Evidence level: B
先给结论
池⑤ 的《三质↔气虚 RSA 反证边界》设计里,F1–F5 被写成五条并列的”证伪条件”,而 §11 又写”进入 779 intake 的条件:H1 + H2 同时通过且 F1–F5 全部未触发”。这一句把五道止损阀直接当成了准入证。两件事的阈值本该不一样,这里用了同一套。
本轮只读复核(不改正文)算下来,最硬的一句是:
F2 的间隙是 Δr 0.10 → 0.15,宽 0.05;
F2 自己的 95% 噪声半宽 0.136(ρ=0.5);
F3 每条件 n=12,噪声半宽 0.49。
间隙只有噪声的 1/2.7 和 1/9.8 —— "中等衰减"这个区间,物理上判不出来。
一、五把尺子,五个刻度,被串成一个 AND
F1–F5 分别长在五个不同的量纲上:|r|(相关值)、Δr(差值)、票数(k of n)、ΔCFI(拟合指标差)、比例(受试者误解率)。五者没有共同刻度,却被一个 AND 串起来当门票用。
这带来的第一个后果是可算的:若四道独立闸门各自的假杀率分别是 0.50、0.50、0.131、0.370(取”真值恰好压在门槛上”这个决策最相关的点),全部通过的概率是 13.7%。也就是说,一个”刚好合格”的项目有 86.3% 概率被至少一道闸门判死。而”刚好合格”恰恰是准入判断唯一真正要处理的区间——明显好和明显差的项目,用一道闸门就够。
多道止损阀串联不等于”更严格”,只等于”更容易否决”。 严格与否要看单闸的判据带宽,不看串联的道数。
二、F1:门槛压在目标值上,n=120 只分得开 0.50 与 0.35
F1 是”H1 不满足即降级 E3″,而 H1 的门槛是 |r| ≥ 0.50。真值恰好 0.50 时,被判失败的概率是 50.0%;真值 0.55 时仍有 22.7%。这不是精度差,是阈值设在了目标值上,等于把所有”说不清”都归进不可逆的那一侧(R27)。
n=120/组时,r=0.50 处的 95% CI 半宽是 0.136。按 Cohen 的锚点(0.30 与 0.50 差 0.20),判据半带宽是 0.10,R26 比值 0.74 < 1;按更严的锚点 0.40,半带宽 0.05,比值降到 0.37。要把”0.50 与 0.40″分开,需要 SE_z ≤ 0.0255,即 n ≥ 1541/组——现设计 120,差 12.8 倍。
两个锚点都给出来,是因为乘性/非线性尺度上的”±X”只在一个锚点成立,不写锚点的百分比会被读成全局。
三、F3:多数表决的票数门槛没随票数重算
F3 是”5 个扰动探针中 ≥ 3 个使 |r| 衰减 ≥ 0.15 即判失败”。这是 (k,n) 多数表决。
每条件 n=12(60 人 / 5 条件,每条件 ≥12),SE_dz = 1/√(12−3) = 0.333,Δr 的 95% 半宽 0.49。真 Δr = 0 时,单个探针”假报 ≥0.15″的概率是 0.274(ρ=0.5)到 0.336(ρ=0)。三个探针凑够票,概率 13.1%–21.3%。
反直觉的一条:探针从 5 个加到 8 个,若票数门槛仍是 3 票(37.5%),假报率从 0.130 升到 0.382;加到 10 个仍是 3 票(30%),升到 0.545。加探针而不改票数门槛,会让闸门更容易假报。 要保住 60% 的票数比,10 个探针需 ≥6 票,假报率才回落到 0.031。
这是因为多数表决的假报率不是 n 的单调函数——它由”票数比 k/n”和 n 共同决定,加票不改比例就是在放松。
四、F3 的阶梯是倒挂的:结论越重,证据越薄
F3 一旦触发,结论从 E3 降到 E2 并”必须说明扰动敏感性”——这是全卡里后果最重的一档。但它的样本最小:每条件 12 人。
Δr 的标准误是 F1(n=120)的 3.61 倍,而门槛只放宽 3.0 倍(0.15 vs 0.05)。要让 F3 达到与 F1 同等的分辨率,每条件需 3460 人(ρ=0.5),5 个条件共 17,302 人——现设计是 60 人。
越往”最弱假设”走,需要的证据越硬,而设计给的样本越少。 这个倒挂不是笔误,是”证伪条件按严重程度排序、样本量按方便程度分配”两套逻辑没有对齐的结果。
五、F5:”>20%” 在 n=20 时实际只能落到 25%
认知访谈 n=20,规则写”出现 >20% 受试者语义误解”。20% × 20 = 4,而 > 不含等号,所以只有 X ≥ 5 才算触发,实现阈值是 5/20 = 25%,比声明值高 1.25 倍。
真误解率恰好 20% 时,触发 F5 的概率是 0.370。这个数在 n=20 时最小,随 n 增大反而上升到 0.466(n=300)——因为大 n 下实现阈值逼近 20%,判据变”灵敏”,而 20% 本身就是门槛。离散计票的阈值实化误差与统计功效的方向是相反的,加样本并不能同时改善两者。
六、顺带把 #22 的三档也扫了一遍:R29 不适用,但另有形态
池④ 上一轮在 K1–K4 上立了 R29「判据单侧自动收紧」,并把 #22 的 A/B/C 列为”疑同一缺陷,待查”。本轮补算:#22 不触发 R29。
按 1 km / 7.83 Hz 复算,A 档真实边界是 σ ≥ 4.283×10⁻²(A = 10 dB,D1′ 记 4.29×10⁻²,吻合),C 档边界 σ ≤ 10⁻³(A = 1 dB)。σ 的不确定度是 ×q:
A 档门槛(σ 下界)随 q 上移:σ_A·q —— 更难进 A
C 档门槛(σ 上界)随 q 下移:σ_C/q —— 更难进 C
B 档 = (σ_C/q, σ_A·q),宽度比从 42.8× 涨到 q=10 时的 4282.9×
两侧同时外扩,方向对称,因此没有单侧偏心。但出现了另一种形状:
R29-b「中间档吸收」——判定力不偏向某一侧,而是全部塌进中间那一档。精度变差时 A 档与 C 档同时消失,所有站都落进”条件性测”。后果与 R29 一样(永远不说”不用测”,永远说”以后再说”),机制不同:R29 是门槛函数形式不同导致单侧收紧,R29-b 是宽档两侧外扩导致全域吸收。
两者不得互相替代:R29 的解法是统一门槛的函数形式;R29-b 的解法是取消”宽档”这个吸收态,或给它设上限。
七、新增两条硬规矩
R30「合取门槛必须报联合功效」:多道止损闸门串联作为准入条件时,必须同时报”单闸假杀率 → 全过概率”。只报”我们有五道检查”会被读成严格,而实际是 13.7% 的通过率。
R31「多数表决的票数门槛必须随票数重算」:(k,n) 结构的假报率不是 n 的单调函数。加探针不改票数比会让假报率上升;任何”多设几个探针更稳”的写法都要重算 k。
八、引用核查中的两个硬伤(如实报)
复核过程中顺手扫了本设计 §12 的引文,发现两处:
| 原写 | 实况 | 处置 |
|---|---|---|
| PMID 24233341(Lehrer PM, HRV biofeedback: effects across domains, Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback 2013) | PubMed 无此记录(efetch 返回空集) | 建议换 25101026(Lehrer PM, Heart rate variability biofeedback: how and why does it work?, Front Psychol 2014;5:756,已核) |
| PMID 39563397(Li Z, acupuncture… functional dyspepsia, Chin Med 2024) | 该号真实为 Loix M, Stearoyl-CoA desaturase-1, Mol Neurodegener 2024;19 —— 主题完全无关 | 建议换 30246392(Liu Y, 电针 ST36 大鼠消化不良模型, Neurogastroenterol Motil 2019)或直接删除该条 |
| PMID 34479992(Chung JW, HRV and TCM patterns) | 假号,已登记 P-1 层 I-2/I-3 | 仍在等 JOE 批,本轮未动 |
本轮不改这个文件:它属 779 intake 三件套范围,且引文治理全在 JOE 待批。只登记,不执行。
证据与局限
本文全部为解析推导与二项/正态模拟,不含任何实测数据。三条必须写明的边界:
- 「判不出」不等于「假说不成立」。 本文只说”这套闸门判不出它想判的答案”,不说”Vata-low ≈ 气虚-low”为真或为假。按 R11,零参数/纯解析判据只承担证伪职能,不得反过来当”判据合格”的证明。
- ρ(两次测量间的相关)未实测。 F2/F3 的噪声全部依赖 ρ,本文给了 ρ = 0 到 0.9 的区间。真实 ρ 取决于同一批人重复测量的间隔与体位控制,未做过预实验。
- 有效推进的边界:本文提出的是判据层的结构问题,不是研究结论。F1–F5 的具体修订(阈值、票数、样本量)全部停在建议层,等 JOE 批。
相关阅读
- 池④ #77 K1–K4 判档体系结构审计(R26 起源)
- 池③ #187 ICC 闸门 CI 宽度前置补全(R27 起源)
- 池④ #26 六站逐站过闸(R29 起源)
- 池⑤ #19 #20 证伪优先方法学 / 预注册规范(F1–F5 出处)
引用锚点
- Task Force of ESC/NASPE. Heart rate variability: standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use. Circulation. 1996. PMID: 8598068.
- Cohen J. A power primer. Psychol Bull. 1992. PMID: 19565683.
- Lehrer PM, Gevirtz R. Heart rate variability biofeedback: how and why does it work? Front Psychol. 2014;5:756. PMID: 25101026.
- Lakens D. Equivalence Tests: A Practical Primer for t Tests, Correlations, and Meta-Analyses. Soc Psychol Personal Sci. 2017. PMID: 28736600.
- Nosek BA, Ebersole CR, DeHaven AC, Mellor DT. The preregistration revolution. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2018. PMID: 29531091.
- Koo TK, Li MY. A Guideline of Selecting and Reporting Intraclass Correlation Coefficients for Reliability Research. J Chiropr Med. 2016. PMID: 27330520.
- Chen FF. Sensitivity of Goodness of Fit Indexes to Lack of Measurement Invariance. Struct Equ Modeling. 2007. doi:10.1080/10705510701301834.
免责声明:本文为方法学审计,涉及中医体质、阿育吠陀三质与自主神经指标,属健康相关主题。文中所有结论均为统计判据层面的推导,不构成任何诊断、治疗或体质判定建议,不得用于临床决策或产品化。
review_status: draft —— 未经 779 intake 审核,不得标 accepted。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Five falsification gates strung into one ticket: the scale of F1–F5 is coarser than the gap it measures
Evidence level: B
Conclusion First
In the design of Pool ⑤’s “Three Constitutions ↔ Qi Deficiency RSA Falsification Boundary”, F1–F5 are written as five parallel “falsification conditions,” while §11 states: “Condition to enter the 779 intake: H1 + H2 both pass AND F1–F5 all do NOT trigger.” This sentence treats the five stop-loss valves directly as an admission ticket. The thresholds for these two functions should differ, yet the same set is used.
This round involves only read-and-review (no changes to the main text). The most critical calculation is:
The gap for F2 is Δr 0.10 → 0.15, width 0.05;
F2's own 95% noise half-width is 0.136 (ρ=0.5);
F3 per condition n=12, noise half-width 0.49.
The gap is only 1/2.7 and 1/9.8 of the noise — "moderate attenuation" cannot be physically distinguished.
I. Five Rulers, Five Scales, Strung Together into One AND
F1–F5 grow on five different dimensions: |r| (correlation), Δr (difference), votes (k of n), ΔCFI (fit index difference), and proportion (misunderstanding rate). These five lack a common scale yet are strung together by an AND gate to serve as the ticket.
The first consequence is calculable: if the false-kill rates of the four independent gates are 0.50, 0.50, 0.131, and 0.370 (taking the decision-relevant point where “truth lies exactly on the threshold”), the probability of passing all is 13.7%. Thus, a “just-qualified” project has an 86.3% chance of being killed by at least one gate. Note that “just-qualified” is precisely the interval that admission judgment must truly handle; obviously good and obviously bad projects can be judged by a single gate.
Serialing multiple stop-loss valves does not mean “stricter”; it means “easier to reject.” Whether it is strict depends on the bandwidth of the single-gate criterion, not the number of gates in series.
II. F1: Threshold Set on Target Value, n=120 Distinguishes 0.50 from 0.35
F1 is “if H1 fails, downgrade to E3,” while H1’s threshold is |r| ≥ 0.50. When truth is exactly 0.50, the probability of failure is 50.0%; at truth 0.55, it remains 22.7%. This is not poor precision; it is because the threshold is set on the target value, effectively casting all “unclear” cases into the irreversible side (R27).
With n=120/group, the 95% CI half-width at r=0.50 is 0.136. Using Cohen’s anchor (difference of 0.20 between 0.30 and 0.50), the criterion half-bandwidth is 0.10, yielding R26 ratio 0.74 < 1; using the stricter anchor 0.40, half-bandwidth is 0.05, ratio drops to 0.37. To separate “0.50 from 0.40,” we need SE_z ≤ 0.0255, i.e., n ≥ 1541/group — the current design of 120 is off by 12.8 times.
Both anchors are provided because “±X” on multiplicative/nonlinear scales holds only at one anchor; percentages without the anchor will be read as global.
III. F3: Majority Vote Threshold Not Recalculated with Votes
F3 is “among 5 disturbance probes, ≥3 cause |r| attenuation ≥0.15 → failure.” This is (k,n) majority voting.
Per condition n=12 (60 people / 5 conditions, each ≥12), SE_dz = 1/√(12−3) = 0.333, Δr’s 95% half-width 0.49. When true Δr = 0, the probability of a single probe “falsely reporting ≥0.15” ranges from 0.274 (ρ=0.5) to 0.336 (ρ=0). Three probes reaching the threshold yields probability 13.1%–21.3%.
Counterintuitively: Adding probes from 5 to 8, if the vote threshold remains 3 (37.5%), the false-report rate rises from 0.130 to 0.382; adding to 10 with threshold 3 (30%) rises to 0.545. Adding probes without changing the vote threshold makes the gate easier to falsely report. To maintain 60% of votes, 10 probes need ≥6 votes, bringing false-report rate back to 0.031.
This occurs because the false-report rate of majority voting is not a monotonic function of n — it is determined by the ratio k/n and n. Adding votes without adjusting the proportion relaxes the criterion.
IV. F3’s Steps Are Inverted: Heavier Conclusions, Thinner Evidence
Once F3 triggers, the conclusion drops from E3 to E2 and “must explain disturbance sensitivity” — this is the most severe consequence in the whole card. Yet its sample size is smallest: 12 per condition.
Δr’s standard error is 3.61 times that of F1 (n=120), while the threshold relaxes only 3.0 times (0.15 vs 0.05). To match F1’s resolution, each condition would need 3460 people (ρ=0.5), totaling 17,302 for five conditions — the current design is 60.
Moving toward “weakest hypotheses” requires harder evidence, yet the design provides less sample. This inversion is not a typo; it results from misalignment between “falsification conditions ranked by severity” and “sample allocation by convenience.”
V. F5: “>20%” at n=20 Actually Means 25%
The cognitive interview uses n=20, with the rule “trigger if >20% of subjects show semantic misunderstanding.” Since 20% × 20 = 4, and “>” excludes equality, only X ≥ 5 triggers, making the actual threshold 5/20 = 25%, 1.25 times higher than stated.
When true misunderstanding rate is exactly 20%, the probability of triggering F5 is 0.370. This is minimal at n=20; as n increases, it rises to 0.466 (n=300) — because under large n the realized threshold approaches 20%, making the criterion “more sensitive,” while 20% itself is the threshold. The discretization error of the voting threshold and statistical power move in opposite directions; adding sample size does not improve both simultaneously.
VI. Incidentally Reviewing #22’s Three Tiers: R29 Inapplicable, Yet Another Form Emerges
In Pool ④’s previous round, R29 “criterion one-sided automatic tightening” was established on K1–K4, and #22’s A/B/C were listed as “suspected same defect, pending check.” This round completes the calculation: #22 does not trigger R29.
Recalculating at 1 km / 7.83 Hz:
– Tier A’s true boundary is σ ≥ 4.283×10⁻² (A = 10 dB, D1′ recorded as 4.29×10⁻², matching);
– Tier C’s boundary is σ ≤ 10⁻³ (A = 1 dB).
– σ’s uncertainty scales by q:
Tier A threshold (σ lower bound) shifts up with q: σ_A·q — harder to enter A
Tier C threshold (σ upper bound) shifts down with q: σ_C/q — harder to enter C
Tier B = (σ_C/q, σ_A·q), width ratio grows from 42.8× to 4282.9× when q=10
Both sides expand outward symmetrically, so no single-sided bias occurs. However, another shape emerges:
R29-b “Middle Tier Absorption” — judgment power does not lean to one side but collapses entirely into the middle tier. When precision worsens, Tier A and Tier C both vanish, and all stations fall into “conditional measurement.” The consequence matches R29 (always saying “not yet measured,” always saying “later”), but the mechanism differs: R29 arises from different threshold function forms causing single-sided tightening, whereas R29-b stems from both sides of the wide tier expanding outward causing global absorption.
These two cannot substitute each other: R29’s solution is unifying the threshold function form; R29-b’s solution is eliminating the “wide tier” absorbing state or setting its upper limit.
VII. Two New Hard Rules Added
R30 “Conjunction Threshold Must Report Joint Power”: When multiple stop-loss gates are serialized as admission conditions, one must simultaneously report “single-gate false-kill rate → all-pass probability.” Reporting only “we have five checks” will be read as strict, while the actual pass rate is 13.7%.
R31 “Majority Vote Threshold Must Be Recalculated with Votes”: The false-report rate of (k,n) structure is not a monotonic function of n. Adding probes without adjusting the vote ratio increases false reports; any claim “adding more probes makes it more stable” must recalculate k.
VIII. Two Hard Flaws Found in Citation Review (Reported Truthfully)
During review, we scanned the citations in §12 of this design and found two issues:
| Original | Reality | Action |
|---|---|---|
| PMID 24233341 (Lehrer PM, HRV biofeedback: effects across domains, Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback 2013) | PubMed has no record (efetch returns empty set) | Recommend replacing with 25101026 (Lehrer PM, Heart rate variability biofeedback: how and why does it work?, Front Psychol 2014;5:756, verified) |
| PMID 39563397 (Li Z, acupuncture… functional dyspepsia, Chin Med 2024) | This number actually refers to Loix M, Stearoyl-CoA desaturase-1, Mol Neurodegener 2024;19 — topic completely unrelated | Recommend replacing with 30246392 (Liu Y, electroacupuncture ST36 rat dyspepsia model, Neurogastroenterol Motil 2019) or deleting this entry entirely |
| PMID 34479992 (Chung JW, HRV and TCM patterns) | Fake number, already registered in P-1 layer I-2/I-3 | Still awaiting JOE approval; not touched this round |
This round does not change this document: it falls within the 779 intake triad scope, and citation governance is pending JOE approval. We only register it, do not execute.
Evidence and Limitations
All content in this paper consists of analytical derivation and binomial/normal simulations, containing no empirical data. Three boundaries must be explicitly stated:
- “Cannot judge” does not mean “hypothesis false.” This paper states only that “this set of gates cannot judge the answer it wants to judge,” not whether “Vata-low ≈ Qi Deficiency-low” is true or false. Per R11, zero-parameter/pure-analytic criteria bear only falsification function and cannot serve as proof of “criterion qualified.”
- ρ (correlation between two measurements) was not empirically measured. F2/F3’s noise entirely depends on ρ; this paper provides the range ρ = 0 to 0.9. True ρ depends on repeat measurement intervals and posture control of the same batch, which were not pre-tested.
- Boundary of effective advancement: This paper addresses structural issues at the criterion level, not research conclusions. Specific revisions to F1–F5 (thresholds, vote counts, sample sizes) remain at the suggestion level, pending JOE approval.
Related Reading
- Pool ④ #77 K1–K4 tiering system structure audit (origin of R26)
- Pool ③ #187 ICC gate CI width pre-completion (origin of R27)
- Pool ④ #26 six-station sequential gate passage (origin of R29)
- Pool ⑤ #19 #20 falsification-priority methodology / preregistration norms (source of F1–F5)
Reference Anchors
- Task Force of ESC/NASPE. Heart rate variability: standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use. Circulation. 1996. PMID: 8598068.
- Cohen J. A power primer. Psychol Bull. 1992. PMID: 19565683.
- Lehrer PM, Gevirtz R. Heart rate variability biofeedback: how and why does it work? Front Psychol. 2014;5:756. PMID: 25101026.
- Lakens D. Equivalence Tests: A Practical Primer for t Tests, Correlations, and Meta-Analyses. Soc Psychol Personal Sci. 2017. PMID: 28736600.
- Nosek BA, Ebersole CR, DeHaven AC, Mellor DT. The preregistration revolution. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2018. PMID: 29531091.
- Koo TK, Li MY. A Guideline of Selecting and Reporting Intraclass Correlation Coefficients for Reliability Research. J Chiropr Med. 2016. PMID: 27330520.
- Chen FF. Sensitivity of Goodness of Fit Indexes to Lack of Measurement Invariance. Struct Equ Modeling. 2007. doi:10.1080/10705510701301834.
Disclaimer: This paper is a methodological audit involving TCM constitution, Ayurvedic three constitutions, and autonomic nervous system indicators — all health-related topics. All conclusions herein are statistical criterion-level derivations and do not constitute any diagnostic, therapeutic, or constitution judgment advice; they must not be used for clinical decision-making or productization.
review_status: draft — Not yet reviewed by the 779 intake; cannot be marked accepted.
Leave a Reply