Evidence level: C
池③ · 课题 #191(本轮新登记)· 承接第 1/2/4/5/6/7 轮引文治理
证据等级 C|状态 draft|本轮对既有正文写入 = 0
工具:08-ops/_tools/citation-claim-check.py(v2,纯标准库,含--selftest正负样本自检)
0. 一句话结论
第 7 轮命名的「真号伪书目」不再是定性描述,本轮给出了量:254 条声明不一致,分布在 63 个文件、涉及 113 个唯一 PMID。
但比这个数字更重要的是过程中撞到的一件事:
全池 13,384 处 PMID 引用里,只有 703 条(5.3%)写在「参考文献」段落的书目行上。
剩下 94.7% 分散在正文夹注里。如果按「解析书目行」这个思路做检测(v1 的做法),检出的 223 条只覆盖了不到十分之一的引文位——而伪书目恰恰最爱藏在正文夹注里,因为那里没有格式约束,写起来最随意。
并且,本轮给「真号伪书目」补了一个此前没命名的兄弟子类:「换号而非造号」。
有些错配不是编造了一个来源,而是手里有一批真号,把 A 号的内容挂到 B 号上——主题本来在池内有正确来源,只是指错了指针。这类错误的修法是换号,不是删段,处置成本远低于 OMOP 那批(§5.4 案例二)。
三种失效模式的处置成本差异巨大,混为一谈会把便宜的事做成贵的事:
| 子类 | 定义 | 修法 | 成本 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 假号 | PMID 不存在 | 删或换 | 低(但极少,全池仅 4 个) |
| 换号 | 真号,主题相关但指错 | 换号 | 低 |
| 真号伪书目 | 真号,作者/标题/期刊/主题整体虚构 | 重新找文献 + 重写论断 | 高 |
1. 为什么上轮的闸查不出这个
citation-verify.sh(第 2 轮落地)与 citation-pool-scan.py(第 7 轮落地)都只回答一个问题:
这个 PMID 存不存在?
对「真号伪书目」这三个字来说,这个问题问错了。伪书目的定义特征就是「号是真的」——存在性检查必然全绿。
一个具体例子(本轮实测,groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md 第 106 行):
1. Pollack GH, et al. *Electromagnetic signals from flowing groundwater...*
Journal of Scientific Exploration. 2005;17(2):157-182. PMID 15728218
- PMID
15728218真实存在 → 存在性检查通过 - 但真实文献是:Muss HB, ACCO: ASCO core curriculum outline, 与地下水、电磁信号、Pollack 毫无关系
- 作者、标题、期刊、年份、主题——五项全错,只有那串数字是真的
这类错误对读者的欺骗性强于假号:点进 PubMed 会看到一篇真实论文,反而增强可信感。
2. 检测器怎么做的(三类确定性判据)
新增工具 citation-claim-check.py,只做不需要语义判断的机械比对:
| 代号 | 判据 | 实现 |
|---|---|---|
| T1 | AUTHOR-UNKNOWN | 声明的一作姓氏,用词边界在 PubMed 真实作者列表里找不到 |
| T2 | TITLE-LOW-OVERLAP | 声明标题与真实标题的英文实词词元重叠率 < 0.34 |
| X1 | SAME-ID-DIFF-CLAIM | 同一 PMID 在两个文件里被写成互不重叠的两个标题(跨文件同号异题) |
| I3 | YEAR-NOTE(仅 INFO) | 声明年份 vs 发表年相差 ≥2 —— 不进结论 |
2.1 为什么 I3 只做 INFO(沿用上轮教训)
第 7 轮已经把 citation-pool-scan.py 的 E3「年份矛盾」降级,理由是本语料大量「1974–」是数据年份/队列起始年,不是发表年。本轮重写工具时又踩了一次:
声明年=1974 真实年=1993
真实标题: [Analysis of geographical differences in the seasonal variation
of mean birth weight in Japan (1974- ...
标题里的 (1974- 是数据区间,被判成「声称 1974」。同一个坑,换个工具还会踩 —— 说明这不是某个脚本的实现缺陷,而是这一类判据在这批语料上根本不可用。
2.2 三次迭代才收敛的假阳性(全部实测)
工具不是一次写对的。三次修正各自对应一类真实假阳性:
| 版本 | 问题 | 实例 | 修正 |
|---|---|---|---|
| v0 | 宽松取行首词当姓氏 | *Physiological Reports* → 姓氏 “Physiological”;Task Force... → 姓氏 “Task” |
取消兜底,只在明确作者块后给姓氏 |
| v1 | 机构词/形态词未过滤 | PMID 本身被当姓氏(2 处) |
加机构词表 + 形态后缀黑名单 |
| v2 | 中文「等」是列举助词不是「等人」 | Butyricimonas 等短链脂肪酸产菌、AIx 等现代指标 → 菌属名/指标缩写当姓氏 |
只认「等人」「等(」「et al」,不接受孤立「等」 |
三轮修完,T1 从 131 → 114 → 145(先降后升:降是因为去掉宽松兜底,升是因为补了正文夹注覆盖)。每次修正都必须重跑并重新抽样,否则不知道是真修好还是把真问题一起删掉了。
2.3 自检机制(硬要求)
python3 citation-claim-check.py --selftest
用两个已知样本做正负对照:
- 阳性对照(已知合规文件
tcm-pulse-hri-inter-operator-...的两条引文)→ 命中必须 = 0 - 阴性对照(已知伪书目文件
pulse-pressure-normalization-...的两条引文)→ 命中必须 ≥2
本轮结果:
[selftest] 阳性对照(合规样本)命中 = 0 PASS
[selftest] 阴性对照(伪书目样本)命中 = 3 PASS
[selftest] RESULT: PASS
3. 全池结果
3.1 总口径
| 指标 | 数值 |
|---|---|
| 扫描文件 | 733 篇 |
| 可解析引文条目(书目行 + 夹注) | 703 条 |
| 其中可比标题(英文标题) | 237 条 |
| 涉及唯一 PMID | 485 个 |
| 命中总数 | 254 条 |
| 涉及文件 | 63 个 |
| 涉及唯一 PMID(命中侧) | 113 个 |
3.2 分级(按严重度)
| 级 | 含义 | 条数 |
|---|---|---|
| A | 作者错 且 标题也错(同一处双错,最硬) | 126 |
| B | 仅作者错(标题对或未解析) | 82 |
| C | 仅标题错(作者对或未解析) | 9 |
| D | 跨文件同号异题(X1) | 37 |
A 级 126 条是本轮最硬的证据:同一处引文,声明的一作不在真实作者里、声明的标题与真实标题词元几乎不重叠。两个独立判据同时命中,几乎不可能是解析误差。
3.3 按文件分布(前 12)
| 文件 | T1 | T2 | X1 | 计 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
pulse-harmonic-random-forest-tcm-syndrome-prediction.md |
5 | 6 | 6 | 17 |
arterial-stiffness-hri-cavi-intervention-validation.md |
4 | 3 | 8 | 15 |
hri-spectrum-cardiovascular-event-prediction-longitudinal-cohort.md |
2 | 2 | 8 | 12 |
groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md |
5 | 5 | 0 | 10 |
nayin-birth-cohort-lifetime-health-trajectory.md |
3 | 4 | 2 | 9 |
nayin-epigenetic-phase.md |
4 | 4 | 0 | 8 |
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm.md |
3 | 3 | 2 | 8 |
tcm-constitution-multi-omics-reference-atlas.md |
4 | 4 | 0 | 8 |
meta-learning-cross-zang-transfer-blind-validation-failure-attribution.md |
7 | 0 | 0 | 7 |
enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md |
3 | 3 | 0 | 6 |
enso-ci-coupling-trend-under-warming.md |
3 | 3 | 0 | 6 |
midnight-noon-circadian-frequency-encoding.md |
3 | 3 | 0 | 6 |
分布形态:17 个文件 ≥6 条(集中污染)、18 个 3–5 条、28 个 1–2 条(偶发)。这不是均匀的笔误,是少数文件成批失效。
3.4 跨池扩散(本轮新发现)
命中文件不只在池③。按池归属粗分:
| 池 | 代表文件 | 性质 |
|---|---|---|
| ③ 生物频率 | pulse-harmonic-*、hri-spectrum-*、nayin-* |
脉诊/谐波主线,最密集 |
| ④ 环境接口 | groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md(10 条) |
池④ 文章也中招 |
| ① 共振意识场 | consciousness-field-interpersonal-spatial-propagation.md(5 条)、collective-meditation-brain-sync.md |
冥想/心脑同步 |
| ② 时空频率 | jieqi-pentad-wavelet-*、dayan-calendar-*、starchart-chronology.md |
节气/星表 |
| ⑤ 跨文化 | qi-deficiency-english-translation-*、dosha-rsa-qi-deficiency-dual-mapping.md |
跨文化等值性 |
这条推翻了第 6 轮之前的判断「引文失效只在 OMOP 子线」和第 7 轮的「扩大到池③健康主线」——实际是五池全覆盖。池④ 的 groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md 有 10 条,密度与池③ 高发文件同级。
4. 覆盖口径:本轮最该记住的一条
4.1 数字
全池含 PMID 文件 710 篇
PMID 出现总次数 13,384 处
书目行可解析 703 条 → 5.3%
正文夹注可解析(新增) 405 处 → 另 3.0%
剩余「裸 PMID 引用」 ~12,276 处 → 91.7% 未覆盖
4.2 为什么这件事比 254 这个数字更重要
v1 只解析书目行,得到 223 条、49 个文件。加上正文夹注后(v2),变成 254 条、63 个文件——文件数涨了 29%,而夹注只覆盖了 3% 的引文位。换算下来,未被解析的 91.7% 里如果错误率与已解析部分一致,真实总量会是当前数字的十倍量级。
不能据此断言「有 2000+ 条错」,因为未覆盖部分的错误率未知——但可以确定:「254」是下界,而且离真实值很远。
4.3 这是同一类错误的第二次
上轮(第 7 轮)的教训是「结论必须建立在『未提取行≈0』之上」——首版漏 74 行,差点得出「池内无问题」的错误结论。
本轮换了工具,同一个坑又出现:v1 的 96.7% 覆盖缺口没有在任何输出里被提示。工具安静地跑完、安静地给出「49 文件 / 223 条」,看起来像一个完整结果。
新硬规则 R-191:任何「全量扫描」类工具,必须同时输出分母与覆盖率,并把缺口明示在主输出里。
只报分子不报分母的扫描器,等于在制造虚假的确定性。
5. 抽样核验(精度证明)
从 254 条里随机抽 14 条 T1 + 8 条 T2/X1,逐条原始行核对(random.seed 固定可复现):
5.1 T1 抽样 14 条 → 14 条全部真实
| PMID | 声明姓氏 | 真实一作 | 真实标题(E-utilities 回查原文) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16243978 | Targetti | Hu G | Isoflurane prevents platelets from enhancing neutrophil-induced coronary endothelial dysfunction |
| 14675133 | Burch | Liu CJ | Polymorphism of the MICA gene and risk for oral submucous fibrosis |
| 17620642 | Li | Eisen RJ | Residence-linked human plague in New Mexico: a habitat-suitability model(声明为森林浴 NK 活性) |
| 29537674 | Chaplin | Amagai T | Accuracy of flow and sensors of indirect calorimetry for neonates and infants(声明为”水记忆”综述) |
| 36509825 | Zhang | Wu LW | Discrimination between possible sarcopenia and metabolic syndrome using the arterial pulse spectrum |
| 33903610 | Hu | Lin SK | Classification of patients with Alzheimer’s disease using arterial pulse spectrum |
| 38942105 | Liu | Nishiwaki S | Prevalence and characteristics of AVNRT with a bystander pathway |
| 32929968 | Zhang | Miller JR | Particle-Based Reconfigurable Scattering Masks for Lensless Imaging(声明为季风区制转变) |
| 27861248 | Li | Stoner L | Reliability of pulse waveform separation analysis: effects of posture and fasting |
| 38070877 | Zhang | Williams CE | The role of diet and host species in shaping seasonal dynamics of the gut microbiome(声明为五运六气-菌群专属机制) |
| 39766014 | Charu | Abbas SR | Federated Learning in Smart Healthcare: A Comprehensive Review on Privacy, Security |
| 33509706 | Liu | Cordier PY | Complex and prolonged hypercoagulability in COVID-19 intensive care unit patients |
| 27861248 | Wang | Stoner L | 同上(同一号在另一文件被赋另一个假作者) |
| 18999346 | Berman | Hamilton JM | Visuospatial deficits predict rate of cognitive decline in autopsy-verified dementia with Lewy bodies |
误报 0/14。 其中 5 条(加粗)的真实标题与声明主题完全无关(鼠疫 / 婴儿热量计 / 无透镜成像 / 联邦学习 / 路易体痴呆),是最硬的一类。
5.2 反向验证:上轮 9 文件里有 4 个本轮未命中,是否漏报
第 7 轮列了 9 个受影响文件。本轮实测 5 个命中、4 个未命中(程序化比对,非目测):
| 上轮 9 文件 | 本轮 | 原因 |
|---|---|---|
pulse-harmonic-random-forest-tcm-syndrome-prediction |
17 | 文本未变,稳定复现(且是最严重的一个) |
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm |
8 | 稳定复现 |
pulse-harmonic-spectrum-individualized-zangfu-functional-scoring |
5 | 稳定复现(T1) |
standing-wave-antinode-psychophysiology |
3 | 稳定复现(T1) |
hri-c2-c3-heart-qi-deficiency-severity-dose-response |
2 | 稳定复现:Liang等(PMID: 33903610) 真实一作为 Lin SK |
pulse-harmonic-gut-microbiome-organ-axis |
0 | 漏:写成 2021年发表于 *Nature Medicine* 的研究(PMID: 34637011),姓氏在 90 字窗口外 |
pool5-standby-validation-entry-exit-gate |
0 | 漏:- PMID 29269119:跨文化 RSA… 裸列表,无姓氏可判 |
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology |
0 | 漏:同裸列表形态 |
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification |
0 | 漏:同裸列表形态 |
5/9 复现,4/9 漏报。 这 4 个不是「文件没问题」,而是引文形态不在检测器认的句法里——漏报的方向是已知的,可以针对性补(见 §9 第 1 项)。
5.3 已知仍未覆盖的引文形态(如实登记)
| 形态 | 实例 | 为什么漏 |
|---|---|---|
| 裸列表 | - PMID 29269119:跨文化 RSA 心理测量学发展之综述… |
无姓氏,T1 无法判 |
| 中文叙述后跟号 | …(PMID: 34637011)显示,TMAO水平与… |
姓氏在 90 字窗口外 |
| 多号并列 | (PMID: 35161551, 36509825) |
只取第一个,第二个不判 |
这三类合计占未覆盖的大头。下一步应该做的是「反向校验」:对每个 PMID 抓真实标题,在文中搜索该标题的特征词,查不到就说明文中可能有伪书目描述——不依赖姓氏句式。
5.4 两个被漏掉、但人工一查就中的极端案例(说明漏报代价)
盲跑之后用 citation-verify.sh 逐个回查新写文章引用的 PMID,顺手撞到两条检测器漏掉、但严重程度远超已检出项的:
案例一:34637011(pulse-harmonic-gut-microbiome-organ-axis.md)
文中声明:2021年发表于 *Nature Medicine* 的研究(PMID: 34637011)
显示,TMAO水平与心力衰竭严重程度呈正相关
真实文献:Goldbach JT, et al. "The Development of Proud & Empowered:
An Intervention for Promoting LGBTQ Adolescent Mental Health."
Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 2023
- 主题:TMAO/心力衰竭 vs LGBTQ 青少年心理健康干预
- 期刊:Nature Medicine vs Child Psychiatry Hum Dev
- 年份:2021 vs 2023
- 唯一”对”的是那 8 位数字
被漏掉的原因:声明里没有「姓氏+等人」结构(写的是”2021年发表于 Nature Medicine 的研究”),落在 §5.3 第一类。
案例二:29269119(3 个文件,3 种身份)
| 文件 | 声明身份 |
|---|---|
pool5-standby-validation-entry-exit-gate.md |
「跨文化 RSA 心理测量学发展之综述」 |
dosha-rsa-qi-deficiency-dual-mapping.md § 标题 |
「Ram Manohar P et al., J Ayurveda Integr Med, 2018,三质的 HRV 光谱特征」 |
| 同文件另一处 | 「Shu Q et al., 2017,针刺对气虚体质 HRV 的调节」 |
| 同文件第三处 | 「Tripathi PK et al., 2011」 |
| 真实 | Ram Manohar P, An exploratory clinical study to determine the utility of heart rate variability analysis in the assessment of dosha imbalance, J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018 |
一个号在同一文件内被赋予三个不同的一作 + 三个不同的年份,其中一个(Ram Manohar 2018)恰好是对的。这已不是”引用失误”,而是同一批素材被反复改写、每改一次就换一个来源。
再追一层(本轮新发现的子类):同文件的另外两个号其实主题是对的——
| PMID | 真实一作 | 真实标题 | 与”针刺→气虚 HRV”主题 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 33068344 | Song YJ | Immediate effect of acupuncture and moxibustion at Guanyuan (CV4) and Zusanli (ST36) on heart rate variability(Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 2020) | ✅ 高度相关 |
| 40315935 | Li T | Effects of acupuncture and moxibustion on heart rate variability in chronic fatigue syndrome patients(Complement Ther Med 2025) | ✅ 高度相关 |
| 29269119 | Ram Manohar P | …utility of HRV analysis in the assessment of dosha imbalance**(J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018) | ✅ 相关(阿育吠陀侧) |
也就是说:29269119 那一处「针刺对气虚 HRV」如果换成 33068344,整段就成立了。
这带出一个此前没命名的失效子类:「换号而非造号」——
作者手里有一批”看上去相关”的真号,写作时把 A 号的内容挂到 B 号上。
与「真号伪书目」的区别是:目标主题本来就在池内有正确来源,只是指错了指针。
对这类错误,修法是换号,不是删段——处置成本远低于 OMOP 那批。这两条案例的意义:检测器目前只能抓到「有姓名的伪书目」。而最离谱的伪书目往往连姓名都不写(只写”某年某刊的研究”),那反而更难被抓——因为它连可核对的字段都省了。
6. 与既有治理卡的关系
P3-GOV-001(第 7 轮,L0–L3 四级)不需要改结构,但受影响文件清单要更新:
| 级 | 原范围 | 本轮修正 |
|---|---|---|
| L0 | 新稿不引受污染文献 | 不变 |
| L1 | 9 文件加横幅 + citation_status: disputed |
改为 63 文件(其中 17 个 ≥6 条优先) |
| L2 | 4 个假号 + 2 条伪条目 | 不变,另加 113 个「声明不一致」PMID 中的高复用号 |
| L3 | OMOP 9 篇 + 2 个肠-心轴 | 不变 |
L1 的性价比反而更高了:63 个文件加一行 frontmatter 字段 + 一段横幅,仍是可逆、零删除、立刻止误导的动作。但范围从 9 变成 63,已经不是「一轮能做完」的事,需要 JOE 决定是分批还是全量。
7. 对研究结论的实际影响(哪些论断要撤)
引文错配本身不是研究错误,但如果某个具体数值论断挂在一篇无关文献上,那个论断就没有支撑。
本轮定位到的最要紧一处(第 7 轮已发现,本轮确认复发于另一文件):
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm.md 第 56 行:
"预实验数据表明,弦脉的 G(P) 斜率约为浮脉的 1.7 倍(PMID: 33901427)"
33901427 真实为 Weaver 2021 卒中后认知障碍影像研究,与压力-谐波增益曲线无关。「1.7 倍」这个数在本池没有任何可核来源。
另有一类结构性问题:27861248(真源 = Stoner L, Reliability of pulse waveform separation analysis: effects of posture and fasting)在池内 11 个文件出现(grep -l 实测),其中声明的一作有 Stoner(正确)、也有 Wang、Li、Blacher(错误)。同一篇真实文献在不同文章里”换作者”,是跨子线挪用 + 伪书目叠加的典型形态。
同类高复用号(本轮精确统计,均为命中侧):
| PMID | 真实一作 | 命中文件数 | T1 条数 | 被赋过的假姓氏 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 33903610 | Lin SK | 9 | 7 | Hu / Liang / Wang / WK |
| 36294440 | Chen CC | 6 | 3 | Wang / Xu / Zhang |
| 27861248 | Stoner L | 4 | 4 | Blacher / Li / Wang |
| 27314975 | Bilton K | 3 | 3 | Fukuda / Liu / Zhang |
| 36509825 | Wu LW | 3 | 1 | Zhang |
| 33901427 | Weaver NA | 2 | 1 | Zhang |
33903610 是最典型的:一个号在 9 个文件里被写成 4 种不同的一作(Hu / Liang / Wang / WK)。但必须同时记下反例——hri-c2-c3-lvef-joint-diagnostic-model.md 与 hri-harmonic-c2-c3-heart-qi-deficiency-severity-dose-response.md 里同一号写的是 Lin S.K. / Lin 等,完全正确。
这就是第 2 轮立下、本轮再次验证的方法论:同一个号在一篇里对、在另一篇里错。
只查号存在性 → 全绿;只按号统计”有几次引用” → 完全看不出问题。
必须落到「这个号在这一篇的这一处,被用来支撑什么」。
7.1 跨文件同号异题(X1)的独立信号价值
X1 不依赖 PubMed 任何一个字段,只做池内自比对:同一个 PMID 在两篇文章里被写成互不重叠的两个标题,至少有一个错——而且往往两个都错。
本轮 28 组 X1 里最干净的一组:
PMID 33901427
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm.md:106
→ "Pressure-harmonic gain curves for six primary pulse types." ❌
tcm-pulse-hri-inter-operator-...md:147
→ "Strategic infarct locations for post-stroke cognitive impairment" ✅
X1 的意义在于:它不需要联网就能跑。 在离线节点上,这是唯一可用的伪书目信号。
8. 本轮不做什么(守边界)
- 未改任何被审文件:63 个命中文件、
skin-depth-reference-table.md及池④ 受污染文件,mtime 全部未变 - 未标 accepted、未直写 779/782
- 未把「254 条」写成「池内共有 254 处错」——只说「已检出 254 条,真实总量更高、未知」
- 未对未覆盖的 91.7% 做任何错误率外推,只在 §4.2 说明「如果一致会是十倍量级」并明确标注这是条件假设
9. 下一步(按性价比排序)
| # | 动作 | 成本 | 依赖 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 反向校验器:抓真实标题 → 文中搜特征词(覆盖裸列表/多号并列) | 中 | 可自主,下轮 |
| 2 | 把本工具接入 P3-GOV-001 L1 执行(63 文件横幅) |
低 | 待 JOE 批 |
| 3 | 高复用号(27861248 11 处、27314975 10 处、33903610 8 处)逐号定位真源 |
中 | 可自主 |
| 4 | 8 个高发文件的 1.7 倍类数值论断逐条查证 |
中 | 需读全文 |
10. 参考文献(本轮方法论锚点,E-utilities 回查通过)
- Baethge C, et al. Citation inaccuracies in biomedical literature: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Res Integr Peer Rev. 2025. PMID: 40696441
- Mogull SA. Accuracy of cited “facts” in medical research articles: a methodological review. PLoS One. 2017. PMID: 28910404
- Montenegro TS, et al. Reference accuracy in spine surgery literature. J Neurosurg Spine. 2021. PMID: 32977312
三条均为「引文不准确性是系统性而非偶发」的上游依据,与本轮「63 文件 / 254 条 / 17 个文件 ≥6 条」的集中分布形态一致。
池③ · #191 · 2026-10-18 · draft · 未发布 · 未标 accepted
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
证据与局限
本文证据等级为 C,属 measurable,结论限于研究层面的推断,不构成对个体情形的判定。不一致、63 个文件、113 个唯一 PMID。
局限:本文未覆盖全部相关文献,效应量与结论随样本与方法变化;传统体系与现代研究的对照属结构类比而非等价证明,请结合专业判断参考。
Comprehensive Verification of Citation Statement Consistency in Pool 3: Quantification and Deployment of a Detector for \”Real Numbers Fake Bibliographies\
Evidence level: C
Pool ③ · Project #191 (Newly Registered in This Round) · Building upon Citation Governance from Rounds 1/2/4/5/6/7
Evidence Level C | Status draft | Writes to existing main text in this round = 0
Tool:08-ops/_tools/citation-claim-check.py(v2, standard library only, includes--selftestwith positive and negative sample validation)
0. One-Sentence Conclusion
The “True ID False Bibliography” identified in Round 7 is no longer a qualitative descriptor; this round quantifies it: 254 inconsistent statements distributed across 63 files, involving 113 unique PMIDs.
However, more significant than this number is an observation encountered during the process:
Out of 13,384 PMID citations in the full pool, only 703 (5.3%) appear on bibliography lines within the “References” section.
The remaining 94.7% are scattered throughout footnotes in the main text.If detection follows the logic of “parsing bibliography lines” (the v1 approach), the identified 223 items cover less than one-tenth of all citation positions—yet False Bibliographies specifically thrive in main text footnotes, as these areas lack formatting constraints and allow for arbitrary writing.
Furthermore, this round introduces a previously unnamed sibling subclass to “True ID False Bibliography”: “Changing IDs rather than Creating IDs.”
Some mismatches do not involve fabricating a source; instead, they involve having a batch of True IDs and attaching content from ID A to ID B—the topic originally had a correct source within the pool, but the pointer was simply incorrect. The remedy for such errors is changing the ID, not deleting the paragraph, resulting in a disposal cost far lower than that of the OMOM batch (§5.4 Case 2).
The disposal costs for these three failure modes differ significantly; conflating them turns cheap fixes into expensive ones:
| Subclass | Definition | Remedy | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| False ID | PMID does not exist | Delete or Replace | Low (but rare; only 4 in the full pool) |
| Changing ID | True ID, topic-related but incorrect pointer | Change ID | Low |
| True ID False Bibliography | True ID, but author/title/journal/topic entirely fabricated | Find new literature + Rewrite argument | High |
1. Why the Previous Gate Check Missed This
Both citation-verify.sh (Round 2 landing) and citation-pool-scan.py (Round 7 landing) address only a single question:
Does this PMID exist?
For the concept of “fake bibliography with a real number,” this question asks the wrong thing. The defining characteristic of a fake bibliography is that the “number is real”—an existence check will inevitably return green.
A specific example from this round’s testing (groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md, line 106):
1. Pollack GH, et al. *Electromagnetic signals from flowing groundwater...*
Journal of Scientific Exploration. 2005;17(2):157-182. PMID 15728218
- PMID
15728218exists → Existence check passes - However, the actual literature is: Muss HB, ACCO: ASCO core curriculum outline, with no relation to groundwater, electromagnetic signals, or Pollack.
- Author, title, journal, year, and topic—all five are incorrect; only the number is true
This type of error is more deceptive to readers than a fake number: clicking into PubMed reveals a real paper, which paradoxically enhances perceived credibility.
2. Detection Mechanisms: Three Deterministic Criteria
The new tool citation-claim-check.py performs only mechanical comparison requiring no semantic judgment:
| Code | Criterion | Implementation |
|---|---|---|
| T1 | AUTHOR-UNKNOWN | The surname of the first author, extracted via word boundaries, is not found in the real PubMed author list |
| T2 | TITLE-LOW-OVERLAP | The overlap rate of English lexical tokens between the claimed title and the real title is < 0.34 |
| X1 | SAME-ID-DIFF-CLAIM | The same PMID is written as two non-overlapping titles across two files (same ID, different titles) |
| I3 | YEAR-NOTE (INFO only) | Claimed year vs. publication year differs by ≥2 years — not included in conclusions |
2.1 Why I3 is restricted to INFO (Learning from previous iterations)
In Round 7, the citation-pool-scan.py tool downgraded criterion E3 (“year discrepancy”) for the following reason: this corpus contains numerous “1974–” entries which represent data years or cohort start years, not publication years. During the rewrite of this tool, the same issue was encountered again:
Claimed Year = 1974, Real Year = 1993
Real Title: [Analysis of geographical differences in the seasonal variation
of mean birth weight in Japan (1974- ...
The (1974- within the title represents a data range and was incorrectly flagged as “claiming 1974”. The same pitfall recurs with different tools, indicating that this criterion is fundamentally inapplicable for this specific corpus type.
2.2 False Positives Converged Only After Three Iterations (All Verified)
The tool was not correct on the first attempt. Each of the three corrections addressed a distinct class of real false positives:
| Version | Issue | Instance | Correction |
|---|---|---|---|
| v0 | Loose extraction of first word as surname | *Physiological Reports* → Surname “Physiological”; Task Force... → Surname “Task” |
Removed fallback logic; surname extraction only occurs after an explicit author block |
| v1 | Institution words/morphological terms not filtered | PMID itself treated as surname (2 instances) |
Added institution word list + morphological suffix blacklist |
| v2 | Chinese “等” is a listing particle, not “and others” | Butyricimonas 等短链脂肪酸产菌, AIx 等现代指标 → Genus names/abbreviations treated as surnames |
Only recognize “等人”, “等(”, “et al”; reject isolated “等” |
After three rounds of refinement, T1 counts shifted from 131 → 114 → 145 (initial decrease followed by increase: the drop resulted from removing loose fallback logic, while the rise resulted from covering cases in main text footnotes). Each correction requires re-running and re-sampling; otherwise, it is impossible to determine if the fix resolved true issues or merely deleted genuine problems.
2.3 Self-Verification Mechanism (Hard Requirement)
python3 citation-claim-check.py --selftest
Verification is performed using two known samples for positive and negative controls:
- Positive Control (known compliant files
tcm-pulse-hri-inter-operator-..., two citations) → Expected hits must equal 0 - Negative Control (known fake bibliography files
pulse-pressure-normalization-..., two citations) → Expected hits must be ≥2
Current results:
[selftest] Positive Control (Compliant Sample) Hits = 0 PASS
[selftest] Negative Control (Fake Bibliography Sample) Hits = 3 PASS
[selftest] RESULT: PASS
3. Full Pool Results
3.1 Overall Scope
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Scanned files | 733 |
| Parseable citation entries (bibliographic lines + footnotes) | 703 |
| Comparable titles (English titles) | 237 |
| Unique PMIDs involved | 485 |
| Total Hits | 254 |
| Files involved | 63 |
| Unique PMIDs (hit side) | 113 |
3.2 Grading by Severity
| Level | Meaning | Count |
|---|---|---|
| A | Author error and title error (double error at same location, strongest) | 126 |
| B | Only author error (title correct or unparseable) | 82 |
| C | Only title error (author correct or unparseable) | 9 |
| D | Same number across files but different titles (X1) | 37 |
The 126 Level A cases represent the strongest evidence in this round: at a single citation point, the listed first author does not match the real author, and the stated title shares almost no lexical overlap with the actual title. With two independent criteria simultaneously matching, parsing error is highly unlikely.
3.3 File Distribution (Top 12)
| File | T1 | T2 | X1 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
pulse-harmonic-random-forest-tcm-syndrome-prediction.md |
5 | 6 | 6 | 17 |
arterial-stiffness-hri-cavi-intervention-validation.md |
4 | 3 | 8 | 15 |
hri-spectrum-cardiovascular-event-prediction-longitudinal-cohort.md |
2 | 2 | 8 | 12 |
groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md |
5 | 5 | 0 | 10 |
nayin-birth-cohort-lifetime-health-trajectory.md |
3 | 4 | 2 | 9 |
nayin-epigenetic-phase.md |
4 | 4 | 0 | 8 |
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm.md |
3 | 3 | 2 | 8 |
tcm-constitution-multi-omics-reference-atlas.md |
4 | 4 | 0 | 8 |
meta-learning-cross-zang-transfer-blind-validation-failure-attribution.md |
7 | 0 | 0 | 7 |
enso-ci-coupling-multireanalysis-robustness.md |
3 | 3 | 0 | 6 |
enso-ci-coupling-trend-under-warming.md |
3 | 3 | 0 | 6 |
midnight-noon-circadian-frequency-encoding.md |
3 | 3 | 0 | 6 |
Distribution pattern: 17 files with ≥6 hits (concentrated contamination), 18 files with 3–5 hits, and 28 files with 1–2 hits (sporadic). This is not uniform typo noise but rather batch failures in a minority of files.
3.4 Cross-Pool Diffusion (New Finding in This Round)
Hit files are not limited to Pool 3. A broad categorization by pool affiliation reveals:
| Pool | Representative Files | Nature |
|---|---|---|
| ③ Biological Frequency | pulse-harmonic-*, hri-spectrum-*, nayin-* |
Pulse diagnosis/harmonic mainline, most dense |
| ④ Environmental Interface | groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md (10 hits) |
Pool 4 articles also affected |
| ① Resonant Consciousness Field | consciousness-field-interpersonal-spatial-propagation.md (5 hits), collective-meditation-brain-sync.md |
Meditation/brain synchronization |
| ② Spacetime Frequency | jieqi-pentad-wavelet-*, dayan-calendar-*, starchart-chronology.md |
Solar terms/star charts |
| ⑤ Cross-Cultural | qi-deficiency-english-translation-*, dosha-rsa-qi-deficiency-dual-mapping.md |
Cross-cultural equivalence |
This finding overturns previous judgments: the claim in Round 6 that “citation failures exist only along the OMOP subline” and the Round 7 expansion to “Pool 3 health mainline” are incorrect. The issue actually spans all five pools. The Pool 4 file groundwater-aquifer-elf-sleep-quality.md contains 10 hits, matching the density of high-frequency files in Pool 3.
4. Scope of Coverage: The Most Critical Point to Retain in This Round
4.1 Numbers
Total pool containing PMID files 710 articles
Total occurrences of PMID 13,384 instances
Parseable in bibliographic lines 703 entries → 5.3%
Parseable in footnotes (newly added) 405 instances → Additional 3.0%
Remaining "bare PMID citations" ~12,276 instances → 91.7% uncovered
4.2 Why This Matters More Than the Figure “254”
Version 1 parsed only bibliographic lines, yielding 223 entries and 49 files. With the inclusion of footnotes (Version 2), this increased to 254 entries and 63 files—a 29% increase in file count, while footnotes covered only 3% of citations. Consequently, if the error rate in the uncovered portion aligns with that of the parsed section, the true total would be an order of magnitude larger than the current figure.
One cannot assert that “there are over 2,000 errors” because the error rate in the uncovered portion remains unknown. However, it is certain that “254” represents a lower bound, and one is far from the true value.
4.3 This Is the Second Occurrence of the Same Error Type
The lesson from the previous round (Round 7) was that “conclusions must be based on ‘unextracted lines ≈ 0′”—the initial version missed 74 lines, nearly leading to the erroneous conclusion that “no issues exist within the pool.”
In this round, using a different tool, the same pitfall reappeared: the 96.7% coverage gap in Version 1 was not flagged in any output. The tool ran silently, quietly reported “49 files / 223 entries,” and presented itself as a complete result.
New Hard Rule R-191: Any tool performing “full-scan” operations must simultaneously output the denominator and coverage rate, explicitly stating the gap in the main output.
Scanners that report only the numerator without the denominator create a false sense of certainty.
5. Sampling Verification (Precision Validation)
From a random sample of 14 T1 and 8 T2/X1 items out of 254 total, each was verified against the original record (random.seed fixed for reproducibility):
5.1 T1 Sampling: 14 Items → All 14 Verified as Authentic
| PMID | Declared Surname | Actual First Author | Actual Title (Verified via E-utilities) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16243978 | Targetti | Hu G | Isoflurane prevents platelets from enhancing neutrophil-induced coronary endothelial dysfunction |
| 14675133 | Burch | Liu CJ | Polymorphism of the MICA gene and risk for oral submucous fibrosis |
| 17620642 | Li | Eisen RJ | Residence-linked human plague in New Mexico: a habitat-suitability model (Declared as forest bathing NK activity) |
| 29537674 | Chaplin | Amagai T | Accuracy of flow and sensors of indirect calorimetry for neonates and infants (Declared as “water memory” review) |
| 36509825 | Zhang | Wu LW | Discrimination between possible sarcopenia and metabolic syndrome using the arterial pulse spectrum |
| 33903610 | Hu | Lin SK | Classification of patients with Alzheimer’s disease using arterial pulse spectrum |
| 38942105 | Liu | Nishiwaki S | Prevalence and characteristics of AVNRT with a bystander pathway |
| 32929968 | Zhang | Miller JR | Particle-Based Reconfigurable Scattering Masks for Lensless Imaging (Declared as monsoon regime shift) |
| 27861248 | Li | Stoner L | Reliability of pulse waveform separation analysis: effects of posture and fasting |
| 38070877 | Zhang | Williams CE | The role of diet and host species in shaping seasonal dynamics of the gut microbiome (Declared as Five Phases-Six Qi-bacteria specific mechanism) |
| 39766014 | Charu | Abbas SR | Federated Learning in Smart Healthcare: A Comprehensive Review on Privacy, Security |
| 33509706 | Liu | Cordier PY | Complex and prolonged hypercoagulability in COVID-19 intensive care unit patients |
| 27861248 | Wang | Stoner L | Same as above (Same PMID assigned to a different fake author in another file) |
| 18999346 | Berman | Hamilton JM | Visuospatial deficits predict rate of cognitive decline in autopsy-verified dementia with Lewy bodies |
False Positive Rate: 0/14. Among these, 5 items (bolded) had actual titles completely unrelated to the declared theme (plague/neonatal calorimetry/lensless imaging/federated learning/Lewy body dementia), representing the most severe category of error.
5.2 Reverse Verification: Of the 9 files from Round 7, 4 were not hit this round; were they missed?
Round 7 listed 9 affected files. This round’s empirical test yielded 5 hits and 4 misses (programmatic comparison, not visual inspection):
| Round 7 File | This Round | Reason |
|---|---|---|
pulse-harmonic-random-forest-tcm-syndrome-prediction |
17 | Text unchanged, stable reproduction (and most severe) |
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm |
8 | Stable reproduction |
pulse-harmonic-spectrum-individualized-zangfu-functional-scoring |
5 | Stable reproduction (T1) |
standing-wave-antinode-psychophysiology |
3 | Stable reproduction (T1) |
hri-c2-c3-heart-qi-deficiency-severity-dose-response |
2 | Stable reproduction: Liang et al. (PMID: 33903610) has actual first author Lin SK |
pulse-harmonic-gut-microbiome-organ-axis |
0 | Missed: Written as “2021 study published in Nature Medicine” (PMID: 34637011); surname falls outside 90-character window |
pool5-standby-validation-entry-exit-gate |
0 | Missed: - PMID 29269119: Cross-cultural RSA... bare list, no surname for judgment |
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology |
0 | Missed: Same bare list format |
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification |
0 | Missed: Same bare list format |
5/9 Reproduced, 4/9 Missed. These 4 are not “files without issues,” but rather citation formats outside the detector’s recognized syntax—the direction of the miss is known and can be targeted (see §9, Item 1).
5.3 Known Citation Formats Still Not Covered (Registered as Such)
| Format | Instance | Reason for Miss |
|---|---|---|
| Bare list | - PMID 29269119: Cross-cultural RSA psychometrics development review... |
No surname; T1 cannot be judged |
| Chinese narrative followed by number | ... (PMID: 34637011) shows TMAO levels correlate with... |
Surname falls outside 90-character window |
| Multiple IDs in parallel | (PMID: 35161551, 36509825) |
Only first taken; second not judged |
These three categories account for the majority of uncovered cases. The next step should be “reverse verification”: For each PMID, retrieve the real title via API, search for characteristic terms within the text; if not found, it suggests a fake bibliographic description may exist in the text—independent of surname syntax.
5.4 Two Extreme Cases Missed but Immediately Identified Manually (Illustrating Miss Cost)
After blind execution, citation-verify.sh was used to re-check PMIDs cited in newly written articles, accidentally encountering two cases missed by the detector but with severity far exceeding already detected items:
Case 1: 34637011 (pulse-harmonic-gut-microbiome-organ-axis.md)
Declared in text: 2021 study published in *Nature Medicine* (PMID: 34637011)
showing positive correlation between TMAO levels and heart failure severity
Actual Literature: Goldbach JT, et al. "The Development of Proud & Empowered:
An Intervention for Promoting LGBTQ Adolescent Mental Health."
Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 2023
- Theme: TMAO/Heart Failure vs LGBTQ Adolescent Mental Health Intervention
- Journal: Nature Medicine vs Child Psychiatry Hum Dev
- Year: 2021 vs 2023
- Only the 8 digits match correctly
Reason for Miss: The declaration lacked the “Surname + et al.” structure (wrote “2021 study published in Nature Medicine”), falling under Category 1 of §5.3.
Case 2: 29269119 (3 Files, 3 Identities)
| File | Declared Identity |
|---|---|
pool5-standby-validation-entry-exit-gate.md |
“Cross-cultural RSA psychometrics development review” |
dosha-rsa-qi-deficiency-dual-mapping.md § Title |
“Ram Manohar P et al., J Ayurveda Integr Med, 2018, HRV spectral features of the three doshas” |
| Another location in same file | “Shu Q et al., 2017, Acupuncture regulation of HRV in Qi-deficiency constitution” |
| Third location in same file | “Tripathi PK et al., 2011” |
| Actual | Ram Manohar P, An exploratory clinical study to determine the utility of heart rate variability analysis in the assessment of dosha imbalance, J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018 |
One PMID was assigned three different first authors and three different years within the same file; one (Ram Manohar 2018) happens to be correct. This is no longer a “citation error,” but rather the same batch of materials being rewritten repeatedly, switching sources each time.
One layer deeper (new subclass discovered this round): The other two PMIDs in the same file actually have correct themes:
| PMID | Actual First Author | Actual Title | Relevance to “Acupuncture → Qi-deficiency HRV” Theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| 33068344 | Song YJ | Immediate effect of acupuncture and moxibustion at Guanyuan (CV4) and Zusanli (ST36) on heart rate variability (Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 2020) | ✅ Highly relevant |
| 40315935 | Li T | Effects of acupuncture and moxibustion on heart rate variability in chronic fatigue syndrome patients (Complement Ther Med 2025) | ✅ Highly relevant |
| 29269119 | Ram Manohar P | …utility of HRV analysis in the assessment of dosha imbalance* (J Ayurveda Integr Med* 2018) | ✅ Relevant (Ayurvedic side) |
In other words: If 29269119 in the “Acupuncture → Qi-deficiency HRV” section were replaced by 33068344, the paragraph would hold.
This reveals a previously unnamed failure subclass: “Swapping IDs rather than fabricating them”——
The author possesses a batch of “seemingly relevant” real IDs; during writing, they attach the content of ID A to ID B.
The distinction from “Real ID Fake Bibliography” is that the target theme already has a correct source in the pool; it is merely pointing at the wrong needle.
For such errors, the remedy is to swap the ID, not delete the paragraph—disposal cost is far lower than the OMOM batch.Significance of these two cases: The detector currently only catches “fake bibliographies with surnames.” However, the most egregious fake bibliographies often omit names entirely (writing only “a study from a certain year and journal”), making them even harder to catch—as they save the very field needed for verification.
6. Relationship with Existing Governance Cards
P3-GOV-001 (Round 7, Levels L0–L3) does not require structural changes; however, the list of affected files must be updated:
| Level | Original Scope | Current Revision |
|---|---|---|
| L0 | New drafts do not cite contaminated literature | Unchanged |
| L1 | 9 files with banners + citation_status: disputed |
Expanded to 63 files (17 of which have ≥6 high-priority citations) |
| L2 | 4 fake IDs + 2 false entries | Unchanged, plus 113 high-reuse IDs from “inconsistent declarations” in PMID |
| L3 | OMOP 9 papers + 2 gut-heart axes | Unchanged |
L1 offers improved cost-effectiveness: Adding 63 files, a single frontmatter field, and a banner remains a reversible, zero-deletion action that immediately halts misleading citations. However, expanding the scope from 9 to 63 files is no longer a task completable in a single iteration, requiring JOE to decide whether to proceed in batches or implement fully.
7. Practical Implications for Research Conclusions (Retractions Required)
A citation mismatch is not inherently a research error; however, if a specific numerical claim is attached to an irrelevant document, that claim lacks support.
The most critical location identified in this round (first detected in Round 7, confirmed to recur in another file):
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm.md Line 56:
"Pre-experimental data indicates that the G(P) slope of the thready pulse is approximately 1.7 times that of the floating pulse (PMID: 33901427)"
The PMID 33901427 actually refers to Weaver 2021, a study on imaging in post-stroke cognitive impairment, and has no relation to pressure-harmonic gain curves. The figure “1.7 times” has no verifiable source in this corpus.
Another category of structural issues: PMID 27861248 (True Source = Stoner L, Reliability of pulse waveform separation analysis: effects of posture and fasting) appears in 11 files within the corpus (verified via grep -l). While some entries correctly list Stoner as the first author, others incorrectly list Wang, Li, or Blacher. Having the same real document appear with different first authors across different articles is a typical manifestation of cross-subline misappropriation and fabricated bibliographic stacking.
Other high-reuse PMIDs (precisely counted in this round, all hits):
| PMID | True First Author | Files Hit | T1 Count | False Last Names Assigned |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 33903610 | Lin SK | 9 | 7 | Hu / Liang / Wang / WK |
| 36294440 | Chen CC | 6 | 3 | Wang / Xu / Zhang |
| 27861248 | Stoner L | 4 | 4 | Blacher / Li / Wang |
| 27314975 | Bilton K | 3 | 3 | Fukuda / Liu / Zhang |
| 36509825 | Wu LW | 3 | 1 | Zhang |
| 33901427 | Weaver NA | 2 | 1 | Zhang |
33903610 is the most typical case: a single PMID is written as four different first authors (Hu / Liang / Wang / WK) across 9 files. However, a counter-example must also be noted: in hri-c2-c3-lvef-joint-diagnostic-model.md and hri-harmonic-c2-c3-heart-qi-deficiency-severity-dose-response.md, the same PMID is correctly listed as Lin S.K. / Lin et al..
This is the methodology established in Round 2 and verified again this round: A single PMID is correct in one article but incorrect in another.
Checking only for the existence of a PMID yields all green; counting only how many times a PMID is cited reveals no obvious issues.
One must drill down to “what specific claim in this article is supported by this PMID at this location.”
7.1 Independent Signal Value of Cross-File Same-ID Different-Title (X1)
X1 does not rely on any PubMed field; it performs only internal comparison within the corpus: if the same PMID is written with two non-overlapping titles in two different articles, at least one is incorrect—and often both are.
Among the 28 groups of X1 identified in this round, the cleanest group is:
PMID 33901427
pulse-pressure-normalization-hri-algorithm.md:106
→ "Pressure-harmonic gain curves for six primary pulse types." ❌
tcm-pulse-hri-inter-operator-...md:147
→ "Strategic infarct locations for post-stroke cognitive impairment" ✅
The significance of X1 lies in its ability to run offline. On an isolated node, this is the only available pseudo-bibliographic signal.
8. Scope Limitations (Boundary Preservation)
- No modifications to audited documents: The 63 flagged files,
skin-depth-reference-table.md, and the contaminated files in Pool ④ retain their original modification times (mtime). - No labels of “accepted” status were applied, nor were the values 779/782 written directly.
- The count of “254 items” was not rephrased as “there are 254 errors within the pool”; instead, it was stated that “254 instances were detected, with the actual total being higher and currently unknown.”
- No error rate extrapolation was performed for the 91.7% of data not covered; Section 4.2 merely noted that “if consistent, the magnitude would be tenfold” and explicitly marked this as a conditional hypothesis.
9. Next Steps (Ranked by Cost-Effectiveness)
| # | Action | Cost | Dependency |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Reverse Validator: Search for characteristic terms within real titles (covering bare lists and multiple numbers listed together) | Medium | Autonomous; dependent on next round |
| 2 | Integrate this tool into the P3-GOV-001 L1 execution (63-file banner) |
Low | Pending JOE approval |
| 3 | Locate true sources for high-repetition numbers (27861248 appearing 11 times, 27314975 appearing 10 times, 33903610 appearing 8 times) |
Medium | Autonomous |
| 4 | Verify each claim of the “1.7 times” numerical assertion across the 8 high-frequency files | Medium | Requires reading full texts |
10. References (Methodological Anchors for This Round; Verified via E-utilities)
- Baethge C, et al. Citation inaccuracies in biomedical literature: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Res Integr Peer Rev. 2025. PMID: 40696441
- Mogull SA. Accuracy of cited “facts” in medical research articles: a methodological review. PLoS One. 2017. PMID: 28910404
- Montenegro TS, et al. Reference accuracy in spine surgery literature. J Neurosurg Spine. 2021. PMID: 32977312
All three sources provide upstream evidence that citation inaccuracies are systematic rather than incidental, aligning with the concentrated distribution pattern observed in this round (63 files / 254 citations / 17 files with ≥6 citations).
Pool 3 · #191 · 2026-10-18 · draft · unpublished · not accepted
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply