Evidence level: D
导言:为什么是这张表
池子④ 从 #14 到 #33 的十余个课题,全部以同一张 δ 表——skin-depth-reference-table.md(趋肤深度对照表)——为”量级过滤”共同基准。这张表被下游引用次数全库最高,已经上线 lab.holyrange.com。
第 13 轮把 38 张”未解析表”分成四类时,这张表没有被列入 F2/F3(它的大部分表在 F0,δ 数值表 §三 则被工具静默跳过——表头带括号单位”δ @ 7.83 Hz”让解析器认不出)。覆盖率缺口里藏着的,恰恰是全库最重的错。
本轮(#59)用 skin-depth-recompute.py 对 §三 全部 9 行 5 频点逐格复算,结果:9 行里 6 行与它自己声明的 σ/μr 不自洽,且全频点同倍率错。
一、复算方法
δ = √(2/(ωμσ)),其中 ω=2πf、μ=μ₀·μᵣ。对表内标签 σ/μr 逐行代入,f 取 1/7.83/14.3/20/30 Hz 五个频点。
这是教科书经典解,不需要任何外部文献。判”错”的标准只有一个:表内 δ 值与该行自己标注的 σ/μr 复算出的 δ 不一致(偏差 > 2× 或 < 0.5×)。
二、7.83 Hz 主频点结果
| 介质 | 标签 σ | 标签 μr | 表内 δ | 复算 δ | 比 | 判 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 干燥花岗岩 | 10⁻⁴ | 1 | 57 km | 17.99 km | 3.17× | ❌ |
| 潮湿花岗岩 | 10⁻³ | 1 | 18 km | 5.69 km | 3.17× | ❌ |
| 普通混凝土 | 10⁻² | 1 | 5.7 km | 1.80 km | 3.17× | ❌ |
| 钢筋混凝土 | 10⁻¹ | 5 | 2.5 km | 0.254 km | 9.83× | ❌ |
| 黏土/页岩 | 10⁰ | 1 | 1.8 km | 0.180 km | 10× | ❌ |
| 海水 | 4 | 1 | 90 m | 89.9 m | 1.00 | ✅ |
| 低碳钢 | 10⁶ | 100 | 5.7 mm | 18.0 mm | 0.32× | ❌ |
| 纯铁 | 10⁷ | 2000 | 1.3 mm | 1.27 mm | 1.02 | ✅ |
| μ-metal | 10⁶ | 5×10⁴ | 0.25 mm | 0.80 mm | 0.31× | ❌ |
6 行错,3 行对(海水/纯铁/低碳钢中纯铁对)。 其余 5 个频点(1/14.3/20/30 Hz)错行全部同倍率错,说明不是单点笔误,是整行参数配错。
三、错因:与第 38 轮结论吻合
第 38 轮(skin-depth-table-sigma-parameter-provenance-audit.md)曾人工对读指出”端点错配 + 双数据源混用”:δ 值按区间下限/中点算(σ 取更小值 → δ 更大),σ 标签列却写区间上端。
本轮工具复算给出同一结论,且是第二次独立复现:
- 岩石/建材行(3.17×/9.83×/10×):表内 δ 偏大 → 对应 σ 实际比标签小 10–100×。如干燥花岗岩标签 10⁻⁴,但 57 km 对应的实际 σ ≈ 10⁻⁵(区间下限);
- 金属行(0.32×/0.31×):表内 δ 偏小 → 低碳钢标签 μr=100、μ-metal 标签 μr=5×10⁴,但表内 δ 对应 μr≈10 与 μr≈5×10⁵ —— 与标签不符,是另一套厂商数据源。
四、更严重的后果:黏土行方向性反转
§四”风水可读”快查表拿表内 δ 算 A(dB)(A = 8.686·z/δ),所以 A 表忠实于 δ 表。但 δ 表错了,A 表跟着错:
| 场景 | 表内 δ | 表内 A | 真 δ | 真 A | 影响 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 km 黏土/页岩 | 1.8 km | 4.8 dB | 0.180 km | 48.3 dB | ⛔ 方向性反转 |
| 1 km 花岗岩 | 57 km | 0.15 dB | 17.99 km | 0.48 dB | 同向(仍透明) |
| 1 cm 低碳钢 | 5.7 mm | 15.2 dB | 18.0 mm | 4.8 dB | 同向(仍中) |
| 1 mm μ-metal | 0.25 mm | 34.7 dB | 0.80 mm | 10.8 dB | 同向(仍强屏蔽) |
关键在黏土/页岩行:表内写”1 km 黏土页岩只衰减 4.8 dB”,按它自己标签 σ=10⁰ 复算,真值是 48.3 dB——这是强屏蔽体(5.6 个趋肤深度,振幅衰减 99.6%)。
而 §五 结论”靠山屏蔽地磁 ELF 在 1–30 Hz 段没有物理基础”正是拿这行 4.8 dB 当依据。修正后,该否定结论只对低电导岩体(σ ≤ 10⁻³ S/m,干燥/一般花岗岩、玄武岩)成立;对高含水黏土、页岩、湿沉积层(σ ≈ 10⁻²–10⁰ S/m),百米级即可产生 dB 级衰减、千米级可达数十 dB——“靠山屏蔽”对这类地形不能一概否定。
这与第 38 轮 §5 的方向性结论一致,本轮是工具独立复现。
五、跨文件矛盾:R5X 违反的真正一端
delta-table-scan.py v1.6 的跨文件检查(R5X)本轮抓出:skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md(第 13 轮已判错的那张)与 skin-depth-reference-table.md 互成矛盾,6 条违反里 4 条另一端是 reference-table:
| 配对 | basement | reference | 偏差 |
|---|---|---|---|
| steel @7.83 | 5 mm·83 dB | 10 mm·15.2 dB | 2.73× |
| steel @7.83 | 5 mm·83 dB | 1 mm·1.52 dB | 10.9× |
| granite @7.83 | 100 m·27 dB | 1000 m·0.15 dB | 18× |
| mu_metal @7.83 | 2 mm·30 dB | 0.1 mm·3.47 dB | 0.43× |
这推翻第 19 轮”改一格 32 m→17.99 km 消 6 条违反”(#68)的前提:错源不是 basement 一个文件,reference-table 是独立第二处。必须两个文件一起改,R5X 才能归零。
六、证据与局限
- 证据层级 E3:δ(ω)=√(2/(ωμσ)) 为教科书经典解;4 篇 DOI(Revil 2013 弥散、Jonscher 1977 介电响应、Laštovičková 1992 岩石电导率频变、Mehran 1977 黏土低频弥散)仅支撑”σ 在 ELF 存在弥散、μr 非常数”这一前提,不支撑任何数值。本文无 PMID(均地物/材料期刊,不在 PubMed),如实标 E3,不构成 E1。
- 局限 1:判”错”仅指”与表格自述 σ/μr 不自洽”,不指真实地下 δ 为另一值。若表格本意是”取某个未写出的等效 σ”,问题从”算错”变”没写清 σ”,处置不同但都须改。
- 局限 2:复算依赖表内标签 σ/μr;若标签本身也错(如钢筋混凝土 μr=5 是否反映实际),不自洽判定会连锁偏移。
- 局限 3:§四 A 表”忠实于 δ 表”意味着改 δ 后 A 表必须按新 δ 重算,不能只改 δ 列。
- 局限 4:本文未改任何正文;所有更正(D21/D22/D23 + 既有 D 清单)均待 JOE 批准。
七、一句话总结
全库被引用最多的 canonical 趋肤深度表,9 行 δ 里 6 行与它自己声明的参数不符,全频点同倍率错;连带的”1 km 黏土页岩只衰减 4.8 dB”掩盖了真实 48.3 dB 的强屏蔽,使”靠山屏蔽无物理基础”的结论对高 σ 岩体不成立。这张表已上线,且是 R5X 跨文件矛盾的真正一端——第 19 轮”改一格消 6 条”的处置前提因此失效。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Canonical Skin Depth Table Self-Check: 9 Rows, 6 Rows Mismatch with Own Parameters, Clay Row Direction Reversed
Evidence level: D
Introduction: Why This Table?
Project 4 (covering topics #14 through #33) all relied on the same δ table—skin-depth-reference-table.md (the skin-depth reference table)—as their common “magnitude filter” baseline. This table has the highest downstream citation count in the entire repository and is now live at lab.holyrange.com.
During Round 13, when 38 “unresolved tables” were categorized into four groups, this table was not included in F2/F3 (most of its tables fall into F0, and the δ numerical table in §III was silently skipped by the parser—its header carries bracketed units “δ @ 7.83 Hz” which the parser could not recognize). The coverage gap hiding here contains exactly the heaviest error in the entire repository.
This round (#59) used skin-depth-recompute.py to recompute all 9 rows across the 5 frequency points in §III cell-by-cell. The result: 6 of the 9 rows are inconsistent with their own declared σ/μr, and all frequency points share the same scaling error.
I. Recomputation Method
δ = √(2/(ωμσ)), where ω=2πf, μ=μ₀·μᵣ. Each row’s labeled σ/μr was substituted into the formula, with f set to 1/7.83/14.3/20/30 Hz across five frequency points.
This is the textbook classic solution; no external literature is required. The sole criterion for judging “error” is: the table’s δ values do not match the δ recomputed from the row’s own labeled σ/μr (deviation > 2× or < 0.5×).
II. Results at the Main Frequency Point 7.83 Hz
| Medium | Labeled σ | Labeled μr | Table δ | Recomputed δ | Ratio | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dry granite | 10⁻⁴ | 1 | 57 km | 17.99 km | 3.17× | ❌ |
| Wet granite | 10⁻³ | 1 | 18 km | 5.69 km | 3.17× | ❌ |
| Ordinary concrete | 10⁻² | 1 | 5.7 km | 1.80 km | 3.17× | ❌ |
| Reinforced concrete | 10⁻¹ | 5 | 2.5 km | 0.254 km | 9.83× | ❌ |
| Clay/shale | 10⁰ | 1 | 1.8 km | 0.180 km | 10× | ❌ |
| Seawater | 4 | 1 | 90 m | 89.9 m | 1.00 | ✅ |
| Low-carbon steel | 10⁶ | 100 | 5.7 mm | 18.0 mm | 0.32× | ❌ |
| Pure iron | 10⁷ | 2000 | 1.3 mm | 1.27 mm | 1.02 | ✅ |
| μ-metal | 10⁶ | 5×10⁴ | 0.25 mm | 0.80 mm | 0.31× | ❌ |
6 rows are wrong, 3 rows are correct (seawater, pure iron, and low-carbon steel’s pure iron match). The remaining 5 frequency points (1/14.3/20/30 Hz) show identical scaling errors across all rows, indicating not single-point typos but entire row parameter mismatches.
III. Causes of Error: Consistent with Round 38 Conclusion
Round 38 (skin-depth-table-sigma-parameter-provenance-audit.md) had manually identified “endpoint mismatch + dual data source mixing”: δ values were calculated using interval lower bounds/midpoints (σ taking smaller values → larger δ), yet the σ label column wrote interval upper bounds.
This round’s tool recomputation yields the same conclusion, and it is the second independent reproduction:
- Rock/construction material rows (3.17×/9.83×/10×): Table δ is too large → actual σ is 10–100× smaller than labeled. For example, dry granite’s label is 10⁻⁴, but the 57 km corresponds to actual σ ≈ 10⁻⁵ (interval lower bound);
- Metal rows (0.32×/0.31×): Table δ is too small → low-carbon steel’s label μr=100, μ-metal’s label μr=5×10⁴, but table δ corresponds to μr≈10 and μr≈5×10⁵ — inconsistent with labels, indicating another manufacturer data source.
IV. More Serious Consequence: Clay Row Directionality Reversed
§IV’s “Feng Shui readable” quick-reference table uses table δ to compute A(dB) (A = 8.686·z/δ), so the A table faithfully follows the δ table. But since the δ table is wrong, the A table is also wrong:
| Scenario | Table δ | Table A | True δ | True A | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 km clay/shale | 1.8 km | 4.8 dB | 0.180 km | 48.3 dB | ⛔ Directionality reversed |
| 1 km granite | 57 km | 0.15 dB | 17.99 km | 0.48 dB | Same direction (still transparent) |
| 1 cm low-carbon steel | 5.7 mm | 15.2 dB | 18.0 mm | 4.8 dB | Same direction (still medium) |
| 1 mm μ-metal | 0.25 mm | 34.7 dB | 0.80 mm | 10.8 dB | Same direction (still strong shielding) |
The key lies in the clay/shale row: The table states “1 km clay/shale attenuates only 4.8 dB,” but recomputing from its own label σ=10⁰ gives the true value of 48.3 dB—this is a strong shield (5.6 skin depths, amplitude attenuation 99.6%).
Meanwhile, §V’s conclusion that “mountain shielding of geomagnetic ELF in the 1–30 Hz band lacks physical basis” was based on this row’s 4.8 dB. After correction, that negative conclusion holds only for low-conductivity rock bodies (σ ≤ 10⁻³ S/m, dry/ordinary granite, basalt); for high-water-content clay, shale, wet sedimentary layers (σ ≈ 10⁻²–10⁰ S/m), meter-scale can produce dB-level attenuation and kilometer-scale can reach tens of dB—“mountain shielding” cannot be universally denied for such terrain.
This aligns with Round 38 §V’s directionality conclusion; this round independently reproduced it via tools.
V. Cross-File Contradiction: R5X Violation’s True Endpoint
delta-table-scan.py v1.6’s cross-file check (R5X) identified in this round: skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md (the one already judged wrong in Round 13) and skin-depth-reference-table.md contradict each other, with 4 of the 6 violations pointing to the reference-table:
| Pair | basement | reference | Deviation |
|---|---|---|---|
| steel @7.83 | 5 mm·83 dB | 10 mm·15.2 dB | 2.73× |
| steel @7.83 | 5 mm·83 dB | 1 mm·1.52 dB | 10.9× |
| granite @7.83 | 100 m·27 dB | 1000 m·0.15 dB | 18× |
| mu_metal @7.83 | 2 mm·30 dB | 0.1 mm·3.47 dB | 0.43× |
This overturns Round 19’s premise that “fixing one cell (32 m → 17.99 km) eliminates 6 violations” (#68): the error source is not just the basement file; the reference-table is an independent second location. Both files must be corrected together for R5X to reach zero.
VI. Evidence and Limitations
- Evidence level E3: δ(ω)=√(2/(ωμσ)) is the textbook classic solution; 4 DOIs (Revil 2013 on dispersion, Jonscher 1977 on dielectric response, Laštovičková 1992 on rock conductivity frequency variation, Mehran 1977 on clay low-frequency dispersion) support only the premise that “σ exhibits dispersion in ELF and μr is not constant,” but do not support any numerical values. This paper has no PMID (all are geophysical/materials journals, not PubMed), so it is correctly labeled E3 and does not constitute E1.
- Limitation 1: Judging “wrong” refers only to “inconsistency with the table’s own stated σ/μr,” not to the true underground δ being another value. If the table’s intent was “to take some unstated equivalent σ,” the problem shifts from “computed incorrectly” to “σ not clearly stated,” requiring different handling but still necessitating correction.
- Limitation 2: Recomputation depends on table labels σ/μr; if the labels themselves are wrong (e.g., whether reinforced concrete’s μr=5 reflects reality), inconsistency judgment will cascade.
- Limitation 3: §IV’s A table “faithfully follows the δ table” means after correcting δ, the A table must be recomputed using the new δ, not merely updating the δ column.
- Limitation 4: This paper makes no changes to any main text; all corrections (D21/D22/D23 plus existing D list) await JOE approval.
VII. One-Sentence Summary
The most-cited canonical skin-depth table in the entire repository has 6 of its 9 δ rows inconsistent with their own declared parameters, all frequency points sharing the same scaling error; consequently, “1 km clay/shale attenuates only 4.8 dB” masks the true 48.3 dB strong shielding, rendering the conclusion that “mountain shielding lacks physical basis” invalid for high-σ rock bodies. This table is now live and represents the true endpoint of R5X cross-file contradiction—the premise of Round 19’s “fix one cell to eliminate six violations” is therefore invalidated.
Disclaimer: This document pertains to the compilation, comparison, and research design discussion of traditional knowledge and scientific literature, intended solely for understanding and reference. It does not constitute medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis and treatment. The effect sizes, frequency ranges, and exposure conclusions mentioned herein are inferences at the research report level; individual variations are significant. If you experience discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician for professional judgment.
Leave a Reply