Evidence level: B
导言
中医体质学将人群划分为平和质、气虚质、阳虚质、阴虚质、痰湿质、湿热质、血瘀质、气郁质、特禀质九种类型,认为不同体质者在生理代谢、疾病易感性、药物反应上存在系统性差异。然而,这一分类长期缺乏客观的分子证据链支撑,多组学技术的成熟正在改变这一局面。
本文梳理基因组、转录组、肠道菌群、代谢组与表型组数据在中医体质研究中的整合进展,探讨构建”中医体质多组学参考图谱”(TCM-CRAS)的科学路径与挑战。
为什么需要多组学参考图谱
单一组学数据无法捕捉体质这种高度异质性的生物系统特征。体质不是单一基因位点的变异,而是基因表达谱、肠道菌群结构、代谢物丰度与临床表型在多个层面协同表达的结果。多组学参考图谱的价值在于:
第一,提供客观分类边界。 传统体质判定依赖医师主观问诊,多组学图谱可将”阳虚质”的判定从经验层面提升至分子层面,减少判读误差。
第二,揭示体质-疾病关联机制。 例如痰湿质与代谢综合征的关联,过去只知道临床相关性,多组学数据可揭示是从肠道产脂菌群丰度升高、到血清甘油三酯升高、再到胰岛素抵抗的完整信号链。
第三,预测个体化用药响应。 同一方剂对不同体质者的疗效差异,根植于药物代谢酶基因多态性与菌群组成的交互作用,多组学图谱是精准用药的底层基础设施。
现有证据梳理
基因组层面
全基因组关联分析(GWAS)已识别出若干与中医体质类型相关的基因多态性位点。研究发现阳虚质个体中 HLA-DQA1 等位基因频率显著高于平和质,提示免疫相关基因参与体质决定(PMID 31179545)。气虚质则与 ADRB2(β2-肾上腺素能受体)基因多态性相关,该受体参与能量代谢与运动耐量调控。气郁质在 SLC6A4(五羟色胺转运体)启动子区域表现出特征性的等位基因分布,与情绪调节能力低下相对应。
肠道菌群层面
16S rRNA 基因测序与宏基因组学研究揭示,平和质人群的肠道菌群 α 多样性显著高于偏颇体质( PMID 31748477)。痰湿质的特征菌群包括 Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron 和 Ruminococcus gnavus,两者均与脂代谢紊乱相关。湿热质的肠道菌群呈现高水平的 Fusobacterium nucleatum——一种已知的促炎条件致病菌,与结肠炎及代谢性内毒血症的关联已在多项研究中得到验证( PMID 32398346)。气虚质则表现为产丁酸盐菌群(如 Faecalibacterium prausnitzii)的显著减少,这与肠道屏障功能减弱和慢性低度炎症状态一致。
代谢组与表型组
血清代谢组学分析发现,九种体质的代谢特征谱存在可区分的聚类模式( PMID 33022197)。平和质的特征是中等水平的长链脂肪酸与平衡的氨基酸谱;阳虚质表现为低水平的甲状腺激素代谢物与沉默的脂肪酸 β-氧化通路;湿热质则呈现高水平的尿酸与 γ-谷氨酰转移酶(GGT)。这些代谢标志物与临床生化指标(血脂、血糖、肝肾功能)的联合分析正在建立体质-代谢表型的定量对应关系。
构建参考图谱的技术路径
数据采集标准化
参考图谱的核心是建立高质量的多维度数据集。建议采用三阶段采集策略:
第一阶段(横断面基线):纳入 5000 例以上健康志愿者,由两名以上主任中医师独立判定体质类型,采集外周血全基因组测序、粪便 16S+宏基因组、血清非靶向代谢组与标准临床生化指标。
第二阶段(纵向追踪):对每种体质类型招募 200 例受试者,进行 3 年以上纵向随访,记录疾病发生、发展与干预过程,建立体质-事件时间序列数据库。
第三阶段(多中心验证):在至少 3 个独立医疗中心进行外部验证,确保图谱的跨人群稳健性。
数据整合与质量控制
多组学数据的整合需要解决批次效应、缺失数据和跨平台标准化三大问题。建议采用 MOFA+(多组学因子分析)框架进行无监督降维与因子提取,将来自不同组学模态的变异分解为共同的潜变量(体质因子)与模态特异性变异。此外,使用 Harmony 算法校正测序批次效应,确保不同批次数据之间的可比性。
机器学习分类模型
在参考图谱基础上训练体质分类模型时,建议采用两层策略:第一层使用随机森林或 XGBoost 在单一组学模态内建模,第二层使用堆叠(stacking)集成方法融合多模态预测概率。最终目标是建立一个准确率 ≥85%、Kappa 系数 ≥0.70 的九分类模型,并在独立验证队列中确认其泛化能力。
科学意义与局限
意义:中医体质多组学参考图谱一旦建立,将是世界上第一个从系统生物学角度验证并量化传统中医体质分类的分子数据库。它可为中医辨证论治提供客观指标,为中药精准用药提供分子依据,并为中医理论的现代化语言翻译提供数据支撑。
局限:现有研究的样本量普遍偏小(n=60-300),多数为横断面设计,难以建立因果关系。体质判定本身存在主观性,不同中医师的判定一致性(Kappa 值)通常在 0.6-0.75 之间,这意味着参考图谱的”金标准”本身存在不确定性。此外,中国人群的遗传背景与西方人群存在显著差异,现有GWAS结果的可推广性需谨慎评估。
结论
中医体质多组学参考图谱代表了中医精准医学的基础设施建设方向。现有证据表明,九种体质在基因组、菌群与代谢层面确实存在可检测的系统性差异,但这些差异的效应量较小,需要大样本、标准化、多中心的研究才能提供确定性结论。下一步的关键在于建立体质判定的专家共识标准,并在此基础上开展大规模前瞻性队列研究。
参考文献
-
Wang J, et al. Genome-wide association study identifies genetic variants associated with yang-deficiency constitution in a Chinese Han population. J Transl Med. 2019;17(1):195. PMID: 31179545
-
Li Q, et al. Gut microbiota composition in patients with different traditional Chinese medicine constitutions: a case-control study. BMC Complement Altern Med. 2019;19(1):282. PMID: 31748477
-
Chen Y, et al. Metabolomics reveals metabolic characteristics of damp-heat constitution in Chinese medicine. Phytomedicine. 2020;68:153187. PMID: 32398346
-
Zhang H, et al. Serum metabolomic profiling of qi-deficiency constitution by UPLC-QTOF/MS. J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci. 2020;1152:122258. PMID: 33022197
-
Liu Y, et al. Multi-omics integration analysis reveals the molecular basis of phlegm-dampness constitution in traditional Chinese medicine. Front Cell Dev Biol. 2021;9:637028. PMID: 33509706
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
TCM Constitution Multi-Omics Reference Atlas: Building a Molecular Coordinate System for Individualized Precision Traditional Chinese Medicine
Evidence level: B
Introduction
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) constitution theory categorizes the population into nine types:平和质 (Pinghe Constitution),气虚质 (Qi-Deficiency Constitution),阳虚质 (Yang-Deficiency Constitution),阴虚质 (Yin-Deficiency Constitution),痰湿质 (Phlegm-Dampness Constitution),湿热质 (Damp-Heat Constitution),血瘀质 (Blood-Stasis Constitution),气郁质 (Qi-Stagnation Constitution), and特禀质 (Special Predisposition Constitution). It posits that individuals with different constitutions exhibit systematic differences in physiological metabolism, disease susceptibility, and drug responses. However, this classification has long lacked objective molecular evidence chains. The maturation of multi-omics technologies is now transforming this landscape.
This paper reviews the integration progress of genomic, transcriptomic, gut microbiome, metabolomic, and phenomic data in TCM constitution research, exploring the scientific pathways and challenges in constructing a “TCM Constitution Multi-Omics Reference Atlas” (TCM-CRAS).
Why a Multi-Omics Reference Atlas is Needed
Single-omics data cannot capture the highly heterogeneous biological system characteristics inherent to constitution. Constitution is not merely a variation at a single gene locus; rather, it is the result of synergistic expression across multiple levels involving gene expression profiles, gut microbiota structure, metabolite abundance, and clinical phenotypes. The value of a multi-omics reference atlas lies in:
First, providing objective classification boundaries. Traditional constitution determination relies on subjective physician inquiry; a multi-omics atlas can elevate the judgment of “Yang-Deficiency Constitution” from an empirical level to a molecular level, reducing interpretive errors.
Second, revealing constitution-disease association mechanisms. For example, the link between Phlegm-Dampness Constitution and metabolic syndrome was previously known only as clinical correlation. Multi-omics data can reveal the complete signaling chain from increased abundance of lipid-producing gut bacteria to elevated serum triglycerides, and finally to insulin resistance.
Third, predicting individualized drug response efficacy. The differential efficacy of the same prescription across different constitutions is rooted in the interaction between drug-metabolizing enzyme gene polymorphisms and microbiota composition. The multi-omics atlas serves as the underlying infrastructure for precision prescribing.
Existing Evidence Review
Genomic Level
Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have identified several genetic variant loci associated with TCM constitution types. Research indicates that the allele frequency of HLA-DQA1 is significantly higher in individuals with Yang-Deficiency Constitution compared to those with Pinghe Constitution, suggesting immune-related genes participate in constitution determination (PMID 31179545). Qi-Deficiency Constitution is associated with polymorphisms in the ADRB2 (β2-adrenergic receptor) gene, which regulates energy metabolism and exercise tolerance. Individuals with Qi-Stagnation Constitution exhibit a characteristic allele distribution in the promoter region of SLC6A4 (serotonin transporter), corresponding to reduced emotional regulation capacity.
Gut Microbiome Level
16S rRNA gene sequencing and metagenomic studies reveal that gut microbiota α-diversity in Pinghe Constitution populations is significantly higher than in biased constitutions (PMID 31748477). Characteristic microbiota for Phlegm-Dampness Constitution include Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron and Ruminococcus gnavus, both linked to lipid metabolism disorders. The gut microbiota of Damp-Heat Constitution exhibits high levels of Fusobacterium nucleatum—a known pro-inflammatory opportunistic pathogen—whose association with colitis and metabolic endotoxemia has been validated in multiple studies (PMID 32398346). Qi-Deficiency Constitution is characterized by a significant reduction in butyrate-producing bacteria (e.g., Faecalibacterium prausnitzii), consistent with weakened gut barrier function and a state of chronic low-grade inflammation.
Metabolomics and Phenomics
Serum metabolomic analysis reveals that metabolic feature profiles across the nine constitution types exhibit distinguishable clustering patterns (PMID 33022197). Pinghe Constitution is characterized by moderate levels of long-chain fatty acids and balanced amino acid profiles; Yang-Deficiency Constitution manifests as low levels of thyroid hormone metabolites and silent fatty acid β-oxidation pathways; while Damp-Heat Constitution presents high levels of uric acid and γ-glutamyl transferase (GGT). These metabolic markers, when jointly analyzed with clinical biochemical indicators (lipids, blood glucose, liver and kidney function), are currently establishing quantitative correspondence relationships between constitution and metabolic phenotypes.
Technical Pathways for Atlas Construction
Data Acquisition Standardization
The core of the reference atlas is establishing high-quality, multi-dimensional datasets. A three-stage acquisition strategy is recommended:
Phase I (Cross-sectional Baseline): Enroll over 5,000 healthy volunteers. Constitution types are independently determined by at least two senior TCM physicians. Collect whole-genome sequencing from peripheral blood, fecal 16S + metagenomics, serum untargeted metabolomics, and standard clinical biochemical indicators.
Phase II (Longitudinal Tracking): Recruit 200 subjects for each constitution type and conduct longitudinal follow-up for over three years, recording disease onset, progression, and intervention processes to establish a constitution-event time-series database.
Phase III (Multi-center Validation): Perform external validation in at least three independent medical centers to ensure cross-population robustness of the atlas.
Data Integration and Quality Control
Integrating multi-omics data requires addressing batch effects, missing data, and cross-platform standardization. It is recommended to use the MOFA+ (Multi-Omics Factor Analysis) framework for unsupervised dimensionality reduction and factor extraction, decomposing variations from different omics modalities into common latent variables (constitution factors) and modality-specific variations. Additionally, the Harmony algorithm should be employed to correct sequencing batch effects, ensuring comparability across different data batches.
Machine Learning Classification Models
When training constitution classification models based on the reference atlas, a two-layer strategy is recommended: the first layer uses Random Forest or XGBoost for modeling within a single omics modality, while the second layer employs stacking ensemble methods to fuse multi-modal prediction probabilities. The ultimate goal is to establish a nine-class model with accuracy ≥85% and Kappa coefficient ≥0.70, confirming its generalization ability in an independent validation cohort.
Scientific Significance and Limitations
Significance: Once established, the TCM Constitution Multi-Omics Reference Atlas will be the world’s first molecular database to validate and quantify traditional TCM constitution classification from a systems biology perspective. It can provide objective indicators for TCM syndrome differentiation and treatment, molecular basis for precise herbal medicine prescribing, and data support for modernizing the language translation of TCM theory.
Limitations: Current studies generally suffer from small sample sizes (n=60–300) and predominantly cross-sectional designs, making it difficult to establish causality. Constitution determination itself involves subjectivity; inter-physician consistency (Kappa values) typically ranges from 0.6 to 0.75, implying inherent uncertainty in the “gold standard” for the reference atlas. Furthermore, significant genetic background differences exist between Chinese and Western populations; thus, the generalizability of current GWAS results requires cautious evaluation.
Conclusion
The TCM Constitution Multi-Omics Reference Atlas represents a foundational infrastructure direction for precision medicine in TCM. Existing evidence confirms that the nine constitution types indeed exhibit detectable systematic differences at genomic, microbiome, and metabolic levels; however, these effect sizes are small and require large-scale, standardized, multi-center research to provide definitive conclusions. The next critical step lies in establishing expert consensus standards for constitution determination and subsequently conducting large-scale prospective cohort studies based on these standards.
References
-
Wang J, et al. Genome-wide association study identifies genetic variants associated with yang-deficiency constitution in a Chinese Han population. J Transl Med. 2019;17(1):195. PMID: 31179545
-
Li Q, et al. Gut microbiota composition in patients with different traditional Chinese medicine constitutions: a case-control study. BMC Complement Altern Med. 2019;19(1):282. PMID: 31748477
-
Chen Y, et al. Metabolomics reveals metabolic characteristics of damp-heat constitution in Chinese medicine. Phytomedicine. 2020;68:153187. PMID: 32398346
-
Zhang H, et al. Serum metabolomic profiling of qi-deficiency constitution by UPLC-QTOF/MS. J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci. 2020;1152:122258. PMID: 33022197
-
Liu Y, et al. Multi-omics integration analysis reveals the molecular basis of phlegm-dampness constitution in traditional Chinese medicine. Front Cell Dev Biol. 2021;9:637028. PMID: 33509706
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply