归年”后第1/2/3年:多疾病发病增量能检验”刚柔失守”吗?

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: B

《素问遗篇》把”刚柔失守”与”三年化疫”绑在一起,等于在说:某个异常年份之后第1、2、3年,会有多种疫病依次冒头。这个”逐病逐年”的预测,恰好是能用多疾病长序列逐一检验的——而现代数据已经告诉我们,不同疾病的滞后尺度本来就长得不一样。

正文

“刚柔失守”是运气学说里最神秘的一环:天干与地支失配、气运失常,其后三年内相继成疫。顾植山等学者用它回溯解释了SARS、禽流感等多次疫情,但”回溯解释”有个通病——事后总能找到某个年份来”归年”,却无法事先告诉人们哪一年、哪种病会爆发。要让这个理论获得预测力,唯一的出路是把它的时间结构拆开:归年后的第1年、第2年、第3年,各病的发病增量到底是多少?

现代流行病学的第一个回答是:滞后尺度是”病种特异”的。中国一项覆盖2004-2018年、四大气候区(热带季风、亚热带季风、温带、高原)、多类型感染性腹泻的固定效应泊松回归研究发现:极端降雨后一个月,高原区痢疾发病率降低18.7%;极端日照后两个月,高原区痢疾上升21.9%、温带区伤寒副伤寒上升17.2%(PMID 36141780)。注意这里的气候区×疾病类型×滞后时点的三重交互——同样是”极端事件”,痢疾和伤寒的响应时点、方向、大小都不一样,而它们的滞后都只在0-2个月内。这提示:“归年后的某一年”这个粗粒度标签,不可能对每种病都成立,痢疾这类肠道病在归年后的滞后根本到不了”年”的尺度。

再看滞后能拉到多长的病。美国科罗拉多州一项21年(1997-2017)的分布式滞后非线性模型(DLNM)研究,把隐孢子虫与贾第虫两种寄生虫病放在一起比较:温度极端对两病的影响方向相反——高温极值显著增加隐孢子虫风险、却显著降低贾第虫风险;而降水极值对两病的影响相似,且突出了超过8个月的长期滞后的主导作用(PMID 38830305)。同一套数据、同一种气候暴露,两种”病”的滞后结构和方向完全不同——这正是”多疾病必须分开检验、不能合并归年”的活教材。也说明确实存在滞后以”月到年”为尺度的病种(媒介、水源、土壤污染型),它们才有资格进入”归年后第1/2/3年”的检验窗口。

呼吸道病毒则提供了”区域异质性”的维度。中国81家哨点医院、22省份7种呼吸道病毒(RSV、流感、副流感、腺病毒、偏肺病毒等)与气象因子的回顾研究发现:每种病毒的季节模式各异——RSV与流感在北方单峰、在南方双峰,偏肺病毒北方冬春单峰,腺病毒和冠状病毒几乎没有明确季节性;温度、气压、水汽压、降雨对多数病毒解释力最强,且任何两个因子配对交互后解释力都增强(PMID 33713616)。2025年针对中国流感A/H3N2的全国监测研究进一步发现:温带区冬季流行、亚热带/热带区夏秋季流行,病毒迁移先引入新变异株、气象因素随后触发流行,温度阈值约1°C与24°C(PMID 40276694)。季节模式的南北分野意味着:即使”归年”逻辑成立,它对温带和亚热带疾病的”当年/次年”含义也完全不同——用全国合并数据做归年检验,会把这些异质性全部平均掉。

年际尺度有没有真实信号?有。中国31省2007-2018年动态面板研究发现,厄尔尼诺年呼吸道传染病发病率比正常年高5.842%,且人均可支配收入与受教育年限能显著削弱这一关联(PMID 35270663)。ENSO是2-7年周期的年际气候振荡,与岁运”太过不及”的周期同量级,它证明”气候年际状态→多省多病种发病率变化”这条链路真实存在——但注意,这项研究的滞后是同年/当年效应,而不是归年后第1-3年的滞后效应。换句话说:年际气候信号是真实的,但它默认落在当年;把信号强行移到”三年后”,需要专门的滞后检验,不能想当然。

那么”多疾病归年增量检验”该怎么设计?参照已有模板(PMID 38830305 的DLNM + PMID 36141780 的气候区meta):选取流感、RSV、痢疾、伤寒、疟疾、登革热等气候敏感传染病的长序列(1950年至今法定传染病报告),按干支”太过不及/刚柔失守”归年,对每种病分别拟合”短滞后DLNM vs 短+1/2/3年滞后DLNM”,用时间外验证比较ΔAUC/互信息增量,再做跨病种、跨气候区的meta。结果只会有三种:增量在多数病种显著(归年成立)、只在滞后长的病种显著(归年部分成立,需按病种收窄)、全部不显著(归年是文化叙事)。关键是事先不合并、逐病检验——这正是”刚柔失守”从玄学走向统计的关键一步。

证据与局限

已验证: 气候-疾病滞后尺度病种特异——肠道病0-2月(PMID 36141780),寄生虫病可超8个月且同暴露方向相反(PMID 38830305);7种呼吸道病毒季节模式南北异质、因子交互增强解释力(PMID 33713616),H3N2温带冬季/亚热带夏秋流行、阈值1°C与24°C(PMID 40276694);ENSO年际振荡使厄尔尼诺年呼吸道传染病发病率高5.842%(PMID 35270663)。

部分验证: 年际气候振荡(ENSO,2-7年周期,与岁运周期同量级)对多省多病种发病率有真实影响,但证据落在”同年/当年”效应,”归年后1-3年滞后”尚无多疾病系统检验。

待验证: “刚柔失守/太过不及”归年后第1/2/3年发病增量的独立信息量(逐病种DLNM+时间外ΔAUC/互信息+置换检验);归年滞后窗口在不同病种、不同气候区间的差异性;全国合并 vs 分气候区归年检验的结果差异(异质性会不会被平均掉)。

相关阅读

证据等级: B
参考文献: PMID 36141780, PMID 38830305, PMID 33713616, PMID 40276694, PMID 35270663


免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

After \”Gui Nian\”: Can the Incremental Increase in Disease Incidence in Years 1, 2, and 3 Test \”Loss of Harmony Between Hard and Soft\”?

Evidence level: B

The Su Wen Wei Pian links “loss of rigidity and softness” (刚柔失守) to “epidemics transforming over three years,” implying that following an anomalous year, multiple epidemic diseases will emerge sequentially in the subsequent 1st, 2nd, and 3rd years. This “year-by-year disease succession” prediction is uniquely amenable to validation via long disease sequences, whereas modern data indicates that lag scales for different diseases inherently vary significantly.

Main Text

“Loss of rigidity and softness” (刚柔失守) represents the most enigmatic component within Yijing Studies运气学说: a misalignment between Heavenly Stems and Earthly Branches, resulting in abnormal qi flow, followed by successive epidemics over three years. Scholars such as Gu Zhishan have utilized this concept to retrospectively explain multiple outbreaks, including SARS and avian influenza. However, “retrospective explanation” carries a common limitation—it can always identify a specific year to serve as the “return year” after the fact, yet fails to predict in advance which year and which disease will erupt. To confer predictive power on this theory, the only path forward is to deconstruct its temporal structure: What are the specific incremental onset rates for each disease in the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd years following the return year?

The first response from modern epidemiology is that lag scales are “pathogen-specific.” A fixed-effects Poisson regression study covering 2004–2018 across four major climatic zones (tropical monsoon, subtropical monsoon, temperate, plateau) and multiple types of infectious diarrhea found that one month after extreme rainfall, shigellosis incidence decreased by 18.7% in the plateau region; two months after extreme solar radiation, shigellosis increased by 21.9% in the plateau region and typhoid fever/paratyphoid fever increased by 17.2% in the temperate region (PMID 36141780). Note the triple interaction here: climatic zone × disease type × lag time point. For the same “extreme event,” shigellosis and typhoid fever exhibit different response timings, directions, and magnitudes, with lags confined to 0–2 months. This suggests that the coarse-grained label of “a specific year after the return year” cannot hold true for every disease; for intestinal diseases like shigellosis, the lag simply does not reach the scale of “years” following the return year.

Next, consider diseases with lags extending longer durations. A distributed lag nonlinear model (DLNM) study spanning 21 years (1997–2017) in Colorado, USA, compared two parasitic diseases: cryptosporidiosis and giardiasis. Temperature extremes exerted opposing effects on both—high temperature extremes significantly increased cryptosporidiosis risk while significantly decreasing giardiasis risk; conversely, precipitation extremes had similar effects on both, highlighting the dominant role of long-term lags exceeding 8 months (PMID 38830305). With the same dataset and identical climatic exposure, the lag structures and directions for these two “diseases” are entirely different—serving as a living textbook demonstrating that “multiple diseases must be tested separately and cannot be merged under a single return year.” It also confirms that certain pathogen types (vector-borne, waterborne, soil-pollution related) possess lag scales ranging from “months to years,” qualifying them for inclusion in the validation window of “years 1/2/3 after the return year.”

Respiratory viruses provide the dimension of “regional heterogeneity.” A retrospective study involving 81 sentinel hospitals across 22 provinces and seven types of respiratory viruses (RSV, influenza, parainfluenza, adenovirus, metapneumovirus, etc.) and meteorological factors found that each virus exhibits distinct seasonal patterns—RSV and influenza show single peaks in the north and double peaks in the south, while metapneumovirus shows a single winter-spring peak in the north; adenovirus and coronaviruses lack clear seasonality. Temperature, atmospheric pressure, water vapor pressure, and rainfall explained the most variance for most viruses, with interaction terms between any two factors further enhancing explanatory power (PMID 33713616). A 2025 national monitoring study specifically targeting influenza A/H3N2 in China further revealed that temperate regions experience winter epidemics while subtropical/tropical regions experience summer-autumn epidemics; viral migration introduces new variants first, followed by meteorological factors triggering outbreaks, with temperature thresholds around 1°C and 24°C (PMID 40276694). The north-south divergence in seasonal patterns implies that even if the “return year” logic holds, its meaning regarding “current year/next year” differs fundamentally between temperate and subtropical diseases—merging national data for return year validation would average out all this heterogeneity.

Are there genuine signals at the interannual scale? Yes. A dynamic panel study across 31 provinces in China (2007–2018) found that respiratory infectious disease incidence was 5.842% higher in El Niño years compared to normal years, and per capita disposable income and years of education significantly attenuated this association (PMID 35270663). ENSO is an interannual climatic oscillation with a 2–7 year cycle, commensurate in magnitude with the “excess/deficiency” cycles of the age qi. It proves that the link from “interannual climatic state → multi-province, multi-disease incidence changes” is real—but note that the lag in this study was a same-year/contemporary effect, not a lag effect occurring 1–3 years after the return year. In other words: interannual climatic signals are genuine, but they default to the current year; shifting this signal forcibly to “three years later” requires specific lag testing and cannot be assumed.

So, how should a “multi-disease return year incremental validation” be designed? Refer to existing templates (DLNM from PMID 38830305 combined with climatic zone meta-analysis from PMID 36141780): Select long time series (since 1950 or current statutory infectious disease reporting) for climate-sensitive infectious diseases such as influenza, RSV, shigellosis, typhoid fever, malaria, and dengue fever. Align these with “excess/deficiency” or “loss of rigidity and softness” return years based on Heavenly Stems and Earthly Branches. For each disease, fit “short-lag DLNM vs. short + 1/2/3 year lag DLNM,” compare ΔAUC and incremental mutual information using out-of-time validation, and conduct meta-analyses across diseases and climatic zones. Results will fall into one of three categories: significant increment for most diseases (return year valid), significant only for long-lag diseases (return year partially valid, requiring disease-specific narrowing), or non-significant across the board (return year is cultural narrative). The key is to not merge beforehand and to test each disease individually—this is the critical step moving “loss of rigidity and softness” from metaphysics to statistics.

Evidence and Limitations

Verified: Pathogen-specific lag scales between climate and disease—intestinal diseases 0–2 months (PMID 36141780), parasitic diseases exceeding 8 months with opposing directions under same exposure (PMID 38830305); seven types of respiratory viruses show north-south heterogeneity in seasonal patterns with enhanced explanatory power from factor interactions (PMID 33713616), H3N2 shows temperate winter/subtropical summer-autumn epidemics with thresholds at 1°C and 24°C (PMID 40276694); ENSO interannual oscillation correlates with 5.842% higher respiratory infectious disease incidence in El Niño years (PMID 35270663).

Partially Verified: Interannual climatic oscillations (ENSO, 2–7 year cycle, commensurate with age qi cycles) exert real effects on multi-province, multi-disease incidence, but evidence falls on “same-year/contemporary” effects; no systematic multi-disease validation exists yet for “1–3 year lags after return year.”

To Be Verified: Independent information content of incremental disease onset in years 1/2/3 after “return year” for “loss of rigidity and softness”/excess-deficiency (disease-specific DLNM + out-of-time ΔAUC/mutual information + permutation tests); differential lag windows across diseases and climatic zones; result differences between national merged vs. climate-zone-specific return year validation (whether heterogeneity is averaged out).

Related Reading

  • “Three-Year Epidemic” Lag Scales: Systematic Validation Across Multiple Diseases
  • Long-Lag Yunqi (1–3 Years): Meteorological-Disease Associations: Do They Carry Information Independent of Short Lags?](/research/science-yixue/yunqi-long-lag-independent-information)
  • Five Movements and Six Qi + Modern Statistical Models: Synergy or Interference?](/research/science-yixue/yunqi-dlnm-hybrid-incremental-value)
  • Five Movements and Six Qi Prediction Models vs. Modern Epidemiological Models: Who is More Accurate?](/research/science-yixue/yunqi-disease-prediction-vs-modern-epidemiology)
  • Research Pool: Spatiotemporal Frequency Topology](/research/pools/pool-2-spatiotemporal-frequency-topology)

Evidence Level: B
References: PMID 36141780, PMID 38830305, PMID 33713616, PMID 40276694, PMID 35270663


Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *