Evidence level: C
我们做过一份山体预筛 SOP:进山做 ELF 屏蔽实测之前,先按岩石电导率 σ 把候选山体分三档——值得先测、预算有余再测、别测。
分档这件事看着最不需要动脑,恰恰最容易出错。把这份 SOP 的三档抄在纸上数一遍界,会发现:它给了四个界,而三个档只需要两个界。
一、先数界
三档的规矩是:k = 3 个档,需要 k − 1 = 2 个界。
SOP 表里实际写的是:
| 档位 | σ 界 | 换算成衰减 A(dB) | 表里标的 A |
|---|---|---|---|
| A 档(优先测) | ≥ 1e-2 | 4.83 | ≥ 10 |
| B 档(条件性测) | 1e-3 – 1e-1 | 1.53 – 15.27 | 1 – 10 |
| C 档(不测) | ≤ 1e-4 | 0.48 | < 1 |
数一下 σ 轴上出现了几个界:1e-4、1e-3、1e-2、1e-1。四个。
而 A 列只给了两个标签:1 和 10。
四对二,这里就已经不对了。 多出来的两个界不是笔误,它们分别是 C/B 界的两种写法(1e-4 vs 1e-3)和 B/A 界的两种写法(1e-1 vs 1e-2)。
二、多出来的界造成了什么
把三档写成集合,直接摆在 σ 轴上:
A = [1e-2, ∞) B = [1e-3, 1e-1] C = (0, 1e-4]
两处毛病,各占一个数量级:
| 区间 | 宽度 | 毛病 |
|---|---|---|
| (1e-4, 1e-3) | 1 个数量级 | 没有任何一档收它 |
| [1e-2, 1e-1] | 1 个数量级 | A 档和 B 档同时收它 |
在 σ ∈ [1e-5, 1e0] 这 5 个数量级的范围内,”没人管”和”两个抢”加起来 2 个数量级,占 40%。
具体到一个样本上是什么后果:
- 某座山的岩样测出 σ = 5e-4(A ≈ 1.08 dB)。翻遍 SOP 三档,没有一档告诉你该怎么办。它落在空隙里。
- 另一座山 σ = 5e-2(A ≈ 10.8 dB)。A 档说”第一批测”,B 档说”预算有余再上”——这两句建议差一整个决策级,而两个档都说自己是它的归属。
执行的人只能自己拍板。在这一段上,SOP 不是判据,是一道选择题。
三、还有第二块死区:一条规则把自己的档判没了
SOP 里另有一条容差规则:
预筛判档时采用”下限原则”…… 任何档位判定的”最低期望 A(dB) 都应 > 3 dB,否则降档”。
这条本身很合理——衰减太小就测不出东西,别浪费仪器时间。但把它套到 B 档下缘,会撞墙:
B 档下缘 σ = 1e-3 ⇒ A = 1.53 dB < 3 dB ⇒ 必须降档
降档目标 = C 档,而 C 档只收 A < 1 dB(σ < 4.29e-4)
⇒ σ ∈ [4.29e-4, 1e-3) 留 B 不合格,进 C 也不合格
这是一块”规则要求你降档、但降档后没有档可落”的地。
把这条规则的影响算全:A = 3 dB 对应 σ = 3.86e-3,而 C 档上界是 4.29e-4。整块死区是 σ ∈ [4.29e-4, 3.86e-3],宽 9.00 倍,对应 A ∈ [1.00, 3.00] dB。
而这一块和第二节的空隙在 [4.29e-4, 1e-3) 上重叠——这一段既”没档”,又”降档没落点”,是双重死区。
四、四对二这件事本来可以一眼看出来
这里有个很朴素的检查,值得写进规程:
判据量对参数单调 ⇒ 分成 k 档只需 k−1 个界。
若同一张表并列两个尺度(σ 和 A),两个尺度上的界必须一一对应。
界数不等,必有多余界;多余界必然与某个档的定义相矛盾。
这份 SOP 就是最干净的反例:3 档、4 个 σ 界、2 个 A 标签。任何一个”数一遍”的动作都能抓到。
而我们过去几轮在池④ 反复抓的,全是更细的东西——判据维度选错、量词过宽、带宽不够、阈值位置不对。这些都比”界数对不对”靠后。 界数错了,后面所有讨论都是在一个不存在的东西上做精细加工。
五、那个”42.8 倍”其实复算不出来
上一轮留了个待办:按新立的档位密度定理(R32)复查这份 SOP,理由是”相邻档界之比 r = 42.8 倍,比另一个课题宽松得多,值得算一次看是否过关”。
这轮算了,两件事:
第一,42.8 复现不出来。 按表内 σ 界(1e-4 与 1e-2)算,r = 100;按 A 列的 1 dB 与 10 dB 反解 σ 界再算,r 还是 100。两种口径都是 100,不是 42.8。(48.3 是 A = 48.293·√σ 里的那个系数,可能是抄串了。)如实记:这一项来历未定。
第二,更根本的是——R32 的形式是”设相邻档界之比 r”,它假定档界构成一个有序划分。这份 SOP 的档界不构成划分(第一节的空隙与重叠),第 1 和第 2 个界之间根本不存在”相邻”关系,中间还隔着 B 档的两个界。
⇒ r 无定义。
正确答复不是"过关"或"不过关",而是"R32 不适用,
先修档界使其构成划分,再谈 q<r"。
这本身是 R32 的一次负面检验,而且是好事:它告诉我们 R32 有前提。上一轮我们写的注意事项是”凡见分档体系,先算 r 与 q”——这句要补半句:先查它是不是划分,再算 r 与 q。
六、顺手抓到一条引文的区间错配
SOP 的参考支持文献里有一条:
PMID 20000094 — 建筑地磁屏蔽 1.2–2.0× 衰减;用于交叉佐证山体/建筑 σ 量级差。
回查:这条文献真实、作者正确、数值 1.2–2.0× 正确。 它是 Chernykh 等 2010 年发表于 Gigiena i Sanitariia 的《多层住宅内地磁场的屏蔽》,测的是多层住宅内天然地磁场(直流、准静态)降低 1.2 到 2.0 倍。
问题在别的方向:
| 项 | 文献测的 | SOP 要支撑的 |
|---|---|---|
| 场的类型 | 天然地磁场,≈ 0 Hz(直流) | 7.83 Hz(舒曼基频) |
| 屏蔽机制 | 高磁导率材料的静磁分流,与频率无关 | 导体内的趋肤效应,δ ∝ 1/√(σf) |
| 厚度尺度 | 建筑构件(厘米到米) | 山体(公里) |
直流屏蔽由磁导率主导、与频率无关;ELF 屏蔽由电导率×频率主导、随频率开方变化。同一份材料上这两个数不能互相换算——除非磁导率和电导率同时已知,而那恰是这份 SOP 要求进现场去测的量。
处置建议:这条不要删(它作为”材料屏蔽现象确实存在”的存在性证据仍然有效),但要改标成「直流地磁屏蔽的建筑实测,不可用于校核 ELF 衰减量级」。
这是引文问题的第四种形态:号对、作者对、数值对、但物理区间不对。 前三种(号不存在、号存在但错指、号对但作者错)我们之前都抓过;这一种最难,因为所有”查号”的动作都会放行。
七、证据与局限
证据等级 C。 这是工程公式层面的解析审计,没有一次实测。
三条局限,不得省略:
- 公式只在一个口径成立。
A = 48.293·√σ是 1 km 厚度、7.83 Hz、μr=1 的特定值。换厚度或换介质磁导率,系数会变。但”3 档给了 4 个界”是纯计数矛盾,与系数无关——核心结论不受影响。 - “该改哪一档”是取舍,不是判决。 两条路各有代价:保留 1 dB / 10 dB 这两个好记的数,就得把 σ 界改成 4.29e-4 / 4.29e-2(σ 不再是整十次幂,现场简易 EC 计的阈值也要跟着改);保留 σ 的整十次幂,就得放弃 1 dB / 10 dB,把整个三档的语义重写。这是工程取舍,要人定。
- 第六节的引文判定只到”区间错配”,不是”假引文”。 不得据此扩大到”这份 SOP 的引文都不可信”。
不许做的三条推论:
- 不许读成”靠山预筛没用”。要读成”预筛的档界要重画“。
- 不许读成”σ 不重要”。恰恰相反——正因 σ 是主参数,界画错了代价才大。
- 不许把”r 无定义”写成”r 很大所以宽松”。这是两件完全不同的事。
本文是 draft,未标 accepted,未进 779,未发布。 配套审计卡:08-ops/experiments/pool4-tier-boundary-counting-gap-overlap-audit.md(P4-AUDIT-021)。修订建议 D42 六条全在建议层,等 JOE 批。
免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。
Three tiers assigned to four realms: one order of magnitude ignored, another contested by two tiers.
Evidence level: C
We developed a mountain pre-screening SOP: before entering the field to conduct ELF shielding measurements, candidates are classified into three tiers based on rock conductivity σ—those to measure immediately, those to measure if budget permits, and those not to measure.
This tiering appears the least cognitively demanding step, yet it is most prone to error. Counting the boundaries in this SOP reveals: it defines four boundaries, yet three tiers require only two.
I. Counting the Boundaries
The rule for three tiers is: k = 3 tiers require k − 1 = 2 boundaries.
The SOP table actually specifies:
| Tier | σ Boundary | Converted Attenuation A(dB) | Table Label A |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tier A (Priority Measure) | ≥ 1e-2 | 4.83 | ≥ 10 |
| Tier B (Conditional Measure) | 1e-3 – 1e-1 | 1.53 – 15.27 | 1 – 10 |
| Tier C (Do Not Measure) | ≤ 1e-4 | 0.48 | < 1 |
Counting the boundaries on the σ axis: 1e-4, 1e-3, 1e-2, 1e-1. Four.
Column A provides only two labels: 1 and 10.
Four versus two—this is already inconsistent. The extra two boundaries are not typos; they represent alternative expressions of the C/B boundaries (1e-4 vs 1e-3) and the B/A boundaries (1e-1 vs 1e-2).
II. Consequences of the Extra Boundaries
Expressing the three tiers as sets on the σ axis:
A = [1e-2, ∞) B = [1e-3, 1e-1] C = (0, 1e-4]
Two errors, each spanning one order of magnitude:
| Interval | Width | Error |
|---|---|---|
| (1e-4, 1e-3) | 1 order of magnitude | No tier covers it |
| [1e-2, 1e-1] | 1 order of magnitude | Tiers A and B both claim it |
Within the σ ∈ [1e-5, 1e0] range spanning five orders of magnitude, the “uncovered” and “contested” regions together cover 2 orders of magnitude (40%).
Consequences for specific samples:
- A mountain sample yields σ = 5e-4 (A ≈ 1.08 dB). Checking all three tiers, no tier specifies action. It falls in the gap.
- Another mountain yields σ = 5e-2 (A ≈ 10.8 dB). Tier A says “measure first,” Tier B says “measure if budget allows”—these recommendations differ by one decision level, yet both tiers claim ownership.
Practitioners must decide independently. In this region, the SOP is not a criterion but a choice question.
III. A Second Dead Zone: A Rule Invalidates Its Own Tier
The SOP includes another tolerance rule:
When pre-screening assigns tiers, apply the “lower-bound principle”: the minimum expected A(dB) for any tier must exceed 3 dB; otherwise, downgrade.
This is reasonable—insufficient attenuation yields no measurable signal, wasting instrument time. Applying it to Tier B’s lower bound creates a conflict:
Tier B lower bound σ = 1e-3 ⇒ A = 1.53 dB < 3 dB ⇒ must downgrade
Downgrade target = Tier C, but Tier C only accepts A < 1 dB (σ < 4.29e-4)
⇒ σ ∈ [4.29e-4, 1e-3) leaves Tier B ineligible, yet entering Tier C is also ineligible
This is a “rule requires downgrade, but no tier accepts the downgraded value” zone.
Calculating the full impact: A = 3 dB corresponds to σ = 3.86e-3, while Tier C’s upper bound is 4.29e-4. The dead zone spans σ ∈ [4.29e-4, 3.86e-3], width 9.00×, corresponding to A ∈ [1.00, 3.00] dB.
This dead zone overlaps with the gap from Section II on [4.29e-4, 1e-3)—this segment is both “uncovered” and “downgraded with no landing spot,” creating a double dead zone.
IV. The Four-versus-Two Issue Should Be Obvious
A simple check deserves inclusion in protocols:
If the criterion monotonically depends on the parameter, dividing into k tiers requires only k−1 boundaries.
If a single table uses two scales (σ and A), boundaries on both scales must correspond one-to-one.
Mismatched boundary counts imply extra boundaries; extra boundaries necessarily contradict tier definitions.
This SOP provides the cleanest counterexample: 3 tiers, 4 σ boundaries, 2 A labels. Any “count once” action immediately identifies this.
Our previous rounds in Pool 4 repeatedly identified finer issues—misselected criterion dimensions, overly broad quantifiers, insufficient bandwidth, misplaced thresholds. These are secondary to “boundary count mismatch.” If the boundary count is wrong, subsequent discussions refine a non-existent structure.
V. The “42.8×” Factor Cannot Be Recalculated
A pending task from the previous round: re-evaluate this SOP using the newly established tier density theorem (R32), because “the ratio of adjacent tier boundaries r = 42.8× is much looser than another project, worth checking.”
This calculation yielded two results:
First, 42.8 cannot be reproduced. Using the table’s σ boundaries (1e-4 and 1e-2), r = 100; solving σ boundaries from A column values (1 dB and 10 dB) still yields r = 100. Both methods give 100, not 42.8 (48.3 is the coefficient A = 48.293·√σ, possibly mis-copied). Record accurately: this item’s origin is undetermined.
Second, more fundamentally— R32’s form “set adjacent tier boundary ratio r” assumes boundaries form an ordered partition. This SOP’s boundaries do not form a partition (gaps and overlaps from Section I); between the 1st and 2nd boundaries no “adjacent” relationship exists, separated by Tier B’s two boundaries.
⇒ r is undefined.
The correct answer is not "passed" or "failed," but "R32 does not apply;
first repair the tier boundaries to form a partition, then evaluate q < r."
This constitutes a negative validation of R32, which is beneficial: it reveals R32’s prerequisite. Our previous note “for any tiering system, first compute r and q” must add: first verify it forms a partition, then compute r and q.
VI. An Inconsistent Citation Interval Caught Incidentally
Among the SOP’s reference literature:
PMID 20000094 — Building geomagnetic shielding 1.2–2.0× attenuation; used for cross-validation of mountain/building σ scale differences.
Verification: this citation is authentic, authorship correct, numerical range 1.2–2.0× accurate. It refers to Chernykh et al. 2010 in Gigiena i Sanitariia, “Shielding of the Earth’s Magnetic Field in Multi-Story Residential Buildings,” measuring reduction of natural geomagnetic fields (DC, quasi-static) by 1.2 to 2.0 times within multi-story buildings.
The discrepancy lies elsewhere:
| Item | Literature Measured | SOP Requires |
|---|---|---|
| Field type | Natural geomagnetic field, ≈ 0 Hz (DC) | 7.83 Hz (Schumann fundamental) |
| Shielding mechanism | Static magnetic shunting via high-permeability materials, frequency-independent | Skin effect in conductors, δ ∝ 1/√(σf) |
| Thickness scale | Building components (centimeters to meters) | Mountains (kilometers) |
DC shielding is dominated by permeability, frequency-independent; ELF shielding is dominated by conductivity×frequency, scaling with square root of frequency. These two numbers cannot be interconverted for the same material—unless both permeability and conductivity are known, which is precisely what this SOP requires field measurement.
Recommendation: Do not delete this citation (it remains valid existence evidence that “material shielding phenomena do occur”), but relabel it as “Building geomagnetic shielding measurement cannot calibrate ELF attenuation scale.”
This represents the fourth citation error type: number correct, author correct, numerical range correct, but physical interval mismatched. We previously identified three types (number missing, number present but misreferenced, number correct but author wrong); this fourth type is most difficult because all “number lookup” actions accept it.
VII. Evidence and Limitations
Evidence Level C. This is analytical audit at the engineering formula level, without field measurement.
Three limitations, none to be omitted:
- The formula holds only for one scale.
A = 48.293·√σapplies specifically to 1 km thickness, 7.83 Hz, μr=1. Changing thickness or medium permeability alters the coefficient. However, “3 tiers define 4 boundaries” is a pure counting contradiction, independent of the coefficient—the core conclusion remains unaffected. - “Which tier to adjust” is a trade-off, not a verdict. Both paths incur costs: retaining the memorable 1 dB / 10 dB requires changing σ boundaries to 4.29e-4 / 4.29e-2 (σ is no longer powers of ten, requiring field portable EC meter threshold adjustments); retaining σ’s powers of ten requires abandoning 1 dB / 10 dB and rewriting the entire three-tier semantics. This is an engineering trade-off requiring human judgment.
- Section VI’s citation judgment stops at “interval mismatch,” not “false citation.” Do not extrapolate to “all citations in this SOP are unreliable.”
Three forbidden inferences:
- Do not read “mountain pre-screening is useless.” Read instead “pre-screening tier boundaries must be redrawn.”
- Do not read “σ is unimportant.” On the contrary—because σ is the primary parameter, boundary errors incur greater cost.
- Do not write “r undefined” as “r very large, hence loose.” These are fundamentally different statements.
This document is draft, not marked accepted, not entered into 779, not published. Supporting audit card: 08-ops/experiments/pool4-tier-boundary-counting-gap-overlap-audit.md (P4-AUDIT-021). Revision recommendations D42 all at suggestion level, pending JOE approval.
Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.
Leave a Reply