Evidence level: B
本文性质:方法学 + 库内审计,draft,未进 accepted,未直写 779/782。
一句话结论:σ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km 山体 A ≥ 10 dB这条 A 档门槛,在 σ 区间的最不利端只有 4.83 dB;它只在区间另一端成立。“区间能过”不等于”门槛成立”——这是本库此前 13 轮审计工具都没检出来的一类缺陷。
一、问题从哪来:一个被反复引用、但没人验过方向的门槛
池④ 这条线上,mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md §二 的三档表是下地采样决策的总闸门:
| 档位 | 山体类型 | σ (S/m) | 1 km A(dB) @ 7.83 Hz | 建议 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A 档(优先测) | 湿玄武岩、含金属硫化矿/磁铁矿山体、断裂带蚀变岩 | ≥ 10⁻² | ≥ 10 dB | 第一批测点 |
| B 档(条件性测) | 含水/含裂隙花岗岩、含黏土断层带、含盐水侵染灰岩 | 10⁻³–10⁻¹ | 1–10 dB | A 档测完仍有预算再上 |
| C 档(不测或仅作对照) | 干燥未蚀变花岗岩、火成岩体外缘 | ≤ 10⁻⁴ | < 1 dB | 跳过 |
这张表已经被后面几篇文章反复引用(high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md 的 K1 门槛、elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md §5、多份实验设计)。
前几轮已经查出过它的一处硬错:A 档「σ ≥ 10⁻² → A ≥ 10 dB」在 σ=10⁻² 处只有 4.83 dB,被记为”门槛高估 ~2×”。
但那个判定本身有个盲点:它拿 σ 区间的一个端点(10⁻²)去判,然后直接下”门槛错”的结论。σ 在这里是开区间(≥ 10⁻²,上限在表里没写),区间内 σ 越大 A 越大 —— 那么”门槛能否成立”就取决于你取区间哪一端。
这正是本轮要堵的口子。
二、物理事实:σ 与 δ、A 的方向是相反的
三个式子决定了全部推理,不需要任何文献:
δ = √(2 / (ω μ σ)) → σ ↑ 则 δ ↓(开方反比)
A(dB) ≈ 8.7 · d / δ → δ ↓ 则 A ↑(反比)
∴ A ∝ √σ(d、f、μ 固定时)
所以在同一条 σ 区间里:
- 取 σ 最小端 → δ 最大 → A 最小(门槛最容易不达标)
- 取 σ 最大端 → δ 最小 → A 最大(门槛最容易达标)
对 A ≥ 10 dB 这种下界断言,最不利端永远是 σ 最小端。反之,对 δ ≤ 67 km 这种上界断言,最不利端是 σ 最大端(真值要么本来就小,要么被压得更小)。
换句话说:判一个带区间的门槛,必须先想清楚”最不利端点在哪一侧”。 这一步此前从来是隐式的,靠人记。
三、把 A 档门槛两端的数算出来
固定 f = 7.83 Hz、d = 1 km、μr = 1:
A(σ=10⁻²) = 4.829 dB ← 区间最小端(若 σ 真取到 10⁻²)
A(σ=10⁻¹) = 15.271 dB
A(σ=1) = 48.29 dB
反解「1 km 处 A 正好 10 dB」所需的 σ:
δ_need = 8.7 × 1000 / 10 = 870 m
σ_need = 2 / (2π × 7.83 × μ0 × 870²) ≈ 4.29 × 10⁻² S/m
于是 A 档那条门槛可以写成一个精确的等价命题:
σ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km A ≥ 10 dB成立,当且仅当 σ 实际落在 ≥ 4.29×10⁻²。
若 σ 落在 [10⁻², 4.29×10⁻²) 这一段,1 km 处 A 不足 10 dB。
也就是:这条门槛在它自己声明的区间里,只有约 0.63 个数量级(10⁻² → 4.29×10⁻²)是”不成立”的,其余都成立。
这不是”门槛错了 2 倍”,而是一个更精确、也更有操作价值的描述:门槛的真实分界是 4.29×10⁻²,不是 10⁻²。差的那 0.63 个数量级,恰好是野外 σ 实测的分辨率边缘 —— 这正是它危险的地方。
四、这不是孤例:15 条断言卡在同一处
本轮把 delta-table-scan.py 从 v1.2 升到 v1.3,加了一个此前没有的判定:当 σ 是区间时,把声明值分别在两个端点下过一遍,看结论是否一致。四种结果:
| 结果 | 含义 | 可下的结论 |
|---|---|---|
both |
两端都成立 | 无条件成立(最硬的一档) |
signed |
只有一端成立 | 不能判对、也不能判错 —— 属”未量化方向”,必须报出来 |
none |
两端都不成立 | 无条件不成立 |
None |
σ 是单点 | 无需端点判读 |
全库跑下来(扫描根 .,780 全库):
断言总数 344|minmatch 200|endpoint: both=9, signed=15, 单点=320
15 条 signed。逐条看,最关键的是这三类:
| 位置 | 声明 | 最不利端真值 | 结论 |
|---|---|---|---|
mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md:55(中英各 1) |
σ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km A ≥ 10 dB | 4.829 dB | 端点不足,需改为 σ ≥ 4.29×10⁻² |
schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md:45(中英各 1)+ 3 处引用 |
σ ≤ 10⁻⁴ → δ ≥ 670 km | 17.99 km | 端点不成立(第 9–13 轮已判,本次由工具自动复现) |
elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md 等审计表 |
引用上两行的判读 | — | 属”引用了错值”,随源一起改 |
注意第二条的意义:δ ≥ 670 km 这条,前 4 轮是靠人工逐格复算才判死的(且成因追了 4 轮仍未定)。v1.3 的端点判读是零人工、自动复现——这是工具第一次独立命中它。
五、一个反直觉的副作用:门槛”太松”比”太严”更危险
前面 elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md 把 A 档门槛记为「高估 ~2×」,方向读起来像是”门槛太严、把好东西挡在外面”。
但按端点算清楚之后,实际效果是双向的:
- 若 σ = 10⁻²(区间最不利端):A = 4.83 dB,达不到 10 dB → 这条”值得优先测”的标签给早了;
- 若 σ = 10⁻¹(区间中间):A = 15.27 dB,远超 10 dB → 门槛又显得过严。
所以这张表的真问题不是”偏 2 倍”,而是:它在用一个区间定义一个应该由单点决定的分档。σ 是采样后才知道的量(该 SOP 自己写”按 10 g 岩石样品实测 σ 决定分档”),却用采样前的文献区间去写判据 —— 逻辑上是”用粗粒度输入下细粒度结论”。
这与本库此前记下的两类缺陷同族:
- 池④ #51「区间跨档」(判据分辨率不够却给了单一结论)
- 池③ #192「一条伪造引文改写核心数值结论」(结论精度超过输入精度)
本轮的贡献是给出了第三个具体形态:区间端点的方向性被忽略——不是区间太宽,也不是数值算错,而是没说明用的是哪一端。
六、把它变成可执行的三条规矩(R7–R9)
写入 08-ops/experiments/pool4-sigma-endpoint-direction-governance.md(P4-AUDIT-009),摘要如下:
R7(端点判读):凡 σ(或任何进公式的参数)以区间/开区间给出,而声明值是不等式断言时,必须在两端各判一次,并报告 both / signed / none。只判一端即视为未完成判定。已固化进 delta-table-scan.py 的 endpoint_check()。
R8(signed 不得升级为”已修正”或”已证伪”):signed 只说明”方向未量化”,处置动作是补写端点(把 ≥ 10 dB 改成 σ ≥ 4.29×10⁻² 时 ≥ 10 dB),不是判错、也不是改数值。此条防止把”没写清”当成”算错了”去改正文。
R9(判据参数与采样顺序必须一致):若某分档的判据参数(σ)在流程上是采样后才测得,则文献区间只能用于预筛层级,不得直接写成”测得值 Δ 门槛”。本条专门针对 SOP 类文件。
七、证据与局限
证据等级 E3(结构类比 + 解析复算),非 E1。
- 全部为公式复算(δ=√(2/(ωμσ))、A≈8.7d/δ)与库内文本解析,无任何实测;
- 4.29×10⁻² 是在 μr=1、均匀半空间、无位移电流假设下的自洽阈值;真实山体 σ 随频率弥散(Revil 2013)、μr 可 >1(Kariya & Shankland 1983 对下地壳干岩石的测量即显示强频散),故野外阈值会偏离这个数,方向不保证;
- 本文判”门槛分界应为 4.29×10⁻²”仅指与表格自述 σ 自洽,不指野外真实分界;
- 15 条
signed中只精算了 3 类(A 档门槛、670 km、审计表引用),其余未逐条复算; both只有 9 条、signed15 条,说明本库带区间的断言本来就少(320 条是单点 σ),因此”15 条”这个数不能外推为”库内缺陷率”;- 端点判读依赖 σ 区间的正确解析。开区间(
≥/≤)的上/下界是工具人为给 3 个数量级余量的约定,不是文件写明的,这是本文最脆的一环; - 工具仍只认 markdown 表格 + 文本正则,正文散句中的区间断言覆盖不全(覆盖率 38/58 表 = 65.5%,含 F0 剔除 4 张后的分母口径)。
未做:未改任何已发布正文(A 档门槛的文、670 km 的源文及其 5 处引用全部未动,等 JOE 批);未做 σ 实测;未新增「靠山→健康」通路(净增通路 0);未标 accepted;未直写 779/782。
参考文献
- Revil A. Effective conductivity and permittivity of unsaturated porous materials in the frequency range 1 mHz–1 GHz. Water Resources Research, 2013. doi:10.1029/2012WR012700
—— 用于说明 σ 的频率弥散:真实岩石电导率不是常数,本文的单一 σ 取值是简化。 - Laštovičková M, Bochníček J. A contribution to the measurement of frequency dependence of electrical conductivity of rocks. Studia Geophysica et Geodaetica, 1992. doi:10.1007/BF01613900
—— 同上,岩石电导率频散的直接测量证据。 - Kariya KA, Shankland TJ. Electrical conductivity of dry lower crustal rocks. Geophysics, 1983;48:52–61. doi:10.1190/1.1441407
—— 干燥下地壳岩石的电导率量级,用于界定 10⁻⁴–10⁻² 这档 σ 的合理性边界。 - Mehran M, Arulanandan K. Low frequency conductivity dispersion in clay-water-electrolyte systems. Clays and Clay Minerals, 1977;25:39–48. doi:10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107
—— 黏土/页岩(本表 B 档主要岩性之一)的低频电导率弥散,说明 B 档 “1–10 dB” 的区间宽度有物理来源。
以上 4 个 DOI 均经 Crossref 逐条回查(标题/期刊/年份/作者一致)。本文无 PMID:4 篇均属地球物理与材料学期刊,不在 PubMed 索引范围,故按宪章 §2 只能记 E3,不构成 E1。
附:复算脚本(可复现)
MU0 = 4π×10⁻⁷ ; DBN = 8.685889638
δ(f,σ,μr) = √( 2 / (2π f MU0 μr σ) )
A(d,σ) = DBN · d / δ
A(1 km, 10⁻²) = 4.829 dB
A(1 km, 10⁻¹) = 15.271 dB
δ_need(A=10dB, d=1km) = 8.7×1000/10 = 870 m
σ_need = 2/(2π·7.83·MU0·870²) = 4.29×10⁻² S/m
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Same σ interval, A-gear threshold passable only at one end: interval endpoint directional gate
Evidence level: B
Nature of this paper: Methodology + internal audit, draft, not yet accepted, not directly written for 779/782.
One-sentence conclusion: For the A-threshold conditionσ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km mountain A ≥ 10 dB, the least favorable end of the σ interval yields only 4.83 dB; it holds true only at the opposite end of the interval. “Interval passability” does not equal “threshold validity”—this is a class of defect missed by the previous 13 rounds of audit tools in this repository.
I. Where the Problem Originates: A Repeatedly Cited, Yet Unverified Directional Threshold
On Pool ④, the three-tier table in §II of mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md serves as the master gate for on-site sampling decisions:
| Tier | Lithology Type | σ (S/m) | 1 km A(dB) @ 7.83 Hz | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier A (Priority Measurement) | Wet basalt, metal sulfide-bearing ore bodies, magnetite mine bodies, alteration rocks within fault zones | ≥ 10⁻² | ≥ 10 dB | First batch of measurement points |
| Tier B (Conditional Measurement) | Water-bearing or fractured granite, clay-bearing fault zones, limestone infiltrated by saline water | 10⁻³–10⁻¹ | 1–10 dB | Proceed only if budget remains after Tier A measurements |
| Tier C (Skip or Reference Only) | Dry unaltered granite, outer margins of igneous rock bodies | ≤ 10⁻⁴ | < 1 dB | Skip |
This table has been repeatedly cited in subsequent articles (the K1 threshold in high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md, §5 of elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md, and multiple experimental designs).
Previous rounds identified a critical error in this table: the Tier A claim “σ ≥ 10⁻² → A ≥ 10 dB” yields only 4.83 dB at σ = 10⁻², leading to the conclusion of “threshold overestimation by ~2×”.
However, that judgment itself contains a blind spot: it uses one endpoint of the σ interval (10⁻²) to evaluate the threshold, then directly concludes “the threshold is wrong.” Here, σ represents an open interval (≥ 10⁻², with the upper limit not specified in the table); within this interval, larger σ values correspond to larger A values. Therefore, whether “the threshold holds” depends entirely on which end of the interval is selected.
This is precisely the gap we must address in this round.
II. Physical Facts: σ and δ, A Direction Opposite
Three equations determine the entire inference; no literature is required:
δ = √(2 / (ω μ σ)) → σ ↑ 则 δ ↓(开方反比)
A(dB) ≈ 8.7 · d / δ → δ ↓ 则 A ↑(反比)
∴ A ∝ √σ(d、f、μ 固定时)
Therefore, within the same σ interval:
- Selecting the minimum σ end → δ is maximum → A is minimum (the threshold is most likely to fail)
- Selecting the maximum σ end → δ is minimum → A is maximum (the threshold is most likely to be met)
For assertions of a lower bound such as A ≥ 10 dB, the most unfavorable end is always the minimum σ end. Conversely, for assertions of an upper bound such as δ ≤ 67 km, the most unfavorable end is the maximum σ end (the true value is either already small or suppressed further).
In other words: To judge a threshold with an interval, one must first clarify “which side is the most unfavorable endpoint.” This step was previously implicit, relying on human memory.
III. Calculating the Threshold Values at Both Ends of Level A
With fixed parameters f = 7.83 Hz, d = 1 km, and μr = 1:
A(σ=10⁻²) = 4.829 dB ← minimum end of the interval (if σ truly reaches 10⁻²)
A(σ=10⁻¹) = 15.271 dB
A(σ=1) = 48.29 dB
Solving for the σ required when A exactly equals 10 dB at 1 km:
δ_need = 8.7 × 1000 / 10 = 870 m
σ_need = 2 / (2π × 7.83 × μ0 × 870²) ≈ 4.29 × 10⁻² S/m
Thus, the Level A threshold can be stated as a precise equivalent proposition:
σ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km A ≥ 10 dBholds if and only if σ actually falls in ≥ 4.29×10⁻².
If σ lies in the interval [10⁻², 4.29×10⁻²), then A at 1 km is less than 10 dB.
This means: within the interval it declares, only approximately 0.63 orders of magnitude (10⁻² → 4.29×10⁻²) render the threshold “not holding”; the rest do hold.
This is not “the threshold being off by a factor of 2,” but rather a more precise and operationally valuable description: the true dividing line is 4.29×10⁻², not 10⁻². That missing 0.63 orders of magnitude corresponds precisely to the resolution edge of field measurements of σ — and this is exactly where the danger lies.
IV. This is not an isolated case: 15 assertions converge at the same point
This round upgrades delta-table-scan.py from v1.2 to v1.3, adding a previously absent validation: when σ is an interval, the declared value is tested at both endpoints to check for consistency. Four outcomes emerge:
| Outcome | Meaning | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
both |
Both endpoints hold | Unconditionally true (the strongest tier) |
signed |
Only one endpoint holds | Cannot be confirmed nor rejected — belongs to “unquantified direction” and must be reported |
none |
Neither endpoint holds | Unconditionally false |
None |
σ is a single point | No endpoint evaluation needed |
Running the full repository (scanning root . across 780 files):
Total assertions: 344 | minmatch: 200 | endpoint: both=9, signed=15, single-point=320
15 signed assertions. Examining each individually, the most critical ones fall into these three categories:
| Location | Declaration | Worst-case endpoint truth value | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|
mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md:55 (1 Chinese, 1 English) |
σ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km A ≥ 10 dB | 4.829 dB | Endpoint insufficient; must revise to σ ≥ 4.29×10⁻² |
schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md:45 (1 Chinese, 1 English) + 3 citations |
σ ≤ 10⁻⁴ → δ ≥ 670 km | 17.99 km | Endpoint fails (already determined in rounds 9–13; this time automatically reproduced by the tool) |
Audit tables such as elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md |
Referencing the two rows above | — | Belong to “citing incorrect values”; updated along with the source |
Note on the significance of the second item: The claim δ ≥ 670 km was previously invalidated only after manual recalculation of each cell over the first four rounds (and the underlying cause remained unresolved after four iterations). The v1.3 endpoint evaluation is zero manual effort, automatically reproduced — marking the first time the tool independently hit this result.
V. A Counterintuitive Side Effect: “Too Loose” Thresholds Are More Dangerous Than “Too Strict”
The preceding elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md records the A-grade threshold as “overestimated by ~2ד, which initially suggests the threshold is “too strict, blocking good things outside.”
However, calculating precisely at the endpoints reveals the actual effect is bidirectional:
- If σ = 10⁻² (the least favorable end of the interval): A = 4.83 dB, falling short of 10 dB → the label “worth prioritizing for measurement” was applied prematurely;
- If σ = 10⁻¹ (the middle of the interval): A = 15.27 dB, far exceeding 10 dB → the threshold now appears overly strict.
Thus, the true issue with this table is not “off by 2×”, but rather: it uses an interval to define a grade that should be determined by a single point. σ is a quantity known only after sampling (the SOP itself states “classify based on measured σ from 10 g rock samples”), yet the criterion is written using pre-sampling literature intervals — logically, this constitutes “deriving fine-grained conclusions from coarse-grained inputs.”
This aligns with two previously recorded defects in this repository:
- Pool ④ #51 “Interval spanning grades” (insufficient criterion resolution yet yielding a single conclusion);
- Pool ③ #192 “A fabricated citation rewriting the core numerical conclusion” (conclusion precision exceeds input precision).
This round contributes a third specific form: the directional nature of interval endpoints is ignored — not because the interval is too wide, nor because the calculation is wrong, but because it fails to specify which endpoint is used.
VI. Executable Rules (R7–R9)
Write to 08-ops/experiments/pool4-sigma-endpoint-direction-governance.md (P4-AUDIT-009), summary as follows:
R7 (Endpoint Assessment): Whenever σ (or any parameter entering the formula) is given as an interval or open interval, and the declared value is an inequality assertion, both endpoints must be evaluated, reporting both / signed / none. Evaluating only one endpoint is considered incomplete. This rule is now fixed into delta-table-scan.py via endpoint_check().
R8 (signed may not be upgraded to “corrected” or “falsified”): signed merely indicates “direction not quantified”; the remedial action is supplementing endpoints (changing ≥ 10 dB to σ ≥ 4.29×10⁻² when ≥ 10 dB), not correcting errors or altering numerical values. This rule prevents treating “unclear specification” as “calculation error” and thereby modifying the main text.
R9 (Criterion parameters and sampling order must align): If the criterion parameter (σ) for a given tier is measured after sampling in the workflow, then literature intervals can only be used for pre-screening levels, and cannot be directly written as “measured value Δ threshold.” This rule specifically targets SOP-style documents.
VII. Evidence and Limitations
Evidence Level E3 (Structural Analogy + Analytical Recalculation), not E1.
- All values are derived from formulaic recalculation (δ=√(2/(ωμσ)), A≈8.7d/δ) and in-text parsing, with no field measurements;
- The value 4.29×10⁻² represents the self-consistent threshold under the assumptions of μr=1, a uniform half-space, and zero displacement current; true mountain conductivity σ exhibits frequency dispersion (Revil 2013), and μr can exceed 1 (Kariya & Shankland 1983 measured strong dispersion in dry lower-crust rocks), so the field threshold will deviate from this number and the direction is not may support;
- The statement that “the threshold boundary should be 4.29×10⁻²” refers only to self-consistency with the σ values stated in the table, not to the actual field boundary;
- Among the 15
signedentries, only three categories were precisely recalculated (E3 threshold, 670 km, and audit table citations); the remainder were not individually verified; - The count of
bothis only 9 entries, whilesignedtotals 15, indicating that this repository contains few interval-based assertions (320 entries are single-point σ values); therefore, the number “15” cannot be extrapolated to represent the “in-house defect rate”; - Endpoint interpretation depends on correct parsing of σ intervals. The upper/lower bounds for open intervals (
≥/≤) are conventions set by the tool with a human-imposed margin of three orders of magnitude, not explicitly stated in the files; this is the most fragile link in this paper; - The tool still recognizes only markdown tables and text regex, leaving interval assertions scattered in the prose undercovered (coverage 38/58 tables = 65.5%, with the denominator excluding the 4 F0 tables).
Not done: no changes to any published text (the E3 threshold text, the source for 670 km and its five citations remain untouched pending JOE approval); no σ field measurements; no new “backrest→health” pathway added (net increase in pathways = 0); not marked accepted; did not directly write 779/782.
References
- Revil A. Effective conductivity and permittivity of unsaturated porous materials in the frequency range 1 mHz–1 GHz. Water Resources Research, 2013. doi:10.1029/2012WR012700
—— Used to explain the frequency dispersion of σ: the true electrical conductivity of real rock is not constant; the single σ value used here is a simplification. - Laštovičková M, Bochníček J. A contribution to the measurement of frequency dependence of electrical conductivity of rocks. Studia Geophysica et Geodaetica, 1992. doi:10.1007/BF01613900
—— Same as above, direct measurement evidence of frequency dispersion in rock conductivity. - Kariya KA, Shankland TJ. Electrical conductivity of dry lower crustal rocks. Geophysics, 1983;48:52–61. doi:10.1190/1.1441407
—— Magnitude of electrical conductivity for dry lower crustal rocks, used to define the reasonable boundary of the 10⁻⁴–10⁻² range for σ. - Mehran M, Arulanandan K. Low frequency conductivity dispersion in clay-water-electrolyte systems. Clays and Clay Minerals, 1977;25:39–48. doi:10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107
—— Low-frequency conductivity dispersion in clay/shale (one of the main lithologies in this table’s Category B), indicating that the “1–10 dB” interval width for Category B has a physical basis.
All four DOIs above have been individually verified via Crossref (title/journal/year/authors consistent). This paper has no PMID: all four articles belong to geophysical and materials science journals, outside the PubMed indexing scope; therefore, per Charter §2 they can only be recorded as E3 and do not constitute E1.
Appendix: Recalculation Script (Reproducible)
MU0 = 4π×10⁻⁷ ; DBN = 8.685889638
δ(f,σ,μr) = √( 2 / (2π f MU0 μr σ) )
A(d,σ) = DBN · d / δ
A(1 km, 10⁻²) = 4.829 dB
A(1 km, 10⁻¹) = 15.271 dB
δ_need(A=10dB, d=1km) = 8.7×1000/10 = 870 m
σ_need = 2/(2π·7.83·MU0·870²) = 4.29×10⁻² S/m
Disclaimer: This document is a compilation, comparison, and research design discussion of traditional knowledge and scientific literature, intended solely for understanding and reference. It does not constitute medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. The effect sizes, frequency ranges, and exposure conclusions mentioned herein are largely inferences at the research report level; individual variations can be significant. If you experience physical discomfort or health concerns, please seek medical attention and have them evaluated by a qualified physician.