区间断言逐条判定:20 条 RANGE-unjudged 的「该不该写成区间」裁决(P4-AUDIT-014)

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: C

一句话结论:全库 20 条 RANGE-unjudged 没有一条”该改成单点”——因为触发它们的 σ 本身就是文献区间,δ/A 传播成区间是物理上正确的写法。但其中 16 条存在数值错误(building-mountain 12 条 δ 整体高估 16–100×、B 档 4 条 dB 上界低估),4 条数值自洽(elf-skin-depth 分档门槛)。“区间不可单点判”(R13)说的是判读方式;”区间数值对不对”是另一件事,两者必须分开报。 本文只判不改:修正已发布正文归 D 清单等 JOE 批。

一、为什么这一题必须做

第 16 轮(2026-10-23,#63 工具 v1.5)给 delta-table-scan.py 加了 R13「区间断言不可单点判」,把 20 条区间格标为 RANGE-unjudged——既不判对也不判错。第 16 轮随即登记 #65:「12 条区间断言正文处置——须逐条判『该不该写成区间』」。

但”该不该写成区间”这个问法本身有歧义,必须先拆成两个正交问题:

问题 含义 答案
Q1:这格该不该是区间写法? σ 是区间 → δ/A 是区间,还是 σ 本该是单点? 见 §三,逐条判
Q2:这格的区间数值对不对? 区间的两个端点与 σ 区间自洽吗? 见 §四,独立复算

R13 只回答了 Q1 的”判读方式”(区间不可当单点),完全没回答 Q2。而 Q2 才是这一轮真正的发现:20 条里有 16 条数值是错的。

二、方法:判定矩阵

对 20 条逐条做三件事:

  1. 查 σ 来源:该格对应的 σ 是文献区间还是单点?
  2. 复算端点:δ = √(2/(ωμσ)),把 σ 区间两端代入,得到 δ 区间应然值(A(dB) = 8.686·d/δ 同理)。
  3. 比对方向:区间两端与 σ 递增的关系是否物理正确(σ 越大 δ 越小)。

判定分三类:

类 定义 处置
合理 σ 是区间、δ/A 区间与复算自洽(偏差 < 30%) 保留区间写法;RANGE-unjudged 维持;无动作
数值错 σ 是区间、但 δ/A 区间端点与复算偏差显著(> 30%) 保留区间写法;改正文端点(归 D 清单等 JOE)
该单点 σ 本该是单点、被误写成区间 改正文为单点(归 D 清单等 JOE);本轮实测 0 条

三、逐条判定(20 条)

3.1 building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md(cn L52–57 + lab L41–46 = 12 条)

表头「1–30 Hz 趋肤深度 δ (km)」,σ 列全部为文献区间 → 全部为合理区间写法。但端点数值与复算偏差显著:

介质 σ 区间 (S/m) μr 表写 δ (km) 复算 δ @30Hz (km) 偏差(低端/高端)
干燥花岗岩 1e-5 – 1e-3 1–10 90–900 2.9–29.1 31× / 31×
玄武岩 1e-4 – 1e-2 1–50 28–280 0.9–9.2 31× / 31×
沉积岩 1e-3 – 1e-1 1 9–90 0.3–2.9 31× / 31×
钢筋混凝土 1e-3 – 1e-1 10–100 9–90 0.09–0.9 100× / 100×
普通红砖 1e-4 – 1e-2 1 28–280 0.9–9.2 31× / 31×
钢板/钢梁 1e6 – 1e7 1000–10000 0.005–0.05 0.0003–0.004 km 16× / 16×

复算口径:f=30 Hz、μr 取区间下限(最保守,δ 最大)。若按 1–30 Hz 全频段 + 全 μr 区间,真值区间更宽(花岗岩 0.9–159 km),表写 90–900 km 仍整体高估。

⭐ 对第 13 轮结论的修正:第 13 轮(P4-AUDIT-008 §4 D9–D10)把 building-mountain 判为「区间排列与 σ 递增同向 → 读者会读成 σ 越大 δ 越大(物理上反了)」。本轮复算推翻该方向论断:表写 90–900 km 低端小、高端大,与物理一致(σ 小 → δ 大)。真正的问题是数值整体高估约 31×(30Hz 口径),不是方向反了。 方向论断是第 13 轮把”数值错”误读成”方向错”。修正后的 D9–D10 描述:building-mountain §2 表 δ 区间整体高估 ~31×(钢筋混凝土 100×),方向无误。

为什么值得认真对待:这篇的立论是「山体对 ELF 几乎透明」。按复算(花岗岩 δ 2.9–29 km @30Hz)比表写(90–900 km)更透明——表写反而把山体显得”不那么透明”。与 skin-depth-basement 的 562× 错同族:错把正确结论写得对它自己不利。按 R2 判据不推翻结论,但必须改。

3.2 elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md(cn L205–206 + lab L217–218 = 4 条)

这是修正版 #22 分档门槛表(§6.2),A′ 档 σ∈[1e-2,1e-1] → 1 km A = 4.8–15 dB;B 档 σ∈[1e-3,1e-2] → 1.5–4.8 dB。复算:

档 σ (S/m) 1 km A(dB) 复算 表写 判定
A′ 1e-2 – 1e-1 4.83 – 15.3 dB 4.8–15 dB ✅ 合理(偏差 < 3%)
B 1e-3 – 1e-2 1.53 – 4.83 dB 1.5–4.8 dB ✅ 合理(偏差 < 3%)

→ 4 条全部数值自洽,保留区间写法,无动作。 这 4 条是”分档门槛”(档位范围),不是测量值——R13 的正确用法就在于此。

3.3 mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md(cn L63 = 1 条)+ 引用它的两处

B 档「σ 10⁻³–10⁻¹ → 1 km A = 1–10 dB」。复算:σ=1e-3 → 1.53 dB;σ=1e-1 → 15.3 dB。表写 1–10 dB:

位置 表写 应然 偏差
mountain-sop cn L63 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB 上界低估 5 dB(15→10)
sigma-endpoint cn L41(引用) 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB 同上
sigma-endpoint lab L48(引用) 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB 同上
schumann-station lab L37(引用) 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB 同上

→ 4 条全部”合理区间写法、数值上界低估”。其中 mountain-sop 是源,其余 3 条是引用(R14:引用的不是主张,但引用的错值仍要随源修正)。

这个错在 elf-skin-depth 审计 §6.1 已独立登记过:「湿花岗岩 10⁻³–10⁻¹ → 1–10 dB,⚠️ 上界低估」——本轮把它的影响面追全了:1 源 + 3 引用 = 4 处。

为什么值得认真对待:B 档上界 10 dB 写成 10,导致”σ=1e-1 的含盐灰岩 1 km 能挡 15 dB”被低估成 10 dB——低估了高 σ 岩性的屏蔽能力,会影响 #42 高 σ 岩性路径的 K1 门槛判断。

四、汇总判定表

文件 条数 类 处置
building-mountain cn + lab 12 数值错(δ 高估 16–100×) 改正文端点(D9/D10 修正后)
elf-skin-depth cn + lab 4 合理(自洽 <3%) 无动作
mountain-sop cn 1 数值错(上界低估) 改正文端点(并入 D1/D2)
sigma-endpoint cn + lab 2 数值错(引用 mountain-sop) 随源修正
schumann-station lab 1 数值错(引用 mountain-sop) 随源修正
合计 20 合理 4 / 数值错 16 / 该单点 0 —

⭐ 本轮核心结论:
1. 20 条全部”该保留区间写法”——触发它们的 σ 全是文献区间,写成区间是物理正确。R13 的”不可单点判”是判读纪律,不是”区间写法有问题”。
2. 16 条数值错,其中 12 条(building-mountain)是δ 整体高估 16–100×,4 条(B 档)是 dB 上界低估。
3. 对第 13 轮”方向反了”的修正:building-mountain 方向无误,错在数值。这修正了 D9–D10 的描述。
4. R13 的盲区被补上:工具把区间标”不可判”后,区间本身的数值对不对就没人看了。本文证明:不可判 ≠ 没问题。这与 R3「未解析 ≠ 无问题」是同一族教训。

五、证据边界

  • 全部为公式复算 + 库内文本核算,无任何实测。
  • δ = √(2/(ωμσ)) 与 A = 8.686·d/δ 假设均匀半空间、无位移电流、μr/σ 为常数;真实山体分层各向异性且 σ 随频率弥散(Kariya & Shankland 1983 10.1190/1.1441407 / Laštovičková & Bochníček 1992 10.1007/BF01613900 / Revil 2013 10.1029/2012WR012700 / Mehran & Arulanandan 1977 10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107,4 DOI Crossref 回查通过,均非 PubMed → 无 PMID → E3)。
  • 判定”数值错”仅指”与表格自述 σ/μr 区间不自洽”,不指真实地下 δ 为另一值(若本意是某未写出的等效 σ,问题从”算错”变”没写清 σ”)。
  • 复算口径 f=30 Hz(表头 1–30 Hz 的上端);若作者本意是 7.83 Hz,真值区间为表中值的 1/1.96(σ 同)——无论哪档口径,表写值都显著高估。
  • 本文未改任何已发布正文;修正动作全部登记 D 清单等 JOE 批。

六、相关阅读

  • 同池 #65 pool4-range-unjudged-20-assertions-adjudication-governance.md(P4-AUDIT-014)
  • building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md(被判定 12 条)
  • elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md(被判定 4 条,自洽)
  • mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md(B 档源,上界低估)
  • pool4-sigma-endpoint-direction-gate.md(R7/R8 端点判读规则来源)

七、参考文献

  1. PMID 36676419 — Cheng Y, Materials (Basel) 2023, 低剩磁屏蔽材料测试(工程级 ELF 屏蔽基线)
  2. PMID 28654641 — Binhi VN, Prato FS, PLoS One 2017, 低磁环境生物效应综述(”局部地磁微扰 ≠ 生物体整体低磁”边界)
  3. PMID 38132339 — Sarimov RM, Biology (Basel) 2023, 低磁条件生物效应综述(补充)
  4. PMID 24131394 — Sirav B, Electromagn Biol Med 2014, ELF 变压器磁场生物效应(建筑 ELF 暴露基线)
  5. Kariya & Shankland 1983, 10.1190/1.1441407(岩石电导率频散)
  6. Laštovičková & Bochníček 1992, 10.1007/BF01613900(岩石电导率频散)
  7. Revil 2013, 10.1029/2012WR012700(孔隙介质电导率)
  8. Mehran & Arulanandan 1977, 10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107(黏土频散)

稿签:
– evidence_level: C(公式复算,无实测)
– review_status: draft
– 不得直接标 accepted
– 进入 779 intake 需先做地形 MT 至少 3 处剖面


免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

证据与局限

本文证据等级为 C,属 pure,结论限于研究层面的推断,不构成对个体情形的判定。不可单点判”(R13)说的是判读方式;”区间数值对不对”是另一件事,两者必须分开报。

局限:本文未覆盖全部相关文献,效应量与结论随样本与方法变化;传统体系与现代研究的对照属结构类比而非等价证明,请结合专业判断参考。

Segmented Assertions Evaluated Individually: 20 Decisions on Whether to Write as Ranges for RANGE-unjudged Assertions (P4-AUDIT-014)

Evidence level: C

Range-Unjudged Item-by-Item Assessment: Deciding Whether to Express as a Range

One-sentence conclusion: None of the 20 RANGE-unjudged items in the full corpus should be converted to single-point values. This is because the σ (sigma) triggering them originates from documented intervals, and propagating δ/A into an interval is physically correct notation. However, 16 items contain numerical errors: the building-mountain category has 12 δ values overestimated by factors of 16–100×; the B-grade category has 4 dB upper bounds underestimated. Conversely, 4 items are numerically self-consistent (elf-skin-depth categorization thresholds). The statement “Ranges cannot be judged as single points” (R13) refers to the method of interpretation, whereas “Are the numerical values within the range correct?” is a separate question. These two aspects must be reported separately. This document assesses but does not alter: corrections to published text have been assigned to the D-list for JOE approval.

Item ID Category / Type Issue Description Error Magnitude / Nature Evidence Level
1–12 building-mountain δ values overestimated 16–100× higher than reference D (numerical error)
13–16 B-grade dB upper bounds underestimated Lower than expected limits D (numerical error)
17–20 elf-skin-depth Categorization thresholds Self-consistent with model C (validated)

Key Distinctions

  • Interpretation vs. Accuracy: The decision to use a range (R13) is about how we read the result, not whether the numbers inside it are right.
  • Scope of Correction: Only 16 items need numerical revision; 4 remain as published.
  • Next Steps: All identified errors are logged for formal review and correction in the official record.

I. Why This Question Must Be Addressed

In Round 16 (2026-10-23, #63 tool v1.5), R13 “Interval Assertion Cannot Be Judged by Single Points” was added to delta-table-scan.py, marking 20 interval cells as RANGE-unjudged—neither judged correct nor incorrect. Round 16 immediately logged #65: “Handling of the main text for 12 interval assertions—each must be judged individually on ‘whether it should be written as an interval’.”

However, the phrasing “whether it should be written as an interval” itself is ambiguous, requiring decomposition into two orthogonal questions:

Question Meaning Answer
Q1: Should this cell be written in interval form? Is σ an interval → δ/A is an interval, or should σ itself be a single point? See §III, judged individually
Q2: Are the interval values correct for this cell? Do the two endpoints of the interval cohere with σ’s interval? See §IV, independently recalculated

R13 only addressed the “judgment method” of Q1 (intervals cannot be treated as single points), completely failing to address Q2. Yet Q2 represents the true discovery of this round: 16 out of 20 values are numerically incorrect.

II. Method: Judgment Matrix

For each of the 20 items, three actions are performed:

  1. Trace σ source: Is the corresponding σ for this cell derived from a literature range or a single point?
  2. Recalculate endpoints: δ = √(2/(ωμσ)); substitute both ends of the σ range to obtain the expected δ interval (A(dB) = 8.686·d/δ follows similarly).
  3. Compare direction: Does the relationship between the interval endpoints and the σ increase align with physical expectations (i.e., larger σ yields smaller δ)?

Judgments fall into three categories:

Category Definition Action
Reasonable σ is a range, and the δ/A interval is internally consistent with the recalculated values (deviation < 30%) Retain range notation; maintain RANGE-unjudged status; no action required
Numerical error σ is a range, but the δ/A interval endpoints show significant deviation from the recalculated values (> 30%) Retain range notation; correct the interval endpoints (add to D list, etc. JOE)
Single point σ should have been a single point but was incorrectly written as a range Convert the term to a single point (add to D list, etc. JOE); zero items verified in this round

III. Item-by-Item Verification (20 items)

3.1 building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md (cn L52–57 + lab L41–46 = 12 items)

The table header “1–30 Hz skin depth δ (km)” lists σ columns as literature intervals → all written as reasonable intervals. However, endpoint values and recalculated deviations are significant:

Medium σ interval (S/m) μr Written δ (km) Recalculated δ @30Hz (km) Deviation (low/high end)
Dry granite 1e-5 – 1e-3 1–10 90–900 2.9–29.1 31× / 31×
Basalt 1e-4 – 1e-2 1–50 28–280 0.9–9.2 31× / 31×
Sedimentary rock 1e-3 – 1e-1 1 9–90 0.3–2.9 31× / 31×
Reinforced concrete 1e-3 – 1e-1 10–100 9–90 0.09–0.9 100× / 100×
Common red brick 1e-4 – 1e-2 1 28–280 0.9–9.2 31× / 31×
Steel plate/beam 1e6 – 1e7 1000–10000 0.005–0.05 0.0003–0.004 km 16× / 16×

Recalculation scope: f=30 Hz, μr takes interval lower bound (most conservative, δ largest). If using 1–30 Hz full band + full μr interval, true range is wider (granite 0.9–159 km); written 90–900 km remains overall overestimated.

⭐ Correction to Round 13 conclusion: Round 13 (P4-AUDIT-008 §4 D9–D10) judged building-mountain as “interval arrangement and σ increase same direction → readers will read σ larger δ larger (physically reversed)”. This round’s recalculation overturns that directional claim: written 90–900 km low end small, high end large, consistent with physics (σ small → δ large). The real issue is numerical overall overestimation by ~31× (30Hz scope), not direction reversed. Directional claim is Round 13 misreading “numerical error” as “directional error”. Corrected D9–D10 description: building-mountain §2 table δ interval overall overestimated ~31× (reinforced concrete 100×), direction correct.

Why worth serious attention: This paper’s thesis is “mountain almost transparent to ELF”. By recalculation (granite δ 2.9–29 km @30Hz) compared to written (90–900 km), it is more transparent—written instead makes mountain appear “less transparent”. Same family as skin-depth-basement 562× error: writing correct conclusion against its own interest. By R2 criterion do not overturn conclusion, but must revise.

3.2 elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md (cn L205–206 + lab L217–218 = 4 items)

This is revised #22 tier threshold table (§6.2), A′ tier σ∈[1e-2,1e-1] → 1 km A = 4.8–15 dB; B tier σ∈[1e-3,1e-2] → 1.5–4.8 dB. Recalculation:

Tier σ (S/m) 1 km A(dB) recalc Written Verdict
A′ 1e-2 – 1e-1 4.83 – 15.3 dB 4.8–15 dB ✅ reasonable (deviation < 3%)
B 1e-3 – 1e-2 1.53 – 4.83 dB 1.5–4.8 dB ✅ reasonable (deviation < 3%)

→ All 4 items numerically self-consistent, retain interval notation, no action. These 4 items are “tier thresholds” (tier ranges), not measured values—R13’s correct usage lies here.

3.3 mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md (cn L63 = 1 item) + two places citing it

B tier “σ 10⁻³–10⁻¹ → 1 km A = 1–10 dB”. Recalculation: σ=1e-3 → 1.53 dB; σ=1e-1 → 15.3 dB. Written 1–10 dB:

Location Written Should be Deviation
mountain-sop cn L63 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB upper bound underestimated 5 dB (15→10)
sigma-endpoint cn L41 (cited) 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB same as above
sigma-endpoint lab L48 (cited) 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB same as above
schumann-station lab L37 (cited) 1–10 dB 1.5–15 dB same as above

→ All 4 items “reasonable interval notation, numerical upper bound underestimated”. Among them mountain-sop is source, remaining 3 are citations (R14: cited not claims, but cited wrong values still must follow source correction).

This error independently logged in elf-skin-depth audit §6.1: “wet granite 10⁻³–10⁻¹ → 1–10 dB, ⚠️ upper bound underestimated”—this round traces its impact scope fully: 1 source + 3 citations = 4 locations.

Why worth serious attention: B tier upper bound 10 dB written as 10, leads to “σ=1e-1 salt-bearing limestone 1 km can block 15 dB” underestimated to 10 dB—underestimates high σ rock shielding capability, affecting #42 high σ rock path K1 threshold judgment.

IV. Summary Judgment Table

File Count Category Action
building-mountain cn + lab 12 Numerical error (δ overestimated 16–100×) Correct endpoint (post-D9/D10 revision)
elf-skin-depth cn + lab 4 Reasonable (self-consistent <3%) No action
mountain-sop cn 1 Numerical error (upper bound underestimated) Correct endpoint (merge into D1/D2)
sigma-endpoint cn + lab 2 Numerical error (cites mountain-sop) Correct per source
schumann-station lab 1 Numerical error (cites mountain-sop) Correct per source
Total 20 Reasonable 4 / Numerical error 16 / Single-point 0 —

⭐ Core conclusions for this round:
1. All 20 entries use “retainable interval notation”—their σ values correspond to literature intervals; writing them as intervals is physically correct. R13’s “cannot judge single-point” is a reading discipline, not an indication that “interval notation is problematic.”
2. 16 entries show numerical errors, of which 12 (building-mountain) involve δ overestimated by 16–100×, and 4 (Category B) involve dB upper bound underestimated.
3. Correction for Round 13 “direction reversed”: building-mountain direction is correct; the error lies in the numerical value. This revises the description of D9–D10.
4. R13 blind spot is filled: after the tool marks intervals as “unjudgeable,” no one checks whether the numerical values of those intervals are correct. This paper demonstrates that “unjudgeable ≠ no problem.” This aligns with the lesson from R3 that “unresolved ≠ no problem.”

V. Evidence Boundaries

  • All calculations are formula re-computations + in-library text verification; no field measurements were conducted.
  • δ = √(2/(ωμσ)) and A = 8.686·d/δ assume a uniform half-space, no displacement current, and constant μr/σ; real mountain strata are anisotropic with σ dispersing across frequency (Kariya & Shankland 1983 10.1190/1.1441407 / Laštovičková & Bochníček 1992 10.1007/BF01613900 / Revil 2013 10.1029/2012WR012700 / Mehran & Arulanandan 1977 10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107, 4 DOI Crossref checks passed, none PubMed → no PMID → E3).
  • “Numerical error” refers only to inconsistency with the table’s own stated σ/μr range, not to a different true subsurface δ (if the intent was an unstated equivalent σ, the issue shifts from “miscalculated” to “σ not clearly defined”).
  • Re-computation uses f = 30 Hz (upper end of the table header 1–30 Hz); if the author intended 7.83 Hz, the true range is 1/1.96 of the table values (σ unchanged) — under either convention, the tabulated values significantly overestimate.
  • This paper does not alter any published text; all corrections are logged in the D-list and JOE batch.

VI. Further Reading

  • Pool4 #65 pool4-range-unjudged-20-assertions-adjudication-governance.md (P4-AUDIT-014)
  • building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md (judged 12 assertions)
  • elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md (judged 4 assertions, internally consistent)
  • mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md (Tier B source, upper-bound underestimation)
  • pool4-sigma-endpoint-direction-gate.md (source for R7/R8 endpoint adjudication rules)

VII. References

  1. PMID 36676419 — Cheng Y, Materials (Basel) 2023, testing of low remanence shielding materials (engineering-grade ELF shielding baseline)
  2. PMID 28654641 — Binhi VN, Prato FS, PLoS One 2017, review of low-magnetic environment biological effects (boundary: “local geomagnetic micro-perturbations ≠ whole-body low magnetic state”)
  3. PMID 38132339 — Sarimov RM, Biology (Basel) 2023, review of low-magnetic condition biological effects (supplemental)
  4. PMID 24131394 — Sirav B, Electromagn Biol Med 2014, ELF transformer magnetic field biological effects (building ELF exposure baseline)
  5. Kariya & Shankland 1983, 10.1190/1.1441407 (rock conductivity dispersion)
  6. Laštovičková & Bochníček 1992, 10.1007/BF01613900 (rock conductivity dispersion)
  7. Revil 2013, 10.1029/2012WR012700 (porous medium conductivity)
  8. Mehran & Arulanandan 1977, 10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107 (clay dispersion)

Draft Notes:
– evidence_level: C (formula recalculation, no experimental measurement)
– review_status: draft
– do not mark as accepted directly
– entry into 779 intake requires at least three MT terrain profiles


Disclaimer: This article constitutes an organization, cross-reference, and research design discussion of traditional knowledge and scientific literature, intended solely for understanding and reference. It does not constitute medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. The effect sizes, frequency ranges, and exposure conclusions mentioned herein are largely inferences at the research report level, with significant individual variation; if experiencing physical discomfort or health concerns, please seek medical attention and have them evaluated by a qualified physician.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *