Evidence level: B
分层不是在原有结论上磨细刻度,它是把一个问题换成几个问题——而这几个问题能不能合回一句,取决于一个从没人算过的比值。
正文
一、分层前后,问的不是同一句话
不分层时,问题只有一个:风水穴到最近断层的距离,是否系统性地大于随机点。分层之后,问题变成几个:在活动断层附近,穴位是否更远;在死断层附近,是否也更远;在压性断层附近,是否同样。
这不是同一句话的细化,是几句话。只有各层方向一致、按样本量加权,才会合回原来那一句。任何一层反向,加权平均就可能被拉到零甚至翻转——这就是辛普森悖论。PMID 26854260 在一项多中心 HIV 队列里实测过这种翻转:忽略点位聚类,聚合数据里的趋势会在分组后反向。PMID 22246415 是同一件事的另一面:同一批肺癌数据,聚合分析与分区分析给出互相矛盾的结论。
二、”类型”是制图者的选择,不是氡的属性
活动断层与死断层,本质是一条时间窗的划分——”晚更新世以来有没有活动”,窗口是人定的。张性、压性、走滑是应力状态的划分,而同一条断层沿走向可以转换性质,分段后每段的力学属性都可能不同。倾角、破碎带宽度、断层泥厚度,这些都没进标签。
标签是离散的,机制是连续的,中间还隔着一层制图者的取舍。真正的机制变量是渗透率,它决定氡能不能上来。而渗透率恰恰不是”类型”的函数。PMID 37020109 在北亚平宁两条结构复杂的断层带上做了系统的原位露头渗透率测量,结论是”强烈的空间非均质”:同一条带内部,不同脆性结构相差异极大。PMID 23373845 对一条成熟走滑断层带做水压试验加数值模拟,测出的是各向异性渗透率叠加内部分区。PMID 31290141 更直接:断层既可以当通道,也可以当屏障。
所以”活动断层是氡的高速通道”在类型层面成立,在点位层面经常不成立。
三、组内差是三个数量级,这是本篇最要紧的数字
北安纳托利亚断裂带西段 12 个测点、连续观测 12 个月,土壤氡 29 到 7059 Bq/m³,均值 1930(PMID 26903173)——极差两百多倍。印度 Kachchh 2001 年地震震区 277 个点覆盖约 8250 km²,11.3 到 15,319 Bq/m³,均值 1331(PMID 42631768)——三个数量级。印尼 Lembang 断裂带平均 14,117 Bq/m³,异常点超 20,000,且西段系统性高于东段(PMID 36442382)。希腊北部五个活动断层,断层轴附近信号/背景比从 2 到 13(PMID 12941512)——同类断层,增益差六倍。
换言之,同一个”活动断层”标签下的点位之间,本身就能差三个数量级。
分层的收益是”组间差除以组内差”。组内差跨三个数量级时,方差缩减微乎其微,切掉的样本量却是实打实的。这不是统计学推论,是算术。
四、切碎样本的代价,在置换检验上格外明显
样本分三四层,每层可能只剩二三十个穴位点,最小可检距离差随之抬升——原来能分辨的 150 米与 400 米,分层后未必分得出来,”不显著”于是成了”这一层没有避让”。这不是结论,是分辨率不够。
再叠上”逐层各做一次检验”:三层各出一个 p 值,名义 5% 的实际族错误率接近 15%,还多给了一个自由度——哪层显著就报哪层。PMID 17599075 把这套做法直接叫亚组分析的谬误,药方三条:必须用正规的交互检验、必须预注册、必须有足够功效。PMID 32820592 补技术细节:分层稀疏时,分层置信区间的覆盖率会明显失真,多数方法在这个区间不能信。
五、分层还会塞进新的混杂
活动断层多在山地,死断层多在平原与盆地边缘;风水穴选址又同时受水源、坡度、耕地驱动。于是”穴位远离活动断层”很可能只是”穴位不在陡山上”。分层没解决这个问题,只把地形效应关进层内,让人以为控制过了。这与 #468 的坐标精度是两件事:那里错的是位置,这里错的是归组。
公道的另一半:不分层也不对。若效应修饰真存在——比如压性、走滑挤压侧氡反而偏低——不分层会把方向相反的两层平均成零,得出”无关联”的错误结论。争点不是”分不分”,而是”分完怎么报”。
六、判决三件事
其一,分层变量尽量按连续或多分类处理,层间差异用一个交互项检验,不逐层扫 p。其二,先算组内/组间方差比(ICC);ICC 低就承认分层不划算,改用把断层距离当连续变量、断层段当随机效应的地统计模型。其三,每层都报”最小可检出距离差”,层太小就合并,或明确写”该层不可判”。三件事做完,”避让”才有确定的意思。
易学落点:风水自己就是分层的,但它分层的依据不是类型,是通塞。《雪心赋》讲龙有真假、有过峡束气入首,同一条山脉分段看,不同段落吉凶不同——这已经是”断层分段”的古代版本。区别在于:古人按”气通不通”分,现代人按”活动/死””张/压”分。前者直接对着输运效率,后者只是一个粗糙代理,而且常常失效。用标签的标签去追机制,是分层最容易犯的错。更值得记的一句是”石山不可葬”——岩石裸露、裂隙过通,气反而留不住;这与氡的乘积形式(源浓度×渗透率)在结构上同构:既要有源,也要留得住。真正的分层变量,应该是这个”留”字。
证据与局限
已验证: 断层带内部渗透率呈强烈空间非均质、且可同时充当流体通道与屏障(PMID 37020109、23373845、31290141);同类断层上不同测点的土壤氡可跨两到三个数量级(PMID 26903173、42631768、36442382、12941512);聚合与分区分析可给出方向相反的结论(PMID 26854260、22246415);亚组分析须用交互检验、须预注册、须有功效(PMID 17599075),分层稀疏时置信区间覆盖率失真(PMID 32820592)。
部分验证: “活动断层供气更强”在类型-区域层面有实测支持(PMID 30425320、32339146、42631768),但从未有人把”断层类型”作为分层变量,系统检验过风水穴距离分布的组间异质性;”断层的渗透性随断层泥与矿物沉淀自我封闭、故活动性与通透性并非单调对应”是基于断层带结构研究的合理推论(PMID 37020109、23373845),尚无直接的时序封闭速率实测。
待验证: 分层前后效应量比值的实际分布;”穴位远离活动断层”在控制地形与水源后是否仍存在;断层段(而非断层类型)作为分析单元时结论是否改变;中国南方湿润区与西北干旱区是否因分类判据保存条件不同而呈现完全不同的分层结果。
相关阅读
证据等级: B(断层带渗透率非均质、土壤氡的组内变异幅度均有 PubMed 实测支撑;”按断层类型分层后风水穴避让结论是否稳健”本身无先例,属研究设计裁决)
参考文献: PMID 12941512, PMID 17599075, PMID 22246415, PMID 23373845, PMID 26854260, PMID 26903173, PMID 30425320, PMID 31290141, PMID 32339146, PMID 32820592, PMID 36442382, PMID 37020109, PMID 42631768
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Categorizing Faults Turns \”Avoidance\” into Several Different Statements
Evidence level: B
Stratification is not merely refining the scale on an existing conclusion; it transforms a single question into several. Whether these can be reconciled into one statement depends on a ratio that has never been calculated before.
Main Text
I. The Question Changes Before and After Stratification
Without stratification, there is only one question: Is the distance from a Feng Shui site to the nearest fault systematically greater than that of random points? After stratification, the question becomes multiple: Is the site farther near active faults? Is it also farther near dead faults? Is it similarly distant near compressive faults?
This is not a refinement of the same sentence; it is several sentences. Only if all layers align directionally and are weighted by sample size will they reconcile back into the original statement. If any layer reverses direction, the weighted average may be pulled to zero or even flip—this is Simpson’s Paradox. PMID 26854260 demonstrated this flip in a multi-center HIV cohort: ignoring point clustering caused trends in aggregated data to reverse after grouping. PMID 22246415 shows the other side of the same coin: the same lung cancer dataset yielded contradictory conclusions from aggregated versus stratified analyses.
II. “Type” Is a Cartographer’s Choice, Not a Property of Radon
Active versus dead faults are essentially a temporal window division—”has there been activity since the late Pleistocene?”—a window defined by humans. Normal, reverse, and strike-slip classify stress states, yet a single fault can change its nature along its trace; mechanical properties of each segment may differ. Dip angle, fault zone width, and clay thickness are not included in the labels.
Labels are discrete; mechanisms are continuous, separated by a layer of cartographer discretion. The true mechanism variable is permeability, which determines whether radon can rise. Permeability is not a function of “type.” PMID 37020109 conducted systematic in-situ outcrop permeability measurements on two structurally complex fault zones in the North Apennines, concluding in “strong spatial heterogeneity”: different brittle structural phases within the same zone differed vastly. PMID 23373845 performed hydraulic testing combined with numerical simulation on a mature strike-slip fault zone, measuring anisotropic permeability superimposed with internal zoning. PMID 31290141 is even more direct: faults can act as conduits or as barriers.
Thus, “active faults are high-speed conduits for radon” holds at the typological level but frequently fails at the point level.
III. Intra-group Variation Spans Three Orders of Magnitude; This Is the Most Critical Number in This Piece
In the western North Anatolian Fault Zone, 12 measurement points observed continuously for 12 months showed soil radon ranging from 29 to 7059 Bq/m³, with a mean of 1930 (PMID 26903173)—a range of over two hundred times. In the Kachchh earthquake zone in India covering ~8250 km² with 277 points, values ranged from 11.3 to 15,319 Bq/m³, with a mean of 1331 (PMID 42631768)—three orders of magnitude. In the Lembang fault zone, Indonesia, the average was 14,117 Bq/m³ with anomalies exceeding 20,000, and the western segment was systematically higher than the eastern (PMID 36442382). In five active faults in northern Greece, the signal-to-background ratio near the fault axis ranged from 2 to 13 (PMID 12941512)—a six-fold difference among similar faults.
In other words, points under the same “active fault” label can differ by three orders of magnitude.
The benefit of stratification is the ratio of “between-group difference divided by within-group difference.” When intra-group variation spans three orders of magnitude, variance reduction is negligible, yet the discarded sample size is real. This is not a statistical inference; it is arithmetic.
IV. The Cost of Fragmenting Samples Is Especially Visible in Permutation Tests
Dividing samples into three or four layers may leave only twenty to thirty sites per layer, raising the minimum detectable distance difference. What was once resolvable at 150 meters versus 400 meters may no longer be distinguishable after stratification, rendering “not significant” effectively meaning “no avoidance in this layer.” This is not a conclusion; it is insufficient resolution.
Compounding this with “performing one test per layer”: three layers yield three p-values, pushing the nominal 5% family-wise error rate close to 15%, while also consuming an extra degree of freedom—report significance only where a layer is significant. PMID 17599075 explicitly labels this practice as the fallacy of subgroup analysis, prescribing three remedies: must use formal interaction tests, must preregister, and must have sufficient power. PMID 32820592 adds technical details: when stratification is sparse, coverage of stratified confidence intervals becomes significantly distorted; most methods cannot be trusted in this interval.
V. Stratification Also Introduces New Confounders
Active faults are often in mountainous areas, while dead faults are typically at the edges of plains and basins. Feng Shui site selection is simultaneously driven by water sources, slope, and arable land. Thus, “sites far from active faults” may simply mean “sites not on steep mountains.” Stratification does not solve this; it merely confines the topographic effect within layers, leading one to believe control has been achieved. This is distinct from #468 regarding coordinate precision: there, the error lies in location; here, it lies in grouping.
The fair counterpoint: not stratifying is also incorrect. If effect modification truly exists—for example, if compressive or reverse faults on the squeeze side show lower radon—stratification averages opposing directions into zero, yielding the erroneous conclusion of “no association.” The debate is not “whether to stratify,” but “how to report after stratifying.”
VI. Three Things Must Be Decided
First, treat stratification variables as continuous or multi-class whenever possible; test inter-layer differences with one interaction term, not by sweeping p-values layer by layer. Second, calculate the ratio of within-group to between-group variance (ICC); if ICC is low, admit stratification is not cost-effective and instead use geostatistical models treating fault distance as continuous and fault segments as random effects. Third, report the “minimum detectable distance difference” for each layer; merge layers if too small, or explicitly state “unjudgable for this layer.” Once these three things are done, “avoidance” has a definite meaning.
Yijing Studies Application: Feng Shui itself is inherently stratified, but its basis is not type, but flow and obstruction. Xue Xin Fu discusses true versus false dragons, overpasses, and qi gathering at entrances; viewing the same mountain range in segments yields different auspiciousness for each segment—this is already an ancient version of “fault segmentation.” The difference lies in how ancients stratified by “whether qi flows,” whereas moderns stratify by “active/dead” or “normal/compressive.” The former directly addresses transport efficiency; the latter is a rough proxy that often fails. Chasing mechanisms with labels is the most common error in stratification. A more memorable principle is “do not bury on exposed rock”—where rocks are bare and fissures are overly permeable, qi cannot be retained. This is structurally isomorphic to radon’s multiplicative form (source concentration × permeability): there must be a source, but also retention. The true stratification variable should be this “retention.”
Evidence and Limitations
Verified: Fault zones exhibit strong spatial heterogeneity in permeability and can simultaneously act as fluid conduits and barriers (PMID 37020109, 23373845, 31290141); soil radon at different points on similar faults can span two to three orders of magnitude (PMID 26903173, 42631768, 36442382, 12941512); aggregated and stratified analyses can yield opposite conclusions (PMID 26854260, 22246415); subgroup analysis requires interaction tests, preregistration, and sufficient power (PMID 17599075), with confidence interval coverage distortion when stratification is sparse (PMID 32820592).
Partially Verified: “Active faults provide stronger radon supply” has empirical support at the typological-regional level (PMID 30425320, 32339146, 42631768), but no one has ever used “fault type” as a stratification variable to systematically test between-group heterogeneity in Feng Shui site distance distributions. The inference that “permeability self-seals with fault clay and mineral precipitation, so activity and permeability are not monotonically correlated” is a reasonable deduction based on fault zone structural studies (PMID 37020109, 23373845), but lacks direct empirical measurement of temporal sealing rates.
To Be Verified: The actual distribution of effect size ratios before and after stratification; whether “sites far from active faults” persists after controlling for topography and water sources; whether conclusions change when fault segments (rather than fault types) serve as analysis units; and whether southern humid regions and northwestern arid regions in China show completely different stratification results due to differing classification criteria preservation conditions.
Related Reading
- Spatial Distance Distribution of Feng Shui Sites vs High-Radon Structural Belts vs Random Baseline
- Can Faults’ “150 Meters” Predict Feng Shui’s “Auspicious/Inauspicious” Thresholds
- Is the Precision of Gazetteer Coordinates Sufficient to Support a 10-Kilometer Grid
- Research Pool: Spacetime Frequency Topology
Evidence Level: B (Spatial heterogeneity of fault zone permeability and intra-group variation magnitude in soil radon are supported by PubMed measurements; “whether Feng Shui avoidance conclusions remain robust after stratification by fault type” itself has no precedent, belonging to a research design judgment)
References: PMID 12941512, PMID 17599075, PMID 22246415, PMID 23373845, PMID 26854260, PMID 26903173, PMID 30425320, PMID 31290141, PMID 32339146, PMID 32820592, PMID 36442382, PMID 37020109, PMID 42631768
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply