池④ 三元表工具化:把「σ 门槛」写成可执行的 (σ, f, t) 判档器

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: C

池④ · 课题 #45 完成(第 39 轮登记为「绿灯可自主,0 成本」)
证据等级 C|状态 draft|本轮对既有正文写入 = 0


0. 为什么这件事必须做(不是”顺手加个命令”)

第 39 轮(#42)的结论是:

10 dB 判据线不是「σ 门槛」,是 σ×f×t 三元曲面。

但这句话当时只在文章里。工程侧的真实情况是:

  • skin-depth-recompute.py 仍按固定 δ 表工作(TABLE16_DELTA)
  • 22 的 A/B/C 分档仍写成「σ ≥ 10⁻² → A 档」

  • 23 的量级过滤 SOP 仍以单点门槛为准

结论改了、工具没改 = 结论不会被执行。 下一个人(或下一个 agent)跑脚本时,拿到的还是旧口径。这就是本轮要消掉的落差。


1. 交付了什么

08-ops/_tools/skin-depth-recompute.py 新增 4 个子命令,原有 5 个命令一字未改:

子命令 作用 典型用法
ternary 打印完整三元表:4 个 σ × 5 个 f × 5 个 t 网格的 A(dB) ... ternary
judge 单点判档:给定 (σ, f, t) → A(dB) + K1/K2/K3 ... judge --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83 --t-km 1
boundary 给定 (σ, f),各 dB 目标所需厚度 ... boundary --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83
contour 给定 (A, f),各 σ 所需厚度的判据线 ... contour --db 10 --f 7.83

1.1 判档规则(写死在工具里,不靠人记)

K1 可测  : A ≥ 13 dB   (10 dB 判据线 + 3 dB 边缘带)
K2 边缘  : 7 ≤ A < 13 dB → 强制双站差分,禁止单点结论
K3 透明  : A < 7 dB
K4 不可判: 不判 —— 需 σ 可信度信息,工具无法得知

K4 故意留空:如果 σ 只有区域地质图估计,那么算出来再精确也没有意义。工具没有能力判断输入 σ 的可靠性,所以不提供 K4,而是把这条写进 judge 的输出提示里——与第 35 轮 G0(”观测手段不足 → 不可判定,禁写无效应”)同一条纪律。

1.2 良导体近似自检(防止公式被误用)

A = 8.686·t/δ 只在良导体近似 σ/(ωε₀) ≫ 1 下成立。judge 每次都会把该比值打出来:

σ=0.01 S/m, f=7.83 Hz → σ/(ωε₀) = 2.296e+07  成立

全网格最差的组合(σ=10⁻⁴, f=30 Hz)实测 5.99e+04(σ=10⁻⁴ 时 σ/(ωε₀) 与 f 成反比,故 1 Hz 处是 1.80e+06、30 Hz 处降到 5.99e+04),仍远大于 1,公式成立。这条自检的意义是:将来若有人把频率推到 kHz 或 σ 降到 10⁻⁶,工具会自己提示公式失效,而不是安静地给出一个错数。


2. 回归锚点:工具必须复现文章的 4.83 dB

新工具最容易出的问题不是算错,而是悄悄和已有结论不一致。所以落地第一件事是拿上轮的硬数字做回归:

python3 skin-depth-recompute.py judge --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83 --t-km 1
σ=0.01 S/m, μr=1, f=7.83 Hz, t=1 km
  δ            = 1,799 m = 1.8 km
  A            = 4.83 dB   →  K3-透明
  良导体近似   : σ/(ωε₀) = 2.296e+07  成立
  交叉提示     : 该组合下 10 dB 需 t = 2.07 km

4.83 dB —— 与第 39 轮文章逐位一致。 这同时验证了三件事:

  1. 上轮那个「1 km / 10⁻² / 7.83 Hz 只有 4.83 dB,过不了 10 dB 线」的判定成立
  2. 本轮的工具没有引入新的实现偏差
  3. contour 给出的「需 2.07 km 才过 10 dB」与 judge 的交叉提示自洽

2.1 回归测试清单(本轮全部执行)

测试 目的 结果
py_compile 语法 ✅ 通过
judge --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83 --t-km 1 复现 4.83 dB ✅ 一致
judge --sigma 1e-1 --f 30 --t-km 3 高 σ 高端(89.68 dB → K1) ✅ 合理
contour --db 10 --f 7.83 判据线单调性 ✅ σ↓ → t↑ 单调
ternary 全网格输出 + 良导体自检 ✅ 通过
check-md skin-depth-reference-table.md 旧逻辑未被破坏 ✅ 仍报 37 格偏差(与上轮记录一致)
delta --f 7.83 --sigma 1e-2 旧命令输出不变 ✅ 一致

第 6 项最关键:check-md 仍返回 37 格偏差,说明新增子命令没有污染原来的判定逻辑。改工具时最怕的就是”修好了新功能、弄坏了旧功能”,而旧功能恰恰是审计别人用的。


3. 三元表本身(工具的默认输出)

3.1 f = 7.83 Hz(舒曼基频,本池主战场)

σ (S/m) δ (km) t=0.5 km t=1 km t=1.5 km t=2 km t=3 km
1e-1 0.569 7.64 15.27 22.91 30.54 45.81
1e-2 1.80 2.41 4.83 7.24 9.66 14.49
1e-3 5.69 0.76 1.53 2.29 3.05 4.58
1e-4 18.0 0.24 0.48 0.72 0.97 1.45

读法(对着判档规则看):

  • σ=10⁻¹、t=1 km → 15.27 dB = K1(真的挡得住)
  • σ=10⁻²、t=1 km → 4.83 dB = K3(挡不住)
  • σ=10⁻²、t=3 km → 14.49 dB = K1(同一个 σ,厚度够了就挡住)
  • σ=10⁻³ 在表中五档厚度全部 < 7 dB(K3);实测要到 t = 6.55 km 才 10.00 dB,且该点算 K2 边缘带(不是 K1)

3.2 同一个 σ,只改频率(这是”三元”的证明)

σ=10⁻²、t=1 km:

f 1 Hz 7.83 Hz 14 Hz 20 Hz 30 Hz
A (dB) 1.73 4.83 6.46 7.72 9.45
判档 K3 K3 K3(边缘下沿) K2 K2

结论:σ 一样、厚度一样,1 Hz 到 30 Hz 差了 5.5 倍。所以「靠山挡不挡得住 7.83 Hz」和「挡不挡得住 50 Hz」是两个问题,不能共用一个答案。

3.3 判据线的正确读法(contour @ 10 dB, 7.83 Hz)

σ (S/m) δ (km) 过 10 dB 所需 t
1e-1 0.569 0.65 km
1e-2 1.80 2.07 km
1e-3 5.69 6.55 km
1e-4 18.0 20.7 km

这张表就是「σ≥10⁻² → A 档」这个旧门槛的正确替代物:不是”σ 够大就挡得住”,而是”σ 对应一个必须达到的最小厚度“。


4. 与既有 SOP 的接口(怎么被真正用起来)

4.1 #22 A/B/C 分档的改法

旧口径 新口径
σ ≥ 10⁻² → A 档(强屏蔽) 查 contour --db 10 --f <目标频率>,看 t 是否 ≥ 所需厚度
σ ≤ 10⁻³ → C 档(透明) 同上;且若 σ 只有地质图估计 → K4 不可判,禁写「无效应」

4.2 #23 量级过滤 SOP 的改法

旧 SOP 用固定 δ 做量级排除。新做法:

# 结论要写"挡不住"之前,先跑这条
python3 skin-depth-recompute.py judge --sigma <σ> --f <f> --t-km <t>
# 若输出 K2 或 K4 → 不得下"挡不住"的结论

这条是为了防止一个具体的误用:把 4.83 dB 当成”山体对 ELF 基本透明”的证据。4.83 dB 在 10 dB 判据下是透明,但如果目标频率是 30 Hz、厚度 3 km,同一个 σ 就有 28.4 dB。“透明”必须带频率和厚度条件才成立。


5. 本轮不做什么(守边界)

  • 未改 check-md 的判定逻辑:TABLE16_* 常量、2 倍容差、args.file 只用于 §C 列表——这些缺陷(第 37、38 轮已记录)本轮不动,因为动它会污染审计基线
  • 未改任何既有正文:skin-depth-reference-table.md、high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md 等 mtime 未变
  • 未改 canonical 判定:#40(A 走标签重算还是 C 双列并存)仍待 JOE
  • 未做 σ 实测:工具不解决 σ 未知这个根本问题
  • 未新增「靠山→健康」通路(净增通路 0)

6. 下一步

# 动作 依赖
1 把 contour 输出接进 #22 分档文档,替换单点门槛表述 需先定 #40 canonical(否则改完又要改)
2 #44 σ 频率弥散补正:若补正后判据线位移 > 3 dB → 表 2.3 需重出 可自主,下一步
3 给 delta-table-scan.py 加 MISSING-ENDPOINT 断言(σ 单元格必须标 LO/HI/GM) 可自主(第 38 轮登记)

注意 #40 是前置:contour 出来的是「按区间下限 σ 算的厚度」,如果 canonical 最终选 C(双列并存),contour 也要出双列版本。在 JOE 定之前,不要把它写进 SOP 正文——本轮只落在工具和本卡里。


7. 参考文献

本文为工具交付,不引入新物理结论。所依赖的解析式与方法学锚点见第 39 轮 #42:

  1. Lovat G, et al. Analytical Evaluation of the Low-Frequency Magnetic Shielding of Thin Planar Magnetic Shields. IEEE Trans Electromagn Compat. 2021. DOI: 10.1109/temc.2020.2989204
  2. Jones AG. Static shift of magnetotelluric data and its removal in a sedimentary basin environment. Geophysics. 1988. DOI: 10.1190/1.1442533
  3. Satpathy S. Pattern of induced currents in a conducting sphere in an oscillating uniform field. Pure Appl Geophys. 1971. DOI: 10.1007/bf00875519

三条均经 Crossref 回查(标题/刊名/年份/首作者逐项一致)。三条均为「解析近似 vs 有限体真实响应」的方法学依据;本文所有数值仍在解析近似范围内,未做有限体修正。


池④ · #45 · 2026-10-18 · draft · 未发布 · 未标 accepted


免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

证据与局限

本文证据等级为 C,属 hypothesis,结论限于研究层面的推断,不构成对个体情形的判定。不是「σ 门槛」,是 σ×f×t 三元曲面。

局限:本文未覆盖全部相关文献,效应量与结论随样本与方法变化;传统体系与现代研究的对照属结构类比而非等价证明,请结合专业判断参考。

Pool 4: Tooling Sigma Tables by Turning the \”σ Threshold\” into an Executable (σ, f, t) Classifier

Evidence level: C

Pool ④ · Topic #45 Completed (Registered in Round 39 as “Green Light for Autonomous, 0 Cost”)
Evidence Level C | Status draft | Writes to existing body in this round = 0


0. Why This Must Be Done (Not Just “Adding a Command”)

The conclusion from Round 39 (#42) was:

The 10 dB criterion line is not a “σ threshold,” but a σ×f×t ternary surface.

However, at that time, this statement existed only in the text. The engineering reality is:

  • skin-depth-recompute.py still operates on a fixed δ table (TABLE16_DELTA)
  • The A/B/C categorization from #22 remains written as “σ ≥ 10⁻² → Category A”
  • The magnitude filtering SOP from #23 still relies on a single-point threshold

Conclusion changed, tools unchanged = Conclusion will not be executed. The next person (or agent) running the script will receive the old parameters. This is the gap this round aims to eliminate.


1. What Was Delivered

Four sub-commands were added to 08-ops/_tools/skin-depth-recompute.py; the original five commands remain unchanged:

Sub-command Function Typical Usage
ternary Prints the full ternary table: A(dB) across a 4σ × 5f × 5t grid ... ternary
judge Single-point categorization: Given (σ, f, t) → A(dB) + K1/K2/K3 ... judge --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83 --t-km 1
boundary Given (σ, f), thickness required for each dB target ... boundary --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83
contour Given (A, f), criterion line for thickness required at each σ ... contour --db 10 --f 7.83

1.1 Categorization Rules (Hardcoded in the Tool, No Memory Required)

K1 Measurable : A ≥ 13 dB   (10 dB criterion + 3 dB margin)
K2 Edge       : 7 ≤ A < 13 dB → Mandate dual-station differential; prohibit single-point conclusion
K3 Transparent : A < 7 dB
K4 Unjudgable : Not judged —— Requires σ reliability info, which the tool cannot ascertain

K4 is intentionally left blank: If σ is estimated only from regional geological maps, calculating a precise value is meaningless. Since the tool lacks the capability to judge input σ reliability, it does not provide K4 but instead writes this rule into the judge output prompt—aligning with Round 35 G0 (“Insufficient observational means → Unjudgable; prohibit writing invalid effects”).

1.2 Good Conductor Approximation Self-Check (Preventing Formula Misuse)

The formula $A = 8.686 \cdot t/\delta$ holds only under the good conductor approximation where $\sigma/(\omega\epsilon_0) \gg 1$. The judge command outputs this ratio every time:

σ=0.01 S/m, f=7.83 Hz → σ/(ωε₀) = 2.296e+07  Valid

The worst-case combination across the full grid (σ=10⁻⁴, f=30 Hz) measures 5.99e+04 (since σ/(ωε₀) is inversely proportional to f at σ=10⁻⁴, the value drops from 1.80e+06 at 1 Hz to 5.99e+04 at 30 Hz). It remains far greater than 1, so the formula holds. The significance of this self-check is that if someone later pushes frequency to kHz or lowers σ to 10⁻⁶, the tool will itself flag formula failure, rather than silently outputting an incorrect number.


2. Regression Anchor: Tool Must Reproduce Article’s 4.83 dB

The most common issue with the new tool is not calculation errors, but silent inconsistency with existing conclusions. Therefore, the first step upon landing is to use the hard numbers from the previous round for regression:

python3 skin-depth-recompute.py judge --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83 --t-km 1
σ=0.01 S/m, μr=1, f=7.83 Hz, t=1 km
  δ            = 1,799 m = 1.8 km
  A            = 4.83 dB   →  K3-Transparent
  Good Conductor Approx : σ/(ωε₀) = 2.296e+07  Valid
  Cross Hint       : Under this combination, 10 dB requires t = 2.07 km

4.83 dB —— Matches the Round 39 article digit-for-digit. This simultaneously validates three things:

  1. The judgment from the previous round (“1 km / 10⁻² / 7.83 Hz yields only 4.83 dB, failing the 10 dB line”) holds true.
  2. The tool in this round has not introduced new implementation deviations.
  3. The contour output (“requires 2.07 km to pass 10 dB”) is self-consistent with the judge cross-hint.

2.1 Regression Test Checklist (Executed Fully This Round)

Test Purpose Result
py_compile Syntax ✅ Passed
judge --sigma 1e-2 --f 7.83 --t-km 1 Reproduce 4.83 dB ✅ Consistent
judge --sigma 1e-1 --f 30 --t-km 3 High σ/High f (89.68 dB → K1) ✅ Reasonable
contour --db 10 --f 7.83 Monotonicity of criterion line ✅ σ↓ → t↑ monotonic
ternary Full grid output + Good conductor self-check ✅ Passed
check-md skin-depth-reference-table.md Old logic not disrupted ✅ Still reports 37 grid deviations (consistent with previous round)
delta --f 7.83 --sigma 1e-2 Old command output unchanged ✅ Consistent

Item #6 is most critical: check-md still returns 37 grid deviations, indicating that the new sub-commands did not pollute the original judgment logic. The greatest fear when modifying tools is “fixing new features while breaking old ones,” and the old functions are precisely what others audit.


3. The Ternary Table Itself (Default Tool Output)

3.1 f = 7.83 Hz (Schumann Fundamental Frequency, Primary Battlefield of This Pool)

σ (S/m) δ (km) t=0.5 km t=1 km t=1.5 km t=2 km t=3 km
1e-1 0.569 7.64 15.27 22.91 30.54 45.81
1e-2 1.80 2.41 4.83 7.24 9.66 14.49
1e-3 5.69 0.76 1.53 2.29 3.05 4.58
1e-4 18.0 0.24 0.48 0.72 0.97 1.45

Reading guide (referencing categorization rules):

  • σ=10⁻¹, t=1 km → 15.27 dB = K1 (Truly blocks)
  • σ=10⁻², t=1 km → 4.83 dB = K3 (Does not block)
  • σ=10⁻², t=3 km → 14.49 dB = K1 (Same σ; sufficient thickness blocks)
  • At σ=10⁻³, all five thickness tiers in the table are < 7 dB (K3); practical measurement requires t = 6.55 km for 10.00 dB, and this point falls into the K2 edge band (not K1)

3.2 Same σ, Only Frequency Changed (Proof of “Ternary”)

σ=10⁻², t=1 km:

f 1 Hz 7.83 Hz 14 Hz 20 Hz 30 Hz
A (dB) 1.73 4.83 6.46 7.72 9.45
Categorization K3 K3 K3 (Lower edge of margin) K2 K2

Conclusion: With identical σ and thickness, 1 Hz to 30 Hz differs by a factor of 5.5. Therefore, whether “mountains block 7.83 Hz” and whether they block “50 Hz” are two distinct questions; a single answer cannot apply to both.

3.3 Correct Reading of the Criterion Line (contour @ 10 dB, 7.83 Hz)

σ (S/m) δ (km) Thickness t Required for 10 dB
1e-1 0.569 0.65 km
1e-2 1.80 2.07 km
1e-3 5.69 6.55 km
1e-4 18.0 20.7 km

This table serves as the correct replacement for the old threshold “σ ≥ 10⁻² → Category A”: it is not “if σ is large enough, it blocks,” but rather “σ corresponds to a minimum required thickness.”


4. Interface with Existing SOPs (How to Be Truly Used)

4.1 Modification of #22 A/B/C Categorization

Old Stance New Stance
σ ≥ 10⁻² → Category A (Strong Shielding) Query contour --db 10 --f <target_frequency>; verify if t ≥ required thickness
σ ≤ 10⁻³ → Category C (Transparent) Same; and if σ is only estimated from geological maps → K4 Unjudgable, prohibit writing “no effect”

4.2 Modification of #23 Magnitude Filtering SOP

The old SOP used a fixed δ for magnitude exclusion. The new approach:

# Before concluding "does not block", run this first
python3 skin-depth-recompute.py judge --sigma <σ> --f <f> --t-km <t>
# If output shows K2 or K4 → Do not write "does not block" conclusion

This prevents a specific misuse: Treating 4.83 dB as evidence that “mountains are transparent to ELF.” While 4.83 dB is transparent under the 10 dB criterion, if the target frequency is 30 Hz and thickness is 3 km, the same σ yields 28.4 dB. “Transparent” only holds under specific frequency and thickness conditions.


5. What Is Not Done This Round (Boundary Keeping)

  • Did not modify check-md judgment logic: TABLE16_* constants, 2x tolerance, args.file used only for §C lists—these defects (recorded in Rounds 37, 38) are not touched this round to avoid polluting the audit baseline.
  • Did not modify any existing body text: skin-depth-reference-table.md, high-sigma-lithology-elf-shielding-path.md, etc., have unchanged mtime.
  • Did not modify canonical judgment: #40 (A via tag recalc vs C dual-column coexistence) still pending JOE.
  • Did not perform σ measurement: The tool does not solve the fundamental problem of unknown σ.
  • Did not add a “Mountain → Health” pathway (Net new pathways = 0).

6. Next Steps

# Action Dependency
1 Integrate contour output into #22 categorization doc, replacing single-point threshold phrasing Requires first settling #40 canonical (otherwise change again after fix)
2 #44 σ Frequency Dispersion Correction: If correction shifts criterion line > 3 dB → Table 2.3 needs re-generation Autonomous, next step
3 Add MISSING-ENDPOINT assertion to delta-table-scan.py (σ cells must label LO/HI/GM) Autonomous (Registered Round 38)

Note #40 is a prerequisite: contour outputs “thickness calculated using lower-bound interval σ.” If the canonical final choice is C (dual-column coexistence), contour must also output a dual-column version. Before JOE finalizes it, do not write this into SOP body text—this round only lands in the tool and this card.


7. References

This article delivers a tool, not new physical conclusions. The analytical expressions and methodological anchors relied upon are detailed in Round 39 #42:

  1. Lovat G, et al. Analytical Evaluation of the Low-Frequency Magnetic Shielding of Thin Planar Magnetic Shields. IEEE Trans Electromagn Compat. 2021. DOI: 10.1109/temc.2020.2989204
  2. Jones AG. Static shift of magnetotelluric data and its removal in a sedimentary basin environment. Geophysics. 1988. DOI: 10.1190/1.1442533
  3. Satpathy S. Pattern of induced currents in a conducting sphere in an oscillating uniform field. Pure Appl Geophys. 1971. DOI: 10.1007/bf00875519

All three verified via Crossref (Title/Journal/Year/First Author match item-by-item). All three provide methodological basis for “analytical approximation vs. finite-body true response”; all numerical values in this article remain within the analytical approximation range, no finite-body correction applied.


Pool ④ · #45 · 2026-10-18 · draft · Unpublished · Not marked accepted


Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *