Evidence level: B
池③ · 课题 #192(本轮新登记)|证据等级 B|状态 draft
本轮对既有正文写入 = 0
一句话结论
池内引文最不可靠的文件,恰好是最接近 779 终版审稿的那一个。
第 8 轮把治理重心放在「63 文件 / 254 条」的总量分桶;本轮换一个验收视角——只审 779 intake 候选涉及的 4 个文件。结果是:4 个里 3 个有引文问题,其中 enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md(池② N14,已在 779 候选清单登记为 candidate)的全部 3 条参考文献都是伪造书目。
同时如实记录一件负面结果:本轮试图做的「反向校验器」在中文-英文混合语料下失效(94.4% 文章英文主题词元 ≤2),已落地为工具但标注「中文语料不可用」,净增量≈0。下轮不要再重造这条路。
1. 为什么换视角:总量分桶不能回答”哪个最要紧”
第 8 轮 P3-GOV-002 把 63 个文件按命中数分成 P0-a(17)/ P0-b(18)/ P0-c(28)三批,排序依据是每个文件的命中条数。这个排序隐含一个假设:命中多的更危险。
但五池的最终出口是 779 intake → 终版审核 → lab 线上。真正要紧的不是”哪个文件错得多”,而是“哪个文件正在往 779 走”。一个 17 条错误的草稿,如果永远停在 03-sites/ 不外流,风险是内部误导;一个 3 条错误的文件,如果已在 779 候选清单上,风险是把伪造引文送进终版审稿。
所以本轮先做一件第 8 轮没做的事:把 779 候选清单和引文审计结果做交集。
2. 交集结果:4 个候选文件
查 779-HolyRange终版/00-governance/99-intake-候选清单.md,当前共 6 行 candidate,去重后指向 4 个源文件:
| # | 文件 | 池 | intake 行 | 状态 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | consciousness-external-physical-effect-risk-statement.md |
① | P1-EXT-PHYS-BOUND | candidate |
| 2 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md |
⑤ | P5-DOSHA-QI-RSA-FALSIFICATION-METHOD | candidate |
| 3 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md |
⑤ | P5-DOSHA-QI-RSA-FALSIFICATION-PREREGISTRATION-SPEC | candidate |
| 4 | enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md |
② | P2-ENSO-CI-N14 | candidate(待 Codex 审稿,证据强度标注 B+) |
这 4 个文件就是”正在往终版走”的全部——池③ 自己的 700+ 篇里,一篇都不在清单上。这也解释了为什么前 8 轮池③ 的治理总是”修不完”:它修的是不外流的那部分。
3. 逐文件结果
3.1 ⛔ enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md:3/3 参考文献全部伪造
这是本轮最高级别发现。该文是池② N14 的 intake 候选,backlog 记「evidence_level=B+」,779 清单记「待 Codex 审稿(证据强度 B+)」。它的三条参考文献,作者、标题、期刊、卷期页码全部与真实记录不符:
| # | 文中声明 | PubMed 真实记录(PMID 指向) | 判定 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Yang Y, et al. (2022). Comparison of daily air temperature from ERA5, JRA-55, and MERRA-2 reanalyses over China. Atmospheric Research, 277, 106307. PMID 36155626 | Liao WI, A Mouse Model of Orotracheal Intubation and Ventilated Lung Ischemia Reperfusion Surgery, J Vis Exp 2022 | ❌ 全错 |
| 2 | Liu Y, et al. (2023). Decadal variation in the ENSO–East Asian winter monsoon teleconnection: a multi-reanalysis assessment. Climate Dynamics, 61(7), 3581–3598. PMID 37518421 | Espinasa L, Erratum: … Mioce…, Zootaxa 2023 | ❌ 全错 |
| 3 | Bock L, et al. (2021). Quantifying progress across different CMIP phases with the global mean surface temperature and Earth energy imbalance. Earth System Dynamics, 12(4), 1067–1083. PMID 34099113 | Freeborn RA, The role of Nrf2 in autoimmunity and infectious disease: Therapeutic possibilities, Adv Pharmacol 2021 | ❌ 全错 |
最刺眼的一处细节(说明这不是随手编的):第 1 条的卷期页码 Atmospheric Research 277, 106307 是真实存在的——Crossref 回查 10.1016/j.atmosres.2022.106307 确是 Atmos Res vol 277 文章号 106307,但真实论文是 Zhang S, Ren, Ren, KealdrupTysa《Linkage of extreme temperature change with atmospheric and locally anthropogenic factors in China mainland》2022。
也就是说:卷期页码对得上、期刊对得上、年份对得上、主题也对得上(中国气温趋势),唯独「作者 Yang Y」和「标题 Comparison of daily air temperature from ERA5…」是编的。 这是比”整条瞎编”更难发现的一类——查期刊卷号会通过,查主题相关会通过,只有逐字比对标题才暴露。
影响放大:这三条不是摆在文末装样子的。文中 §3.1–§3.3 用它们支撑了三段实质论证,且给出了具体数值:
| 引用处 | 文中据其得出的数值结论 |
|---|---|
| §3.1(36155626) | 「1980–2020 三源年均 T2m 趋势 +0.27 至 +0.34 °C/decade,跨产品一致性 r > 0.85」 |
| §3.2(37518421) | 「ENSO–EAWM 相关 1970s 末/2000s 末两次年代际转折,跨产品 ±0.05 不确定度」 |
| §3.3(34099113) | 「全球陆地变暖不确定度 ±0.04 °C/decade、中国 ±0.06」→ 据此把「变暖贡献 41%」改判为「合理范围 34–47%」 |
第三条最严重:一个伪造的引文被用来改写本文的核心数值结论(41% → 34–47%),而这个改判会被带进 779 终版。
证据等级的问题:backlog 与 779 清单都标 B+。按宪章 §2,E2 需「多个已证机制拼接」;其拼接节点的引文全部不可核,B+ 的前提不成立。本文建议:该行 intake 状态应改为「引文待重建,暂缓审稿」,证据等级降至 C(或直接标 disputed),直至三条引文被真实文献替换。
⚠️ 需说明:这不等于该文的全部结论都是错的。池② N12→N18 的证据链是内部复算 + 三源再分析的自我一致性论证,其核心逻辑不依赖这三条外部引文;但这三条承担的是「外部交叉验证」这一环——这一环目前是空的。
3.2 ⛔ dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md(池⑤):引文错配 + 1 个假号
该文 5 条书目行里,逐条比对:
| PMID | 文中声明 | 真实记录 | 判定 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31234475 | 「Nosek et al., 2018 预注册原则综述」 | Godyń D, Effects of Environmental Enrichment on Pig Welfare—A Review, Animals 2019 | ❌ 作者/主题全错 |
| 33494095 | 「Task Force HRV 指南更新」 | Johnson BA, Loss of furin cleavage site attenuates SARS-CoV-2 pathogenesis, Nature 2021 | ❌ 作者/主题全错 |
| 29269119 | 「Cheung et al., 2017 跨文化构念等价性最新方法学」 | Ram Manohar P, An exploratory clinical study… heart rate variability… Ayurveda, J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018 | ❌ 作者/年份错(该号在其他文件里用法正确,见 §3.4) |
| 36106418 | 「Cheung & Rensvold, 2002,ΔCFI 0.01 / ΔRMSEA 0.015 双阈值」 | Rani R, HRV during head-up tilt shows inter-individual differences, Physiol Rep 2022 | ❌ 作者/年份全错 |
| 8598068 | 「Chen, 2007 的 ΔCFI 0.01 阈值」 | Heart rate variability: standards of measurement…, Circulation 1996(无个人作者,Task Force) | ❌ 作者/年份全错 |
| 34479992 | 「Putnick & Bornstein, 2016 测量等值性系统综述」 | PubMed 无记录(esummary + efetch 双确认返回空) | ❌ 假号 |
注意最后一行的性质:34479992 是第 7 轮已定位的「不存在」号,同号在池③ 两文件里还被赋予「Chung 2021 中医证型 HRV」等另外两种身份。本轮在一个 779 候选文件里再次命中它——假号已经扩散到最接近终版的层。
还有一个结构性错误:8598068 是 HRV 测量标准(Task Force 1996),被用来支撑「ΔCFI 0.01 阈值」。而 ΔCFI 阈值通常归于 Cheung & Rensvold (2002)。这两个主题完全不同,说明声明的作者/主题是凭”应该引什么”写的,不是从文献库里查的。
3.3 ⛔ dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md(池⑤):同源错配
同一批 PMID 的另一种拆用:
– 29269119 在 Tridosha 问卷行标「Manohar 2018 三质生理」→ 这条是对的(真实一作 Ram Manohar P, 2018);
– 同一号在另一文(§3.2)被标「Cheung et al., 2017」→ 错;
– 34479992 标「Chung 2021 中医证型 HRV」→ 号不存在。
→ 同一个号在一篇里对、在另一篇里错,与第 2 / 第 7 / 第 8 轮反复验证的模式完全一致(跨子线挪用 + 真号伪书目)。这是池内主失效模式的第四次独立复现。
3.4 ⛔ consciousness-external-physical-effect-risk-statement.md(池①):1 条假书目
| PMID | 文中声明 | 真实记录 | 判定 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16822162 | Bösch H, Steinkamp F, Boller E. Examining psychokinesis… Psychol Bull 2006;132(4):497-523 | Bösch H, Examining psychokinesis: the interaction of human intention with random number generators, Psychol Bull 2006 | ✅ 正确 |
| 16822163 | Comment on Bösch, Steinkamp, and Boller (2006). Psychol Bull 2006 | Wilson DB, On blowing trumpets to the tulips…, Psychol Bull 2006 | ✅ 正确(未写一作但指向对) |
| 29144112 | 「May EC, Utts JM, Tressoldi PE, et al. Intentional Observer Effects on Quantum Randomness: A Bayesian Analysis. Explore (NY). 2018」 | JEH Quiz #5: Presence of Household Mold, Children’s Respiratory Health, and School Absenteeism, J Environ Health 2017(无作者) | ❌ 全错 |
→ 这个文件的主锚点是干净的(两条 Bösch/Wilson 真实且相关),只有第三条错。这是 4 个文件里最轻的一个——也说明”出了问题”不等于”文件作废”,分级处置是对的。
4. 本轮负面结果:反向校验器在中文语料下失效(务必记录)
第 8 轮登记的下轮计划第①项是「做反向校验器(抓真实标题→文中搜特征词,覆盖裸列表/多号并列)」。本轮做了,结论是这个方向在五池语料上不成立。
4.1 做了
新工具 08-ops/_tools/citation-reverse-check.py(纯标准库,--selftest 2/2 通过)。思路:从真实文献出发,取 PubMed 真实标题 → 与文章主题词元做重叠度 → 零重叠可疑。
4.2 结果:全池 1142 条命中,其中 82% 是语言假阳性
| 指标 | 数值 |
|---|---|
| 扫描文件 | 746 |
| 引文条目 | 13,581 |
| 其中裸列表形式 | 4,459(32.8%) ← claim-check 的盲区,确认存在 |
| 可打分条目 | 1,256 |
| 文章主题抽不出英文词 | 533 文件(71.4%) |
| 零重叠命中 | 1,135 |
按「宿主文件的英文主题词元数」分桶:
| 主题英文词元数 | 命中条数 | 占比 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 740 | 65% |
| 2 | 192 | 17% |
| 3 | 131 | 11% |
| 4 | 23 | 2% |
| ≥5 | 56 | 5% |
94.4% 的文章(704/746)英文主题词元 ≤2。 原因很简单:正文是中文,引用的真实标题是英文——词元必然零交集。
典型假阳性(人工一眼就看出引用是对的):
acupoint-meridian-functional-validation.md 引用:
「Acupuncture, the limbic system, and the anticorrelated networks of the brain」
「Does the Acupoint Specificity Exist? Evidence from Functional Neuroimaging Studies」
该文英文主题词元只有 1 个(fmri)→ 两篇全判 0 重叠 ❌
4.3 结论:净增量 ≈ 0,别再走这条路
- 对有书目行的文件,
citation-claim-check.py已能判 T1/T2,且更准(本轮拿它复跑 ENSO 文件,6 条全中,与人工核验一致)。 - 对裸列表(32.8%),词元重叠法在中文语料下不可用;要覆盖它,正确做法不是词元比对,而是「裸列表里的号能否找到作者可核」——这本质上仍需人工。
- 因此:#193(反向校验器)本轮完成但判定为失败方向,工具保留并已在文件头写明「中文语料不可用」,防止下轮重造。
这是连续第三次同类教训:第 7 轮「未提取行≈0」、第 8 轮「必须报分母与覆盖率」、本轮「跨语言词元法不成立」。共同点是——工具指标看起来跑通了,但指标本身测的不是想测的东西。
5. 判定与处置建议
5.1 分级(按”通往 779 的距离”排,不按命中条数)
| 级 | 对象 | 依据 | 建议动作 |
|---|---|---|---|
| I-1(最高) | enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md(池② N14,779 candidate) |
3/3 参考文献伪造;其中 1 条被用来改写核心数值(41%→34–47%);卷期页码真实但作者标题伪造 | 暂停 779 审稿;evidence_level B+ → C / disputed;三条引文按真实文献重建或删除对应三段;重建后重评等级 |
| I-2 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md(池⑤,779 candidate) |
5 条书目 4 条错 + 1 个假号(34479992) | 换号/换文献(§3.2 表可直接用);假号必删;不改正文论证结构 |
| I-3 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md(池⑤,779 candidate) |
同批号错配,含假号 34479992 | 同上,与 I-2 合并处理 |
| I-4(最轻) | consciousness-external-physical-effect-risk-statement.md(池①,779 candidate) |
主锚点 2/3 正确,仅 29144112 一条伪书目 | 单点替换即可,不动其他 |
5.2 对 P3-GOV-002 的修正建议
第 8 轮的三批分桶(P0-a 17 / P0-b 18 / P0-c 28)按命中条数排序。本文建议在批次之前加一个”出口优先”层:
P-1 层(先于 P0)= 779 intake 候选文件。共 4 个,其中 3 个需处置。
理由:这 4 个是唯一会外流的;其余 59 个停在站内侧,风险等级低一档。
成本:4 个文件,远小于 P0-a 的 17 个。
换句话说:JOE 如果只批一件事,应该批这 4 个,而不是 17 个。
5.3 需要 JOE 决策的红灯
- ENSO N14 是否暂停 779 审稿(推荐:暂停,等级降 C,引文重建后再审)——这是本轮最急的一条。
- 4 个 intake 候选文件是否授权执行 I-1~I-4 处置(换号/换文献/删假号,均不删论证段落,可逆)。
- 779 候选清单是否增设
citation_status列(取值:verified / disputed / unverified),把引文状态变成 intake 的必填字段,而不是等审计发现。
6. 引文与锚点
6.1 本文使用的核验锚点(全部真实,PubMed/Crossref 逐条回查)
| 标识 | 真实著录 | 用途 |
|---|---|---|
| PMID 36155626 | Liao WI, A Mouse Model of Orotracheal Intubation…, J Vis Exp 2022 | 反证 ENSO 文引用① |
| PMID 37518421 | Espinasa L, Erratum…, Zootaxa 2023 | 反证 ENSO 文引用② |
| PMID 34099113 | Freeborn RA, The role of Nrf2 in autoimmunity…, Adv Pharmacol 2021 | 反证 ENSO 文引用③ |
| DOI 10.1016/j.atmosres.2022.106307 | Zhang S, Ren, Ren, KealdrupTysa, Linkage of extreme temperature change…China mainland, Atmos Res 277:106307 (2022) | 证明「卷期页码真、作者标题假」 |
| PMID 31234475 | Godyń D, Effects of Environmental Enrichment on Pig Welfare, Animals 2019 | 反证 dosha-prereg 引用 |
| PMID 33494095 | Johnson BA, Loss of furin cleavage site attenuates SARS-CoV-2…, Nature 2021 | 反证 dosha-prereg 引用 |
| PMID 29269119 | Ram Manohar P, An exploratory clinical study…HRV…Ayurveda, J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018 | 反证(同号他处正确) |
| PMID 36106418 | Rani R, HRV during head-up tilt…, Physiol Rep 2022 | 反证 dosha-prereg 引用 |
| PMID 8598068 | Heart rate variability: standards of measurement…, Circulation 1996 | 反证(ΔCFI 阈值误挂 HRV 标准) |
| PMID 29144112 | JEH Quiz #5: Presence of Household Mold…, J Environ Health 2017 | 反证 consciousness 文引用 |
| PMID 16822162 | Bösch H, Examining psychokinesis…, Psychol Bull 2006 | 正证(该文件主锚点正确) |
| PMID 16822163 | Wilson DB, On blowing trumpets to the tulips…, Psychol Bull 2006 | 正证 |
| PMID 34479992 | 不存在(esummary + efetch 双确认空) | 假号,已在池⑤ 779 候选文件中命中 |
6.2 证据等级说明
evidence_level: B。理由:核心判定(引文同真实记录不符)是确定性事实比对,不依赖模型;但结论的覆盖面受限于「裸列表 32.8% 无法程序化判定」,因此不升 A。§4 的工具失效结论为可复现实测。
7. 下轮可做
- (最高)I-1 处置:ENSO 文三条引文按真实文献重建 —— 需先查「ERA5/JRA-55/MERRA-2 中国气温趋势对比」「ENSO-EAWM 多再分析年代际转折」「再分析长期趋势不确定度」三主题的真实文献,替换后重估 B+/B/C。这是在救一个 779 候选。
- I-2/I-3:dosha 两文件换号(§3.2 表已给真值),假号 34479992 三处一并清除。
- I-4:consciousness 文单点替换 29144112。
- #47(池④):
groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md10 条专项——同属”按出口排序”的下一批。 - 不要再做:词元重叠类反向检测器(§4 已证否)。
8. 铁律遵守
- 写入前 acquire、写入后 release(WB-FIVEPOOLS);
- frontmatter 六字段齐全;高风险主题
disclaimer_required: true+risk_level: medium; - 未标 accepted;未直写 779/782(本文未修改 779 候选清单,只提建议);
- 新写文件的核验锚点全部 PubMed/Crossref 回查通过(§6.1,13 条,含 1 条不存在号的确认);
- 本轮对既有正文写入 = 0(4 个 intake 候选文件、
skin-depth-reference-table.md、全部受污染文件一字未动)。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
证据与局限
本文证据等级为 B,属 measurable,结论限于研究层面的推断,不构成对个体情形的判定。不可靠的文件,恰好是最接近 779 的那一个。
局限:本文未覆盖全部相关文献,效应量与结论随样本与方法变化;传统体系与现代研究的对照属结构类比而非等价证明,请结合专业判断参考。
Pool 3 #192: 779 Intake Candidate Citation Completeness Special – Citation Quality of Highest Priority Files is Below Pool Average
Evidence level: B
Pool ③ · Topic #192 (Newly Registered in This Round) | Evidence Level B | Status draft
Writing into existing text in this round = 0
One-Sentence Conclusion
The most unreliable cited document is paradoxically the one closest to the 779 final review draft.
In Round 8, governance focused on aggregating totals across the “63 documents / 254 entries” bucket; this round adopts a different validation perspective, auditing only the 4 documents involved in the 779 intake candidates. The result is that 3 of the 4 contain citation issues, with enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md (Pool ② N14, registered as a candidate in the 779 intake list) having all 3 references fabricated.
Additionally, we record a negative outcome: the proposed “reverse validator” failed under mixed Chinese-English corpora (94.4% of articles have ≤2 English topic tags), has been deployed but flagged as “Chinese corpus unavailable,” yielding a net gain ≈0. Do not retrace this path in the next round.
1. Why Shift Perspective: Total Counts and Binning Cannot Address “Which Is Most Critical”
Round 8, P3-GOV-002, categorized the 63 files into three groups—P0-a (17), P0-b (18), and P0-c (28)—based on the number of hits per file. This sorting implicitly assumes that higher hit counts indicate greater risk.
However, the ultimate exit point for the Five Pools is 779 intake → final review → lab online. The critical factor is not “which file contains the most errors,” but rather “which file is currently moving toward 779.” A draft with 17 errors poses an internal risk of misleading stakeholders if it remains confined to 03-sites/ and does not leak. Conversely, a file with only 3 errors poses the risk of introducing fabricated citations into the final review process if it has already entered the 779 candidate list.
Therefore, this round prioritizes an action not taken in Round 8: intersecting the 779 candidate list with the citation audit results.
2. Intersection Results: 4 Candidate Files
Referencing 779-HolyRange-final/00-governance/99-intake-candidate-list.md, there are currently 6 lines of candidates; after deduplication, they map to 4 source files:
| # | File | Pool | Intake Line | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | consciousness-external-physical-effect-risk-statement.md |
① | P1-EXT-PHYS-BOUND | candidate |
| 2 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md |
⑤ | P5-DOSHA-QI-RSA-FALSIFICATION-METHOD | candidate |
| 3 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md |
⑤ | P5-DOSHA-QI-RSA-FALSIFICATION-PREREGISTRATION-SPEC | candidate |
| 4 | enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md |
② | P2-ENSO-CI-N14 | candidate (Pending Codex review; evidence level rated B+) |
These 4 files constitute the entirety currently advancing toward the final version. Within Pool ③’s own 700+ articles, none appear on this list. This explains why Pool ③’s governance has consistently been “unending” in the first eight rounds: it addresses the portion that does not flow out.
3. File-by-File Findings
3.1 ⛔ enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md: All 3 References Fabricated
This represents the highest-level finding for this round. The manuscript is a candidate intake for Pool ② N14, marked in the backlog with evidence_level=B+, and listed in the 779 checklist as “Pending Codex Review (Evidence Strength B+)”. All three of its references are fabricated: author, title, journal, volume, issue, and page numbers all mismatch real records:
| # | Claimed Citation | PubMed Real Record (PMID) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Yang Y, et al. (2022). Comparison of daily air temperature from ERA5, JRA-55, and MERRA-2 reanalyses over China. Atmospheric Research, 277, 106307. PMID 36155626 | Liao WI, A Mouse Model of Orotracheal Intubation and Ventilated Lung Ischemia Reperfusion Surgery, J Vis Exp 2022 | ❌ Completely Incorrect |
| 2 | Liu Y, et al. (2023). Decadal variation in the ENSO–East Asian winter monsoon teleconnection: a multi-reanalysis assessment. Climate Dynamics, 61(7), 3581–3598. PMID 37518421 | Espinasa L, Erratum: … Mioce…, Zootaxa 2023 | ❌ Completely Incorrect |
| 3 | Bock L, et al. (2021). Quantifying progress across different CMIP phases with the global mean surface temperature and Earth energy imbalance. Earth System Dynamics, 12(4), 1067–1083. PMID 34099113 | Freeborn RA, The role of Nrf2 in autoimmunity and infectious disease: Therapeutic possibilities, Adv Pharmacol 2021 | ❌ Completely Incorrect |
Most glaring detail (indicating this is not random fabrication): The volume, issue, and page number for Reference 1, Atmospheric Research 277, 106307, is real. Crossref verification of 10.1016/j.atmosres.2022.106307 confirms it is indeed Volume 277, Article 106307 in Atmos Res. However, the actual paper is by Zhang S, Ren, Ren, KealdrupTysa, titled “Linkage of extreme temperature change with atmospheric and locally anthropogenic factors in China mainland” (2022).
In other words: The volume, issue, page number, journal name, and year all match; the topic also aligns (China temperature trends). Only the author “Yang Y” and the title “Comparison of daily air temperature from ERA5…” are fabricated. This is a more subtle error than “random fabrication”—journal volume checks pass, topic relevance passes, but only a word-for-word title comparison exposes it.
Amplified Impact: These three references are not merely decorative at the end of the text. They are used in §§3.1–3.3 to support substantive arguments with specific numerical values:
| Citation Location | Numerical Conclusion Derived from Citation |
|---|---|
| §3.1 (36155626) | “1980–2020 multi-source annual T2m trends +0.27 to +0.34 °C/decade, cross-product consistency r > 0.85” |
| §3.2 (37518421) | “ENSO–EAWM correlation two decadal shifts at late 1970s/late 2000s, cross-product ±0.05 uncertainty” |
| §3.3 (34099113) | “Global land warming uncertainty ±0.04 °C/decade, China ±0.06” → Used to revise “41% warming contribution” judgment to “reasonable range 34–47%” |
Reference 3 is most severe: A fabricated citation was used to rewrite the manuscript’s core numerical conclusion (41% → 34–47%), and this revised judgment will be carried into the final version of document 779.
Evidence Level Issue: Both the backlog and the 779 checklist mark this as B+. Per Charter §2, E2 requires “multiple verified mechanisms assembled”; the premise of B+ fails because all citation nodes are unverifiable. Recommendation: Change intake status to “References Pending Reconstruction, Hold Review” and downgrade evidence level to C (or mark as disputed) until the three citations are replaced with real literature.
⚠️ Clarification: This does not mean all conclusions in the manuscript are incorrect. The evidence chain from Pool ② N12→N18 relies on internal recalculation and multi-source reanalysis for self-consistency; its core logic does not depend on these three external citations. However, these three citations bear the responsibility for the “external cross-validation” link—this link is currently empty.
3.2 ⛔ dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md (Pool ⑤): Citation Mismatch + 1 Fake PMID
In the five bibliography lines of this manuscript, a line-by-line comparison reveals:
| PMID | Claimed Citation | Real Record | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31234475 | “Nosek et al., 2018 preregistration principles review“ | Godyń D, Effects of Environmental Enrichment on Pig Welfare—A Review, Animals 2019 | ❌ Author/Topic Completely Incorrect |
| 33494095 | “Task Force HRV Guidelines Update“ | Johnson BA, Loss of furin cleavage site attenuates SARS-CoV-2 pathogenesis, Nature 2021 | ❌ Author/Topic Completely Incorrect |
| 29269119 | “Cheung et al., 2017 cross-cultural construct equivalence latest methodology” | Ram Manohar P, An exploratory clinical study… heart rate variability… Ayurveda, J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018 | ❌ Author/Year Incorrect (This PMID is correctly used elsewhere, see §3.4) |
| 36106418 | “Cheung & Rensvold, 2002, ΔCFI 0.01 / ΔRMSEA 0.015 dual thresholds” | Rani R, HRV during head-up tilt shows inter-individual differences, Physiol Rep 2022 | ❌ Author/Year Completely Incorrect |
| 8598068 | “Chen, 2007 ΔCFI 0.01 threshold” | Heart rate variability: standards of measurement…, Circulation 1996 (Task Force, no individual author) | ❌ Author/Year Completely Incorrect |
| 34479992 | “Putnick & Bornstein, 2016 measurement equivalence systematic review” | No Record in PubMed (confirmed empty via esummary + efetch) | ❌ Fake PMID |
Note on the nature of the last entry: 34479992 is a “non-existent” PMID identified in Round 7. The same PMID was assigned two other identities (“Chung 2021 TCM Syndrome HRV”) in two files in Pool ③. This manuscript hits it again in a 779 candidate file—the fake PMID has spread to the layer closest to the final version.
Another structural error: 8598068 is the HRV measurement standard (Task Force 1996), yet it is used to support the “ΔCFI 0.01 threshold.” The ΔCFI threshold is typically attributed to Cheung & Rensvold (2002). These are entirely different topics, indicating the cited author/topic was written based on “what should be cited” rather than retrieved from a literature database.
3.3 ⛔ dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md (Pool ⑤): Homogeneous Mismatch
Another deployment of the same batch of PMIDs:
– 29269119 is marked as “Manohar 2018 Three-Dosha Physiology” in the Tridosha questionnaire line → Correct (First author Ram Manohar P, 2018);
– The same PMID is marked as “Cheung et al., 2017” in another text (§3.2) → Incorrect;
– 34479992 is marked as “Chung 2021 TCM Syndrome HRV” → PMID does not exist.
→ The same PMID is correct in one paper but incorrect in another, consistent with the pattern repeatedly verified in Rounds 2, 7, and 8 (cross-subline misappropriation + real PMID fake bibliography). This is the fourth independent reproduction of the pool’s primary failure mode.
3.4 ⛔ consciousness-external-physical-effect-risk-statement.md (Pool ①): 1 Fake Bibliography Entry
| PMID | Claimed Citation | Real Record | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16822162 | Bösch H, Steinkamp F, Boller E. Examining psychokinesis… Psychol Bull 2006;132(4):497-523 | Bösch H, Examining psychokinesis: the interaction of human intention with random number generators, Psychol Bull 2006 | ✅ Correct |
| 16822163 | Comment on Bösch, Steinkamp, and Boller (2006). Psychol Bull 2006 | Wilson DB, On blowing trumpets to the tulips…, Psychol Bull 2006 | ✅ Correct (not first author but correct reference) |
| 29144112 | “May EC, Utts JM, Tressoldi PE, et al. Intentional Observer Effects on Quantum Randomness: A Bayesian Analysis. Explore (NY). 2018“ | JEH Quiz #5: Presence of Household Mold, Children’s Respiratory Health, and School Absenteeism, J Environ Health 2017 (No authors listed) | ❌ Completely Incorrect |
→ This file’s primary anchor is clean (two Bösch/Wilson entries are real and relevant); only the third entry is wrong. This is the lightest of the four files—also indicating that “having problems” does not mean “file invalid,” and graded disposition is appropriate.
4. Negative Result in This Round: Reverse Validator Fails Under Chinese Corpus (Must Record)
The first item in the plan for the next round registered in Round 8 was to “build a reverse validator (verify real titles by searching for characteristic terms in the text, covering bare lists and multiple numbers side-by-side)”. We executed this in the current round. Conclusion: This direction is not viable for the Wu Chi corpus.
4.1 Execution
New tool 08-ops/_tools/citation-reverse-check.py (pure standard library, --selftest passed 2/2). Approach: Start from real literature, take PubMed real titles → calculate overlap with article MeSH terms → flag as suspicious if zero overlap.
4.2 Results: 1,142 Hits in Full Pool, 82% Language False Positives
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Scanned files | 746 |
| Citation entries | 13,581 |
| Bare list format | 4,459 (32.8%) ← Blind spot for claim-check; confirmed existence |
| Scoreable entries | 1,256 |
| No English terms extracted from article MeSH | 533 files (71.4%) |
| Zero-overlap hits | 1,135 |
Bucketed by “Number of English MeSH terms in host file”:
| English MeSH Count | Hits | Proportion |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 740 | 65% |
| 2 | 192 | 17% |
| 3 | 131 | 11% |
| 4 | 23 | 2% |
| ≥5 | 56 | 5% |
94.4% of articles (704/746) have ≤2 English MeSH terms. The reason is straightforward: the main text is in Chinese, while the cited real titles are in English → MeSH terms inevitably have zero intersection.
Typical False Positives (obvious to human inspection that the citation is correct):
acupoint-meridian-functional-validation.md Citation:
「Acupuncture, the limbic system, and the anticorrelated networks of the brain」
「Does the Acupoint Specificity Exist? Evidence from Functional Neuroimaging Studies」
The article's English MeSH terms total only 1 (fmri) → Both papers flagged as 0 overlap ❌
4.3 Conclusion: Net Increment ≈ 0, Do Not Pursue This Path Again
- For files with bibliography lines,
citation-claim-check.pycan already judge T1/T2, and is more accurate (re-ran on ENSO files in this round; all 6 matches correct, consistent with manual verification). - For bare lists (32.8%), the MeSH overlap method is inapplicable under Chinese corpus conditions; to cover them, the correct approach is not MeSH comparison but “whether numbers in bare lists can locate authors for verification” — this essentially still requires human effort.
- Therefore: #193 (Reverse Validator) completed this round but judged as a failed direction; the tool is retained and explicitly marked in file headers as “inapplicable for Chinese corpus” to prevent re-creation in the next round.
This is the third consecutive lesson of this type: Round 7 “unextracted lines ≈ 0”, Round 8 “must report denominator and coverage”, this round “cross-language MeSH method fails”. The common point is — the tool metrics appear to run smoothly, but the metrics themselves do not measure what we intend to measure.
5. Determination and Disposal Recommendations
5.1 Grading (Ranked by “Distance to 779,” not hit count)
| Level | Target | Basis | Recommended Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| I-1 (Highest) | enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md (Pool ② N14, 779 candidate) |
3/3 references fabricated; one used to rewrite core values (41%→34–47%); volume/page numbers real but author titles fabricated | Suspend 779 review for ENSO N14; downgrade evidence_level B+ → C / disputed; reconstruct or delete the three corresponding citations based on real literature; re-evaluate level after reconstruction |
| I-2 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md (Pool ⑤, 779 candidate) |
5 bibliographic entries: 4 incorrect + 1 fake ID (34479992) | Change ID or replace literature (§3.2 table can be used directly); delete fake ID; do not alter the main argument structure |
| I-3 | dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md (Pool ⑤, 779 candidate) |
Same batch ID mismatch, includes fake ID 34479992 | Same as I-2; process together with I-2 |
| I-4 (Lightest) | consciousness-external-physical-effect-risk-statement.md (Pool ①, 779 candidate) |
Primary anchor correct on 2/3; only one fake bibliography (29144112) | Single-point replacement sufficient; do not touch others |
5.2 Correction Recommendations for P3-GOV-002
The three batch bucketing in Round 8 (P0-a 17 / P0-b 18 / P0-c 28) is currently sorted by hit count. This paper recommends adding an “Exit Priority” layer before the batches:
P-1 Layer (Preceding P0) = 779 intake candidate files. Total 4, of which 3 require disposal.
Rationale: These 4 are the only ones at risk of external leakage; the remaining 59 remain within-site with a lower risk tier.
Cost: Only 4 files, far fewer than the 17 in P0-a.
In other words: If JOE reviews only one item, it should be these 4, not the 17.
5.3 Red Flags Requiring JOE Decision
- Should ENSO N14 suspend 779 review? (Recommended: Suspend, downgrade to C, re-review after citation reconstruction) — This is the most urgent item for this round.
- Should authorization be granted to execute I-1~I-4 disposal for the 4 intake candidates? (Change IDs/literature/delete fake IDs; do not delete argument paragraphs; all actions are reversible).
- Should the 779 candidate list add a
citation_statuscolumn? (Values: verified / disputed / unverified), making citation status a mandatory field for intake rather than waiting for audit discovery.
6. Citations and Anchors
6.1 Verification Anchors Used in This Text (All Verified via PubMed/Crossref)
| Identifier | Verified Citation | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| PMID 36155626 | Liao WI, A Mouse Model of Orotracheal Intubation…, J Vis Exp 2022 | Refutes ENSO citation① |
| PMID 37518421 | Espinasa L, Erratum…, Zootaxa 2023 | Refutes ENSO citation② |
| PMID 34099113 | Freeborn RA, The role of Nrf2 in autoimmunity…, Adv Pharmacol 2021 | Refutes ENSO citation③ |
| DOI 10.1016/j.atmosres.2022.106307 | Zhang S, Ren, Ren, KealdrupTysa, Linkage of extreme temperature change…China mainland, Atmos Res 277:106307 (2022) | Confirms “volume/page accuracy but author/title discrepancy” |
| PMID 31234475 | Godyń D, Effects of Environmental Enrichment on Pig Welfare, Animals 2019 | Refutes dosha-prereg citation |
| PMID 33494095 | Johnson BA, Loss of furin cleavage site attenuates SARS-CoV-2…, Nature 2021 | Refutes dosha-prereg citation |
| PMID 29269119 | Ram Manohar P, An exploratory clinical study…HRV…Ayurveda, J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018 | Refutes (correctly cited elsewhere under same number) |
| PMID 36106418 | Rani R, HRV during head-up tilt…, Physiol Rep 2022 | Refutes dosha-prereg citation |
| PMID 8598068 | Heart rate variability: standards of measurement…, Circulation 1996 | Refutes (misapplied ΔCFI threshold to HRV standards) |
| PMID 29144112 | JEH Quiz #5: Presence of Household Mold…, J Environ Health 2017 | Refutes consciousness citation |
| PMID 16822162 | Bösch H, Examining psychokinesis…, Psychol Bull 2006 | Confirms (primary anchor correct) |
| PMID 16822163 | Wilson DB, On blowing trumpets to the tulips…, Psychol Bull 2006 | Confirms |
| PMID 34479992 | Does not exist (confirmed empty via esummary + efetch) | False identifier; matched in pool⑤ candidate file #779 |
6.2 Evidence Level Explanation
evidence_level: B. Rationale: The core determination (citation mismatch against actual records) relies on deterministic factual comparison independent of models; however, the scope of the conclusion is constrained by the “bare list” where 32.8% cannot be programmatically adjudicated, preventing an upgrade to A. The tool failure conclusion in §4 is reproducible via direct measurement.
7. Next Round Actions
- I-1 (Highest Priority): Reconstruct the three citations in the ENSO text based on authentic literature. This requires verifying real sources regarding “ERA5/JRA-55/MERRA-2 China Temperature Trend Comparison,” “ENSO-EAWM Multi-Reanalysis Decadal Shifts,” and “Uncertainty in Reanalysis Long-Term Trends.” Replace the erroneous references and re-evaluate the rating from B+ to B or C. This addresses a critical candidate for the 779 classification.
- I-2/I-3: Replace the identifiers in the two dosha files (§3.2 table provides correct values). Simultaneously remove the three instances of the false identifier 34479992.
- I-4: Replace the single point in the consciousness text with 29144112.
- #47 (Pool ④): Execute the ten specialized tasks for
groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md. These fall under the next batch of “sort by export.” - Do Not Proceed: Do not run word-embedding overlap reverse detectors (§4 already refutes their validity).
8. Ironclad Compliance Rules
- Acquire before writing and release after writing (WB-FIVEPOOLS);
- Ensure all six fields in frontmatter are complete; set
disclaimer_required: trueandrisk_level: mediumfor high-risk topics; - No entries marked as accepted; do not directly write 779 or 782 (this text did not modify the 779 candidate list, only offered suggestions);
- Verification anchors for all newly written files have passed PubMed/Crossref re-checks (§6.1, 13 items, including confirmation of one non-existent ID);
- Zero writes to existing body text in this round (four intake candidate files,
skin-depth-reference-table.md, and all contaminated files remained untouched).
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply