Evidence level: C
缺了百分之几不重要,为什么缺才重要:同一缺失率换一个缺失机制,例数口径与混合模型口径的覆盖率可以一个稳如泰山、一个直接塌方。
正文
前一篇已经论证过:气功外气判读里每例的「遍数」天然会不齐,样本量申报必须带上「遍数完整性」字段。但那条论证的第一轮仿真有一个隐藏假设——缺失是均匀浮动的:缺哪一遍与被试是谁、测出来是什么都无关。统计学上这叫 MCAR(完全随机缺失)。真实判读现场很少这么干净:补读往往集中在状态波动或结果可疑的例上,也就是缺失概率取决于那个没测到的值本身——这叫 MNAR(非随机缺失)。中间还有一档 MAR(随机缺失):缺失概率只取决于已经观测到的信息,比如被试的基础状态。三档机制的区分是重复测量模型无偏性讨论的标准前提(PMID 32033617)。
关键在于:缺失机制的档位换一档,两种口径的命运就完全不同。 2025 年一项五法比较仿真给出了清晰的分界线(PMID 40247172):在 4-10% 的 MCAR 缺失下,所有方法都无偏、置信区间覆盖都在 95% 附近;而在高达 40% 的 MAR 脱落下,线性混合模型与协方差模式模型仍然无偏、覆盖仍接近 95%,而按例数分析的朴素口径(完全例分析、配对 t 检验)偏倚随脱落率上升、覆盖与把握度同步塌方。也就是说,在 MCAR 和 MAR 档,混合模型口径守得住,例数口径先失守。
但 MNAR 档是另一回事。Yang 等 2014 年的 Monte Carlo 仿真(PMID 24079928)表明:传统混合模型在 MAR 下确实表现良好,可一旦缺失与结果本身相关(MNAR),混合模型同样失守——而且没有一种方法能在所有缺失机制下都无偏,作者的实际建议是先问「数据为什么缺」,再做跨机制假设的敏感性分析。更硬的证据来自解析推导:Yang、Wang、Maxwell 2015 年直接从数学上证明(PMID 25098455),在「随机斜率依赖」的 MNAR 缺失下,典型线性混合模型的均值截距与斜率估计都有偏,且斜率估计会被系统性地拉向完成者那一侧——偏倚不是抽样的运气问题,是权重结构被 MNAR 破坏的必然结果。
对共振意识场这条研究线的直接含义是:判读现场「补读集中在可疑例」不是理论假设,而是 MNAR 的真实现场形态。如果遍数不齐数据的裁决只建立在均匀浮动假设的第一轮仿真上,那结论只能覆盖 MCAR 一档。所以这一题的裁决设计是:缺失机制三档 × 会话数两档 × 会话内相关两档的网格仿真,同批数据分别用例数口径与混合模型口径估计,记录各自置信区间覆盖率与偏差。裁决判据:若 MNAR 档混合模型覆盖率跌破 0.90 或绝对偏差超过 0.02,则遍数完整性申报必须加「缺失机制」字段,MNAR 场景一律改用敏感性分析框架申报;若 MNAR 档混合模型仍守住,则说明该场景的 MNAR 强度不足以击穿似然法的稳健性,单字段申报即可放行。
证据与局限
已验证:缺失机制三档的界定与重复测量模型无偏性条件(PMID 32033617);MCAR/MAR 档混合模型无偏且覆盖正常、例数口径在 MAR 档失守(PMID 40247172)。
部分验证:MNAR 档传统混合模型会失守、无万全方法、须敏感性分析(PMID 24079928,Monte Carlo 仿真层面)。
待验证:随机斜率依赖 MNAR 下混合模型的解析偏倚方向(PMID 25098455)能否推广到「遍数不齐 + 补读集中」这一具体场景;判读现场补读的真实 MNAR 强度从未被实测——这正是本篇裁决仿真要补的缺口。
相关阅读
L1 网络状态:本主题(缺失机制分层 × 口径覆盖率裁决)尚未进入 L1 对应网络;最近邻边 E-061「体验通道」当前状态为「L1→L2 依据具(工具就绪 + 跨情境失效风险已标注)|open」。本文为纯测量学方法学课题,证据等级限 C。
证据等级: C
参考文献: PMID 32033617, PMID 40247172, PMID 24079928, PMID 25098455
证据等级:A=有PubMed直接支撑,B=科学类比/间接证据,C=传统文化共识/初步探索
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Coverage Decision of Missingness Mechanism Stratification: When Do Case Count and Mixed Model Approaches Fail Under Uniform, Subject-Related, and Outcome-Related Missingness?
Evidence level: C
The proportion of missing data is secondary; why the data is missing is critical. Under identical missingness rates, different missing mechanisms can cause the coverage of sample-based and mixed-model approaches to remain stable or collapse entirely.
1. Introduction
In Yijing Studies (易学), the application of pattern and timing (理气) often relies on specific structural analogies (结构类比). However, when integrating these traditional frameworks with modern statistical models—such as those used in Feng Shui (风水) or Bazi (八字)—researchers frequently encounter missing data. This section examines how the mechanism of missingness, rather than just its quantity, determines whether the sample-based approach and the mixed-model approach maintain their intended coverage.
2. Stratified Coverage Decisions
The decision on which model to apply depends on the nature of the missingness:
| Missingness Type | Description | Impact on Coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Uniform Missingness | Data is missing randomly across all subjects. | Both sample-based and mixed-model approaches maintain stable coverage. |
| Subject-Related Missingness | Data is missing based on specific subject characteristics (e.g., birth year in Bazi). | Coverage remains robust for both approaches. |
| Outcome-Related Missingness | Data is missing based on the result itself (e.g., whether a Feng Shui prediction was accurate). | Critical failure: Sample-based coverage collapses; mixed-model coverage remains stable. |
3. Analysis of Mechanisms
3.1 Uniform Floating Gaps
When missingness is uniform, the distribution of the remaining data remains representative of the original population. Consequently, the sample-based approach (relying on observed cases) and the mixed-model approach (incorporating imputed or structural values) both retain their theoretical coverage.
3.2 Subject-Related Gaps
In contexts like Bazi, where certain pillars may be incomplete due to birth date constraints, the missingness is tied to the subject’s identity. As long as the missingness mechanism is independent of the outcome variable, both the sample-based and mixed-model frameworks continue to provide reliable coverage.
3.3 Outcome-Related Gaps
This scenario represents the most significant challenge in evidence-level (证据等级) analysis. If missingness is related to the outcome—such as when a Feng Shui form sha (形煞) is only recorded if it causes a negative event—the sample-based approach suffers from selection bias. In this case, the coverage of the sample-based method can collapse entirely, whereas the mixed-model approach, by accounting for the structural analogy of the missing data, maintains its coverage.
4. Conclusion
The stability of statistical inference in Chinese metaphysics research hinges on understanding the missingness mechanism. Uniform and subject-related gaps allow for flexible modeling, but outcome-related gaps necessitate the use of mixed models to preserve evidence integrity.
Body
The preceding article established that in the interpretation of external Qi Gong readings, the number of repetitions per case (“遍数”) is inherently uneven; therefore, sample size declarations must include a “repetition completeness” field. However, the first simulation round of that argument relied on a hidden assumption: missingness is uniformly floating—meaning the absence of a repetition is unrelated to which subject was tested or what value was measured. Statistically, this is known as MCAR (Missing Completely at Random). In real-world interpretation settings, such cleanliness is rare: supplementary readings often concentrate on cases exhibiting state fluctuations or suspicious results. In these instances, the probability of missingness depends on the unmeasured value itself—this is termed MNAR (Missing Not at Random). A middle category, MAR (Missing at Random), applies when missingness depends only on observed information, such as the subject’s baseline state. Distinguishing these three mechanisms is the standard prerequisite for discussing unbiasedness in repeated-measurement models (PMID 32033617).
The critical point is: shifting the missingness mechanism by one level fundamentally alters the fate of the two analytical approaches. A 2025 comparative simulation involving five methods established a clear boundary (PMID 40247172): under MCAR with 4–10% missingness, all methods remain unbiased and confidence interval coverage stays near 95%; however, under MAR with up to 40% dropout, linear mixed models and covariance pattern models remain unbiased with coverage close to 95%, whereas the naive count-based approach (complete-case analysis, paired t-tests) suffers increasing bias as dropout rises, with coverage and power collapsing simultaneously. Thus, in MCAR and MAR regimes, the mixed-model approach holds steady while the count-based approach fails first.
The MNAR regime is different. Yang et al.’s 2014 Monte Carlo simulation (PMID 24079928) showed that traditional mixed models perform well under MAR but also fail once missingness correlates with the outcome itself (MNAR)—and no single method remains unbiased across all missingness mechanisms. The authors’ practical recommendation is to first ask “why the data is missing,” followed by sensitivity analyses across different mechanisms. Stronger evidence comes from analytical derivation: Yang, Wang, and Maxwell (2015) proved mathematically (PMID 25098455) that under “random-slope-dependent” MNAR missingness, the mean intercept and slope estimates in typical linear mixed models are both biased, with slope estimates systematically pulled toward the side of completers. This bias is not due to sampling luck but is an inevitable consequence of MNAR destroying the weighting structure.
For the research line on resonance consciousness fields, this has direct implications: the observation that “supplementary readings concentrate on suspicious cases” is not a theoretical assumption but the true MNAR form of the interpretation setting. If decisions based on uneven repetition counts rely solely on the first simulation round assuming uniform missingness, conclusions can only cover the MCAR case. Therefore, this decision framework is designed as follows: a grid simulation varying three missingness mechanisms (MCAR, MAR, MNAR) × two session counts × two intra-session correlation levels, applying both count-based and mixed-model estimation to the same dataset, recording respective confidence interval coverage and bias. The decision criterion is: if under MNAR the mixed-model coverage drops below 0.90 or absolute bias exceeds 0.02, then the repetition completeness declaration must add a “missingness mechanism” field, and MNAR scenarios shall always be reported using the sensitivity analysis framework; if the mixed model remains robust under MNAR, it indicates that the MNAR intensity in this scenario is insufficient to break the likelihood-based robustness, allowing single-field declaration.
Glossary Note (non-promissory): Mixed-model approach refers to statistical methods that account for repeated measures and correlations within subjects, rather than treating each measurement as independent.
Evidence and Limitations
Verified: Definition of the three-tier mechanism gap and unbiasedness conditions for repeated-measurement models (PMID 32033617); MCAR/MAR tier mixed models remain unbiased with adequate coverage of normal cases, though the MAR tier fails under sample-size constraints (PMID 40247172).
Partially Verified: Traditional mixed models for the MNAR tier exhibit bias, lack a universal solution, and require sensitivity analysis (PMID 24079928, Monte Carlo simulation level).
Pending Verification: Whether the analytical bias direction of mixed models under MNAR with random slope dependence (PMID 25098455) generalizes to the specific scenario of “incomplete readings plus concentrated make-up readings”; the true MNAR intensity of on-site make-up readings has never been empirically measured—this represents the gap this article’s simulation aims to fill.
Related Reading
- Sample size declaration criteria when replicates are unbalanced: equivalence of count-based and mixed-model approaches
- Stepwise positioning of the minimum calibrated sample size
- Decoupling coverage and width for the reduced-scale criterion
- HRV session reliability and window length
- Research Pool 1: Resonance Consciousness Field
L1 Network Status: This topic (missingness mechanism layering × criterion coverage adjudication) has not yet entered the corresponding L1 network. The nearest-neighbor edge E-061 “Experience Channel” is currently in the state “L1→L2 basis established (tools ready + cross-context failure risk flagged) | open”. This article is a pure measurement methodology topic; evidence level is limited to C.
Evidence Level: C
References: PMID 32033617, PMID 40247172, PMID 24079928, PMID 25098455
Evidence level: A = direct PubMed support; B = scientific analogy / indirect evidence; C = traditional consensus / preliminary exploration.
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply