 dB, which is relatively low. Its directional advice is correct but similarly addresses only one end of the interval.
Commonality: All five rows represent the entire range using only one endpoint. Given $q=100$, the other endpoint differs by a factor of 10.
4. L3: The z-values for the 24 rows are not explicitly stated; even determining whether they cross a threshold is impossible
The 24 rows are distributed across building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md (6), schumann-station-sigma-literature-values.md (6), skin-depth-reference-table.md §2 (5), pool4-sigma-fmeas-directional-judgment-sop.md (5), and schumann-station-sigma-database.md (2).
These rows provide only “medium / σ / μr”; there is no thickness column and no A(dB) value. The tools process them by assigning a “ambiguous z-band” rather than determining a category:
For σ 10⁻³–10⁻¹ (q=100, √q=10) at 7.83 Hz:
| Threshold | Ambiguous z-band | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| 7 dB (K3→K2) | 458 m – 4.58 km | If z < 458 m, both ends are in K3; if z > 4.58 km, both ends are above K2 |
| 13 dB (K2→K1) | 851 m – 8.51 km | Falling within the band = cannot determine category |
This band spans a factor of 10. A “1 km mountain” falls precisely into the intersection region of the 7 dB and 13 dB bands—this explains why the same “1 km, wet granite” can be described as “transparent” in one document and “tens of dB” in another.
This is not a contradiction between documents; each document only captures one endpoint of the interval.
5. Incidental Findings: Systematic Overestimation of the δ Column in Tables #22 and #25 by a Factor of 37.25
During the scan, while cross-verifying the δ column, a fact emerged that is not an interval issue but more fundamental.
mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md §1 and schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md §1 share a three-tier table. The δ column in this table declares:
| Row | σ Interval | δ Declaration | Calculated at 7.83 Hz | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dry Granite | 10⁻⁸–10⁻⁴ | Hundreds of meters – Thousands of km | 18.0 km – 1,800 km | Order-of-magnitude mismatch (off by 2–3 orders) |
| Wet Granite | 10⁻³–10⁻¹ | Tens of meters – Hundreds of meters | 0.569 km – 5.69 km | Order-of-magnitude mismatch (off by 1–2 orders) |
| Wet Basalt | 10⁻²–10⁰ | Meters – Tens of meters | 0.180 km – 1.80 km | Order-of-magnitude mismatch (off by 1–2 orders) |
Citing specific figures from a single table is more rigorous than line-by-line comparison: schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md explicitly states “Tier A σ ≥ 10⁻² → δ ≤ 67 km“. However, at 7.83 Hz, the δ corresponding to σ=10⁻² is 1.7986 km——
67 km / 1.7986 km = 37.2508
The discrepancy is exactly 37.25 times. Meanwhile, mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md §2 defines Tier A criteria as “σ ≥ 10⁻² → ≥ 10 dB” and Tier B as “δ tens of meters – hundreds of meters”. Both files utilize the same numerical set, and the ratio of 37.25 is identical across both documents.
Back-calculation reveals that to yield 67 km for σ=10⁻², the equivalent frequency must be 0.00564 Hz, not 7.83 Hz.
This indicates that the δ column in these two tables was not calculated at 7.83 Hz, but rather inherited from an upstream value across the entire section (otherwise, the identical 37.25 ratio would not appear in both files).
This error (#37) is undetectable by the scanner: I ran delta-table-scan.py against these two files individually, resulting in “Matched files: 0 | Total assertions: 0″——the parser completely failed to recognize the table. The root cause is that its header perception rule fails to identify the column labeled “δ(7.83 Hz)” as a δ column, causing the entire table to be skipped.
This mirrors the lesson from Round 9: The tool executes successfully, but the metric coverage does not reach the target. The distinction here is that this is a coverage gap, not a metric selection error.
It must be distinguished clearly: The A(dB) column is not calculated incorrectly; rather, the interval coverage is incomplete.
| Row | Calculated A at Interval Ends | Stated A in Table | Coverage Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wet Granite (#22 §1) | 1.53 – 15.27 dB | “Order of 1–10 dB” | Lower end approximates correctly; upper end misses by 5.27 dB (exceeds K1) |
| Wet Basalt (#22 §1) | 4.83 – 48.29 dB | “Order of tens of dB” | Upper end correct; lower end 4.83 dB is not “tens” |
Therefore, one cannot claim the “entire table is wrong”—the δ column is erroneous, while the A column is correct but lacks full interval coverage. These are two distinct issues operating independently.
6. Impact on Existing Outputs from the Current Repository
| Existing Output | Impact |
|---|---|
#16 skin-depth-reference-table.md §3 δ Table |
Not within the 37.25× scope (the table’s δ aligns with the formula; measured σ=10⁻⁴ yields ~17.99 km). However, §2 parameter table was flagged by the tool as 5 interval rows with q=10 or 100, constituting an L3 underdetermined state (the table originally lacks z; handled per parameter table guidelines, see Governance Card §4) |
#22 mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md |
δ column requires recalculation (due to 37.25× deviation); Column A remains usable. Since the three-tier classification (A/B/C) relies on Column A, the categorical conclusions remain unchanged, but interval notations such as “1–10 dB” and “tens of dB” should be revised |
#25 schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md |
Same as above: δ column requires recalculation; “δ ≤ 67 km” should be corrected to 1.8 km; the Tier A criterion (σ ≥ 10⁻²) remains unaffected |
| #37 Full Scan (59 Grid MISMATCH) | Conclusions remain unchanged (reflecting internal consistency within the table); however, it must be explicitly clarified that its coverage does not include these two files, and “zero hits” cannot be interpreted as “no issues” |
| #46a / P4-AUDIT-005 (f_meas Directionality) | Orthogonal to this round: f_meas determines “which frequency σ anchors to,” while q determines “the magnitude of difference within the interval.” They can be combined: true uncertainty ≈ √q × f_meas factor |
| #14 H1a Threshold (≤3 dB) | Maintain the judgment from P4-AUDIT-005: Oppose lowering the threshold |
7. Evidence and Limitations
Verified Evidence (Reproducible):
- The equations $A_{max}/A_{min} = \sqrt{\sigma_{max}/\sigma_{min}}$ and $q \le (13/7)^2 = 3.449$ represent unconditional safety thresholds derived as analytical identities, independent of any literature assumptions;
- The full-library scan counts (925 files / 866 tables / 31 tables containing $\sigma$ / 117 $\sigma$ rows / 31 interval rows / 5 cross-tier cases / 24 without $z$) can be reproduced line-by-line via
sigma-interval-tier-audit.py scan, with JSON export capability; - Tool self-checks passed 15/15, covering four boundary cases: “cross-tier determination,” “same-tier determination,” “scientific notation parsing for superscripts,” and “distinguishing interval delimiters from negative superscript signs”;
- The 37.25x deviation in the $\delta$ column was confirmed by recalculating two files character-by-character; the identical ratio appearing at different $\sigma$ values across both files is verifiable at the file level;
- Strong frequency dependence in rock $\sigma$ is supported by five independent literature sources (Mehran 1977, Jonscher 1977, Revil 2013, Laštovičková 1992, Hall 2004), indicating that “intervals” reflect genuine physical uncertainty rather than fictional constructs;
- Three PMID citations were verified via E-utilities, and five DOIs via Crossref; titles, first authors, journals, and publication years remain consistent across all checks.
Limitations (Must Read Concurrently with Conclusions):
- The cause of the 37.25x deviation is not addressed in this text. Only the equivalence of “frequency 0.00564 Hz” and the consistency of ratios at two locations are confirmed; no speculation is made regarding upstream causes such as manual calculation errors, unit confusion, or copying from a table based on another frequency. It cannot be excluded that the table’s author intentionally employed a low-frequency scope, though the header explicitly states 7.83 Hz (thus deemed inconsistent with the header);
- The tool recognizes only Markdown tables. Naked numerical assertions in the main text (e.g., “a certain mountain attenuates by 3 dB”) fall outside the scope, similar to issues raised in Round 9 regarding naked lists;
- The figures 117 and 31 represent “tool-recognized” counts, not necessarily “truthfully existing” counts in the library. Unrecognized does not imply non-existence; given current table header rules, two critical tables were missed in recognition (see §5), so the actual number of $\sigma$ rows should be $\ge 117$;
- The tier threshold of 13/7 dB is self-defined by Pool ④, not an industry standard. If the threshold changes, the 3.449 line shifts accordingly ($q \le (T_{K1}/T_{K2})^2$). This paper does not advocate for external validation of this threshold;
- The approximations of good conductors, infinite thickness plates, and normal incidence remain in effect; absolute values of $A(\text{dB})$ are not claimed to represent true field values for any specific site;
- $q > 3.449$ does not equal “this row is wrong.” It equals “this row cannot yield a single-tier conclusion without locking $z$”—this represents an underdetermined system, not an error.
8. Action Recommendations for the Next Iteration
| Priority | Action | Dependency |
|---|---|---|
| P1 | Complete the 24 rows in column z for L3—this is the sole prerequisite to unlock all determinations, costing nothing locally | None |
| P1 | Modify the dual columns for the 5 rows in L2 (one column at the interval lower bound, one at the upper bound + tier), or add a conditional clause stating “limited to σ taking X for this row” | Requires JOE authorization to modify existing text |
| P1 | Recalculate columns δ for #22/#25 (37.25× deviation)—pure arithmetic, but modifies published article text, requires JOE authorization | Requires JOE |
| P2 | Add header rules to delta-table-scan.py to cover column names with units, such as “δ(7.83 Hz)” |
Can be done locally |
| P2 | Incorporate the unconditional safety threshold q ≤ (T₁/T₂)² into P4-AUDIT-004 as an admission check for new table generation | Can be done locally |
| P3 | Backward scan pool ③ OMOM three-axis attribution table and pool ⑤ F1–F5 thresholds for similar under-determination | Pending completion of P1 |
This document is a draft. All content consists of analytical recalculation and text parsing from this repository; no field measurements were conducted.
This does not constitute a truth claim regarding ELF attenuation for any specific mountain or site.
Before entering version 779 final, an intake process is required; before entering version 782, the text must be de-AI’d.
“Zero rows with unconditional safety among the 31 rows” is the hardest number in this round, and also the one least suitable to be packaged as “fixed”—it merely clarifies under-determination without modifying a single row.
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply