Evidence level: B
把中医偏颇体质患者的粪便菌群移植到无菌小鼠体内,观察小鼠会不会”变得偏颇”——这是把”体质是客观生理状态”这个假设推到极致的因果实验。
正文
中医体质学说有一个隐藏很深、却极其关键的假设:偏颇体质(痰湿、湿热、阳虚、阴虚……)不只是”一群症状的集合”,而是某种可以”寄宿”在身体里的客观状态——你吃什么、住哪里、生什么病,都受这个状态牵引。过去二十年的菌群研究给这个假设提供了一个可能的”物质载体”:肠道菌群。不同体质的人,肠道菌群确实不一样——湿热质人群的菌群多样性下降、功能偏向炎症与代谢紊乱(PMID 40258500)。但相关不等于因果:是体质决定了菌群,还是菌群在塑造体质?
要回答这个问题,现代微生物学有一台终极”照妖镜”:无菌小鼠(germ-free mice)+ 粪菌移植(FMT)。无菌小鼠出生在隔离环境里,肠道里没有任何细菌,像一张白纸。把人的粪便菌群移植进去,这张白纸上就会”画出”供体菌群的生态。接下来观察小鼠长成什么样——如果偏颇体质患者的菌群能让小鼠也表现出偏颇的表型,那就说明菌群本身携带并传递着体质的信息。
先看西医已经做到的:菌群确实能把代谢表型”传”过去。 2013 年发表于《Science》的经典研究把”肥胖不一致双胞胎”(一对双胞胎一个胖一个瘦)的粪便菌群分别移植到无菌小鼠体内,所有小鼠吃完全一样的食物,结果只有接受”胖双胞胎菌群”的小鼠长胖了,接受”瘦双胞胎菌群”的小鼠保持苗条;更妙的是,把两类小鼠同笼饲养,瘦菌群能”入侵”肥胖小鼠的肠道,把肥胖表型救回来(PMID 24009397)。2024 年另一项研究把多囊卵巢综合征(PCOS)患者的粪便移植到无菌小鼠,小鼠出现了卵巢功能紊乱、胰岛素抵抗和肥胖样表型(PMID 39333864);2025 年的最新研究更进一步,把肥胖儿童和瘦儿童的菌群分别移植给幼年无菌小鼠,表型差异一直持续到成年——雄鼠出现棕色脂肪”变白”、代谢受损,雌鼠出现高血糖和肠道屏障功能障碍(PMID 40288637)。这一串实验说明一个铁律:菌群能把宿主的代谢状态”打包传递”给下一个宿主。
再看中医自己已经做过的:证候的菌群也能传。 关键证据来自脾虚证。上海交通大学团队把”脾虚证患者”的粪便菌群移植到小鼠体内,成功建立了脾虚证小鼠模型——免疫指标(IgA、IL-1β、TNF-α、5-HT)出现特征性改变,CD8⁺/CD3⁺ 比值升高,肠道菌群结构与健康对照组显著不同(PMID 38621910)。也就是说,中医证候的”偏颇”确实可以经由菌群移植在动物身上重现——这不是玄学,而是已经在实验室里重复出来的结果。另一项慢传输型便秘(脾虚相关)研究也做了同样的 FMT:从脾虚便秘小鼠取菌移植到假无菌小鼠,受体小鼠的肠道肽(SP、VIP)和菌群结构都跟着变了(PMID 35610004)。
把这些证据拼起来,”体质可否经由菌群传递”有了初步答案:偏颇体质的一部分信息,确实编码在菌群里,而且可以通过移植传导给新的宿主。 体质在这里不是虚无缥缈的”气”,而是可以”装进试管、打进小鼠”的生物学实体。这对中医的现代化意义重大——它意味着体质量表评分背后有可操作的微生物学基础,也意味着调理体质不只关乎个人的生活方式,还关乎你肠道里的”生态位”。
但必须诚实:现有的证据离”九种体质全部可传递”还很远。已证明可传递的集中在脾虚/阳虚类(有直接 FMT 实验),以及代谢相关表型(肥胖/PCOS 的”痰湿样”状态,借西医实验间接支持)。湿热、阴虚、气郁等其他体质,目前只有横断面相关性,还没有对应的 FMT 动物实验。真正的完整验证需要一整套系统实验:九种体质的供体粪便分别移植到无菌小鼠,用体质量表(如王琦九分法)的客观化指标 + 代谢/免疫表型做”双终点”复评,才能把每一条”体质→菌群→表型”链条钉死。
证据与局限
已验证: 粪菌移植可传递代谢表型——肥胖双胞胎菌群传胖、瘦菌群同笼拯救(PMID 24009397);PCOS 菌群致小鼠卵巢/代谢紊乱(PMID 39333864);肥胖儿童菌群致成年期代谢表型(PMID 40288637);脾虚证患者菌群 FMT 可在小鼠重现脾虚表型(PMID 38621910)。
部分验证: 不同中医体质(湿热/痰湿/阴虚等)与菌群构成差异已有多个横断面研究(PMID 40258500),但多为相关性、样本量中等;”九种体质全谱系 FMT”尚未系统开展。
待验证: ①九种体质粪便分别 FMT 到无菌小鼠的”偏颇表型传递”全谱系验证(体质量表客观化指标+代谢/免疫双终点);②湿热/阴虚/气郁等非脾虚类体质的 FMT 动物实验;③传递表型的剂量-反应关系(供体菌群量/多样性与受体表型强度)。
相关阅读
证据等级: B
参考文献: PMID 38621910, PMID 35610004, PMID 24009397, PMID 39333864, PMID 40288637, PMID 40258500
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Can Dysbiosis-Related Gut Bacteria Transmit \”Imbalance\” to Others?
Evidence level: B
Transferring fecal microbiota from patients with a TCM dysbalanced constitution (phlegm-dampness, damp-heat, yang deficiency, yin deficiency…) into germ-free mice to observe whether the mice “become dysbalanced” pushes the hypothesis that “constitution is an objective physiological state” to its extreme causal limit.
Main Text
The TCM constitution theory harbors a deeply embedded yet critically important assumption: a dysbalanced constitution (phlegm-dampness, damp-heat, yang deficiency, yin deficiency…) is not merely “a collection of symptoms” but rather a certain objective state that can “inhabit” the body—one that guides what you eat, where you live, and what illnesses you develop. Over the past two decades, microbiome research has provided a potential “material carrier” for this hypothesis: the gut microbiota. Individuals with different constitutions indeed exhibit distinct gut microbiotas; for instance, individuals with a damp-heat constitution show reduced microbial diversity and functional shifts toward inflammation and metabolic dysregulation (PMID 40258500). However, correlation does not imply causation: does the constitution determine the microbiota, or is the microbiota shaping the constitution?
To answer this question, modern microbiology possesses a ultimate “mirror”: germ-free mice + fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT). Germ-free mice are born in isolation environments with no bacteria in their intestines, akin to a blank canvas. Transferring human fecal microbiota onto this canvas allows the ecological signature of the donor microbiota to be “drawn.” Subsequent observation of the mice’s development reveals whether a dysbalanced constitution from a patient can induce a dysbalanced phenotype in the recipient. If so, it indicates that the microbiota itself carries and transmits constitutional information.
First, consider what Western medicine has already achieved: microbiota can indeed “transfer” metabolic phenotypes. A landmark 2013 study published in Science transplanted fecal microbiota from “discordant obese twin pairs” (one twin obese, one lean) into germ-free mice. Despite identical diets, only mice receiving the “obese twin microbiota” gained weight, while those receiving the “lean twin microbiota” remained slender; more remarkably, when housed together, the lean microbiota could “invade” the obese mice’s intestines and restore a lean phenotype (PMID 240009397). A 2024 study further transplanted fecal microbiota from patients with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) into germ-free mice, resulting in ovarian dysfunction, insulin resistance, and obesity-like phenotypes (PMID 39333864); a 2025 study advanced further by transplanting microbiota from obese versus lean children into juvenile germ-free mice, where phenotypic differences persisted into adulthood—male mice exhibited “whitening” of brown fat and metabolic impairment, while female mice developed hyperglycemia and intestinal barrier dysfunction (PMID 40288637). This series of experiments establishes a firm rule: microbiota can “package and transmit” the host’s metabolic state to the next host.
Next, consider what TCM itself has already accomplished: syndromic microbiotas can also be transferred. Key evidence comes from the spleen-deficiency syndrome. A team from Shanghai Jiao Tong University successfully established a spleen-deficiency syndrome mouse model by transplanting fecal microbiota from “spleen-deficiency syndrome patients.” Immune indicators (IgA, IL-1β, TNF-α, 5-HT) showed characteristic alterations, the CD8⁺/CD3⁺ ratio increased, and the gut microbiota structure differed significantly from healthy controls (PMID 38621910). In other words, the “dysbalance” of a TCM syndrome can indeed be reproduced in animals via FMT—this is not esotericism, but a result repeatedly verified in the laboratory. Another study on slow-transmission constipation (related to spleen deficiency) performed a similar FMT: transferring bacteria from spleen-deficient constipated mice to pseudo-germ-free mice resulted in changes in the recipient mice’s intestinal peptides (SP, VIP) and microbiota structure (PMID 35610004).
Synthesizing these evidences provides a preliminary answer to “whether constitution can be transmitted via microbiota”: part of the information regarding a dysbalanced constitution is indeed encoded in the microbiota and can be transmitted to new hosts via transplantation. Here, constitution is not an ethereal “qi,” but a biological entity that can be “placed in a test tube and injected into a mouse.” This holds significant implications for the modernization of TCM—it implies that the scoring behind constitution profiles rests on an actionable microbiological foundation, and that regulating constitution involves not only individual lifestyle but also the “ecological niche” within one’s intestines.
However, honesty is required: current evidence is far from proving “all nine constitutions are transmissible.” Proven transmission focuses on spleen-deficiency/yang-deficiency categories (direct FMT experiments) and metabolic-related phenotypes (obesity/PCOS “phlegm-dampness-like” states, indirectly supported by Western medicine experiments). For other constitutions such as damp-heat, yin deficiency, and qi stagnation, only cross-sectional correlations exist; corresponding FMT animal experiments are currently lacking. True comprehensive validation requires a systematic suite of experiments: transplanting fecal samples from donors of all nine constitutions into germ-free mice, using objective metrics from constitution scales (e.g., Wang Qi’s nine-category method) plus metabolic/immune phenotypes as “dual endpoints” to firmly lock each “constitution → microbiota → phenotype” chain.
Evidence and Limitations
Verified: FMT can transmit metabolic phenotypes—obese twin microbiota causes obesity, lean microbiota rescues phenotype in co-housing (PMID 240009397); PCOS microbiota induces ovarian/metabolic dysregulation in mice (PMID 39333864); obese child microbiota induces adult metabolic phenotypes (PMID 40288637); spleen-deficiency syndrome patient microbiota FMT reproduces spleen-deficiency phenotype in mice (PMID 38621910).
Partially Verified: Differences in gut microbiota composition among different TCM constitutions (damp-heat/phlegm-dampness/yin deficiency etc.) have been documented in multiple cross-sectional studies (PMID 40258500), but mostly correlational with moderate sample sizes; a systematic “full-spectrum FMT for all nine constitutions” has not yet been conducted.
To Be Verified: ① Full-spectrum verification of “dysbalanced phenotype transmission” via FMT of all nine constitution fecal samples into germ-free mice (using objective constitution scale metrics + dual endpoints of metabolism/immunity); ② FMT animal experiments for non-spleen-deficiency constitutions such as damp-heat/yin deficiency/qi stagnation; ③ Dose-response relationships regarding transmitted phenotypes (donor microbiota quantity/diversity vs. recipient phenotype intensity).
Related Reading
- Constitution and Gut Microbiota: Chicken or Egg?
- Can Constitution Regulation Alter Microbiota, and Can Microbiota Intervention Alter Constitution?
- Correlation Studies on Constitution and Gut Microbiota
- Research Pools ×5
Evidence Level: B
References: PMID 38621910, PMID 35610004, PMID 240009397, PMID 39333864, PMID 40288637, PMID 40258500
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply