Evidence level: B
1. 先给结论
治理报告 2026-11-05 给出一条看起来最省事的执行方案:
「14 个 lab 假号的 cn 版全部已含正确号 →『只改 lab 版那串数字、论证一字不动』这条方案,本轮 14 篇全部成立,可一次性批量执行。」
复核一遍之后,结论要分两层说清楚,不能一句话否掉这条方案:
方案本体的技术前提是成立的。 逐个核了 16 个号,cn 版确实每一篇都已经写着正确的号——「只改 lab 的 digit string、论证一字不动」这个大方向没问题。
但方案的三处外围前提没有一条被验过,而它们恰好决定执行会不会翻车:
| 层 | 报告口径 | 实测 | 会出什么事故 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 数量 | 声称「20 个假号」 | 声称 20 / 实数 19 / 实测 22。三个数各不相同,每一处都能逐行核对:① 报告那张「上轮 19 个」清单,逐行数只有 18 个不同号(14 个挤在一行 + 4 行单列),加本轮新增 350124830 = 19,所以”20″这个数从一开始就没有出处;② 24233341 既在 18 行清单里,又被另标为「第 19 个假号」——19 被用两次;③ 报告把 19104495 算进假号,但它真实存在(只是指错文,见 §4),应减 1;④ 报告漏了 4 个「PubMed 查无此号」的:28726973、15199541、16030677、357544612,其中 357544612 任何报告与台账都没提过,躺在 11-06 03:14 刚落盘的 rater-count-marginal-precision-diminishing-returns.md L45(cn 版 L48 同句是 35754612)→ 19 − 1 + 4 = 22 |
照报告的成员名单执行,会漏 4 处(357544612 正落在最新文章里,恰恰是「新文章 222 PMID 全真 0 假号」这句结论最易漏的地方),并且会误删 19104495(它该换号而不是删) |
| 方案粒度 | 「只改 lab」+「可一次性批量执行」 | 必须逐处替换,不能整篇整替。两个号会出事:194811481 所在文件 L51/L64 早已是真值(整替后同一号在一篇里有多种写法,回滚不了);24233341 的假号只存在于两行审计台账(那两行是”报过什么”的证据,改了等于销毁) |
改完无法判断到底改没改到;台账一改,下一轮扫描会把它重新判成假号 |
| 依据本身 | 报告即实况 | 报告里的 35124830 题录是错的(写 Front Psychol 2022;13:872,实为 Stat Med 2022;41(11):1986-2004);28726973 被记成「(无真值)」而实际有(见 §5) |
照错的题录去核,会把一个真号判成错号;照「无真值」去删号,会删掉一条本来能救回来的引用 |
而这三层错有一个共同来源,不是懈怠,是方法学盲点:修复方案被当成”已知结论”引用,而不是被当成”待验证断言”。 本文把这一条立成规矩(R40,§6)。
而这三层错的共同来源不是懈怠,是一个方法学盲点:修复方案被当成”已知结论”引用,而不是被当成”待验证断言”。本文把这一条立成规矩。
2. 第二层:为什么”整篇整替”会出事
拿 grounding-acupoint-impedance-pathology-amplification-scale.md 举例。lab 版里:
L37 高唤醒模型(PMID 194811481) ← 假号(多一位)
L51 PMID 27152281; PMID 9811051; PMID 19481481 ← 已经是真值
L64 … PMID 9811051, PMID 19481481 … ← 已经是真值
也就是说,同一个文件里假号和真值并存——L37 打错,L51/L64 打对。若按”整篇整替”的思路处理,得到的结果是:L37 被修正的同时,L51/L64 也被再替换一遍;如果替换实现写的是”把真值处也统一成某个规范写法”,就会出现同一号在一篇里出现三种写法而无法回滚。更糟的是无法判断 L37 到底有没有被改到——因为改前改后,全文的 19481481 计数都是”有”。
24233341 是更硬的例子:falsification-gate-suite-scale-mismatch-conjunction.md 的 pmids 数组(L25)与参考文献表(L145)早已是正确号 25101026,带 24233341 的只有 L109 与 L120 两行——而那两行恰恰是审计台账自身的对照记录(L120 原文写的就是「PMID 24233341 … PubMed 无此记录 → 建议换 25101026」)。
由此得出一条硬约束:审计台账行永不改。 改台账等于销毁”报过什么、判过什么”的证据,而且会让同一个号在下一轮扫描里被重新判为假号——修复动作反而制造了新缺口。
3. 第三层:假号下面还埋着假文献
34479992 是本库最著名的一条:同一个不存在的号,在三篇文章里被赋予三种不同身份:
| 文件 | 该号被说成什么 |
|---|---|
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md |
Chung JW et al., J Acupunct Meridian Stud, 2021《中医证型与 HRV》 |
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md |
Putnick & Bornstein, 2016《跨文化测量等值性系统综述》 |
pool5-standby-validation-entry-exit-gate.md |
HRV 跨族裔参考值的等值性研究 |
按第二条身份核验,真值是存在的:27942093 = Putnick DL, Bornstein MH. Measurement Invariance Conventions and Reporting. Dev Rev 2016;41:71-90, DOI 10.1016/j.dr.2016.06.004(当日 EuropePMC 回查,题名/作者/卷页/DOI 四项全对)。
但按第一条身份核验,检索「Chung JW + J Acupunct Meridian Stud + 2021」在 PubMed/EuropePMC 上命中 0。
所以”给假号找个真值换上去”这条通用药方在这里失效:换成
27942093只救得了第二处,第一处与第三处的被引文献本身就不存在,换号只是把”号不存在”升级成”号存在但指向别的东西”——从会报警的错,变成不会报警的错。
这是引文失效里最需要区别对待的一类:号是假的,文献也是假的。处置必须逐处分支,不能整号统一替换。
4. 第五种失效形态:同处并列两个编号,一个真一个假
consciousness-intention-rng-evidence-boundary.md 里有一句:
冥想 → DMN/α波改变(已证,PMID 19104495 / PNAS 1112029108)
两个编号一起写在同一行,看起来像”双保险”,实际:
19104495真实存在,但指向 2009 年《Bone Marrow Transplant》一篇讲 ATG 免疫抑制与 EBV 相关淋巴增殖的论文 → 完全不相干;- DOI
10.1073/pnas.1112029108也真实存在,指向 Brewer JA 等, PNAS 2011;108(50):20254-20259《Meditation experience is associated with differences in default mode network activity and connectivity》——与声明内容完全吻合。其真值 PMID 是22114193。
教训不是”这篇引错了”,而是”DOI 校验通过会掩盖 PMID 是错的”。
PMID 与 DOI 是两个独立编号空间,一个对不蕴含另一个对。凡”题录里同时挂了两种编号”的场合,两种都必须各自回查——而本库此前的校验流程里,DOI 走 Crossref、PMID 走 esummary,两套检查互不交叉,正好让这种错长期存活。
5. 第五层(最该记住的):报告本身是待验证断言
三处实测,全都发生在治理报告里:
| 项 | 报告口径 | 实测 |
|---|---|---|
35124830 题录 |
「Front Psychol 2022;13:872」 | Vanacore A, Pellegrino MS. Stat Med 2022;41(11):1986-2004, DOI 10.1002/sim.9341(两本刊,卷页完全不同) |
| lab-only 假号数量 | 「删一位即真值、全在 lab」报 14 个 | 15 个(14 + 251736621,后者报告只在正文提过、未计入那张清单);若按「全库 lab-only」口径则 16 个(再加 357544612,任何报告与台账都没提过)。cn 版同句写 35754612,真值 = Jiang Z, Raymond M, DiStefano C 等, Educ Psychol Meas 2022;82(5) |
28726973 |
「(无真值)」 | 有真值:29582913 = Hartogs BMA, Bartels-Velthuis AA, Van der Ploeg K, Bos EH, Methods Inf Med 2017;56(6):419-426, DOI 10.3414/me16-02-0033 |
第三条特别值得停一下。原文声明是「7 名完成 8 周训练的患者中,4 人在退出阶段出现效应逆转,作者结论是持续练习可能是维持效应的必要条件」。而 29582913 的摘要逐条对上:
- 「Seven participants completed the full protocol … single-subject ABA multiple baseline experimental design」→ 7 人、ABA 单被试设计;
- 「The effect of treatment was reversed in four patients during the withdrawal phase」→ 4 人退出期逆转;
- 「A prolonged treatment or continued home practice may be required for enduring effects」→ 持续练习的必要性。
「无真值」不是一个可以随便写下的判定。 台账此前记「(无真值)」的潜台词是”这个号背后没有真实文献”,但实际是”我不知道怎么把它找回来“。两句话在处置上的含义完全不同:前者导向删号,后者导向”换个检索式再试一次”。本轮改用语义检索(题名关键词 + 摘要特征词 + 人数/设计细节),一次命中。
规矩:凡判”无真值”,必须附上试过的检索式;”未找到”与”不存在”是两个结论,不得混写。
16030677 则暴露另一个层级——它不是假号,是不该有 PMID 的文献被硬配了一个:Rey L. Thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions…, Physica A 2003;322:281-305。Crossref 确认 DOI 10.1016/s0378-4371(03)00047-5 真实,但卷页是 323:67-74,出版日期 2003-05。也就是说”去掉 PMID、改 DOI 引用”只修好了第一层,卷页 322:281-305 这个第二层错还在。报告只提了第一层。
6. 一条能防住这五层的规矩:R40
把本轮实证压缩成一句可执行的:
R40「修复方案是可证伪断言」
任何”照这份清单/方案直接执行”的指令,在执行前必须对清单本身做三件事:① 重新数一遍条目数(报告称 20 个、清单逐行只列 19 个、实测 22 个——三个数都要重数);② 抽验至少一条真值题录的刊名/卷页/作者(本轮抽到 1 条即错);③ 确认每条的执行粒度(整篇整替 vs 逐处替换,本轮 2 条会出错)。
与 R22(canonical 表优先逐算)同族,但作用对象不同:R22 管”被引的表要重算”,R40 管”拿去执行的方案要重数”。
配套的两条操作细则:
- 位数检查只对一半假号有效:全库 9 位及以上的 PMID 声明共 13 个文件可被位数正则抓出;但本批 8 个 8 位假号(B 表 6 个:
34479992/29144112/24233341/28726973/15199541/16030677;A 表 2 个:23226598/28775237)位数全部合规,位数检查一律放行。 - 两份编号各自核:凡题录里同时挂 PMID 与 DOI,两条链都要走完;只核一个等于没核。
7. 证据与局限
证据强度:B。 本文每条结论都锚在当日实时回查的题录上(27942093、29582913、22114193、35124830、35754612、DOI 10.1016/s0378-4371(03)00047-5 六项均四项比对通过),但没有一条是”引文修复方案复核”这一行为本身的同行评议研究——这类方法学问题不在 PubMed 收录范围内。因此本文的强度来自”可复现的机械核验”,不是来自文献共识。
四条局限,须如实写下:
- 未执行任何修正。 全文所有条目处于 patch-ready 状态,
grep -c复验显示假号计数与改前一致。本文的价值只在”把执行前置条件定死”,不改一个字。 - 行号会漂。 本库每小时有新文章落盘,行号以 2026-11-07 06:5x 快照为准;下一轮执行前必须重取行号,不能照抄。
- “文献不存在”是检索结论,不是本体结论。
Chung 2021 中医证型 HRV在本轮三种检索式下 0 命中,但《J Acupunct Meridian Stud》历史上有过未被 PubMed 收录的年份——严格说只能报”在 PubMed/EuropePMC 检索不到”,不能报”该文献从未存在”。 - 2 条需要 JOE 选口径,不是技术问题。
15199541(HPA 报告)是”保留报告去 PMID”还是”换成 PubMed 收录综述”,取决于原文论述是否就是要引那份政府报告;这是取舍,不是对错。
8. 待验证(本文反推出的两条可测课题)
- 课题 A:把 R40 的三步检查做成脚本(条目数重数 + 题录抽验 + 粒度标记),在下一批 D 清单执行时跑一遍,测”报告口径与磁盘实况的偏差率”——本轮抽样 3 项错 3 项(100%),样本太小,需扩到全库 22 个号重测才能给出偏差区间。
- 课题 B:”同处并列 PMID + DOI”的写法在全库有多少处?若比例显著(>5%),则应把”两编号各自核”写进所有写手的提交门禁,而不是仅作审计提醒。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Only modifying the lab is wrong in three aspects: review of the citation batch repair solution
Evidence level: B
1. Preliminary Conclusion
The Governance Report dated 2026-11-05 proposes an execution strategy that appears to be the most expedient:
“All 14 Chinese versions of lab pseudonyms already contain the correct numbers → ‘Only modify the digit string in the lab version, leaving the argumentation text unchanged.’ This approach validates all 14 papers in this round and can be executed in a single batch.”
Upon review, the conclusion must be articulated on two distinct levels; this approach cannot be entirely rejected in a single statement:
The technical premise of the solution itself is valid. A verification of 16 numbers confirms that the Chinese versions indeed already contain the correct numbers—’Only modify the digit string in the lab version, leaving the argumentation text unchanged’ is the correct general direction.
However, three peripheral premises of the solution have not been verified, and they precisely determine whether execution will fail:
| Layer | Report Statement | Actual Measurement | Consequence of Error |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quantity | Claims “20 pseudonyms“ | Claimed 20 / Actual count 19 / Measured 22. These three figures differ, and each can be verified line-by-line: ① The report’s list of “previous round 19 pseudonyms,” when counted line-by-line, contains only 18 distinct numbers (14 crowded into one row + 4 listed individually), plus the new 350124830 from this round = 19, so the number “20” had no basis from the start; ② 24233341 appears both in the 18-row list and is separately marked as “the 19th pseudonym”—19 is used twice; ③ The report includes 19104495 as a pseudonym, but it actually exists (it was misattributed, see §4), so subtract 1; ④ The report omits 4 numbers with “no PMID found in PubMed”: 28726973, 15199541, 16030677, 357544612, among which 357544612 was never mentioned in any report or ledger, appearing on line L45 of rater-count-marginal-precision-diminishing-returns.md dated 11-06 03:14 (the Chinese version line L48 reads 35754612 for the same sentence) → 19 − 1 + 4 = 22 |
Executing based on the report’s member list would miss 4 locations (357544612 falls exactly within the newest article, precisely where the conclusion “New article 222 PMID: all true, zero pseudonyms” is most easily overlooked), and would incorrectly delete 19104495 (it should be replaced, not deleted) |
| Solution Granularity | “Only modify lab” + “can be executed in a single batch” | Must replace each location individually; cannot replace entire papers at once. Two numbers will cause issues: 194811481 resides in files L51/L64 which already contain true values (replacing entirely would result in the same number appearing in multiple forms within one paper, making rollback impossible); 24233341‘s pseudonym exists only in two audit ledger rows (these rows serve as evidence of “what was reported,” so modifying them equals destroying evidence) |
After modification, it becomes impossible to determine whether the replacement was successful; once the ledger is altered, the next round of scanning will reclassify it as a pseudonym |
| Basis Itself | Report equals reality | The citation for 35124830 in the report is incorrect (listed as Front Psychol 2022;13:872, but actually Stat Med 2022;41(11):1986-2004); 28726973 is marked as “(no true value)” but actually has one (see §5) |
Following the incorrect citation will cause a valid number to be judged as erroneous; deleting based on “no true value” will remove a citation that could otherwise be recovered |
The common source of these three errors is neither negligence nor oversight, but rather a methodological blind spot: the repair solution was cited as “known conclusion” rather than treated as “pending verification assertion.” This paper establishes this rule (R40, §6).
2. Second Layer: Why “Whole-Document Replacement” Causes Errors
Taking grounding-acupoint-impedance-pathology-amplification-scale.md as an example. In the lab version:
L37 High-arousal model (PMID 194811481) ← False number (one extra digit)
L51 PMID 27152281; PMID 9811051; PMID 19481481 ← Already true values
L64 … PMID 9811051, PMID 19481481 … ← Already true values
This means false numbers and true values coexist in the same file—L37 is incorrect, while L51/L64 are correct. If processed using the “whole-document replacement” approach, the result is: L37 is corrected simultaneously with L51/L64 being replaced again; if the replacement implementation standardizes “true values into a uniform format,” it leads to the same number appearing in three different forms within one document, making rollback impossible. Worse still, it becomes impossible to determine whether L37 was actually corrected—because both before and after modification, the count of 19481481 in the full text remains “present.”
24233341 is an even stronger example: the pmids array (L25) and reference table (L145) in falsification-gate-suite-scale-mismatch-conjunction.md already contain the correct number 25101026**, while only lines L109 and L120 carry 24233341—and those two lines are precisely the audit ledger’s own cross-reference records** (line L120 originally states “PMID 24233341 … PubMed has no such record → recommend replacing with 25101026”).
This yields a hard constraint: audit ledger rows must never be modified. Modifying the ledger destroys evidence of “what was reported and what was judged,” and causes the same number to be reclassified as false in the next round of scanning—the repair action instead creates new gaps.
3. Third Layer: False Citations Buried Beneath False Numbers
34479992 is the most notorious entry in this repository: the same non-existent identifier is assigned three distinct identities across three articles:
| File | What the number is claimed to be |
|---|---|
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md |
Chung JW et al., J Acupunct Meridian Stud, 2021 “TCM Syndrome and HRV” |
dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-preregistration-specification.md |
Putnick & Bornstein, 2016 “Cross-cultural measurement invariance systematic review” |
pool5-standby-validation-entry-exit-gate.md |
HRV cross-ethnicity reference value invariance study |
Verifying against the second identity, the true value exists: 27942093 = Putnick DL, Bornstein MH. Measurement Invariance Conventions and Reporting. Dev Rev 2016;41:71-90, DOI 10.1016/j.dr.2016.06.004 (confirmed via EuropePMC on that day, with title/author/volume/page/DOI all matching).
However, verifying against the first identity, searching “Chung JW + J Acupunct Meridian Stud + 2021” on PubMed/EuropePMC yields zero hits.
Therefore, the general remedy of “finding a true value to swap onto a false number” fails here: swapping to
27942093only fixes the second instance; the cited literature for the first and third instances does not exist at all. Changing the number merely upgrades “the number does not exist” to “the number exists but points to something else”—transforming an alarm-triggering error into a silent error.
This represents the class of citation failure requiring the most differentiated treatment: the number is false, and the literature is also false. Resolution must branch individually for each instance; uniform replacement across all numbers is not feasible.
4. Fifth Failure Mode: Two Numbers Listed Side-by-Side, One True and One False
The file consciousness-intention-rng-evidence-boundary.md contains the following line:
Meditation → DMN/α-wave alteration (verified, PMID 19104495 / PNAS 1112029108)
Both identifiers appear on the same line, creating an appearance of “double insurance,” yet in reality:
19104495is valid, but it refers to a 2009 article in Bone Marrow Transplant concerning ATG immunosuppression and EBV-associated lymphoproliferation → completely unrelated;- DOI
10.1073/pnas.1112029108is also valid, pointing to Brewer JA et al., PNAS 2011;108(50):20254-20259 “Meditation experience is associated with differences in default mode network activity and connectivity” — which aligns perfectly with the stated claim. Its corresponding PMID is22114193.
The lesson is not “this citation was wrong,” but rather “passing DOI validation can mask the fact that the PMID is incorrect.”
PMID and DOI belong to two independent numbering spaces; correctness of one does not imply correctness of the other. In any instance where a record lists both types of identifiers simultaneously, each must be independently verified — yet our prior validation workflow checked DOI via Crossref and PMID via esummary, with no cross-checking between the two systems, allowing such errors to persist undetected.
5. Layer 5 (Most Critical): The Report Itself is an Unverified Assertion
Three instances of measurement error were identified, all occurring within the final report:
| Item | Reported Value | Actual Value |
|---|---|---|
35124830 citation |
“Front Psychol 2022;13:872” | Vanacore A, Pellegrino MS. Stat Med 2022;41(11):1986-2004, DOI 10.1002/sim.9341 (Two different journals and page ranges) |
| Number of lab-only false IDs | Reported 14 (“Delete one to get true value, all in lab”) | 15 (14 + 251736621, which was mentioned in the main text but not included in that list); if using the “all lab-only” definition, 16 (adding 357544612, which is not mentioned in any report or ledger). The Chinese version of the same sentence states 35754612; true value = Jiang Z, Raymond M, DiStefano C et al., Educ Psychol Meas 2022;82(5) |
28726973 |
“(无真值)” (No true value) | Has true value: 29582913 = Hartogs BMA, Bartels-Velthuis AA, Van der Ploeg K, Bos EH, Methods Inf Med 2017;56(6):419-426, DOI 10.3414/me16-02-0033 |
The third instance is particularly significant. The original text states: “In seven participants who completed the full protocol, four showed reversal of effect during withdrawal, leading authors to conclude that continued practice may be necessary to maintain effects.” This matches the abstract of 29582913 point-by-point:
- “Seven participants completed the full protocol … single-subject ABA multiple baseline experimental design” → 7 participants, ABA single-subject design;
- “The effect of treatment was reversed in four patients during the withdrawal phase” → 4 participants showed reversal during withdrawal;
- “A prolonged treatment or continued home practice may be required for enduring effects” → necessity of continued practice.
“No true value” is not an arbitrary judgment. The ledger previously marked “(无真值)” implying “no real literature exists behind this ID,” but the actual meaning was “I do not know how to retrieve it.” These two statements have fundamentally different implications for handling: the former leads to deletion, while the latter prompts “try a different search strategy.” This round used semantic retrieval (title keywords + abstract features + participant count/design details), achieving a single hit.
Rule: Any determination of “no true value” must include the search strategies attempted; “not found” and “does not exist” are two distinct conclusions and must not be conflated.
16030677 exposes another layer—it is not a false ID, but a literature item that should not have a PMID was forcibly assigned one: Rey L. Thermoluminescence of ultra-high dilutions…, Physica A 2003;322:281-305. Crossref confirms DOI 10.1016/s0378-4371(03)00047-5 is real, but the volume/page is 323:67-74, with publication date 2003-05. Thus, “removing PMID and changing DOI citation” only fixed the first layer; the second-layer error (volume/page 322:281-305) remains. The report only addressed the first layer.
6. One Rule to Guard Against These Five Layers: R40
Compress this round of empirical evidence into one executable statement:
R40 “Repair schemes are falsifiable claims”
Any instruction to “execute directly according to this list/scheme” must, before execution, perform three things on the list itself: ① recount the number of entries (the report claims 20, the list enumerates only 19 row-by-row, and the actual measurement yields 22— all three counts must be re-tallied); ② spot-check at least one true-value record’s journal title/volume/page/author (in this round, spotting just 1 error is sufficient); ③ confirm the execution granularity for each item (whole-article replacement vs. spot-by-spot substitution; in this round, 2 items will fail).
Related to R22 (where the canonical table takes priority for step-by-step calculation), but acting on different objects: R22 governs “the cited tables must be recalculated,” whereas R40 governs “the schemes taken for execution must be re-counted.”
Two accompanying operational details:
- Digit checks apply only to half the false IDs: Among all 13 files declaring PMID statements of 9 digits or more in the full database, digit-regex can capture them; however, this batch’s 8 false IDs of 8 digits (Table B has 6:
34479992/29144112/24233341/28726973/15199541/16030677; Table A has 2:23226598/28775237) all comply with digit rules, so digit checks are universally passed. - Cross-check both numbering chains: For any record listing both PMID and DOI, both chains must be traversed; checking only one equals no check at all.
7. Evidence and Limitations
Evidence Level: B. Each conclusion in this text is anchored to specific records retrieved in real-time for the given date (27942093, 29582913, 22114193, 35124830, 35754612, DOI 10.1016/s0378-4371(03)00047-5; all six passed the four-way comparison). However, none of these are peer-reviewed studies on the methodology itself—”citation repair scheme verification”—as such methodological questions fall outside the scope of PubMed indexing. Therefore, the strength of this text derives from “mechanically verifiable reproducibility,” not from literature consensus.
Four limitations must be stated explicitly:
- No corrections were applied. All entries in this text remain in patch-ready status; re-verification via
grep -cconfirms the count of false identifiers matches the pre-modified state. The value of this text lies solely in “fixing the execution prerequisites,” without altering a single character. - Line numbers may drift. This repository receives new articles hourly; line numbers are based on the snapshot of 2026-11-07 06:5x. Line numbers must be re-extracted before the next execution cycle; they cannot be copied directly.
- “Non-existent literature” is a retrieval conclusion, not an ontological one.
Chung 2021 TCM syndrome HRVyielded zero hits under all three search strategies in this round, yet Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies has historically published years not included in PubMed. Strictly speaking, one can only report “not found via PubMed/EuropePMC searches,” not “this document never existed.” - 2 items require JOE to select the scope, not a technical issue.
15199541(HPA report) involves the choice between “retaining the report without PMID” or “substituting with a PubMed-indexed review.” This depends on whether the original argument specifically cites that government report; this is a matter of selection, not right or wrong.
8. To Be Verified (Two Testable Topics Derived by Reverse Inference in This Paper)
- Topic A: Script the three-step verification of R40 (item count re-counting, citation spot-checking, granularity marking) and run it during the next batch of D-list executions to measure “the deviation rate between report scope and disk reality”—this round’s sample of 3 items yielded 3 errors (100%), which is too small; the full database of 22 items must be re-tested to establish the deviation interval.
- Topic B: How many instances in the full database feature “co-located PMID + DOI”? If this proportion is significant (>5%), then “mutual verification of both identifiers” should be embedded in the submission gate for all authors, rather than serving merely as an audit reminder.
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply