Evidence level: C
一句话结论:同一个材料、同一个频点、同一张”厚度—衰减”表,本库里有两份正本给出了互不相容的数字。判它们打架不需要知道地下真实电导率是多少——只需要一条恒等式:
A ∝ d。这是第 15 轮那条”同文件内互检”的跨文件版,也是它第一次真正抓到本库的主体缺陷形态。
一、为什么”跨文件”比”同文件”重要
第 15 轮做了一件很值钱的事:把 A(dB) ≈ 8.7·d/δ 里的 A ∝ d 抽出来,做成一条零参数检查——同一个文件里,同一材料同一频点下若出现两组”厚度—衰减”,两者之比必须相等。
它判死了本库最硬的一处错(skin-depth-basement 里散文写「1 km 花岗岩 A ≈ 0.27 dB」、表格写「100 m 花岗岩 27 dB」,厚度差 10 倍而衰减差 100 倍)。
但它报出的违反只有 1 处。原因不是本库干净,而是它的判据里有一条硬门槛:
厚度至少差 2 倍,才值得比(更小的差不构成可判信号)
这条门槛在数学上是对的(同厚度时比例检验退化),在工程上却把最硬的一类矛盾挡在门外:
同厚度、不同 A —— 这根本不需要比例,只需要”相等”。而恰恰是这一类,在双语镜像 + 审计文互引的库里才是主体。
二、这一轮把范围推到跨文件,先撞了两次墙
把”同材料同频点”的配对范围从单文件扩到全库,第一次跑出来的违者是 32 对。这个数字不可信——按第 15 轮的纪律(每条新出现的违反都必须逐条归因才可采信),逐条看下来,32 对里绝大多数是假阳性,来源只有两个:
墙一:审计文与台账被当成”主张方”。
pool4-unparsed-table-classification-governance.md 里有一段并排写的是:
散文: 1 km 花岗岩 → A ≈ 0.27 dB
§3 表: 100 m 花岗岩 → A = 27 dB
这两行本来就该不同——它是在引用一处矛盾,不是在主张一个数值。同理,backlog 里也抄了同一段。把它们与正本互比,等于把”有人在引用错值”当成”这个文件也错了”。
墙二:散文里的材料名跨行串味。
一份 SOP 里有两行相邻的列表:
- 30 cm 混凝土墙 @ 50 Hz:δ ≈ 80 cm → A ≈ 3.3 dB
- 2 mm μ-metal @ 50 Hz:δ ≈ 0.5 mm → A ≈ 35 dB
第一行的 A ≈ 3.3 dB 被工具认成了 μ-metal——因为”最近材料词”是按字符距离算的,而换行不是边界,下一行的 μ-metal 字符反而更近。于是在”同厚度 2 mm”下,凭空多出一条「μ-metal 3.3 vs 35 dB,差 10.6 倍」的假矛盾。中英双语镜像各中一次,共 4 条假阳性。
两道墙都堵上之后,32 对收敛到 6 对。 这是本轮第二次验证”放宽匹配必须同步收紧排除”——第 14 轮踩了三次、第 15 轮踩了三次,本轮再踩两次。
三、留下的 6 对,全部指向同两处伤口
| # | 材料 @ 频点 | 厚度比 | A 比 | 偏差 | A 侧 | B 侧 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 花岗岩 @ 7.83 Hz | 10× | 100× | 10× | mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 1000 m / 0.27 dB |
skin-depth-basement L76 100 m / 27 dB |
| 2 | μ-metal @ 7.83 Hz | 20× | 8.65× | 0.43× | skin-depth-basement L72 2 mm / 30 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L131 0.1 mm / 3.47 dB |
| 3 | 钢板 @ 7.83 Hz | 2× | 5.46× | 2.73× | skin-depth-basement L73 5 mm / 83 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L129 10 mm / 15.2 dB |
| 4 | 钢板 @ 7.83 Hz | 5× | 54.6× | 10.9× | skin-depth-basement L73 5 mm / 83 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L130 1 mm / 1.52 dB |
| 5 | 花岗岩 @ 7.83 Hz | 10× | 180× | 18× | skin-depth-basement L76 100 m / 27 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L125 1000 m / 0.15 dB |
| 6 | 花岗岩 @ 7.83 Hz | 10× | 100× | 10× | skin-depth-basement L76 100 m / 27 dB |
pool4-mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent L19 1000 m / 0.27 dB |
看这张表有一个很清晰的信号:6 对里有 4 对的一侧是同一个文件、同一行——skin-depth-basement 的 L76「100 m 花岗岩 27 dB」。
第 13–15 轮已经在同文件内判过这一行(它和本文自己的散文 0.27 dB 差 1000 倍)。本轮的意义是:换一个方向再判,还是它。它不只与自己的散文打架,还与另外两份正本(skin-depth-reference-table 0.15 dB、mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 0.27 dB)打架。
而这两份正本彼此是相容的:0.15 dB vs 0.27 dB,差 1.8 倍,在 2 倍容差内。两条独立来源说”1 km 花岗岩衰减不到 1 dB”,一条说”100 m 花岗岩衰减 27 dB”——按 A ∝ d,100 m 应当只有 1 km 的十分之一,即 0.015–0.027 dB。
结论不依赖任何 σ 取值:只要承认 A ∝ d,L76 就错了。而 A ∝ d 在 d ≪ δ 的近似下是恒等式,不依赖 σ。
四、必须说清的三条边界
第一,这不证明”另外两份是对的”。 A ∝ d 只约束同一材料内部的相对关系,它没有说 0.15 dB 或 0.27 dB 哪个才是真值。两处都错的”错错相消”同样能通过比例检验——第 15 轮那张 μ-metal 行就是这样:它在逐格复算里判 OK,恰恰因为表的上下两节用了同一个错的 δ。
第二,本检验只可证伪,不可验证。 比例对得上 ≠ 数值对。所以本轮的 6 条违反可以当作”至少有 6 处不相容”的证据;但“只有 6 处”不能当作质量指标——它只反映本次识别规则能看见多少(见下条)。
第三,覆盖率必须报三项(R12 规矩):
| 项 | 值 |
|---|---|
| ① 扫描根 | 780-网站与内容中枢(全库 2,403 个 md) |
| ② 识别规则 | 等式断言的”厚度–A(dB)”点;同材料 + 同频点 + 同 μr;符号距离 ≤ 2×;转述/审计文不作主张方 |
| ③ 静默跳过 | 含可判点的 md 共 11 个,其中 5 个是转述/审计文被排除;正本仅 6 个文件 / 28 个点 |
第三项是本轮最该被记住的数字:整个库能参与跨文件互比的,只有 28 个点、14 组配对。 这个规模小到什么程度?—— 6 条违反是从 14 组配对里出来的,违反率听起来很高,但样本量根本不足以推出任何”全库矛盾率”。这一点必须在写进任何结论前先说。
五、顺带修掉的第 8 类失败模式:区间被压成左端点
做跨文件配对时撞到一件更基础的事:工具把区间格压成了等式。
parse_num_ex("1–10 dB") → (1.0, "1", "eq")
也就是说,表格里写 A 1–10 dB(B 档范围)的格子,被当成 A = 1 dB 的等式断言送去比对。全库命中 δ/A 列的区间格共 42 处,其中 20 处明确属于”整格就是一个区间”。
这类格不是”值算错了”,而是判读型归属错了——它表达的是档位范围,不是一个测量值。把它当等式判,等于凭空造出一条错误断言。
修复方式刻意保守:不做区间端点判读,只做”不冒充等式”。识别出区间后,比较符记为 range,判读结果记为”不可判”,单独列一档 RANGE-unjudged,不进 MISMATCH。
为什么不做双端点判读?因为 A 与 δ 的”好/坏方向”相反,且这里的区间表达的是档位而非测量不确定度。强行判端点会重演第 12 轮那件事:判了 A 档、下一轮又自我证伪改成 C 档。区间只可报”不可单点判”,不可报”通过”。
修完后 MISMATCH 总数一条未变(24 + 34 + 196),OK 从 146 降到 138,差额 8 条正是从”被当成等式且恰好落在容差内”翻成”不可判”的那批。
六、这一轮真正学到的
教训一:门槛本身就是盲区。
d_ratio ≥ 2 是上一轮为了让比例检验有信号而设的,它没错;但它把”同厚度不同 A”整类挡在门外。任何为了降噪而设的门槛,都会同时定义一类永远看不见的缺陷。 跨文件这一轮的第一件事,就是把门槛拆成两条:同厚度 → 判”相等”;不同厚度 → 判”成比例”。
教训二:引用不是主张。
在一个”审计文互相引用”的库里,把审计文当主张方,会把”有人在引用错值”读成”这个文件也错了”。32 → 6 的收敛,一半来自这一条。
教训三:换行是语义边界。
nearest_material 用字符距离是合理的,但它默认”文本是连续的”。列表里每行一个材料时,这个假设就破了。工具里所有”就近取”的逻辑,都要问一句:跨行还算不算同一个主语?
七、证据与局限
外部文献支撑的是公式与参数前提,不是本库的数字。
A(dB) ≈ 8.686·d/δ与δ = √(2/(ωμσ))是均匀导电半空间下的标准结果;其在岩石上的适用性受电导率频散限制:Kariya & Shankland (1983, Geophysics, doi:10.1190/1.1441407) 报告干燥下地壳岩石的电导率随频率变化;Laštovičková & Bochníček (1992, Stud. Geophys. Geod., doi:10.1007/BF01613900) 专门测量岩石电导率的频率依赖性;Revil (2013, Water Resour. Res., doi:10.1029/2012WR012700) 给出非饱和多孔介质有效电导率与介电常数在宽频段的模型;Mehran & Arulanandan (1977, Clays Clay Miner., doi:10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107) 报告黏土—水—电解质体系的低频电导率频散。- 四篇均在 Crossref 回查通过。均为地物/材料期刊,不在 PubMed 收录范围 → 无 PMID → 如实标 E3,不构成 E1。
局限(必须与结论同读):
- 本检验判”不相容”仅指文件内两处数字不满足
A ∝ d,不指真实地下 A 为另一值,也不指谁的 σ 引用错了。 A ≈ 8.7d/δ假设均匀半空间、无位移电流、μr/σ 为常数。真实山体分层、各向异性、σ 随频率弥散——上列四篇均支持频散存在,故公式本身在宽频段只是量级估算。- 有效配对仅 14 组、正本仅 6 文件 28 点,不足以外推任何”全库矛盾率”。
- 只覆盖等式断言;不等式断言(
A ≥ 10 dB)与文字区间(”数百米–数千米”)不参与。 - 转述/审计文被整体排除,意味着若某处矛盾只存在于审计文与正本之间、且正本本身不自相矛盾,本检验看不见。
- ASCII 图内的标注仍在盲区;本轮
skin-depth-basementL80 那条散文点被”同行材料”规则保留(材料与 A 值确在同一行),但同文件的 ASCII 图段仍未纳入。
免责声明:本文是库内文本一致性的方法学审计,不是地球物理测量结论,不构成任何”靠山能否屏蔽 ELF”的实证判断,更不构成健康或医疗建议。任何据此做的采样决策,须先经 #14 阶段3 实测与 779 终版审核。
八、下一步
- #64:把 R5 / R5X / R7 三条零参数检查合并成一张”断言充分性矩阵”,统一回答”这批断言里有几成是可判的”。
- D1′/D1/D2 单独提请 JOE:
mountain-sopA 档门槛σ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km A ≥ 10 dB的最不利端只有 4.83 dB,真实分界是σ ≥ 4.29×10⁻²。这是唯一影响采样决策的一项,已连续 3 轮挂起。 - #59:F2 余 4 + F3 余 6 逐格复算(仍是 P2)。
- 不要做:把 R5X 扩成跨材料或跨 μr(物理上不成立,第 15 轮已立铁律);用”通过数”当质量指标(R11)。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Cross-file Contradiction: When Two Delta Tables Clash, You Can Determine Who Is Right Without Checking Parameters
Evidence level: C
One-sentence conclusion: Two official tables within this repository for the same material, frequency, and “thickness–attenuation” relationship yield mutually incompatible numbers. Resolving this conflict does not require knowing the true subsurface conductivity—it relies solely on the identity
A ∝ d. This is the cross-file iteration of the “intra-file cross-check” introduced in Round 15, and it is the first time this repository’s core structural defect has been definitively identified.
I. Why “Cross-file” is More Critical Than “Intra-file”
Round 15 performed a valuable operation: it extracted the A ∝ d proportionality from the formula A(dB) ≈ 8.7·d/δ to create a zero-parameter check. Within any single file, if two entries exist for the same material and frequency, the ratio of their thicknesses must equal the ratio of their attenuation values.
This check definitively identified the repository’s most glaring error: in skin-depth-basement, prose states “1 km granite A ≈ 0.27 dB” while the table lists “100 m granite 27 dB”—a thickness ratio of 10 yielding an attenuation ratio of 100.
However, this check reported only one violation. This is not because the repository is clean; rather, its criterion includes a hard threshold:
Thickness must differ by at least 2× to be comparable (smaller differences do not constitute a detectable signal).
Mathematically, this threshold is correct (the proportionality test degenerates when thicknesses are equal). However, engineering-wise, it excludes the most severe class of contradictions:
Same thickness, different A — This fundamentally does not require proportionality; it requires “equality.” And precisely this class constitutes the majority of conflicts in a bilingual mirror + audit-text cross-reference repository.
II. Extending the Scope to Cross-file: First Two Walls Collided
Expanding the pairing scope from “same file” to “entire repository” yielded 32 violations. This number is unreliable—per Round 15 discipline (each newly detected violation must be individually attributed to be credible), most of the 32 pairs are false positives, originating from two sources:
Wall One: Audit texts and ledgers mistaken for “claimants.”
In pool4-unparsed-table-classification-governance.md, two lines appear side-by-side:
Prose: 1 km granite → A ≈ 0.27 dB
§3 Table: 100 m granite → A = 27 dB
These two lines were meant to be different—they are citing a contradiction, not asserting a single value. Similarly, the backlog copied the same segment. Comparing them against official tables treats “someone citing a wrong value” as “this file is also wrong.”
Wall Two: Material names crossing row boundaries in prose.
One SOP contains two adjacent list items:
- 30 cm concrete wall @ 50 Hz: δ ≈ 80 cm → A ≈ 3.3 dB
- 2 mm μ-metal @ 50 Hz: δ ≈ 0.5 mm → A ≈ 35 dB
The tool misidentified A ≈ 3.3 dB as belonging to μ-metal—because “nearest material word” is calculated by character distance, and newlines are not boundaries; the μ-metal text in the next row is closer. Under “same thickness 2 mm,” this created a phantom contradiction: “μ-metal 3.3 vs 35 dB, differing by 10.6×.” The bilingual mirror caught this once in each language, totaling 4 false positives.
After blocking both walls, the 32 pairs converged to 6 pairs. This marks the second verification of “relaxing matching must simultaneously tighten exclusion”—Round 14 tripped three times, Round 15 tripped three times, and this round trips twice.
III. The Remaining 6 Pairs All Point to Two Wounds
| # | Material @ Frequency | Thickness Ratio | A Ratio | Deviation | Side A | Side B |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Granite @ 7.83 Hz | 10× | 100× | 10× | mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 1000 m / 0.27 dB |
skin-depth-basement L76 100 m / 27 dB |
| 2 | μ-metal @ 7.83 Hz | 20× | 8.65× | 0.43× | skin-depth-basement L72 2 mm / 30 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L131 0.1 mm / 3.47 dB |
| 3 | Steel plate @ 7.83 Hz | 2× | 5.46× | 2.73× | skin-depth-basement L73 5 mm / 83 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L129 10 mm / 15.2 dB |
| 4 | Steel plate @ 7.83 Hz | 5× | 54.6× | 10.9× | skin-depth-basement L73 5 mm / 83 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L130 1 mm / 1.52 dB |
| 5 | Granite @ 7.83 Hz | 10× | 180× | 18× | skin-depth-basement L76 100 m / 27 dB |
skin-depth-reference-table L125 1000 m / 0.15 dB |
| 6 | Granite @ 7.83 Hz | 10× | 100× | 10× | skin-depth-basement L76 100 m / 27 dB |
pool4-mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent L19 1000 m / 0.27 dB |
A clear signal emerges from this table: 4 of the 6 pairs involve the same file and line—skin-depth-basement L76 “100 m granite 27 dB.”
Rounds 13–15 already judged this line within the same file (it differs by 1000× from its own prose value of 0.27 dB). The significance of this round is: judging from the opposite direction still yields the same result. It not only conflicts with its own prose but also with two other official tables (skin-depth-reference-table 0.15 dB and mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 0.27 dB).
These two official tables are consistent with each other: 0.15 dB vs 0.27 dB differs by 1.8×, within the 2× tolerance. Two independent sources state “1 km granite attenuation is less than 1 dB,” while one states “100 m granite attenuation is 27 dB”—per A ∝ d, 100 m should be only one-tenth of 1 km, i.e., 0.015–0.027 dB.
Conclusion does not depend on any σ value: as long as A ∝ d is accepted, L76 is wrong. And A ∝ d holds as an identity under the approximation d ≪ δ, independent of σ.
IV. Three Boundaries That Must Be Clarified
First, this does not prove “the other two are correct.” A ∝ d only constrains relative relationships within the same material; it does not specify which of 0.15 dB or 0.27 dB is the true value. Even “double errors canceling each other” can pass proportionality tests—this is exactly what happened with the μ-metal row in Round 15: it passed incremental recalculation precisely because both upper and lower sections of the table used the same erroneous δ.
Second, this test can only falsify, not verify. Matching proportions ≠ matching values. Therefore, the 6 violations in this round serve as evidence of “at least 6 incompatibilities”; but “only 6” cannot serve as a quality metric—it merely reflects how many the current identification rules can detect (see next section).
Third, coverage must report three items (per R12 rules):
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| ① Scan root | 780-Website and Content Hub (2,403 md files in full repository) |
| ② Identification rule | “Thickness–A(dB)” points of the equality assertion; same material + same frequency + same μr; symbol distance ≤ 2×; transcribed/audit texts excluded as claimants |
| ③ Silent skip | 11 md files containing judgable points, of which 5 were excluded as transcribed/audit texts; official tables cover only 6 files / 28 points |
The third item is the most critical number of this round: only 28 points across 14 pairs in the entire repository can participate in cross-file comparison. How small is this scale?—6 violations emerged from 14 pairs, making the violation rate sound high, but the sample size is insufficient to infer any “full-repository contradiction rate.” This must be stated before writing any conclusion.
V. Incidentally Fixed Failure Mode #8: Intervals Compressed to Left Endpoints
During cross-file pairing, we encountered a more fundamental issue: the tool compressed interval cells into equations.
parse_num_ex("1–10 dB") → (1.0, "1", "eq")
That is, table cells stating A 1–10 dB (B-grade range) were treated as the equation assertion A = 1 dB. Across the entire repository, 42 interval cells hit the δ/A column, of which 20 are explicitly “entire cell is an interval.”
These cells are not “value calculation errors”; rather, judgmental attribution is wrong—they express grade ranges, not measurement values. Treating them as equations creates phantom assertions.
The fix is deliberately conservative: do not interpret interval endpoints; only avoid pretending to be equations. After identifying intervals, the comparison symbol is marked range, the judgment result is “unjudgable,” and they are listed separately under RANGE-unjudged, not entering MISMATCH.
Why not interpret both endpoints? Because A and δ have opposite “good/bad directions,” and here intervals express grades rather than measurement uncertainty. Forcing endpoint interpretation would repeat Round 12’s error: judging A-grade, then self-falsifying to C-grade in the next round. Intervals can only report “unjudgable at single points,” not “passed.”
After the fix, MISMATCH total remained unchanged (24 + 34 + 196), OK dropped from 146 to 138, with the difference of 8 coming from those “mistakenly treated as equations but falling within tolerance.”
VI. What This Round Truly Taught Us
Lesson One: Thresholds are blind spots.
The d_ratio ≥ 2 threshold was set in the previous round to give proportionality tests a signal; it is not wrong, but it excludes “same thickness, different A” entirely. Any threshold set to reduce noise simultaneously defines a class of defects that can never be seen. The first task of this cross-file round was to split the threshold into two: same thickness → judge “equality”; different thickness → judge “proportionality.”
Lesson Two: Citations are not claims.
In a repository where “audit texts cross-cite each other,” treating audit texts as claimants causes “someone citing a wrong value” to be read as “this file is also wrong.” The convergence from 32 to 6 is half due to this rule.
Lesson Three: Newlines are semantic boundaries.
nearest_material using character distance is reasonable, but it assumes “text is continuous.” When each list item represents a separate material, this assumption breaks. All “nearest-taking” logic in the tool must ask: does crossing lines still count as the same subject?
VII. Evidence and Limitations
External literature supports formulas and parameter premises, not the repository’s numbers.
A(dB) ≈ 8.686·d/δandδ = √(2/(ωμσ))are standard results for uniform half-space; their applicability to rock is limited by conductivity dispersion: Kariya & Shankland (1983, Geophysics, doi:10.1190/1.1441407) reports frequency-dependent conductivity of dry lower crust rocks; Laštovičková & Bochníček (1992, Stud. Geophys. Geod., doi:10.1007/BF01613900) specifically measured frequency dependence of rock conductivity; Revil (2013, Water Resour. Res., doi:10.1029/2012WR012700) provides a model for effective conductivity and dielectric constant of unsaturated porous media across wide bandwidths; Mehran & Arulanandan (1977, Clays Clay Miner., doi:10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107) reports low-frequency conductivity dispersion of clay–water–electrolyte systems.- All four papers passed Crossref verification. All are earth/materials journals, not within PubMed scope → no PMID → correctly marked E3, not E1.
Limitations (must be read alongside conclusions):
- This test judges “incompatibility” only when two numbers within the same file do not satisfy
A ∝ d; it does not mean the true subsurface A is another value, nor that whose σ citation is wrong. A ≈ 8.7d/δassumes uniform half-space, no displacement current, constant μr/σ. Real layered mountains, anisotropy, and σ dispersion with frequency—these four papers all support dispersion existence, so the formula itself is only an order-of-magnitude estimate across wide bandwidths.- Only 14 valid pairs, 6 official files with 28 points, insufficient to extrapolate any “full-repository contradiction rate.”
- Only covers equality assertions; inequality assertions (
A ≥ 10 dB) and textual intervals (“hundreds of meters to thousands of meters”) are excluded. - Transcribed/audit texts are entirely excluded, meaning if a contradiction exists only between an audit text and an official table, and the official table itself is not internally contradictory, this test cannot see it.
- Annotations within ASCII diagrams remain in blind spots; this round’s
skin-depth-basementL80 prose point was retained by the “same-row material” rule (material and A value indeed appear on the same line), but the ASCII diagram segment of the same file was not included.
Disclaimer: This document is a methodological audit of textual consistency within the repository, not a geophysical measurement conclusion. It does not constitute any empirical judgment on “whether ELF can be shielded by mountains,” nor does it provide health or medical advice. Any sampling decisions based on this must first undergo #14 Stage 3 measurement and the final 779 review.
VIII. Next Steps
- #64: Merge R5 / R5X / R7 three zero-parameter checks into a single “Assertion Sufficiency Matrix,” uniformly answering “what fraction of these assertions are judgable.”
- D1′/D1/D2 separately request JOE:
mountain-sopA-grade thresholdσ ≥ 10⁻² → 1 km A ≥ 10 dBhas its worst endpoint at only 4.83 dB, while the true boundary isσ ≥ 4.29×10⁻². This is the only item affecting sampling decisions, and it has been pending for three consecutive rounds. - #59: Incremental recalculation of remaining F2 (4) and F3 (6) cells (still P2).
- Do not do: Expand R5X across materials or μr (physically invalid, Round 15 established ironclad rules); use “passed count” as quality metric (R11).