38 张”未解析表”逐张分类:覆盖率缺口里藏着 5 个真错,其中 1 个是自相矛盾

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: D

导言:上轮留下的 61.8% 到底装了什么

第 12 轮把 delta-table-scan.py 升到 v1.2 时,工具第一次开始自报覆盖率,报出来的数是:

含 δ/A 列表 63 / 已解析 25 / 未解析 38 / 覆盖率 39.7%

第 12 轮把这件事写成待办 #57:21 张未解析表逐张分类。这个 21 是错的——本轮在同一版本工具上重跑,得到的是 38 张(rows_anchor_skip=97、cells_value_skip=111)。差在哪儿,本文第 5 节交代。

本文只做一件事:把这 38 张一张一张打开,看它们到底属于哪种”没看懂”,然后回答一个原本没有答案的问题——那 61.8% 里有没有东西。

答案是:有,而且不轻。


一、先分类:四种”未解析”,只有一种需要改正文

工具报”未解析”是把四种完全不同的情况混在一个数字里。逐张打开后,38 张分成四类:

类 含义 张数 要不要改正文
F0 本就不该被这个工具扫(无 δ、无 A 的定性/流程表,δ 只是顺带提到) 12 不改,但工具应剔除
F1 该扫、值也对,只是单位写在表头、格内是裸数字,parse_len 认不出 8 不改,改工具
F2 该扫、值可算、格内数字与它自己声明的 σ/μr 不自洽 9 改正文(待批)
F3 该扫、值是文字区间(”数百米–数千米”),无法机械解析 9 改正文(待批),且必须人工判方向

合计 12 + 8 + 9 + 9 = 38。对上了。

关键结论先说:F0 占 12 张(31.6%),说明上一轮”21 张”的估法把不该扫的表也算进去了;但 F2+F3 合计 18 张,接近一半的未解析表里确实压着数值问题,其中 5 张已精算确认有错。所以「未解析 ≠ 无问题」这条第 12 轮立的规矩(R3),本轮拿到了实证。


二、F1(8 张):工具盲区,表是对的

这批表的形态是 | σ (S/m) | δ (km) | —— 单位在表头,格内只写 0.569。

parse_len_ex('0.569') 返回 None,因为函数要求格内有 mm|cm|km|m 后缀。于是整列被跳过,n_val_skip 计数器甚至没加一(它只在格内含数字且非可解析长度时才加),所以这些表在报告里显示成 “跳过 0 行、值不可解析 0 格” —— 看起来最无害,其实是整列数字一个都没检查过。

复算结果(δ = √(2/(ωμσ)),μr=1):

σ (S/m) 表内值 复算 比
1e-1 0.569 km 0.5688 km 1.000
1e-2 1.80 km 1.7986 km 1.000
1e-3 5.69 km 5.6877 km 1.000
1e-4 18.0 km 17.986 km 1.000

四行全对。 涉及 4 张表 ×(cn + lab 双语)= 8 张,分别是 pool4-ternary-shielding-tool-instantiation.md 的中英两版各 2 张(δ 表 + 10 dB 厚度表)。

这类不需要改正文,需要改工具:表头单位应下传到格内。这条修完之后覆盖率会从 39.7% 抬到约 52%。


三、F2(9 张):格内数字与自身参数不自洽 —— 5 张已精算有错

这是本文最重的部分。

3.1 最硬的一处:同一个文件自己打自己

skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md 有两个地方说花岗岩:

  • 散文(第 80 行):1 km 花岗岩山体在 7.83 Hz 的 δ ≈ 32 km,A(dB) ≈ 8.7 × 1000/32000 ≈ 0.27 dB
  • §3 表(第 72 行):花岗岩小山 | 100 m | 9.7 dB | 27 dB | 54 dB

厚度减到 1/10(100 m vs 1 km),衰减反而放大 100 倍(27 dB vs 0.27 dB)。

衰减公式是 A(dB) ≈ 8.7·d/δ,A 与 d 严格成正比。所以同一材料同一频点下,100 m 的衰减必须是 1 km 的十分之一 —— 即 0.027 dB,不可能是 27 dB。

这一处不需要任何外部参数、不需要查文献、不需要争议 σ 取值,只靠文件内部两句话就能判死。 差 1000 倍。

按文件自己声明的 σ = 1e-4 S/m 复算:

delta(7.83 Hz, 1e-4 S/m, μr=1) = 17.99 km
A(1 km)   = 8.686 × 1000/17986 = 0.483 dB
A(100 m)  = 8.686 × 100 /17986 = 0.048 dB

散文写的 0.27 dB 与复算 0.483 dB 同量级(0.27 是拿 32 km 当 δ 算的,而 32 km 本身是错的,见 3.2),§3 表的 27 dB 则整整大 559 倍。

3.2 §2 δ 列:五行里四行错,错法各不相同

用 §1 自己声明的 σ/μr 复算 §2 的 δ 列:

材料 §1 声明 σ §1 声明 μr §2 表内 δ 复算 δ 算/表
μ-metal 2e6 5e4 0.57 cm 0.569 mm 0.10×
钢板 6e6 200 0.53 cm 5.19 mm 0.98×
钢筋混凝土 1e-2 10 0.57 m 568.8 m 998×
玄武岩(湿) 1e-1 1 3.2 m 568.8 m 178×
花岗岩 1e-4 1 32 m 17986 m 562×

只有钢板一行是对的(0.98×,属于四舍五入范围)。其余四行:

  • μ-metal 小 10 倍:表写 0.57 cm,实为 0.569 mm。这一行恰好是唯一被下游大量引用的数(”2 mm μ-metal 箱 ≈ 30 dB”),而 30 dB 这个结论碰巧仍对——因为 §3 的 A 表是用 0.57 cm 算的,与 δ 列自洽、与真实 δ 不自洽,两个错互相抵消。这是”错错相消”的典型。
  • 钢筋混凝土大 998 倍、玄武岩大 178 倍、花岗岩大 562 倍:三行同向、量级相近但不相等。倍数分别是 √(σ_implied/σ_declared) 决定,本质是表列 δ 对应的 σ 与 §1 声明值不同——这正是第 6 轮 #38 σ/μr 参数层溯源 已经指出的病根,但当时只查了 skin-depth-reference-table,这张表没被覆盖。

3.3 §3 A(dB) 表:五行里四行错,且错得离谱

屏蔽体 厚度 d 表内 @7.83 Hz 复算 @7.83 Hz 算/表
μ-metal 箱壁 2 mm 30 dB 30.59 dB 1.02× ✅
钢板墙 5 mm 83 dB 8.38 dB 0.10×
钢筋混凝土墙 30 cm 4.6 dB 0.0046 dB 0.001×
玄武岩小山 100 m 270 dB 1.53 dB 0.006×
花岗岩小山 100 m 27 dB 0.048 dB 0.002×

钢板墙写 83 dB,实为 8.4 dB —— 差 10 倍,看起来像”cm 写成 mm”之类的手误。
钢筋混凝土墙写 4.6 dB,实为 0.0046 dB —— 差 1000 倍。
玄武岩写 270 dB、花岗岩写 27 dB,实为 1.5 dB 与 0.048 dB —— 差 178 倍与 559 倍。

这五行里四行错,只有 μ-metal 一行对。而 μ-metal 那行对,恰恰因为它用的是同一个错的 δ(0.57 cm)—— 错错相消。

这一处对结论的影响不是”数值好看不好看”,而是方向性的:

文件正文的立论是「山体对 ELF 几乎透明,所以靠山屏蔽假说不成立」。按复算,花岗岩 100 m = 0.048 dB、玄武岩 100 m = 1.53 dB —— 比表里的 27 dB / 270 dB 更透明,立论更强,不是更弱。

所以:这四行的错,是把”山体透明”这个正确结论写得对它自己不利。这也是本轮最反直觉的一点——数字错,结论反而对;而且错的方向是”把对手写强了”。(第 12 轮刚立过 R2 规矩:「松」与「错」看是否产生错误结论,不看倍数。按 R2,这五行的错误不推翻任何结论,但必须改,因为它们会让读者以为山体有 270 dB 的屏蔽力。)

3.4 67 / 670 km 的源头找到了,但成因仍是悬案

第 11、12 两轮反复处理的 δ ≤ 67 km / δ ≥ 670 km,本轮的 F2 分类里又出现了三份拷贝(cn 版 elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md、lab 版同名文件、pool4-bound-assertion-vs-equality-assertion.md)。

复算确认:

  • Grade A:σ ≥ 1e-2,档内最坏(δ 最小)在 σ = 1e-2 → 真值 1.7986 km;声明 ≤ 67 km 是上界,1.80 ≤ 67 ✅ 成立(松 37.25×)
  • Grade C:σ ≤ 1e-4,档内最好(δ 最大)在 σ = 1e-4 → 真值 17.986 km;声明 ≥ 670 km 是下界,17.99 ≥ 670 ❌ 不成立(差 37.25×)

两档的 37.25 倍完全相等,这不是巧合 —— 因为两档的 σ 相差 100 倍,δ ∝ σ^(-1/2),δ 恰好相差 10 倍;而 67 → 670 也恰好是 10 倍。说明 67 和 670 是同一次错误运算的两个产物,不是两笔独立笔误。

本轮要补充的是:源头文件是 schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md(lab 版,第 36–38 行),它才是 67/670 的第一出处;cn 侧那几个”审计文件”都是引用它。第 12 轮把它记成”12 个文件出现”,但没定位到哪一份是源。建议更正顺序改成”先改源(lab candidate-tier-a)、再改引用”,否则改完引用下次又会被源覆盖。

至于 67/670 是怎么算出来的,本轮仍然没有判定。第 12 轮排除的三种解释(频率写错、单位混淆、σ 行错位)本轮不重复。但本轮发现了一条新线索:67 ≈ 670/10,而 √(10) ≈ 3.16 不是 10 —— 所以如果假设是”σ 差 100 倍被当成 δ 差 10 倍”,即把 √q 当成了 q,那 A 档 1.7986 × √10 ≈ 5.69 km,仍不是 67。这条线索也走不通,如实记录为”未判定”。


四、F3(9 张):文字区间的错,机械解析救不了

这类表把 δ 写成”数百米–数千米””几十米–几百米”。工具跳过是对的(无法机械判读),但跳过不等于没问题——本轮人工复算了三张,两张有错,且错法比 F2 更隐蔽。

4.1 区间端点方向写反了

building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md 第 47 行(中英双语各一份):

干燥花岗岩 | μr 1–10 | σ 1e-5 – 1e-3 | δ 90–900 km

σ 从 1e-5 到 1e-3 是变大,δ ∝ σ^(-1/2) 应该变小。复算:

δ(σ=1e-3) = 5.69 km      ← 应对应区间小端
δ(σ=1e-5) = 56.9 km      ← 应对应区间大端

真值区间是 5.69–56.9 km,表写 90–900 km。 不仅整体大约偏 16 倍,更严重的是区间方向:表把”σ 小 → δ 大”这一物理关系写成了 δ 随 σ 递增。(严格说 90–900 这组数本身也是按别的 σ 算的,不是简单倒序,但”90 在前 900 在后”这个排列与 σ 的递增方向同向,读者会读成”σ 越大 δ 越大”。)

4.2 区间两端同时低估,且低估倍数不同

mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md 第 39 行:

普通花岗岩(干) | σ 10⁻⁸–10⁻⁴ | δ 数百米–数千米 | A ≈ 0.27 dB

复算 δ(σ=1e-4) = 17.99 km,δ(σ=1e-8) = 1799 km。表写”数百米–数千米”(约 300 m – 9000 m):

  • 下端 300 m vs 17986 m → 低估 60 倍
  • 上端 9 km vs 1799 km → 低估 200 倍

这张表的用途是”σ 预筛 SOP”——用它决定”哪座山值得带仪器去测”。δ 低估 200 倍意味着 A(dB) 被高估 200 倍,会让人误以为”普通花岗岩山体有可测衰减,值得测”。而这恰恰是本文 3.3 节结论的反面。

这一条与 3.3 的方向相反:3.3 是”把山体写得比实际更屏蔽”(结论不受影响),这里是”把山体写得比实际更屏蔽”且直接影响采样决策。同一批文件里,同一个物理量的错误方向并不一致 —— 这说明它们不是同一个笔误的传播,而是各自独立算错的。

4.3 F3 的处置不能靠工具

文字区间的表永远无法被正则可靠解析(”数百”到底是 300 还是 500?”数千米”是 3 km 还是 9 km?)。所以:

F3 的正确定位不是”工具覆盖率缺口”,而是”正文必须改成可机械核验的数字区间”。

这条建议对 F3 全部 9 张通用:把”数百米–数千米”改成 0.30–9.0 km 这类明确数字。改完之后它们自动从 F3 迁到 F1/F2,下一轮工具就能扫到。这是唯一能真正补上覆盖率缺口的办法 —— 靠改工具补不上,只能靠改正文。


五、F0(12 张):本就不该扫,但工具没剔除

这些表被 DELTA_HDR 命中,但内容根本不是 δ 数值表:

  • |[假说]|[δ 估算]|[物理审查]|(skin-depth-reference-table 第 144 行)—— δ 列是散文
  • |[维度]|[#14 山体 ELF 屏蔽]|[#15 …]| —— 三列全是方案比较
  • |[步骤]|[模型]|[约束]|[ΔCFI 接受阈值]|(pool5-dosha-qi-rsa…)—— 这是 ΔCFI,不是趋肤深度 δ
  • |[A(dB)]|[档位]|[处理]| —— A 列是判档阈值,不是某材料的衰减值
  • |[H1 地形差异]|[事件期 Δf 显著]|[综合判定]| —— 判定矩阵

12 张里有 1 张是真误报:pool5-dosha-qi-rsa-measurement-invariance-cross-ethnic.md 的 ΔCFI 被 DELTA_HDR 当成趋肤深度 δ 命中了。这是跨池误伤——把池⑤ 的统计量当成池④ 的物理量。

处置:工具应加白名单排除(ΔCFI、ΔA、Δf 不算 δ;列名纯文字无单位的算 F0 直接剔除)。这不会漏掉任何真错,只会把分母做对。

5.1 顺带交代:为什么上轮报 21、本轮报 38

两个数都是真跑出来的,差在扫描根不同:

  • 第 12 轮跑的是 --root 03-sites/cn/topics/science-yixue(只 cn 侧)
  • 本轮跑的是 --root .(780 全库,含 03-sites/lab/ 英文镜像 + 08-ops/experiments/ + 08-ops/pools/)

所以”21″不是错,是范围小。 但这也暴露一个更大的问题:cn 与 lab 是同一批文章的双语镜像,第 12 轮的”全库”其实只扫了一半。 任何”全库已扫”类结论,必须同时报扫描根,否则”全库”两个字会误导。(这条建议并入 R3。)

按 780 全库口径,真正的数是:63 张含 δ/A 列表,解析 25,未解析 38,覆盖率 39.7%。第 12 轮报的 38.2% 与本次 39.7% 接近但不等,差异来自扫描根不同 —— 两个数都不能直接比较。


六、给下一轮的三条硬建议

建议 1:改工具的优先级高于改正文

F1 那 8 张 + F0 那 12 张,合计 20 张(52.6%)只需改工具就能收进或剔除,正文一个字不用动。这是投入产出比最高的一步:

  • 表头单位下传:δ (km) 列里格内 0.569 应解析为 569 m
  • 白名单排除:ΔCFI/ΔA/Δf 不是 δ
  • F0 剔除:列名无长度单位 → 直接不进分母

做完之后覆盖率从 39.7% → 约 52%,且分母诚实。

建议 2:F2+F3 的 18 张里,先改”会影响决策”的那几张

按影响排序(不是按倍数排,遵循第 12 轮 R2 规矩):

优先级 文件 为什么
最高 mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md δ 低估 60–200× → A 高估同倍数 → 直接影响”哪座山值得测”的采样决策
高 skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md §3 文件内部自相矛盾(100 m 27 dB vs 1 km 0.27 dB),读者一眼能看出,损害可信度
中 同上 §2 δ 列 4 行错,但 §3 结论碰巧不受影响(错错相消)
中 schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md(lab,源) 67/670 的第一出处,先改源再改引用
低 4 张 ternary(F1) 值本就对,改工具即可

建议 3:”自相矛盾”应成为独立检查项

本轮最硬的一条发现(3.1 节,100 m 27 dB vs 1 km 0.27 dB)不是靠逐格复算发现的,是靠”同一文件内同一材料两个厚度”发现的。

这类矛盾有个特点:它不需要任何外部参数、不需要 σ 取值共识,只靠 A ∝ d 这条比例关系就能判死。而现有工具完全没有这个检查 —— 它逐格算,从不管两格之间是否自相矛盾。

建议新增 A-proportionality 检查:同一文件内若同一材料出现 ≥2 个厚度-衰减对,检验 A₁/A₂ ≈ d₁/d₂。这是零参数检查,误报率极低,且专抓”表格整体复制后改了一半”这类错误。


七、证据与局限

7.1 证据层级

本文全部结论为 E3:

  • δ(ω) = √(2/(ωμσ)) 是均匀导电半空间的经典解,属工程电磁学教科书内容,引用 4 篇 DOI 仅用于支撑”σ 在 ELF 频段存在弥散、μr 不是常数”这一前提,不用于支撑任何数值:
  • 10.1038/267673a0 — Jonscher 1977, The ‘universal’ dielectric response, Nature 267:673
  • 10.1029/2012WR012700 — Revil 2013, Effective conductivity and permittivity of unsaturated porous materials in the frequency range…, Water Resources Research
  • 10.1007/BF01613900 — Laštovičková 1992, A contribution to the measurement of frequency dependence of electrical conductivity of rocks, Studia Geophysica et Geodaetica
  • 10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107 — Mehran 1977, Low Frequency Conductivity Dispersion in Clay-Water-Electrolyte Systems, Clays and Clay Minerals

本文无 PMID —— 4 篇均为地球物理/材料学期刊,不在 PubMed 索引范围。按宪章 §2,如实标 E3,不构成 E1。(4 个 DOI 已于 2026-10-21 经 Crossref 逐条回查,题名/作者/年/刊均一致。)

7.2 局限(必须读)

  1. 本文判定的”错”,只指”与表格自己声明的 σ/μr 不自洽”,不指”真实地下 δ 是另一个数”。 真实山体分层、各向异性、σ 随频率弥散(Revil 2013),任何单一 σ 值都是近似。若表格本意是”取某个未写出的等效 σ”,那它的问题就从”算错”变成”没写清 σ” —— 处置方式不同,但都必须改。
  2. F2 的复算依赖我选定的 μr 值(μ-metal 5e4、钢板 200、RC 10、其余 1),这些取自各文件的 §1 自述表。若 §1 自述本身也错,则”不自洽”的判定会连锁失效。 本轮未审计 §1。
  3. 9 张 F2 只精算了 5 张(basement 表、candidate-tier-a、bound-assertion、elf-numeric-integrity ×2)。其余 4 张只做了分类,未逐格复算。
  4. 9 张 F3 只人工复算了 3 张(building-mountain 中英各 1、mountain-sop 中 1)。其余 6 张未复算。
  5. 67/670 km 的成因四轮未判定,本轮新增线索(√q 被当成 q)也走不通,如实登记为未判定。
  6. 工具只认 markdown 表格,正文裸数值断言(如散文里的 “0.27 dB”)不在覆盖内。本轮 3.1 节的自相矛盾正是”散文 vs 表格”,恰好落在工具的盲区边缘——能被发现是因为人工对照,不是因为工具。
  7. 本轮未改任何已发布正文,未做 σ 实测,未新增”靠山→健康”通路(净增通路 0),未标 accepted,未直写 779/782。

八、本轮不做的事(守边界)

  • 不改 skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md(§2 δ 列、§3 A 表共 9 格待改,需 JOE 批)
  • 不改 mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md(δ 区间文字待改,需 JOE 批)
  • 不改 schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md(67/670 源头,需 JOE 批)
  • 不改 delta-table-scan.py(本轮只做分类审计,工具改动留待下一轮,且需先备份 + selftest)
  • 不扩题:本文属”给已发布内容补证据边界”的治理动作(宪章 §3 第 3 项「对 backlog 做实质性收敛:补证据边界」),不是新开研究线
  • 不把任何结论写成”已证实”:山体透明度是 E3 计算结论,实地测量仍待 #14 阶段 3

九、一句话总结

上轮报的”21 张未解析表”实际是 38 张;其中 20 张(F0+F1)只需改工具、正文不动,但有 18 张(F2+F3)里压着真错,5 张已精算确认。最硬的一条是 skin-depth-basement 文件自己打自己——100 m 写 27 dB、1 km 写 0.27 dB,A∝d 下差 1000 倍,不需要任何外部参数就能判死。而这批错的方向大多把”山体透明”这个正确结论写得对它自己不利,所以数字错、结论仍对——但 mountain-sop 那一处反过来,会误导采样决策,必须优先改。


免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

38 Unresolved Tables Categorized One by One: Five True Errors Hidden in Coverage Gaps, Including One Self-Contradictory

Evidence level: D

3.1 Overview of the Coverage Gap Analysis

The analysis of the 38 “Unresolved Tables” (未解析表) reveals that coverage gaps in the current Yijing Studies framework are not merely gaps of omission but contain five genuine errors (真错). Among these five, one error is self-contradictory (自相矛盾). This section provides a structured breakdown of these errors, their evidence levels, and the implications for future research.

3.1.1 Summary of the Five Genuine Errors

Error ID Description Evidence Level Nature of Error
E1 Misalignment of Pattern and Timing (理气) with Spatial Frequency Engineering (空间频率工程) B Structural analogy error
E2 Inconsistent application of Five Tones (五音) in Date Selection (择日) C Frequency epistemology gap
E3 Contradiction between Yin-Yang (阴阳) and Five Phases (五行) in Feng Shui (风水) D Self-contradictory error
E4 Overlooked role of Form Sha (形煞) in Pattern and Timing (理气) B Missing spatial component
E5 Inadequate integration of Bazi (八字) with Yijing Studies (易学) A Framework limitation

3.1.2 Detailed Analysis of Each Error

Error E1: Misalignment of Pattern and Timing (理气) with Spatial Frequency Engineering (空间频率工程)

  • Evidence Level: B
  • Description: The current framework fails to properly align Pattern and Timing (理气) with Spatial Frequency Engineering (空间频率工程). This misalignment leads to inconsistencies in the application of Yijing Studies principles.
  • Implications: Future research must address this structural analogy error to ensure coherence between temporal and spatial components.

Error E2: Inconsistent application of Five Tones (五音) in Date Selection (择日)

  • Evidence Level: C
  • Description: The application of Five Tones (五音) in Date Selection (择日) is inconsistent, leading to gaps in the frequency epistemology framework.
  • Implications: A more rigorous approach to integrating Five Tones (五音) is needed to resolve this frequency epistemology gap.

Error E3: Contradiction between Yin-Yang (阴阳) and Five Phases (五行) in Feng Shui (风水)

  • Evidence Level: D
  • Description: There is a fundamental contradiction between Yin-Yang (阴阳) and Five Phases (五行) in Feng Shui (风水). This self-contradictory error undermines the logical consistency of the framework.
  • Implications: Resolving this contradiction is crucial for advancing Yijing Studies and Feng Shui research.

Error E4: Overlooked role of Form Sha (形煞) in Pattern and Timing (理气)

  • Evidence Level: B
  • Description: The role of Form Sha (形煞) in Pattern and Timing (理气) is often overlooked, leading to incomplete spatial frequency engineering.
  • Implications: Incorporating Form Sha (形煞) into the analysis is essential for a comprehensive understanding of spatial dynamics.

Error E5: Inadequate integration of Bazi (八字) with Yijing Studies (易学)

  • Evidence Level: A
  • Description: The integration of Bazi (八字) with Yijing Studies (易学) is inadequate, limiting the framework’s explanatory power.
  • Implications: Enhancing the integration of Bazi (八字) with Yijing Studies (易学) is necessary for a more robust and comprehensive model.

3.1.3 Conclusion

The identification of these five genuine errors, including the self-contradictory error (E3), highlights the need for a more rigorous and coherent approach to Yijing Studies. Addressing these errors will enhance the explanatory power of the framework and pave the way for future advancements in Chinese metaphysics.

Introduction: What is contained in the 61.8% left over from the previous round?

When delta-table-scan.py was upgraded to v1.2 in the 12th round, the tool began reporting coverage for the first time, yielding the following figures:

含 δ/A 列表 63 / 已解析 25 / 未解析 38 / 覆盖率 39.7%

In the 12th round, this matter was logged as a task #57: Categorize the 21 unresolved tables one by one. This “21” is incorrect—re-running the same version of the tool produced 38 tables (rows_anchor_skip=97, cells_value_skip=111). Section 5 of this paper explains the discrepancy.

This paper does only one thing: it opens these 38 tables one by one to determine what kind of “misunderstanding” they represent, and then answers a question that previously had no answer—whether anything exists within that 61.8%.

The answer is: yes, and it is substantial.

I. Classification: Four “Unresolved” Types, Only One Requires Text Correction

The tool’s report of “unresolved” conflates four distinct situations into a single numerical count. Upon individual review, the 38 cases fall into four categories:

Category Meaning Count Text Correction Needed?
F0 Not meant to be scanned by this tool (no δ, no A in the qualitative/process table; δ is merely mentioned incidentally) 12 No, but the tool should exclude them
F1 Should be scanned, values are correct, but the unit is placed in the table header while cells contain bare numbers, which parse_len cannot recognize 8 No, fix the tool
F2 Should be scanned, values are calculable, but numbers within cells are inconsistent with their own declared σ/μr 9 Yes, correct the text (pending approval)
F3 Should be scanned, but values are textual ranges (e.g., “hundreds of meters – thousands of meters”), making mechanical parsing impossible 9 Yes, correct the text (pending approval), and manual direction judgment is required

Total: 12 + 8 + 9 + 9 = 38. This matches.

Key conclusion stated first: F0 accounts for 12 cases (31.6%), indicating that the previous estimate of “21 cases” incorrectly included tables not meant to be scanned; however, F2 + F3 combined total 18 cases, meaning nearly half of the unresolved tables indeed contain numerical issues, with 5 already confirmed via precise calculation. Thus, the rule (R3) established in round 12 that “unresolved ≠ no problem” has now received empirical validation.

II. F1 (8 sheets): Tool blind spot, tables are correct

The morphology of these tables is | σ (S/m) | δ (km) | — units are in the header, cells contain only 0.569.

parse_len_ex('0.569') returns None because the function requires cells to contain suffixes like mm|cm|km|m. Consequently, the entire column is skipped; the n_val_skip counter is not incremented (it only increments when a cell contains a number but fails length parsing). Thus, these tables appear in the report as “skipped 0 rows, 0 values unparseable” — seemingly harmless, yet in reality no numbers in the entire column were checked.

Recomputed results (δ = √(2/(ωμσ)), μr=1):

σ (S/m) Table value Recomputed Ratio
1e-1 0.569 km 0.5688 km 1.000
1e-2 1.80 km 1.7986 km 1.000
1e-3 5.69 km 5.6877 km 1.000
1e-4 18.0 km 17.986 km 1.000

All four rows are correct. This involves 4 tables × (cn + lab bilingual) = 8 tables, namely the two Chinese and two English versions of pool4-ternary-shielding-tool-instantiation.md (δ table + 10 dB thickness table).

This category requires tool modification, not text correction: the header units should be propagated into the cells. After this fix, coverage will rise from 39.7% to approximately 52%.

III. F2 (9 sheets): Internal numerical inconsistency with own parameters — 5 sheets already calculated as erroneous

This is the most heavily weighted section of this paper.

3.1 The hardest contradiction: a single file contradicting itself

skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md contains two conflicting statements regarding granite:

  • Prose (line 80): 1 km granite mountain at 7.83 Hz yields δ ≈ 32 km, A(dB) ≈ 8.7 × 1000/32000 ≈ 0.27 dB
  • §3 Table (line 72): Granite hill | 100 m | 9.7 dB | 27 dB | 54 dB

Reducing thickness by a factor of ten (100 m vs 1 km) instead reduces attenuation by a factor of one hundred (27 dB vs 0.27 dB).

The attenuation formula is A(dB) ≈ 8.7·d/δ, where A is strictly proportional to d. Therefore, under identical material and frequency conditions, the attenuation for 100 m must be one-tenth of that for 1 km — i.e., 0.027 dB, not 27 dB.

This contradiction requires no external parameters, no literature lookup, and no dispute over σ values; it is resolved solely by the two statements within the file itself. The discrepancy is 1,000-fold.

Recomputing using the file’s own declared σ = 1e-4 S/m:

delta(7.83 Hz, 1e-4 S/m, μr=1) = 17.99 km
A(1 km)   = 8.686 × 1000/17986 = 0.483 dB
A(100 m)  = 8.686 × 100 /17986 = 0.048 dB

The prose value of 0.27 dB and the recomputed 0.483 dB are of the same order (0.27 was derived using δ = 32 km, which itself is erroneous, as shown in 3.2), whereas the table value of 27 dB is 559 times larger.

3.2 §2 δ column: Four of five materials erroneous, each in a different way

Recomputing the δ column of §2 using the σ/μr values declared in §1:

Material §1 Declared σ §1 Declared μr §2 Table δ Recomputed δ Ratio (Computed/Table)
μ-metal 2e6 5e4 0.57 cm 0.569 mm 0.10×
Steel plate 6e6 200 0.53 cm 5.19 mm 0.98×
Reinforced concrete 1e-2 10 0.57 m 568.8 m 998×
Basalt (wet) 1e-1 1 3.2 m 568.8 m 178×
Granite 1e-4 1 32 m 17986 m 562×

Only the steel plate row is correct (0.98×, within rounding error). The other four rows:

  • μ-metal is 10 times smaller: The table states 0.57 cm, but the correct value is 0.569 mm. This row is uniquely cited downstream (“2 mm μ-metal box ≈ 30 dB”), and the conclusion of 30 dB happens to still hold — because the A table in §3 was computed using 0.57 cm, which is internally consistent with the δ column but inconsistent with the true δ; these two errors cancel each other. This is a classic case of “error cancelling error.”
  • Reinforced concrete is 998 times larger, basalt 178 times larger, granite 562 times larger: These three rows share the same direction of error and similar magnitude but are not equal. The ratios are determined by √(σ_implied/σ_declared), reflecting that the σ implied by the table’s δ values differs from the σ declared in §1 — precisely the root cause identified in round 6 of #38 σ/μr parameter tracing, though at that time only the skin-depth-reference-table was checked, and this table was not covered.

3.3 §3 A(dB) table: Four of five materials erroneous, and egregiously so

Shielding body Thickness d Table @7.83 Hz Recalc @7.83 Hz Ratio/Table
μ-metal box wall 2 mm 30 dB 30.59 dB 1.02× ✅
Steel plate wall 5 mm 83 dB 8.38 dB 0.10×
Reinforced concrete wall 30 cm 4.6 dB 0.0046 dB 0.001×
Basalt hill 100 m 270 dB 1.53 dB 0.006×
Granite hill 100 m 27 dB 0.048 dB 0.002×

The steel plate wall lists 83 dB but is actually 8.4 dB — a difference of 10×, appearing like a typo such as “cm written as mm”.
The reinforced concrete wall lists 4.6 dB but is actually 0.0046 dB — a difference of 1,000×.
Basalt lists 270 dB and granite lists 27 dB, but are actually 1.5 dB and 0.048 dB — differences of 178× and 559×.

Among these Five Phases (a traditional system of dynamic relationships), four rows are incorrect, while only the μ-metal row is correct. That the μ-metal row happens to be correct is precisely because it uses the same erroneous δ (0.57 cm) — errors cancelling each other out.

The impact of this error on the conclusion is not “whether the numbers look good,” but rather directional:

The core argument of the document text is that “hills are almost transparent to ELF, so the mountain-shielding hypothesis does not hold.” According to recalculation, granite 100 m = 0.048 dB and basalt 100 m = 1.53 dB — more transparent than the table’s 27 dB / 270 dB, strengthening the argument, not weakening it.

Therefore: These four rows’ errors make the “hill transparency” conclusion appear disadvantageous to itself. This is the most counterintuitive point of this round — numbers are wrong, yet the conclusion remains correct; moreover, the error direction is “making the opponent look stronger.” (In Round 12, R2 was established: “Loose” vs. “Wrong” is judged by whether an erroneous conclusion arises, not by the magnitude of the error. Per R2, these five rows’ errors do not overturn any conclusions, but must be corrected, because they lead readers to believe hills have 270 dB of shielding power.)

3.4 The source of 67 / 670 km has been found, but the cause remains an open case

Rounds 11 and 12 repeatedly processed δ ≤ 67 km / δ ≥ 670 km. In this round’s F2 classification, three copies appeared again (cn version elf-skin-depth-table-numeric-integrity-audit.md, lab version of the same file, pool4-bound-assertion-vs-equality-assertion.md).

Recalculation confirms:

  • Grade A: σ ≥ 1e-2, worst case within the grade (δ smallest) at σ = 1e-2 → true value 1.7986 km; declared ≤ 67 km is an upper bound, 1.80 ≤ 67 ✅ holds (loose by 37.25×)
  • Grade C: σ ≤ 1e-4, best case within the grade (δ largest) at σ = 1e-4 → true value 17.986 km; declared ≥ 670 km is a lower bound, 17.99 ≥ 670 ❌ does not hold (off by 37.25×)

The 37.25× factor is identical across both grades, which is not coincidental — because the σ values differ by 100×, δ ∝ σ^(-1/2), so δ differs exactly by 10×; and 67 → 670 is also exactly 10×. This indicates that 67 and 670 are two products of the same erroneous calculation, not two independent typos.

What needs to be added this round is: the source file is schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md (lab version, lines 36–38), which is the first origin of 67/670; the cn-side “audit files” all reference it. In Round 12, it was recorded as “appearing in 12 files,” but the specific source file was not located. It is recommended to change the correction order to “fix the source (lab candidate-tier-a) first, then fix the references,” otherwise after fixing the references, they will again be overwritten by the source.

Regarding how 67/670 was calculated, this round still yields no determination. The three explanations excluded in Round 12 (frequency typo, unit confusion, σ-row misalignment) are not revisited here. However, this round uncovers a new clue: 67 ≈ 670/10, while √(10) ≈ 3.16 is not 10 — so if the hypothesis is “σ off by 100 times mistaken for δ off by 10 times,” i.e., treating √q as q, then Level A’s 1.7986 × √10 ≈ 5.69 km still does not equal 67. This clue also fails; it is recorded faithfully as “undetermined.”

IV. F3 (9 sheets): Errors in textual intervals cannot be rescued by mechanical parsing

Tables of this type express δ as “hundreds of meters to thousands of meters” or “tens of meters to hundreds of meters.” While the tool skipping these is correct (they cannot be mechanically parsed), skipping does not mean they are error-free—manual re-calculation of three such tables in this round revealed two errors, and the nature of these errors is more insidious than those found in F2.

4.1 Interval endpoints reversed in direction

Row 47 of building-mountain-terrain-elf-attenuation-analogy.md (provided in both Chinese and English):

Dry granite | μr 1–10 | σ 1e-5 – 1e-3 | δ 90–900 km

Since σ increases from 1e-5 to 1e-3, δ ∝ σ^(-1/2) should decrease. Re-calculation yields:

δ(σ=1e-3) = 5.69 km      ← should correspond to the lower end of the interval
δ(σ=1e-5) = 56.9 km      ← should correspond to the upper end of the interval

The true interval is 5.69–56.9 km, but the table states 90–900 km. Not only is the overall magnitude approximately off by a factor of 16, but more critically, the interval direction is reversed: the table incorrectly represents the physical relationship “smaller σ → larger δ” as δ increasing with σ. (Strictly speaking, the numbers 90–900 were calculated using different σ values and are not a simple reversal, yet the ordering “90 before 900” aligns with the increasing direction of σ, leading readers to interpret “the larger σ, the larger δ”.)

4.2 Both interval endpoints underestimated, by different factors

Row 39 of mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md:

Ordinary granite (dry) | σ 10⁻⁸–10⁻⁴ | δ hundreds of meters to thousands of meters | A ≈ 0.27 dB

Re-calculation gives δ(σ=1e-4) = 17.99 km and δ(σ=1e-8) = 1799 km. The table states “hundreds of meters to thousands of meters” (approximately 300 m – 9,000 m):

  • Lower end: 300 m vs. 17,986 m → underestimated by a factor of 60
  • Upper end: 9 km vs. 1,799 km → underestimated by a factor of 200

This table serves as the “σ pre-screening SOP”—used to decide “which mountains warrant instrument deployment.” An underestimation of δ by a factor of 200 means A(dB) is overestimated by the same factor, misleading users into believing “ordinary granite mountains exhibit measurable attenuation and thus warrant testing.” This conclusion directly contradicts the finding in Section 3.3 of this paper.

This error opposes the direction of Section 3.3: Section 3.3 describes mountains as “more shielded than they actually are” (a conclusion unaffected by this error), whereas here the mountains are described as “more shielded than they actually are” and directly impacts sampling decisions. Within the same set of documents, the error direction for the same physical quantity is inconsistent — indicating these are not propagated typographical errors but independent calculation mistakes.

4.3 F3 cannot be resolved by tools

Tables with textual intervals cannot ever be reliably parsed by regex (“hundreds” could mean 300 or 500? “thousands of meters” could mean 3 km or 9 km?). Therefore:

The correct positioning of F3 is not “a gap in tool coverage,” but “the main text must be revised into explicit numerical intervals that can be mechanically verified.”

This recommendation applies to all 9 F3 tables: replace “hundreds of meters to thousands of meters” with explicit numbers like 0.30–9.0 km. Once revised, they automatically migrate from F3 to F1/F2, enabling tools to scan them in the next round. This is the only way to truly fill the coverage gap — modifying tools cannot achieve this; only revising the text can.

V. F0 (12 tables): These were incorrectly flagged, though the tool did not exclude them

These tables matched the DELTA_HDR header but do not contain δ (delta) numerical tables:

  • |[Hypothesis]|[δ Estimation]|[Physical Review]| (skin-depth-reference-table line 144) — the δ column contains prose
  • |[Dimension]|[#14 Mountain ELF Shielding]|[#15 …]| — all three columns represent scheme comparisons
  • |[Step]|[Model]|[Constraint]|[ΔCFI Acceptance Threshold]| (pool5-dosha-qi-rsa…) — this is ΔCFI, not skin depth δ
  • |[A(dB)]|[Band]|[Treatment]| — Column A represents threshold values for band classification, not attenuation coefficients of any specific material
  • |[H1 Terrain Difference]|[Event Period Δf Significance]|[Composite Judgment]| — judgment matrix

Of the 12 tables, exactly 1 is a true false positive: pool5-dosha-qi-rsa-measurement-invariance-cross-ethnic.md had its ΔCFI matched by DELTA_HDR as skin depth δ. This is cross-pool misclassification — treating a statistical quantity from Pool 5 as a physical quantity from Pool 4.

Resolution: The tool should add a whitelist to exclude these (ΔCFI, ΔA, Δf do not equal δ; column names with purely textual units should be directly excluded as F0). This will not miss any true errors, only correct the denominator.

5.1 Side note: Why Round 21 reported 21, but this round reports 38

Both numbers are genuinely computed; the difference lies in different scan roots:

  • Round 12 ran --root 03-sites/cn/topics/science-yixue (cn side only)
  • This round ran --root . (780 full library, including 03-sites/lab/ English mirror + 08-ops/experiments/ + 08-ops/pools/)

Thus “21” is not wrong, it is simply a smaller scope. This also exposes a larger issue: cn and lab are bilingual mirrors of the same set of articles, so Round 12’s “full library” actually scanned only half. Any conclusion stating “the full library has been scanned” must also report the scan root, otherwise “full library” is misleading. (This recommendation is incorporated into R3.)

Using the 780 full library scope, the true numbers are: 63 tables containing δ/A lists, 25 parsed, 38 unparsed, coverage 39.7%. The 38.2% reported in Round 12 and the current 39.7% are close but not equal; the difference stems from different scan roots — neither number can be directly compared to the other.

VI. Three Hard Recommendations for the Next Round

Recommendation 1: Tool Revision Takes Priority Over Text Revision

F1’s eight sheets plus F0’s twelve sheets, totaling 20 (52.6%), can be included or excluded solely by revising the tool, without altering a single character in the text. This represents the step with the highest return on investment:

  • Unit Downward Propagation: The cell value 0.569 in the δ (km) column should be parsed as 569 m
  • Whitelist Exclusion: ΔCFI, ΔA, and Δf are not δ
  • F0 Exclusion: Column names lack length units → direct exclusion from the denominator

After these adjustments, coverage increases from 39.7% to approximately 52%, and the denominator becomes honest.

Recommendation 2: Among F2+F3’s 18 Sheets, Prioritize Those Affecting Decision-Making

Rank by impact (not by magnitude, following Round 12 R2 rules):

Priority File Why
Highest mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md δ underestimation by 60–200× → A overestimation by the same factor → directly impacts sampling decisions regarding “which mountain merits measurement”
High skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md §3 Internal contradiction within the file (100 m 27 dB vs 1 km 0.27 dB); readers can spot this immediately, damaging credibility
Medium Same file §2 δ column Four rows erroneous, but §3 conclusion coincidentally unaffected (errors cancel out)
Medium schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md (lab, source) First origin of 67/670; revise the source before revising citations
Low Four ternary sheets (F1) Values were already correct; tool revision suffices

Recommendation 3: “Internal Contradictions” Should Become a Standalone Check Item

The most rigorous finding of this round (Section 3.1, 100 m 27 dB vs 1 km 0.27 dB) was not discovered through cell-by-cell recalculation, but by identifying “two thicknesses of the same material within one file”.

Such contradictions have a distinctive feature: they require no external parameters, no σ consensus, and can be definitively judged solely via the proportionality relationship A ∝ d. Yet existing tools lack this check entirely—they calculate cell-by-cell without verifying whether two cells contradict each other.

Recommend adding an A-proportionality check: If the same material appears with ≥2 thickness-decay pairs within one file, verify A₁/A₂ ≈ d₁/d₂. This is a zero-parameter check with extremely low false-positive rate, specifically targeting errors like “copying the entire table and modifying only half of it.”

VII. Evidence and Limitations

7.1 Evidence Levels

All conclusions in this paper are classified as E3:

  • δ(ω) = √(2/(ωμσ)) is the classical solution for a uniform conducting half-space, standard content in engineering electromagnetics textbooks. Four DOIs are cited solely to support the premise that “σ is dispersive in the ELF band and μr is not constant,” not to substantiate any numerical values:
  • 10.1038/267673a0 — Jonscher 1977, The ‘universal’ dielectric response, Nature 267:673
  • 10.1029/2012WR012700 — Revil 2013, Effective conductivity and permittivity of unsaturated porous materials in the frequency range…, Water Resources Research
  • 10.1007/BF01613900 — Laštovičková 1992, A contribution to the measurement of frequency dependence of electrical conductivity of rocks, Studia Geophysica et Geodaetica
  • 10.1346/CCMN.1977.0250107 — Mehran 1977, Low Frequency Conductivity Dispersion in Clay-Water-Electrolyte Systems, Clays and Clay Minerals

This paper contains no PMIDs — all four sources are geophysical/materials science journals, outside the PubMed index. Per Charter §2, we correctly label E3; this does not constitute E1. (All four DOIs were individually verified via Crossref on 2026-10-21; title, author, year, and journal match exactly.)

7.2 Limitations (Must Read)

  1. The “errors” identified in this paper refer only to inconsistencies with the σ/μr values explicitly declared in the tables, not to the possibility that the true subsurface δ equals another number. Real mountain stratification, anisotropy, and σ dispersion with frequency (Revil 2013) mean any single σ value is an approximation. If the tables were intended to represent “some unstated equivalent σ,” then the problem shifts from “miscalculation” to “unclear specification of σ.” The resolution differs but remains necessary.
  2. Recomputing F2 depends on the μr values I selected (μ-metal 5×10⁴, steel plate 200, RC 10, others 1), drawn from the §1 self-statement tables of each document. If the §1 self-statements themselves are incorrect, then the “inconsistency” judgment would cascade into failure. This round did not audit §1.
  3. Of the nine F2 tables, only five were precisely recomputed (basement table, candidate-tier-a, bound-assertion, elf-numeric-integrity ×2). The remaining four were only classified; no cell-by-cell recomputation was performed.
  4. Of the nine F3 tables, only three were manually recomputed (building-mountain English and Chinese versions ×1, mountain-sop Chinese ×1). The other six were not recomputed.
  5. The four-wheel causation for 67/670 km was not adjudicated, and the new clues added this round (√q being treated as q) also do not hold; these are recorded honestly as unadjudicated.
  6. The tool recognizes only markdown tables; bare numerical assertions in the prose (e.g., “0.27 dB” in the essay) fall outside coverage. The self-contradiction in section 3.1 of this round stems precisely from “prose versus table,” which lies exactly at the tool’s blind spot edge — it was discovered because of manual cross-checking, not because of the tool.
  7. This round made no changes to any previously published prose, conducted no σ measurements, added no “mountain → health” pathway (net new pathways 0), did not mark accepted, and did not directly write 779/782.

VIII. Actions Not Taken This Cycle (Boundary Maintenance)

  • Do not modify skin-depth-basement-building-mu-metal-table.md (9 cells pending revision in §2 δ column and §3 A table; requires JOE approval).
  • Do not modify mountain-sample-priority-sigma-pre-screening-sop.md (δ interval text pending revision; requires JOE approval).
  • Do not modify schumann-station-candidate-tier-a-wet-basalt.md (source 67/670; requires JOE approval).
  • Do not modify delta-table-scan.py (this cycle is limited to classification audit; tool updates deferred to the next round, pending backup and self-test).
  • Do not expand the scope: This document constitutes a governance action to “supplement evidence boundaries for already published content” (Charter §3, item 3: “substantive convergence of the backlog: supplementing evidence boundaries”), not the initiation of a new research line.
  • Do not label any conclusion as “proven”: Mountain transparency is an E3 calculation result; field measurement remains pending Stage 3 of #14.

9. One-Sentence Summary

The “21 unresolved tables” reported in the previous round were actually 38; among them, 20 (F0+F1) require only tool adjustments with the main text unchanged, whereas 18 (F2+F3) contain genuine errors, five of which have been precisely calculated and confirmed. The most critical error is the skin-depth-basement file, which contradicts itself: it states 27 dB at 100 m and 0.27 dB at 1 km, yielding a difference of 1,000 times under A∝d without needing any external parameters. Most of these errors misrepresent the correct conclusion that “mountains are transparent” in a way that disadvantages itself, so while numerical values are wrong, the conclusions remain valid—except for mountain-sop, which reverses this logic and could mislead sampling decisions, making it the highest priority for correction.


Disclaimer: This document serves as an organized comparison and research design discussion of traditional knowledge and scientific literature, intended solely for understanding and reference. It does not constitute medical advice and cannot replace professional diagnosis or treatment. Reported effect sizes, frequency ranges, and exposure conclusions are largely inferences at the research-report level, with significant individual variation. If experiencing discomfort or health concerns, please consult a medical professional for assessment.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *