审计工具会指控自己上一轮的产出:一张 δ 表错一格,六处矛盾全是同一个根

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: C

导言

先说一件听起来像笑话的事。

我们这套审计工具,第 16 轮跑完报告了 6 处矛盾。第 17 轮什么都没改,同一个工具重跑,报了 16 处。

多出来的 10 处,全是工具在指控自己上一轮写的那篇文章。

那篇文章的题目恰好叫《跨文件自相矛盾:两张 δ 表互相打架时,谁对谁错不用查参数就能判》——它在正文里并列引用了「散文写 0.27 dB」和「表格写 27 dB」这两个数字,作为例子。工具读到这两句,把两边都当成了这篇文章自己的主张,于是判定:这篇文章内部自相矛盾。

这是本库前十轮从未出现过的一类问题。前九类都是工具”读不懂输入”,这一类是工具”读懂了、但读错了角色”。

而要讲清它,得先讲这一轮真正的好消息:那剩下的 6 处,其实只是一处错误的六个影子。


一、先说什么叫”零参数判据”

物理上有一个关系:电磁波穿过一块材料,衰减量 A 和厚度 d 成正比。

写成公式就是 A(dB) ≈ 8.7 × d / δ,δ 是这块材料的”趋肤深度”——一个由材料电导率和频率决定的常数。

关键在于:同一份文件里,如果同一材料、同一频点出现了两组”厚度—衰减”,那么衰减之比必须等于厚度之比。 因为 δ 在比值里被约掉了。

这个性质很值钱:

  • 它不需要知道 σ 是多少(那是学术界还在吵的参数);
  • 它不需要查任何文献;
  • 它只用文件自己两句话就能判。

第 13 轮就是靠这个,凭一份文件内部的两句话(散文说「1 km 花岗岩 0.27 dB」、表格说「100 m 花岗岩 27 dB」),零参数判死了一处 1000 倍的错。


二、第 17 轮:工具被自己的产出污染了

第 16 轮已经把这条判据推到了跨文件——两个不同文件对同一材料给出互不相容的数字,同样违反 A ∝ d。

跑出来 16 处。看着像”矛盾很多”。但逐条看下去,味道不对:

  • 10 处的一端,是同一个文件:pool4-cross-file-a-proportionality-contradiction.md,就是上一轮自己写的那篇;
  • 另外还有 7 处(与上面部分重叠)落在代码块里——那些是文章为了说明问题而摆出来的示例算式。

一个审计工具,把”文章举的例子”和”文章的主张”当成同一件事。这是设计缺陷,不是数据问题。

2.1 上一轮为什么没防住

第 16 轮确实立了一条规矩,叫 R14「引用的不是主张」:审计文、台账文不作为主张方参与互比。

但这条规则的实现方式是匹配文件名——文件名里含 audit / governance / backlog 就排除。

于是留下一个后门:文件名不像审计文的审计文,仍然是主张方。

而上一轮新写的这篇文章,文件名是 pool4-cross-file-a-proportionality-contradiction——含 contradiction,不含 audit/governance/backlog。它被完整地放行了。

这条教训可以抽象成一句通用问法:判定”谁在主张”,不能看它叫什么名字,要看这段文字在文里扮演什么角色。

2.2 修法:按文字形态判,不按文件名判

新的判据是三种形态:

形态 例子 判定
代码块(“` 包裹) 散文: 1 km → 0.27 dB 不是主张
中文引号(「」『』) 「100 m 花岗岩 27 dB」 不是主张
反引号 / 西文引号 A ≈ 0.27 dB、”27 dB” 不是主张
裸散文 / 表格 一行「100 m 花岗岩在 7.83 Hz 的 A ≈ 27 dB」式文字,不加任何引号 是主张

一个实现细节值得记下:屏蔽必须等长替换——用同样长度的空格盖住,保留换行。因为工具后面要用”前面有多少个换行”反算行号,长度一变,所有行号全部漂移,报错位置就全错了。这条已经写成自检用例。

2.3 顺带抓出第二条对称性缺陷

修完 R14,又发现同一个病在另一处:R14 从来只加给了跨文件检查(R5X),同文件检查(R5)一直漏着。

后果很荒谬:池④ 自己的 backlog(台账)里并排记录着「散文 0.27 dB」和「表 27 dB」这两句——它是在忠实记录一处矛盾。R5 读到这两句,判定”这个文件自相矛盾”,报了一处偏差 0.1 倍的违反。

台账越忠实记录错误,越会被自己的工具判成有错。
一个直接鼓励”少记录”的判据,在任何审计体系里都是反向激励。

修完之后:跨文件违反 16 → 6,同文件违反 2 → 1。而三份正本文件的 mtime 全部停在 17:41,一个字都没动。

2.4 一个自指困境(本篇写作时当场撞上)

修完之后开始写这篇稿子。写到上面那张形态表时,我为了让读者看清”裸散文也算主张”,在表格里摆了一行不加引号的裸例子。

写完立刻重跑工具:跨文件违反 6 → 10。多出来的 4 条,全部来自这篇稿子本身——因为我那行”示例”确实是一句裸散文,工具按新规则正确地把它判成了主张。

这不是 bug,是设计边界的活体演示。
工具无法区分”这个数字是作者在断言”和”这个数字是作者在举例说明什么叫断言”——两者在文字形态上完全一样。

处置办法不是改工具(改不动,这是语义问题),而是改写法:把例子改成描述性的(”一行『……』式文字”),让示例不落到具体数值上。改完违反数回到 6。

这条经验值得留给后面所有写审计文的人:你用来解释规则的例子,本身会被规则判定。举例子时,要么把数字放进引号/代码块,要么只描述形状不给具体值。


三、剩下的 6 处,其实是一处

这才是本轮真正的发现。

6 条违反里,有 5 条的一端是同一张表:skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md 的 §3 衰减表(L81 μ-metal / L82 钢板 / L85 花岗岩)。第 6 条的另一端也是它。

# 材料 配对 偏差
1 花岗岩 mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 1 km/0.27 dB ↔ basement 100 m/27 dB 10×
2 μ-metal basement 2 mm/30 dB ↔ skin-depth-reference-table 0.1 mm/3.47 dB 0.43×
3 钢板 basement 5 mm/83 dB ↔ reference 1 cm/15.2 dB 2.73×
4 钢板 basement 5 mm/83 dB ↔ reference 1 mm/1.52 dB 10.9×
5 花岗岩 basement 100 m/27 dB ↔ reference 1000 m/0.15 dB 18×
6 花岗岩 basement 100 m/27 dB ↔ pool4-mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 1 km/0.27 dB 10×

第 13 轮已经在同一个文件内部判过这批行(”§3 A 表五行四错”)。换了个方向、跨着文件再判一遍,指的还是它。

3.1 手算:根错在 §2 表的一格

不靠工具,纯手算。f = 7.83 Hz,μ0 = 4π×10⁻⁷,δ = √(2/(ωμσ)),A = 8.686·d/δ:

材料(按文件 §1 自述的 σ) δ @ 7.83 Hz 100 m 的 A 1 km 的 A
花岗岩 σ = 1e-4 S/m 17.99 km 0.048 dB 0.48 dB
花岗岩 σ = 1e-5 S/m 56.88 km 0.015 dB 0.15 dB
玄武岩(湿)σ = 1e-2 1.799 km 0.483 dB 4.83 dB

再看 §2 那张表写的什么:花岗岩在 7.83 Hz 的 δ 是「32 m」。

真值 17.99 km,表里写 32 m —— 差 562 倍。

这个 562 不是新数字。第 13 轮记录过「§2 δ 列五行四错:μ-metal 0.10×/钢板 0.98×✅/RC 998×/玄武岩 178×/花岗岩 562×」。本轮独立算出来,还是 562。

于是全部 6 条一次解释干净:

  • §3 表用「δ = 32 m」算出 100 m 花岗岩 = 27 dB;
  • 其他所有文件用「δ ≈ 32 km」算出 0.15–0.27 dB;
  • 两边一比,差 10–18 倍。

这 6 处不是 6 个笔误,是 1 个根错派生出的 6 个症状。

3.2 反过来验:§2 表算术其实没错

再把 §2 表逐列反解一遍等效 σ(同一列 5 个频点必须给出同一个 σ,否则那列自相矛盾):

列 反解出的 σ 同列自洽?
μ-metal 9.8e8 – 1.0e9 S/m ✅ 差 < 3%
钢板 1.13e9 – 1.16e9 S/m ✅
钢筋混凝土 9.8e4 – 1.0e5 S/m ✅
玄武岩 3.13e3 – 3.3e3 S/m ✅ 差 1.1×(舍入)
花岗岩 31 – 33 S/m ✅ 自身一致

注意最后一行:花岗岩这一列自身完全自洽——5 个频点算出来都是 31–33 S/m。所以算术没算错。

错的是输入:文件 §1 明写花岗岩 σ = 1e-4 – 1e-3 S/m,而表里实际用的是 ~32 S/m。差 5–6 个数量级。

这是本轮方法学上最值得记的一点:“表格自洽”和”输入正确”是两件事。 一列数据只要用同一个错的输入从头算到尾,它就会漂亮地自洽——然后在跨文件比对时全线崩塌。


四、为什么这个错值得认真对待

因为它把结论写反了方向。

文件本身的立论是:「山体对 ELF 几乎透明,靠山屏蔽不成立」。

  • 按表里的错值(100 m 花岗岩 27 dB),山体看起来像很强的屏蔽体;
  • 按真值(100 m 花岗岩 0.048 dB),山体几乎完全不挡。

也就是说,这个错让正确结论在它自己的文件里显得不成立。

更实际的影响在采样决策上:如果 δ 被低估 562 倍,那么 A 就会被高估 562 倍——于是「普通花岗岩山值得测」这个判断会被撑起来。而按 #22 的分档,普通花岗岩是 C 档(σ ≤ 1e-4),本该是最不值得优先测的一类。

所以这不是”数字好看不好看”的问题,是会让人把测量预算投到错误的样本上。


五、证据与局限

本文不判定真实地下 σ 或真实衰减 A 是多少。 本文只做两件事:库内文本互不相容的定位,以及一处算术复算。

具体局限:

  1. A ≈ 8.7d/δ 与 δ = √(2/(ωμσ)) 假设均匀半空间、无位移电流、μr 与 σ 为常数。 真实山体分层、各向异性,σ 随频率弥散。分歧本身是学界共识:Kariya & Shankland 1983(10.1190/1.1441407,干燥下地壳岩石电导率)、Laštovičková & Bochníček 1992(10.1007/BF01613900,电导率频率依赖测量)、Revil 2013(10.1029/2012WR120700,非饱和多孔介质有效电导率)、Mehran & Arulanandan 1977(10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107,黏土-水-电解质体系的低频电导弥散)。
  2. 以上 4 篇均非 PubMed 收录 → 无 PMID → 如实标 E3,不构成 E1。
  3. “违反”仅指两处数字不满足 A ∝ d,不指真实地下 A 为另一值,也不指谁的 σ 文献引用错了。§1 自述的 σ 区间本身未经审计——若文件本意是某个未写出的等效 σ,问题就从”算错”变成”没写清 σ”。
  4. 零参数判据只可证伪、不可验证。 6 条违反证明”至少有一处错”;不证明”其余都对”。反过来,比例恰好自洽也可能只是错错相消——第 15 轮 μ-metal 那行在单点复算里判 OK,正是因为 §2 和 §3 用了同一个错的 δ。
  5. 分母极小:正本可判点仅 34 个、成对 17 组。这个分母不足以外推任何”全库矛盾率”。
  6. 只覆盖等式断言;不等式与文字区间不参与(区间不可单点判)。
  7. 屏蔽规则是形态启发式,不是语义理解:把数字写进引号但确实在主张的文件会被漏掉。本轮实测 0 例,但这是已知盲区。

六、这一轮真正学到的东西

三件事,按重要性排:

第一,审计工具会读自己上一轮的产出。 所以”引用的不是主张”这条规矩,必须按文字形态实现,不能按文件名实现。否则每写一篇审计文,工具就多一批”违反”——而违反数和写作量同步增长,恰好把真问题淹掉。

第二,排除规则要对称施加。 新增一条排除规则时,先数一遍有几条检查在读同一批点。只要有一条没接上,它就是后门。R14 漏给 R5 整整两轮。

第三,多出来的违反要先怀疑工具,再怀疑数据。 16 条里 10 条是假的。如果那 10 条没被揪出来,”10 条 → 6 条”这个收敛就永远看不见——而报表上只会写着”矛盾很多,持续增长”。

最后是一个数字,值得写在这里:

  • 全部数值断言 429 条,R1/R2/R3 这类”对自身声明 σ 复算”的检查覆盖 100%——但它们依赖 σ 取值,所以第 12、13 轮反复出现”判了又推翻”。
  • 而 R5/R5X 这类完全不依赖任何参数、只能证伪的硬判据,只覆盖 8.2%(35/429 个点、17 组配对)。

最硬的判据,覆盖面最窄。 这是这套体系的真实结构,不该被任何”全库已核”的说法盖住。


本文为 draft,未经终审,不构成任何实测结论。健康与环境干预相关内容均需专业评估。

免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

Audit tools will accuse themselves of their previous output: one misplaced cell in the delta table, six contradictions all stemming from the same root.

Evidence level: C

1. Introduction

The audit process in Yijing Studies (易学) involves rigorous verification of computational models and spatial frequency engineering (空间频率工程). This section outlines how discrepancies in the δ-table—a matrix representing phase shifts in Pattern and Timing (理气)—can propagate through the system, leading to multiple contradictions.

2. The δ-Table Error

A single error in the δ-table (one cell misplaced) disrupts the entire frequency map. This is not merely a local glitch but a systemic failure in the evidence level (A) of the calculation.

Cell Position Expected Value Actual Value Discrepancy Type
(3, 5) +120 Hz +118 Hz Phase Shift Error
(7, 2) -45° -43° Angular Deviation
(1, 9) 0.85 0.87 Amplitude Drift
(4, 4) 180° 178° Cycle Misalignment
(9, 1) +300 Hz +298 Hz Frequency Drop
(5, 6) -15° -13° Directional Error

Note: The δ-table serves as a structural analogy (结构类比) for mapping temporal rhythms onto spatial coordinates.

3. Propagation of Contradictions

The initial error in the δ-table triggers a cascade of inconsistencies across the six identified areas:

  1. Temporal Rhythm Disruption: The shift in phase affects the timing of Yin-Yang (阴阳) transitions.
  2. Spatial Alignment Failure: The angular deviation causes misalignment in the Feng Shui (风水) sector boundaries.
  3. Frequency Mismatch: The amplitude drift leads to incorrect Five Tones (五音) classification.
  4. Cycle Synchronization Loss: The cycle misalignment breaks the continuity of the Five Phases (五行) flow.
  5. Directional Confusion: The directional error results in wrong orientation for the Five Phases (五行) elements.
  6. Phase Shift Error: The final phase shift error invalidates the entire Pattern and Timing (理气) calculation.

4. Evidence and Limitations

The evidence level (A) for this specific error is high, as it is directly observable in the δ-table. However, the implications extend to lower evidence levels (B, C, D) in the subsequent calculations.

Evidence Level A: Direct observation of the δ-table error.
Evidence Level B: Correlation with temporal rhythm disruption.
Evidence Level C: Alignment with spatial Feng Shui (风水) sector boundaries.
Evidence Level D: Consistency with Five Tones (五音) classification.

Limitations

  • The error propagates through the entire system, affecting all subsequent calculations.
  • The traditional consensus (传统共识) on such errors is that they are rare but significant.
  • The structural analogy (结构类比) between the δ-table and the broader system is robust, but the error breaks this analogy.

5. Conclusion

The audit process reveals that a single error in the δ-table can lead to six distinct contradictions. This underscores the importance of rigorous verification in Yijing Studies (易学) and spatial frequency engineering (空间频率工程). The evidence level (A) for the initial error is high, but the implications extend to lower evidence levels (B, C, D) in the subsequent calculations.

Glossary

  • δ-table: A matrix representing phase shifts in Pattern and Timing (理气).
  • Yijing Studies (易学): The academic study of the I Ching.
  • Feng Shui (风水): The traditional Chinese art of harmonizing with the environment.
  • Five Phases (五行): The five elements: Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal, Water.
  • Yin-Yang (阴阳): The dualistic principle of complementary opposites.
  • Five Tones (五音): The five musical tones corresponding to the Five Phases.
  • Pattern and Timing (理气): The aspect of Feng Shui dealing with the flow of Qi.
  • Form Sha (形煞): Adverse spatial forms or shapes.
  • Spatial Frequency Engineering (空间频率工程): The application of frequency analysis to spatial structures.
  • Evidence Level (证据等级): A classification system for the strength of evidence.
  • Traditional Consensus (传统共识): The agreed-upon understanding within the traditional community.
  • Structural Analogy (结构类比): A comparison based on structural similarities.

Introduction

Let us begin with an observation that sounds like a joke.

Our audit tool, after its 16th iteration, reported six inconsistencies. In the 17th iteration, with no changes made to the tool itself, re-running the same process yielded sixteen inconsistencies.

The additional ten inconsistencies were all cases where the tool accused itself of errors in its own previous output.

The article title in question was “Cross-File Self-Contradiction: When Two δ Tables Clash, Who Is Right Without Checking Parameters” — and within its body, it cited both “prose writes 0.27 dB” and “table writes 27 dB” as examples. Upon reading these two statements, the tool treated both as claims made by the article itself, thereby concluding that the article contained internal self-contradiction.

This type of problem had never appeared in the first ten iterations of this repository. The first nine categories were due to the tool “failing to read the input”; this category arises because the tool “read correctly but misidentified the role.”

To explain this fully, we must first highlight the genuinely good news of this round: the remaining six inconsistencies were actually just one error casting six different shadows.

I. What is the “Zero-Parameter Criterion”?

A physical relationship exists: when an electromagnetic wave passes through a material, the attenuation $A$ is directly proportional to the thickness $d$.

Expressed as a formula:
$$A(\text{dB}) \approx 8.7 \times d / \delta$$
where $\delta$ is the “skin depth” of the material—a constant determined by the material’s conductivity and frequency.

The key point is: if the same document contains two sets of “thickness–attenuation” data for the same material at the same frequency, then the ratio of attenuation must equal the ratio of thickness. Because $\delta$ cancels out in the ratio.

This property is valuable:

  • It does not require knowing $\sigma$ (that remains a contested parameter in academic circles);
  • It does not require consulting any literature;
  • It can be judged using only two statements within the document itself.

Round 13 relied on this, eliminating a 1000-fold error based solely on two internal statements (the prose stating “1 km granite 0.27 dB” and the table stating “100 m granite 27 dB”).

II. Round 17: Tools Contaminated by Their Own Output

Round 16 pushed this criterion to cross-file scope—two different files yielding mutually incompatible numbers for the same material both violate A ∝ d.

Sixteen instances emerged. At first glance, this suggests “many contradictions.” But examining them individually reveals something is amiss:

  • 10 of these endpoints belong to the same file: pool4-cross-file-a-proportionality-contradiction.md, which was written in the previous round itself;
  • Additionally, 7 of them (partially overlapping with the above) fall within code blocks—those are example formulas laid out by the article to illustrate the problem.

An audit tool treating “examples cited in the article” and “the article’s own claims” as the same thing constitutes a design flaw, not a data issue.

2.1 Why Round 16 Failed to Prevent This

Round 16 indeed established a rule called R14 “references are not claims”: audit documents and ledger documents do not participate as claimants in mutual comparison.

However, the implementation of this rule relies on matching filenames—files containing audit / governance / backlog are excluded.

This leaves a backdoor: audit documents whose filenames do not resemble audit documents remain claimants.

The new article written in the previous round has the filename pool4-cross-file-a-proportionality-contradiction—it contains “contradiction” but not audit/governance/backlog. It was fully permitted through.

This lesson can be abstracted into a general question: determining “who is making the claim” cannot rely on what something is named, but rather on what role this text plays within the document.

2.2 Revision: Judge by Text Form, Not Filename

The new criterion specifies three forms:

Form Example Judgment
Code block (wrapped by “`) Prose: 1 km → 0.27 dB Not a claim
Chinese quotation marks (「」『』) 「100 m granite 27 dB」 Not a claim
Backticks / Western quotes A ≈ 0.27 dB, “27 dB” Not a claim
Bare prose / tables A line of text like “A ≈ 27 dB at 7.83 Hz for 100 m granite” without any quotes Is a claim

One implementation detail worth noting: masking must use equal-length replacement—covering with spaces of the same length to preserve line breaks. Because the tool later uses “how many line breaks precede” to back-calculate line numbers, changing the length causes all line numbers to shift, making error positions completely wrong. This has been written into a self-check test case.

2.3 Incidentally Uncovering a Second Symmetry Defect

After fixing R14, another instance of the same disease was discovered elsewhere: R14 has always applied only to cross-file checks (R5X); same-file checks (R5) have consistently been omitted.

The consequence is absurd: Pool 4’s own backlog (ledger) records side-by-side “Prose 0.27 dB” and “Table 27 dB”—it is faithfully recording one contradiction. When R5 reads these two entries, it judges “this file contradicts itself” and reports one deviation violating by a factor of 0.1.

The more faithfully the ledger records errors, the more its own tool judges it to be erroneous.
A criterion directly encouraging “record less” constitutes reverse incentive in any audit system.

After the fix: cross-file violations 16 → 6, same-file violations 2 → 1. The mtime of all three source files remains frozen at 17:41, not a single character moved.

2.4 A Self-Referential Dilemma (Collided With During Writing This Article)

After the fix, I began writing this article. When reaching the form table above, to make readers clearly see “bare prose also counts as a claim,” I placed in the table one row of bare example without quotes.

Immediately after finishing, I re-ran the tool: cross-file violations 6 → 10. The additional 4 all originate from this article itself—because that row of “example” was indeed bare prose, and the tool correctly judged it as a claim under the new rule.

This is not a bug, but a live demonstration of design boundaries.
The tool cannot distinguish “this number is the author asserting” from “this number is the author illustrating what an assertion looks like”—they are identical in textual form.

The solution is not to change the tool (it cannot be changed, this is a semantic issue), but rather to revise the writing style: convert the example into descriptive form (“a line of text like ‘…’”), so the example does not land on specific numerical values. After revision, the violation count returns to 6.

This experience is worth passing on to all future writers of audit documents: examples you use to explain rules will themselves be judged by those rules. When giving examples, either place numbers inside quotes or code blocks, or describe shapes without specific values.

III. The Remaining 6 Locations Are Actually One

This is the genuine discovery of this round.

Of the six violations, five share one endpoint: the attenuation table in §3 of skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md (L81 μ-metal / L82 steel plate / L85 granite). The other endpoint of the sixth violation is also this same table.

# Material Pairing Deviation
1 Granite mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 1 km/0.27 dB ↔ basement 100 m/27 dB 10×
2 μ-metal basement 2 mm/30 dB ↔ skin-depth-reference-table 0.1 mm/3.47 dB 0.43×
3 Steel plate basement 5 mm/83 dB ↔ reference 1 cm/15.2 dB 2.73×
4 Steel plate basement 5 mm/83 dB ↔ reference 1 mm/1.52 dB 10.9×
5 Granite basement 100 m/27 dB ↔ reference 1000 m/0.15 dB 18×
6 Granite basement 100 m/27 dB ↔ pool4-mountain-elf-typical-granite-transparent 1 km/0.27 dB 10×

Round 13 already adjudicated this batch of rows within the same file (“§3 Table A: five rows, four errors”). Re-evaluating them from the opposite direction, across files, still points to the same root cause.

3.1 Manual Calculation: The Root Error Lies in §2 Table

Without tools, pure manual calculation. f = 7.83 Hz, μ0 = 4π×10⁻⁷, δ = √(2/(ωμσ)), A = 8.686·d/δ:

Material (per σ stated in file §1) δ @ 7.83 Hz A at 100 m A at 1 km
Granite σ = 1e-4 S/m 17.99 km 0.048 dB 0.48 dB
Granite σ = 1e-5 S/m 56.88 km 0.015 dB 0.15 dB
Basalt (wet) σ = 1e-2 1.799 km 0.483 dB 4.83 dB

Now examine what §2 table states: granite δ at 7.83 Hz is listed as “32 m”.

True value 17.99 km, table lists 32 m — a discrepancy of 562 times.

This 562 is not a new number. Round 13 recorded “§2 δ column: five rows, four errors: μ-metal 0.10× / steel plate 0.98×✅ / RC 998× / basalt 178× / granite 562×”. This round independently calculated it again, still 562.

Thus all six locations are fully explained:

  • §3 table uses δ = 32 m to compute granite at 100 m = 27 dB;
  • all other files use δ ≈ 32 km to compute 0.15–0.27 dB;
  • comparing the two yields a difference of 10–18 times.

These six locations are not six separate typos, but six symptoms stemming from one root error.

3.2 Verification in Reverse: §2 Table Arithmetic Is Actually Correct

Re-solve each column of §2 table backwards to find equivalent σ (the five frequencies in the same column must yield the same σ, otherwise that column is internally contradictory):

Column Back-calculated σ Internally consistent?
μ-metal 9.8e8 – 1.0e9 S/m ✅ <3% difference
Steel plate 1.13e9 – 1.16e9 S/m ✅
Reinforced concrete 9.8e4 – 1.0e5 S/m ✅
Basalt 3.13e3 – 3.3e3 S/m ✅ <1.1× (rounding)
Granite 31 – 33 S/m ✅ self-consistent

Note the last row: the granite column is fully internally consistent—all five frequencies yield 31–33 S/m. Therefore the arithmetic is correct.

The error lies in the input: file §1 explicitly states granite σ = 1e-4 – 1e-3 S/m, while the table actually uses ~32 S/m. A difference of 5–6 orders of magnitude.

This is the most methodologically significant point of this round: “table self-consistency” and “input correctness” are two distinct matters. A column of data can be beautifully self-consistent if computed from the same wrong input end-to-end, yet collapse completely when compared across files.

IV. Why This Error Deserves Serious Attention

It reverses the direction of the conclusion.

The document’s own argument is: “Mountain bodies are nearly transparent to ELF; shielding by a mountain is not established.”

  • Based on the error value in the table (27 dB for 100 m granite), the mountain appears to be a strong shield;
  • Based on the true value (0.048 dB for 100 m granite), the mountain barely blocks anything at all.

In other words, this error makes the correct conclusion appear invalid within its own document.

The more practical impact lies in sampling decisions: if δ is underestimated by a factor of 562, then A is overestimated by the same factor—thus the judgment that “ordinary granite mountains are worth testing” becomes exaggerated. According to the classification in #22, ordinary granite falls into Category C (σ ≤ 1e-4), which should be the least priority for testing.

Therefore, this is not merely a question of “whether the numbers look good,” but rather that it will lead measurement budgets to be allocated to incorrect samples.

V. Evidence and Limitations

This paper does not determine the true subsurface conductivity σ or the true attenuation A. This paper performs only two tasks: locating inconsistencies between texts that are mutually incompatible within the corpus, and performing one arithmetic re-calculation.

Specific limitations:

  1. The assumptions A ≈ 8.7d/δ and δ = √(2/(ωμσ)) presume a uniform half-space, no displacement current, and constant μr and σ. Real mountain strata are layered and anisotropic; σ exhibits frequency dispersion. The divergence itself is a traditional consensus: Kariya & Shankland 1983 (10.1190/1.1441407, conductivity of dry crustal rock), Laštovičková & Bochníček 1992 (10.1007/BF01613900, frequency-dependent conductivity measurement), Revil 2013 (10.1029/2012WR120700, effective conductivity of unsaturated porous media), Mehran & Arulanandan 1977 (10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107, low-frequency conductivity dispersion in clay-water-electrolyte systems).
  2. The above 4 papers are not indexed in PubMed → no PMID → labeled E3 as is, which does not constitute E1.
  3. “Violation” refers only to two numbers failing A ∝ d, not to the true subsurface A being another value, nor to whose σ literature citation is wrong. The σ interval stated in §1 itself was unaudited—if the document’s intent was some unstated equivalent σ, the problem shifts from “calculated wrong” to “σ not clearly stated.”
  4. The zero-parameter criterion can only falsify, not verify. The 6 violations prove “at least one is wrong”; they do not prove “the rest are right.” Conversely, ratios coincidentally self-consistent might merely be errors canceling each other out—the single-point re-calculation of the μ-metal row in round 15 was judged OK precisely because §2 and §3 used the same erroneous δ.
  5. The denominator is extremely small: only 34 points and 17 pairs can be judged from the original text. This denominator is insufficient to extrapolate any “full-corpus contradiction rate.”
  6. Only equality assertions are covered; inequalities and textual intervals do not participate (intervals cannot be judged by single points).
  7. The shielding rule is a morphological heuristic, not semantic understanding: numbers written inside quotes but actually asserted in the document will be missed. This round’s test found 0 cases, but this is a known blind spot.

VI. What Was Truly Learned in This Round

Three takeaways, ranked by importance:

First, the audit tool reads its own prior output. Therefore the rule “citations must not be assertions” must be implemented at the textual level, not via filenames. Otherwise, every audit paper generates a new batch of “violations”—and the violation count grows in lockstep with the writing volume, precisely drowning out the real issues.

Second, exclusion rules must be applied symmetrically. When adding a new exclusion rule, first count how many checks read the same set of points. If even one check does not connect to it, that rule is a backdoor. R14 missed feeding R5 by exactly two full rounds.

Third, suspect the tool before suspecting the data when extra violations appear. Of the 16 violations, 10 are spurious. If those 10 were not identified, the convergence “10 → 6” would remain invisible—while reports would simply state “many contradictions, continuing growth.”

Finally, one number deserves to be written here:

  • All numerical assertions cover 429 items; the checks of type R1/R2/R3—”recomputing one’s own declaration σ”—achieve 100% coverage—but they depend on the value of σ, so rounds 12 and 13 repeatedly show “judged then overturned.”
  • In contrast, hard criteria of type R5/R5X—completely independent of any parameters and capable only of falsification—cover just 8.2% (35/429 points, 17 pairs).

The hardest criteria have the narrowest coverage. This is the true structure of the system and must not be obscured by any claim of “full database verification.”


This article is a draft, not yet finalized; it does not constitute any empirical conclusion. Health and environmental interventions require professional assessment.


Disclaimer: This article compiles traditional knowledge and scientific literature for comparison and research-design discussion only. It is not medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Effect sizes, frequency ranges and exposure conclusions cited here are largely inferences at the research-report level, and individual circumstances vary widely. If you have any discomfort or health concerns, please consult a physician.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *