三质↔气虚RSA反证主线的预注册规范:池5 #14–#18收束后的执行蓝图

Written by

in

Language

Evidence level: B

导言

本文件不是新研究问题,而是执行规范。当池5 在轮次11–17 完成了 #14(构念收敛)、#15(族裔 Bland-Altman)、#16(MG-CFA 等值性)、#17(量表英译 CVI)、#18(F1–F5 证伪边界)的方法学与实验设计收束后,下一阶段唯一的负责任动作就是预注册(pre-registration)——把假设、变量、分析流水线、停损规则在数据采集前公开登记,避免事后自由度把”Vata-low ≈ 气虚-low”再次变成选择性报告。

本文做三件事:(1) 给出预注册必填的最小字段集;(2) 把 #18 的 F1–F5 证伪条件翻译为可操作的事前决策规则;(3) 写明”预注册后不再调整”的边界,避免再次为产量扩题。

正文

1. 预注册必要性

构念收敛研究(#14–#16)容易出现两类事后偏差:(a) 探索性→验证性的滑动(同一份数据既用作”找关联”又用作”证关联”);(b) 翻译等价性的循环(用印度受试者的因子载荷反过来修改中文量表,然后又用修改后的中文量表回到印度样本)。预注册是当代心理测量学(psychometrics)方法学家对跨文化构念研究的标准防御(PMID 31234475)。OSF(Open Science Framework)与 AsPredicted 平台都接受此类设计预注册。

2. 最小字段集(pre-registration template)

字段 必填内容 锁死原则
假设(H1–H3) Vata-low ≈ 气虚-low / Kapha-high ≈ 气足-high / 三质×气虚双量表构念收敛 与 #18 完全一致,本轮不可改
证伪条件(F1–F5) F1 翻译/认知访谈失败 / F2 因子载荷族裔差异>0.30 / F3 RSA 主效应不显著 / F4 扰动周反转 / F5 妊娠/感染亚组失效 任一触发即停止声明”可外推”
样本量 中印各 n≥120 主样本 + 各 60 人扰动周(咖啡因/翻译/体位/感染/妊娠) 与 #18 一致,n 不可事后调
采集设备 ECG(≥500 Hz 采样)+ 桡动脉 IPG + 体位/呼吸传感器 锁死型号,事后不可换
主要分析 MG-CFA(多组验证性因子分析)+ Bland-Altman + Pearson 相关 锁死方法,事后不可换”等价”方法
探索性分析 副指标(HF-HRV、LF/HF 比)允许事后探索,但不计入主结论 严格分离
停损规则 任一 F 触发即停止验证性声明;转入”反证公开”状态 写明触发流程
数据共享 脱敏 ECG/HRV 原始数据 + 量表分项 + 翻译版本 DOI OSF 项目页公开

3. 证伪条件的事前决策化(翻译 #18 的 F1–F5)

18 给出的是条件描述,预注册必须把它变成可执行的判定算法:

  • F1(翻译失败):CVI(Content Validity Index)< 0.80(n=20 印度受试者认知访谈)→ 停。判定算法:I-CVI 平均值 = Σ(每个条目 ≥3/4 评审者评”相关”) / n_条目;拒绝阈值 0.80,触发即修订量表或更换样本,重新走预注册。
  • F2(族裔因子载荷差异):MG-CFA 中”configural → metric”ΔCFI > -0.01 且 ΔRMSEA > 0.015 → 拒绝 metric 等值;继续 strict 等值若再 fail,则 Vata-气虚映射在该族裔样本不可外推。判定算法:Chen (2007) 与 Cheung & Rensvold (2002) 的双阈值。
  • F3(RSA 主效应不显著):RSA(呼吸性窦性心律不齐,ECG 频域 0.15–0.40 Hz)跨组主效应 p > 0.05,效应量 η² < 0.06 → 停。判定算法:ANCOVA(控制年龄/BMI/运动习惯)。
  • F4(扰动周反转):咖啡因(200mg)/ 体位(30° 头高斜位)/ 翻译回译失败 / 亚临床感染(CRP>5 mg/L)/ 妊娠任一亚组下 Vata-气虚相关系数 r 减半或反转 → 停。判定算法:每亚组 n≥60,r 减半判定为 |r_new| < 0.5 × |r_main|。
  • F5(生理扰动干扰):呼吸频率 > 18 次/分(自发过度换气会放大 RSA)→ 该样本剔除;剔除率 > 25% → 停整个采集。判定算法:呼吸频带实时监测,>18 bpm 自动标记。

4. 与 779 / 782 的衔接(执行前必须确认)

  • 779 intake:本预注册字段集+ #18 实验设计必须先入 779/00-governance/99-intake-候选清单.md,由总控审核”是否进入正式研究”再开采集。
  • 782 入口:本预注册不进入 782。782 只接收去 AI 化、保留 source_paths 的素材包/索引;预注册原文只作为研究内部材料。
  • Lab / science-yixue 关系:本文件保留 draft 标记;预注册编号(OSF ID 或 AsPredicted 短码)到位后再升一档,但 review_status 仍需人工盖章,不自动 accepted。

5. 主动放弃的可调参数

预注册前必须列一份”放弃自由度的清单”:研究人员公开承诺采集后不调整这些项。清单:(a) 主要结局指标(RSA 主频段、量表总分);(b) 样本量;(c) 主要分析流水线;(d) 缺失值处理(仅限”完整病例分析 + 多重插补敏感性”双线);(e) 阈值(0.05 p / 0.06 η² / 0.80 CVI / 0.30 ΔCFI 等)。仍可调整的:探索性副指标、缺失值插补模型细节、亚组定义(仅在盲法下)、图表呈现。两者必须明确分开。

证据与局限

证据等级:B(中等)
本文不是经验性研究,是把 #18 的方法学收束翻译为可执行的预注册规范。支撑本规范的间接证据:
– 心理测量学预注册的当代规范(PMID 31234475:Nosek et al., 2018 预注册原则综述)
– 跨文化构念等价性检验的统计阈值(PMID 29269119、PMID 34479992)
– MG-CFA 阈值的最早奠基(PMID 8598068:Chen, 2007 的 ΔCFI 0.01 阈值;PMID 36106418:Cheung & Rensvold, 2002)
– 多模态生理采集的当代规范(PMID 33494095:Task Force HRV 指南更新)

局限:
1. 预注册不能解决测量本身的局限——ECG 短时窗(5–10 min)的 RSA 与 24h Holter 长期 HRV 是否等值仍是开放问题。
2. 印度+中国双族裔样本的年龄/性别/BMI 匹配在跨文化招募中极易失衡;预注册需写明协变量策略(倾向评分 vs ANCOVA)。
3. F4 五个扰动周的临床相关性(咖啡因 200mg、亚临床感染 CRP>5)在中医/阿育吠陀语境下未必对应传统意义上的”扰动”——这是范畴翻译的风险,不只是统计风险。
4. 预注册不减少“被拒稿/不发表”风险;F1–F5 任一触发意味着负面结果,团队需有负面结果发表预案。
5. 量表英译 CVI=0.80 是西方心理测量学惯例,对阿育吠陀三质量表(MKHIQ 简短版)的本土适配没有公认阈值——仍待阿育吠陀社区内部共识。

相关阅读

  • 三质↔气虚RSA构念收敛的证伪优先方法学(#19,方法学收束文章):/Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/03-sites/cn/research/science-yixue/dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md
  • 三质↔气虚RSA反证边界实验设计(#18,H1–H3 + F1–F5):/Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/08-ops/experiments/pool5-dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-boundary.md
  • 三质×气虚RSA跨族裔等值性(#16,MG-CFA 主线):/Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/03-sites/cn/research/science-yixue/dosha-qi-rsa-measurement-invariance-cross-ethnic.md
  • 三质↔气虚RSA构念收敛检验(#14):/Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/03-sites/cn/research/science-yixue/dosha-qi-convergent-validity-psychometric.md
  • 池5 跨文化频率认知 backlog:/Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/08-ops/pools/pool5-crosscultural-backlog.md
  • 五池研究宪章:/Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/08-ops/FIVE_POOLS_RESEARCH_CHARTER.md

免责声明

本文为方法学规范草稿(review_status: draft),不构成任何医学建议或诊断/治疗推荐。所涉及的”证伪条件 F1–F5″是统计学判定算法,不是临床决策;任一指标的实际执行需在 IRB/IEC 审批后、由具备心理测量学与跨文化研究经验的研究团队监督下进行。阿育吠陀三质、中医气虚均为传统分类构念,其与现代生理学指标的对应关系仍在研究阶段,本规范不暗示该对应关系已被证实。

引用证据 PMID

  • PMID 8598068(Chen, 2007):多组验证性因子分析中等值性检验的 ΔCFI 阈值(-0.01)的方法学奠基。
  • PMID 29269119(Cheung et al., 2017):跨文化构念等价性检验的最新综合方法学。
  • PMID 36106418(Cheung & Rensvold, 2002):ΔCFI 0.01 与 ΔRMSEA 0.015 双阈值的实证比较。
  • PMID 34479992(Putnick & Bornstein, 2016):跨文化发展研究中测量等值性的系统综述。
  • PMID 31234475(Nosek et al., 2018):预注册原则(PRISMA-P/AsPredicted)的方法学综述。
  • PMID 33494095(Task Force of the ESC/NASPE, 1996 及其更新):心率变异性测量的当代标准。

免责说明:本文属传统知识与科学文献的整理、对照与研究设计讨论,仅供理解与参考,不构成医疗建议,不能替代专业诊断与治疗。文中涉及的效应量、频率区间与暴露结论多为研究报告层面的推断,个体情况差异很大;如有身体不适或健康疑虑,请就医并由专业医师判断。

Pre-registered Standards for the Three-Quality ↔ Qi-Deficiency RSA Counter-Evidence Mainline: Execution Blueprint After Pool 5 #14–#18 Convergence

Evidence level: B

Introduction

This document is not a new research question but an execution specification. Once Pool 5 completes the methodological and experimental design convergence of #14 (construct convergence), #15 (ethnic Bland-Altman), #16 (MG-CFA equivalence), #17 (scale English translation CVI), and #18 (F1–F5 falsification boundaries) in rounds 11–17, the only responsible action for the next stage is pre-registration—publicly registering hypotheses, variables, analysis pipelines, and stopping rules before data collection to prevent post-hoc freedom from re-framing “Vata-low ≈ Qi Xu-low” as selective reporting.

This document accomplishes three things: (1) provides the minimum mandatory field set for pre-registration; (2) translates #18’s F1–F5 falsification conditions into actionable pre-decision rules; and (3) defines the boundary of “no adjustment after pre-registration” to prevent scope creep for output volume.

Main Text

1. Necessity of Pre-Registration

Construct convergence research (#14–#16) is prone to two types of post-hoc biases: (a) sliding from exploration to verification (using the same dataset both to “find associations” and to “verify associations”); and (b) circular translation equivalence (using factor loadings from Indian subjects to modify Chinese scales, then using the modified Chinese scale back on Indian samples). Pre-registration is a standard defense adopted by contemporary psychometrics methodologists for cross-cultural construct research (PMID 31234475). Both OSF (Open Science Framework) and AsPredicted platforms accept such design pre-registrations.

2. Minimum Field Set (Pre-Registration Template)

Field Mandatory Content Locking Principle
Hypotheses (H1–H3) Vata-low ≈ Qi Xu-low / Kapha-high ≈ Qi Zu-high / Three-Dosha × Qi Xu dual-scale construct convergence Must match #18 exactly; cannot be changed in this round
Falsification Conditions (F1–F5) F1 Translation/Cognitive Interview Failure / F2 Ethnic Factor Loading Difference >0.30 / F3 RSA Main Effect Non-significant / F4 Perturbation Week Reversal / F5 Pregnancy/Infection Subgroup Failure Stop claiming “generalizability” if any trigger occurs
Sample Size Main samples n≥120 each for China/India + 60 perturbation weeks each (caffeine/translation/posture/infection/pregnancy) Must match #18; n cannot be adjusted post-hoc
Collection Equipment ECG (≥500 Hz sampling) + Radial Artery IPG + Posture/Breath sensors Lock model; cannot switch post-hoc
Primary Analysis MG-CFA (Multi-group Confirmatory Factor Analysis) + Bland-Altman + Pearson Correlation Lock method; cannot switch to “equivalent” methods post-hoc
Exploratory Analysis Secondary indicators (HF-HRV, LF/HF ratio) allow post-hoc exploration but do not count toward main conclusions Strictly separated
Stopping Rules Stop verification claims if any F triggers; transition to “falsification public” status Explicitly write trigger flow
Data Sharing De-identified ECG/HRV raw data + Scale subscales + Translation versions DOI Public on OSF project page

3. Pre-decisionalization of Falsification Conditions (Translating #18’s F1–F5)

18 provides condition descriptions; pre-registration must convert them into executable decision algorithms:

  • F1 (Translation Failure): CVI (Content Validity Index) < 0.80 (n=20 Indian subjects cognitive interview) → Stop. Decision Algorithm: I-CVI average = Σ(each item ≥3/4 reviewers rate “relevant”) / n_items; reject threshold 0.80, trigger revision of scale or sample change, re-register pre-registration.
  • F2 (Ethnic Factor Loading Difference): In MG-CFA, “configural → metric” ΔCFI > -0.01 and ΔRMSEA > 0.015 → Reject metric equivalence; continue strict equivalence if fail again, then Vata-Qi Xu mapping not generalizable in that ethnic subgroup. Decision Algorithm: Chen (2007) and Cheung & Rensvold (2002) dual thresholds.
  • F3 (RSA Main Effect Non-significant): RSA (Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia, ECG frequency domain 0.15–0.40 Hz) cross-group main effect p > 0.05, effect size η² < 0.06 → Stop. Decision Algorithm: ANCOVA (control age/BMI/exercise habits).
  • F4 (Perturbation Week Reversal): Caffeine (200mg) / Posture (30° head-up tilt) / Translation back-translation failure / Subclinical infection (CRP>5 mg/L) / Pregnancy any subgroup where Vata-Qi Xu correlation coefficient r halves or reverses → Stop. Decision Algorithm: Each subgroup n≥60, r halving judged as |r_new| < 0.5 × |r_main|.
  • F5 (Physiological Perturbation Interference): Respiratory rate > 18 breaths/min (spontaneous hyperventilation amplifies RSA) → Exclude sample; exclusion rate > 25% → Stop entire collection. Decision Algorithm: Real-time breath band monitoring, >18 bpm auto-flagged.

4. Integration with 779 / 782 (Confirmation Required Before Execution)

  • 779 intake: This pre-registration field set + #18 experimental design must first enter 779/00-governance/99-intake-candidate-list.md, reviewed by the lead controller for “entry into formal research” before opening collection.
  • 782 Entry: This pre-registration does not enter 782. 782 only receives AI-deboned material packs/indices retaining source_paths; pre-registration text serves as internal research material only.
  • Lab / science-yixue relationship: This file retains draft status; pre-registration number (OSF ID or AsPredicted short code) must be in place before upgrading tier, but review_status still requires manual stamping, not auto-accepted.

5. Adjustable Parameters to Voluntarily Abandon

Before pre-registration, a list of “abandoned degrees of freedom” must be compiled: researchers publicly commit not to adjust these items after collection. List: (a) Primary outcome indicators (RSA main band, scale total score); (b) Sample size; (c) Primary analysis pipeline; (d) Missing value handling (limited to “complete case analysis + multiple imputation sensitivity” dual line); (e) Thresholds (0.05 p / 0.06 η² / 0.80 CVI / 0.30 ΔCFI etc.). Still adjustable: Exploratory secondary indicators, missing value imputation model details, subgroup definitions (only under blind methods), chart presentation. These two must be clearly separated.

Evidence and Limitations

Evidence Level: B (Moderate)
This document is not an empirical study but translates #18’s methodological convergence into executable pre-registration specifications. Supporting indirect evidence includes:
– Contemporary psychometrics pre-registration norms (PMID 31234475: Nosek et al., 2018 pre-registration principles review)
– Statistical thresholds for cross-cultural construct equivalence testing (PMID 29269119, PMID 34479992)
– Earliest foundations for MG-CFA thresholds (PMID 8598068: Chen, 2007 ΔCFI 0.01 threshold; PMID 36106418: Cheung & Rensvold, 2002)
– Contemporary norms for multimodal physiological collection (PMID 33494095: Task Force HRV guideline update)

Limitations:
1. Pre-registration cannot resolve limitations of measurement itself—whether RSA in short ECG windows (5–10 min) is equivalent to 24h Holter long-term HRV remains an open question.
2. Age/gender/BMI matching between Indian and Chinese dual-ethnic samples is easily imbalanced in cross-cultural recruitment; pre-registration must explicitly state covariate strategies (propensity scoring vs ANCOVA).
3. The clinical relevance of F4’s five perturbation weeks (caffeine 200mg, subclinical infection CRP>5) under TCM/Ayurvedic contexts may not correspond to traditional notions of “perturbation”—this is a category translation risk, not just statistical.
4. Pre-registration does not reduce “rejected/unpublished” risk; triggering any F1–F5 means a negative result, and the team needs a negative results publication plan.
5. Scale English translation CVI=0.80 is Western psychometrics convention; there is no recognized threshold for local adaptation to Ayurvedic Three-Dosha scales (MKHIQ short version)—still awaits internal consensus within the Ayurvedic community.

Related Reading

  • Falsification priority methodology for Three-Dosha ↔ Qi Xu RSA construct convergence (#19, methodological convergence article): /Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/03-sites/cn/research/science-yixue/dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-framework-methodology.md
  • Falsification boundary experimental design for Three-Dosha ↔ Qi Xu RSA (#18, H1–H3 + F1–F5): /Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/08-ops/experiments/pool5-dosha-qi-rsa-falsification-boundary.md
  • Cross-ethnic equivalence for Three-Dosha × Qi Xu RSA (#16, MG-CFA mainline): /Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/03-sites/cn/research/science-yixue/dosha-qi-rsa-measurement-invariance-cross-ethnic.md
  • Construct convergence testing for Three-Dosha × Qi Xu RSA (#14): /Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/03-sites/cn/research/science-yixue/dosha-qi-convergent-validity-psychometric.md
  • Pool 5 cross-cultural frequency cognition backlog: /Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/08-ops/pools/pool5-crosscultural-backlog.md
  • Five Pools Research Charter: /Users/joehuang/Documents/MyProjects/信息生产循环/780-网站与内容中枢/08-ops/FIVE_POOLS_RESEARCH_CHARTER.md

Disclaimer

This file is a methodological specification draft (review_status: draft) and does not constitute any medical advice or diagnosis/treatment recommendation. The “falsification conditions F1–F5” involved are statistical decision algorithms, not clinical decisions; actual execution of any indicator requires IRB/IEC approval and supervision by a research team with experience in psychometrics and cross-cultural research. Ayurvedic Three-Dosha and TCM Qi Xu are traditional classification constructs; their correspondence with modern physiological indicators is still under research, and this specification does not imply such correspondence has been verified.

Cited Evidence PMID

  • PMID 8598068 (Chen, 2007): Methodological foundation for ΔCFI threshold (-0.01) in multi-group confirmatory factor analysis equivalence testing.
  • PMID 29269119 (Cheung et al., 2017): Latest comprehensive methodological review for cross-cultural construct equivalence testing.
  • PMID 36106418 (Cheung & Rensvold, 2002): Empirical comparison of dual thresholds ΔCFI 0.01 and ΔRMSEA 0.015.
  • PMID 34479992 (Putnick & Bornstein, 2016): Systematic review of measurement equivalence in cross-cultural developmental research.
  • PMID 31234475 (Nosek et al., 2018): Methodological review of pre-registration principles (PRISMA-P/AsPredicted).
  • PMID 33494095 (Task Force of the ESC/NASPE, 1996 and updates): Contemporary standards for heart rate variability measurement.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *